Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Which is why we probably won't circumcise our kids when they are born. We have no religious reason to do so.

And if there were a health benefit then you'd be justified in doing it, and presumably would.

You won't do it (it seems) so - according to you - there is no good reason to do it.

Glad we cleared that up.
 
This post that you replied to Rolfe (have him on ignore, so this is about Rolfe's post,) is the worst logical fallacy of all in this thread. Slippery slope arguments, especially when taken to the extreme like this one, is pretty ignorant.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope

Maybe you should just stop using the big words until you have at least a general idea what they mean, eh?
 
And if there were a health benefit then you'd be justified in doing it, and presumably would.

You won't do it (it seems) so - according to you - there is no good reason to do it.

Glad we cleared that up.

Wasn't anything to "clear up." Because what I will do or think personally, has no bearing on whether or not a law is justified.
 
Maybe you should just stop using the big words until you have at least a general idea what they mean, eh?

ok. This argument is fine then, and nothing wrong with it. You are correct. I have no idea what a "slippery slope" fallacy is then. :rolleyes:

Rolfe said:
But if you go down that road, you're going to have circumcision, pharonisation, castration, tattooing, scarification, cutting off little fingers and virgin sacrifice being condoned.

The pro-circumcision arguments will serve just as well for any of these, because the proponents sincerely believe what they are doing is only minor, and justified by tradition and religion.

[/sarcasm]
 
This post that you replied to Rolfe (have him on ignore, so this is about Rolfe's post,) is the worst logical fallacy of all in this thread. Slippery slope arguments, especially when taken to the extreme like this one, is pretty ignorant.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope

Letting the child decide is a logical fallacy now. And a slippery slope one!
Nihilianth is becoming extremely confused.
 
I do not expect this to become law in San Fran. Why? Because I do not believe that the people of San Fran would allow such a discriminatory law to pass. Once it becomes very clear to all how this law would effect thousands of Muslim and Jewish residents of the city, it will crash and burn.
 
I do not expect this to become law in San Fran. Why? Because I do not believe that the people of San Fran would allow such a discriminatory law to pass. Once it becomes very clear to all how this law would effect thousands of Muslim and Jewish residents of the city, it will crash and burn.

Protecting the well being of children equates to discrimination?

:dl:
 
I do not expect this to become law in San Fran. Why? Because I do not believe that the people of San Fran would allow such a discriminatory law to pass. Once it becomes very clear to all how this law would effect thousands of Muslim and Jewish residents of the city, it will crash and burn.

Perhaps they should show a video of the procedure before the vote (blood, screams and all)? Let the voting public make an informed judgement on whether it constitutes abuse?
 

So where are you answers to this then?

That's because they A. Save lives and B. have an absolutely miniscule chance of doing any damage. As far as I'm aware only a tiny proportion of people are unable to be vaccinated and most of those have some sort of severe problem with their immune system. Given the obvious and vast benefits, this isn't a valid comparison.



Anyways isn't a word. The word you want is anyway.

Further, there are, to simplify, three kinds of surgery. Surgery done to save a life/significantly increase the quality of life, surgery done to increase the quality of life that isn't serious, and elective, usually cosmetic surgery. All three fail miserably as comparisons.

Surgery type 1 is necessary to ensure the person a healthy, continued life. Circumcision (except in cases such as mine) is not, and does not ensure anything remotely similar.

Type 2 gives a good benefit to the person receiving the surgery (for example, a hip replacement) and is pretty much always done on adults who are able to consent. As such, it fails to match circumcision on children because it provides little to no benefit and is performed on a child who cannot consent.

Type 3 again fails because this surgery is always (or should always) be performed on consenting adults who understand what the surgery is. As such, this analogy fails miserably, just as your ridiculous vaccine analogy did.

It's excruciatingly painful and it removes a piece of skin that may potentially be beneficial for sex permanently. Even if you can show it doesn't hurt children, and even if there is no benefit to having a foreskin, then it is still an utterly pointless procedure (again, unlike your two "analogies" above) done purely to sate the whim of a god who probably doesn't exist, and a culture that considers such an action normal.

Point to someone, anyone who said they were the same. Not that they were both pointless and permanent, but that they were almost or completely the same in terms of harm done.
 
It's simple. We let the children decide when they're old enough. Say 18.

This post that you replied to Rolfe (have him on ignore, so this is about Rolfe's post,) is the worst logical fallacy of all in this thread. Slippery slope arguments, especially when taken to the extreme like this one, is pretty ignorant.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope


So you are saying that you see nothing wrong with the law insisting that a purely cosmetic, possibly debilitating, and permanently disfiguring surgery not be made until the individual receiving it can make that decision themselves as an informed adult?

'Cause that's what NT was saying.

That seems perfectly reasonable to me.

From a religious perspective it should also seem much more compelling, because it is not being forced on a helpless and unwitting infant who has no understanding why the procedure is being done. That is the very definition of compulsory religion.

Why do you think that the Constitution should defend that?
 
This post that you replied to Rolfe (have him on ignore, so this is about Rolfe's post,) is the worst logical fallacy of all in this thread. Slippery slope arguments, especially when taken to the extreme like this one, is pretty ignorant.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope

You're making an understandable mistake for someone new to logic. The slippery slope is indeed a fallacy (most of the time), and Rolfe's argument does bear a resemblance to one. What you have failed to realize throughout the thread, however, is that the argument is not a point against circumcision, but a refutation of a fallacious argument you keep making. The technical term for Rolfe's actual argument is Reductio ad absurdumWP.

By the way, going on about how you're putting posters on ignore, especially when you keep addressing their posts anyway, makes you look pretty childish.
 
I agree there are some interventions so minor that there could be no objection to doing them to babies as part of a religious ritual. Marking the forehead with a dab of easily-removed pigment springs to mind. (Or even splashing a little water on the forehead if you want to be completely realistic - see, Nihilianth, that's what we Christians actually do to our infant children to accept them into the religious community.)

I also contend that there are interventions so invasive that they ought not to be permitted under any circumstances, not even for sincerely-held religious reasons. Pharonisation might be an acceptable example of this.

I just want to know who gets to decide where the line should be drawn. Nobody will tell me this.

Rolfe.
 
Protecting the well being of children equates to discrimination?

if the great-majority of the targets will be a specific religious group? you bet.

there are laws banning regulations and rules that disproportionately affect minority groups.

a law banning male-infant circumcision will disproportionately affect Jews & Muslims, and this is probably why it will NOT become law or get tossed out by a Federal court.

this is also a great way to unite Jews and Muslims, so thanks for the unintended positive consequence. ;)
 
Last edited:
I wonder if this will ever be more supported, in the US or elsewhere:

Link

QUESTIONING CIRCUMCISION
A Jewish Perspective

Ronald Goldman, Ph.D.
Foreword by Rabbi Raymond Singer, Ph.D.

Consider these facts:
Circumcision is not universal among Jews.
Jewish press articles have questioned circumcision.
A male child born of a Jewish mother is a Jew, whether he is circumcised or not.
Jewish circumcision has never had anything to do with health concerns.
Circumcision conflicts with significant Jewish laws and values.
An Israeli organization publicly opposes circumcision.
http://www.jewishcircumcision.org/book.htm
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom