Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I think that my comment cuts right to the heart of the matter. Just my observation after participating in many of these circumcision debates.

Well, to be fair, I haven;t participated in any other circumcision thread in this forum before. So....

Absolutely it's my opinion. I'm not claiming it as a legal fact or anything. In my opinion parents shouldn't be able to do this to their children. Maybe someday sanity will prevail. Until then I will continue to point out how silly this mutilation is.

You can think that. It's fine. I can respect your opinion. :)

My opinion is that I just sit on the fence. I couldn't care one way or the other whether a parent decides it or not. I just defend the parent's right to decide in a private manner, and for people to practice their religion in a private manner. I know I wouldn't like the public to come creepin into every little decision I make for my kids when they are born.

And for the record, it appears my wife probably doesn't want to circumcise our kids, if they turn out to be boys. (She has also opted to not be told, until the Big Day.)
 
Being deliberately obtuse of course.

It goes back to my original comment. People who are cut are trying to justify it to themselves so they don't hurt mentally.

ok. Sure. You're right. Amazing how well people know me who have never met me before. But it's all good. :cool:
 
I have read the thread from the start, and I object to you assuming (without evidence) that I have not.

I was responding directly to your assertion: and pointing out that even if people believe a practice is right, or religiously mandated, or culturally normal, that does not mean that it is"off-limits" to being legislated against if it can be shown that the practice is, on balance, more harmful than not carrying out the practice.

I didn't say it was off-limits. My opinion is that it should be. Unless I didn't state that in a way that was easily understandable. In which case, that's my fault.

I would like to see circumcision (and the piercing of children's ears) become as culturally unacceptable as sending children up chimneys or drink driving, even without legislation. It seems to me, admittedly from a culture where circumcision is unusual (such that although my husband, born in 1962, was circumcised, no other sexual partner of mine was, either older or younger than my husband), that there will come a time when the practice will cease to be seen as something that is a parent's right to do to their child but it will be something that will be a man's right to choose for himself only when he is old enough to understand the decision, or unless medically necessary.

And I totally respect your opinion on the matter. I just see no reason why people have such a need to step into a rather benign religious practice that doesn't seem to hurt anyone. Instead, wouldn't it be more productive to come up with a way to lessen the amount of circumcisions without resorting to an outright ban that could easily undermine the respect for the law? And maybe quite possibly criminalizing 50% of the American public? That doesn't make much sense to me, and will likely remain unconvinced that passing a circumcision ban will solve a problem that is greater than any problems that may occur because of the ban.

Personally, I don't believe that parents have the right to violate their children's bodily integrity unless the benefit of doing so clearly outweighs the harm. Thus, the benefit of vaccination outweighs the harm of not vaccinating, even though it involves puncturing a child's skin.

Again, I can respect your opinion. I just don't think that a ban should be forth-coming. So we apparently disagree about banning the practice.

In the end, you will remain unconvinced that not passing a ban would be a good thing, and I shall remain unconvinced that passing a ban would be a good thing. So it would probably just be prudent to just end this conversation on the note of agreeing to disagree. I spent far too much of my life in this thread, and think we should let it die in a peaceful manner.
 
Last edited:
OK, let's go back to what you did say. You said that deliberately cutting a baby's arm would not be a crime if it was done for a religious reason, and you said that it was immoral but that it should not be banned because of the religious aspect. So you are arguing that a deliberate injury to a baby is not, and should not be, a crime, as long as it's done for a religious reason.

That's a bit of a better way to state things. This is what I responded to when I accused you of trolling:

Dave said:
So you, who believe stabbing babies in the name of religion is morally acceptable, are comparing everyone who disagrees with you to Holocaust deniers? Is that a variant on Godwin's Law?

Dave

Obviously nothing about stabbing anyone came up in any of our line of discussion. You mentioned about making "an incision," then you changed it to "stabbing," and back to "incision." Then you decided to flip it on me, by saying "it is ok to stab a baby in the name of a religion." You also ended that post by saying I was comapring you to Holocaust deniers, completely taking what I actually said totally out of context.

Sorry, but that entire post was unfair, and dishonest in the extreme. It was definitely bordering on trolling with the amount of accusations you piled up there.

I will clarify once again about the comaparison to Holocaust deniers real quick.

My comparison was purely in terms of the terminology you are using. You were using the same tactics of deniers by using a more vague, and more extreme-sounding terminology that is loaded with bias, rather than using the more precise term that is medically acceptable.

I still have no idea what people on your side of this discussion have to gain in using incorrect terminology that is imprecise enough to border on dishonesty.

Let's just check that you really said that.





I really can't say much more than that your opinion is one of the most revolting I've ever encountered.

Dave

My opinion is revolting? Because I think that just because something is immoral it shouldn;t be banned?

I would really like to end this discussion, seriously, but I would like your honest take on the WBC decision.

The WBC is morally unacceptable. No. That is not the right word/phrase. The are so damned revolting, that it literally makes me sick even thinking about these downright disgusting, poor excuses of human beings. But guess what? They have every single right as I do, and are exactly equal to me in this society. Their right to free speech should not be abridged, nor denied. Despite how downright, disgustingly despicable they are.
 
And I totally respect your opinion on the matter. I just see no reason why people have such a need to step into a rather benign religious practice that doesn't seem to hurt anyone. Instead, wouldn't it be more productive to come up with a way to lessen the amount of circumcisions without resorting to an outright ban that could easily undermine the respect for the law? And maybe quite possibly criminalizing 50% of the American public? That doesn't make much sense to me, and will likely remain unconvinced that passing a circumcision ban will solve a problem that is greater than any problems that may occur because of the ban.of my life in this thread, and think we should let it die in a peaceful manner.

Do you really think the law would be retroactive?
 
from what I understand of the law, parents can indeed do things to their children, that the children vocally say they do not want.

-braces.

-ear piercings.

-short haircuts.

-go to church and take the sacrament.

yup, there are lots of things parents can force their children can do, that one could not force upon an adult.

Who gives their kids ear piercings against their will?
Other than that, which I would also object to, those are not irreversible procedures that will continue to affect people into adulthood.
 
Who gives their kids ear piercings against their will?
Many people, unfortunately. Thunder and Nihilianth have been using this argument repeatedly from the beginning, despite the obvious logical fallacy. Even while ignoring other people's comparisons of comparable behavior, they use this as validation for circumcision. It's the equivalent of a 5 year old girl saying "Suzy gets to do it, why can't I?"

Before you bring it up, Thunder, I've been reading this thread from the beginning. I'm just now posting because I thought you two would've given up by now.
 
My opinion is revolting? Because I think that just because something is immoral it shouldn't be banned?

Because you think that religion is an acceptable excuse for needlessly committing harm to babies, even though you admit it's morally unacceptable.

I would really like to end this discussion, seriously, but I would like your honest take on the WBC decision.

You're the one who keeps pointing out how everyone else's comparisons are flawed; this one is no better. Freedom of speech is not the same as a license to cut bits off children.

Dave
 
Last edited:
Thunder, do you think it's ok to keep doing something that is a permanent procedure, that hurts, and that has absolutely no benefit and may cause some damage, yes or no?
 
I'd also like to repeat this, since Parky ignored it.

:rolleyes:

vaccines can cause harm, but we do it anyways.
That's because they A. Save lives and B. have an absolutely miniscule chance of doing any damage. As far as I'm aware only a tiny proportion of people are unable to be vaccinated and most of those have some sort of severe problem with their immune system. Given the obvious and vast benefits, this isn't a valid comparison.

all surgery, no matter how small or large, can cause harm. but we do it anyways.

Anyways isn't a word. The word you want is anyway.

Further, there are, to simplify, three kinds of surgery. Surgery done to save a life/significantly increase the quality of life, surgery done to increase the quality of life that isn't serious, and elective, usually cosmetic surgery. All three fail miserably as comparisons.

Surgery type 1 is necessary to ensure the person a healthy, continued life. Circumcision (except in cases such as mine) is not, and does not ensure anything remotely similar.

Type 2 gives a good benefit to the person receiving the surgery (for example, a hip replacement) and is pretty much always done on adults who are able to consent. As such, it fails to match circumcision on children because it provides little to no benefit and is performed on a child who cannot consent.

Type 3 again fails because this surgery is always (or should always) be performed on consenting adults who understand what the surgery is. As such, this analogy fails miserably, just as your ridiculous vaccine analogy did.
male circumcision can cause harm. it rarely does, but it can. however, female genital mutilation...almost ALWAYS causes harm. and in many cases very serious harm.

It's excruciatingly painful and it removes a piece of skin that may potentially be beneficial for sex permanently. Even if you can show it doesn't hurt children, and even if there is no benefit to having a foreskin, then it is still an utterly pointless procedure (again, unlike your two "analogies" above) done purely to sate the whim of a god who probably doesn't exist, and a culture that considers such an action normal.

Point to someone, anyone who said they were the same. Not that they were both pointless and permanent, but that they were almost or completely the same in terms of harm done.

and now, we are done.

So, you're going to stick your fingers in your ears like usual then?

That isn't a surprise Parky. You're as predictable as a double-headed coin.
 
You guys crack me up, you have got to be nuts to try and suggest that circumcision does not reduce sensitivity. I know this is not exactly a controlled experiment but I am not circumcised, if I pull back my foreskin and walk around with my old fella going commando in my underwear it is uncomfortable due to the sensitivity of the exposed head.

I assume that someone who is cut is not continually in discomfort, ergo the sensitivity is reduced from being continually exposed. Either way you can be sure it is not MORE sensitive so ha ha on you for having a numb knob :)

Additionally it is pathetic to try and insist that cutting a bit of flesh from the end of a non anesthetized baby's penis is somehow acceptable. The fact that a baby does not remember it and somehow trying to call parental choice is an outrageous non-justification. How many of you would volunteer for this same procedure if you were given the choice (and I mean the SAME procedure, no anesthetic)? If you would not then you should be ashamed of yourselves for trying to justify its application to anyone else of any age.

:mad:
 
Last edited:
You guys crack me up, you have got to be nuts to try and suggest that circumcision does not reduce sensitivity. I know this is not exactly a controlled experiment but I am not circumcised, if I pull back my foreskin and walk around with my old fella going commando in my underwear it is uncomfortable due to the sensitivity of the exposed head.

This.

Also, I was surprised when I first learned that for some males masturbation requires lubrication.
 
It seems to me the argument goes like this.

Religious group: What we do to our children is so minor and insignificant there's no reason to ban it. And besides, it's our tradition.

Everybody else: You call that minor? It's barbaric!

Religious group: You're just bigoted. It's nothing.

This could go on all week.

So who gets to decide whether something is minor enough to be acceptable, or not?

The religious group believe it should be for them and them only to make that decision. None of anybody else's business.

But if you go down that road, you're going to have circumcision, pharonisation, castration, tattooing, scarification, cutting off little fingers and virgin sacrifice being condoned.

The pro-circumcision arguments will serve just as well for any of these, because the proponents sincerely believe what they are doing is only minor, and justified by tradition and religion.

So - do we let the religious groups themselves decide what is OK, or do we impose an outside arbiter?

Rolfe.
 
It seems to me the argument goes like this.

Religious group: What we do to our children is so minor and insignificant there's no reason to ban it. And besides, it's our tradition.

Everybody else: You call that minor? It's barbaric!

Religious group: You're just bigoted. It's nothing.

This could go on all week.

So who gets to decide whether something is minor enough to be acceptable, or not?

The religious group believe it should be for them and them only to make that decision. None of anybody else's business.

But if you go down that road, you're going to have circumcision, pharonisation, castration, tattooing, scarification, cutting off little fingers and virgin sacrifice being condoned.

The pro-circumcision arguments will serve just as well for any of these, because the proponents sincerely believe what they are doing is only minor, and justified by tradition and religion.

So - do we let the religious groups themselves decide what is OK, or do we impose an outside arbiter?

Rolfe.

Good rule of thumb:What would you want your care takers be allowed to decide for you if you were in a coma for 2 years?

Frankly, I'd rather wake up with my genitals intact, my ears unpierced and necessary medication and nutrition administered. I'd rather not wake up with my earlobes chopped off and learning I am suffering from scurvy because someone decided they shouldn't force me to take vitamins.

In general, I think parents ought to have roughly the same rights and obligations and see no justification for broadly extending the rights of the parents over their childrens' bodies.
 
Good rule of thumb:What would you want your care takers be allowed to decide for you if you were in a coma for 2 years?


Yeah, but whom do you define as "you"? Who gets to make the decision? Because if you leave it to Parky and Nihilianth, they'll just swear blind that they'd feel positively betrayed if they woke up with a prepuce.

Rolfe.
 
Yeah, but whom do you define as "you"? Who gets to make the decision? Because if you leave it to Parky and Nihilianth, they'll just swear blind that they'd feel positively betrayed if they woke up with a prepuce.

Rolfe.

Well it would be a bona-fida miracle....
 
Yeah, but whom do you define as "you"? Who gets to make the decision? Because if you leave it to Parky and Nihilianth, they'll just swear blind that they'd feel positively betrayed if they woke up with a prepuce.

Rolfe.

Who does make the decision now? It seems to be working out mostly right. We just have to stop pretending that children are property of their parents and all would be good.
 
Who does make the decision now? It seems to be working out mostly right. We just have to stop pretending that children are property of their parents and all would be good.


That seems like an internal contradiction. At the moment the interested parties are allowed to make the decision based on the assumption that their children are their property to do with as they wish.

It's only "working out mostly right" if you think it's OK for boys to be deprived of the choice whether or not to be circumcised.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom