Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I don't know that we've been shown any evidence that the priest is hell-bet on doing anything. All we've seen is Nihilianth ignorantly asserting that circumcision is normal Christian practice, in flagrant disregard of the Council of Jerusalem and actual practice down the ages, and then revealing that his church no longer prohibits it and IF a parent asks the priest he won't tell them not to do it.

This is purely a local, social custom, which Nihilianth has misinterpreted as being religious and universal.

Rolfe.
.
He has mentioned consultations.
And that area of the country has some pretty weird leaders in the faith.
I wonder what variety of Catholicism he is looking at, and where does that information come from.
It was never even mentioned during my 30 years snapping mackerals as a common practice. Or even rare.
 
Kidding? Why would I be kidding?

As for the scenario about "those who are cut are desperate to convince themselves and the world they have not been damaged" seems to be slightly on the trollish side of a statement.

Those who are "cut" aren't desparate about anything. Not that I am aware of. I know I certainly am not.

I think that my comment cuts right to the heart of the matter. Just my observation after participating in many of these circumcision debates.

What I AM desperate, is to keep people out of the business of the decisions that parents make for their children. Parents certainly have the right to decide. You may be of the OPINION that they don't, which is fine. But you are wrong if you try to claim it as fact.

Absolutely it's my opinion. I'm not claiming it as a legal fact or anything. In my opinion parents shouldn't be able to do this to their children. Maybe someday sanity will prevail. Until then I will continue to point out how silly this mutilation is.
 
right, cause the circumcision of 8-day old baby boys is the same as a lifetime in brutal slavery.

:cool:

You still entirely miss the point, which is about the reasons for the practices.
It is said circumcision is acceptable because it is traditional.
If that is a good reason to continue a practice, slavery could also still be practised because it was traditional
Really, are you that thick or just being deliberately obtuse?
 
You still entirely miss the point, which is about the reasons for the practices.
It is said circumcision is acceptable because it is traditional.
If that is a good reason to continue a practice, slavery could also still be practised because it was traditional
Really, are you that thick or just being deliberately obtuse?

Being deliberately obtuse of course.

It goes back to my original comment. People who are cut are trying to justify it to themselves so they don't hurt mentally.
 
I highly suggest you go back and read this entire thread, instead of jumping into the middle of a conversation after that horse has been thoroughly and completely mashed apart, and ground up in a meat grinder. :mad::rolleyes::eye-poppi:jaw-dropp:covereyes:boggled:
I have read the thread from the start, and I object to you assuming (without evidence) that I have not.

I was responding directly to your assertion:
And it is their Constitutional right to think that [that God mandates circumcision]. And nobody, not you, not the government, can tell them to think otherwise
and pointing out that even if people believe a practice is right, or religiously mandated, or culturally normal, that does not mean that it is"off-limits" to being legislated against if it can be shown that the practice is, on balance, more harmful than not carrying out the practice.

I would like to see circumcision (and the piercing of children's ears) become as culturally unacceptable as sending children up chimneys or drink driving, even without legislation. It seems to me, admittedly from a culture where circumcision is unusual (such that although my husband, born in 1962, was circumcised, no other sexual partner of mine was, either older or younger than my husband), that there will come a time when the practice will cease to be seen as something that is a parent's right to do to their child but it will be something that will be a man's right to choose for himself only when he is old enough to understand the decision, or unless medically necessary.

Personally, I don't believe that parents have the right to violate their children's bodily integrity unless the benefit of doing so clearly outweighs the harm. Thus, the benefit of vaccination outweighs the harm of not vaccinating, even though it involves puncturing a child's skin.
 
Now you're just plain trolling. You are now scratching and clawing at anything, going so far as to take things out of context, and place words in my mouth that I did not speak. Or rather, words on the screen I did not type. Would have been better to criticize what is written, rather than speculate on what I say.

OK, let's go back to what you did say. You said that deliberately cutting a baby's arm would not be a crime if it was done for a religious reason, and you said that it was immoral but that it should not be banned because of the religious aspect. So you are arguing that a deliberate injury to a baby is not, and should not be, a crime, as long as it's done for a religious reason.

Let's just check that you really said that.

If they did it for a religious reason, then obviously it isn't a criminal action.

True. I can accept it is immoral, then. Still shouldn't be banned, because of the religious aspect.

I really can't say much more than that your opinion is one of the most revolting I've ever encountered.

Dave
 
Actually, this is probably why my diocese (The Diocese of Scranton. In Pennsylvania,) does it. I never sat in on any of the meetings with the priest, while he talked to parents about circumcision. So I dunno what exactly is said. I just remember the parish I grew up was big into doing circumcisions.

So Nihilianth concedes that he has no idea about circumcision as a catholic religious practice.
Whoddathunkit?
 
Missionary position.... (funny story on how that got named).. and the rhythm method.
People that practice the rhythm method have another name also.
Parents.
 
It's actually the road to hell which is so paved.
Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaiman said:
(This is not actually true. The Road to Hell is paved with frozen door-to-door salesmen. On weekends many of the younger demons go ice-skating down it.)

... because it had to be done.
 
err....fail.

But you'll never fail...



...to miss the point, that is.


I wasn't posting that link to circumcision fatalities because I fully endorsed the findings of the "paper" I only did so because it seemed to me the "source" of the claim about 117 fatalities a year in the US due to circumcision. That was the point.
 
This might be the study that the annual rates of death in the US from male circumcision come from.

http://www.mensstudies.com/content/b64n267w47m333x0/?p=488e687276f346699601a0275fc5827b&pi=2

It is not a medical study. It was written by an activist. Here is one of his papers:

http://www.icgi.org/articles/bollinger4.pdf

This is the paper I mentioned last page, and like I've said, it's total nonsense. The author compares female and male infant mortality, and assumes that the relatively higher male mortality is entirely due to circumcision. The real numbers are far lower.

I wasn't posting that link to circumcision fatalities because I fully endorsed the findings of the "paper" I only did so because it seemed to me the "source" of the claim about 117 fatalities a year in the US due to circumcision. That was the point.

like I said, a big fail.

you kept the post. you didn't remove the link after it was shown that the paper is a lie, or at least post again showing that you acknowledge its illegitimacy.

that's why its a fail. Carry on.
 
Last edited:
like I said, a big fail.

you kept the post. you didn't remove the link after it was shown that the paper is a lie, or at least post again showing that you acknowledge its illegitimacy.

that's why its a fail. Carry on.

I put the link there because people wanted access to the source. A number of people had said things along the lines of "I seem to remember some figures posted here about fatalities. Does anyone have the link?"

Others said, "It's way back there in the thread and it's too much trouble to fish out."

I put it there so others could read it.

You're saying I should have "removed" the link? Why?

post again showing that you acknowledge its illegitimacy.

Again, this is you missing the point. Since posting that link my first post was to point out my purpose in posting the link.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom