Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Ooh I'm an oppressed minority!

I can do what I like and nobody can stop me 'cos I'll just call them bigoted!

Nice work if you can get it.

Rolfe.
 
Which no one has suggested.

Then why have a ban? The whole reason for opposing the ban, is because the view is that it is unconstitutional for the government and society to tell people what, and how to raise their kids, and perform religious rituals.
 
Why would he, seeing as he is utterly clueless about everything else?

And that is another logical fallacy right there. Attacking the person, rather than the message.

List the logical fallacies I have used, and didn't admit to. At least I admitted when I was wrong or didn't fully understand something throughout this thread.
 
Perhaps they should show a video of the procedure before the vote (blood, screams and all)? Let the voting public make an informed judgement on whether it constitutes abuse?

Most of the public isn't that thin-skinned. Most of the public actually thinks its still ok to do things like spank children, and pierce their ears. Most of the public doesn't think it's ok to interfere with private familial matters.
 
Ooh I'm an oppressed minority!

I can do what I like and nobody can stop me 'cos I'll just call them bigoted!

Nice work if you can get it.

Rolfe.

as long as the ritual does not cause severe and long-term pain, serious health issues, serious sexual or other disfunction, I think the ritual should be allowed on religious grounds.

but clearly, perhaps its time for this law to indeed get passed and have the Federal courts strike it down.
 
So you are saying that you see nothing wrong with the law insisting that a purely cosmetic, possibly debilitating, and permanently disfiguring surgery not be made until the individual receiving it can make that decision themselves as an informed adult?

'Cause that's what NT was saying.

That seems perfectly reasonable to me.

From a religious perspective it should also seem much more compelling, because it is not being forced on a helpless and unwitting infant who has no understanding why the procedure is being done. That is the very definition of compulsory religion.

Why do you think that the Constitution should defend that?

Too bad this post had nothing to do with a line of conversation about me pointing out a terribly obvious logical fallacy.

Now, to answer the bolded:

1. Because the First Amendment exists, which states thus:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

2. It is not a debilitating surgery. SOME People suggest that "well, the foreskin is there!" but they fail to prove OBJECTIVELY that there is any less feeling during sex, and that not having a foreskin "toughens" the glans, making the feeling numb. (Which is ridiculously false.)

3. "It is permanently disfiguring" is a purely subjective argument. Has no place in law. It is permanent, yes. But the disfiguring part made it subjective.

Only number two, half of number three, and the baby's choice is legitimate enough to actually be considered. However, when weighed against the Constitution, and the lack of how society may benefit from the ban, I just don't see how those arguments are good enough to ban something.
 
You're making an understandable mistake for someone new to logic. The slippery slope is indeed a fallacy (most of the time), and Rolfe's argument does bear a resemblance to one. What you have failed to realize throughout the thread, however, is that the argument is not a point against circumcision, but a refutation of a fallacious argument you keep making. The technical term for Rolfe's actual argument is Reductio ad absurdumWP.

By the way, going on about how you're putting posters on ignore, especially when you keep addressing their posts anyway, makes you look pretty childish.

1. I have admitted to when I used a slippery slope argument.

2. There was nothing in that post to suggest he used Reductio ad absurdum.

3. I was responding to someone whom I did not have on ignore, who reponded in the positive about a ridiculous arguments.

4. The bolded is bordering on the personal attack. Which is something I have yet to do. Would be nice if the amount of this kind of abuse in this thread could come to an end. It doesn't help your image any.

ETA: In any case, I did state that I seem to be failing to be convincing anyone the ban is wrong, and everyone seems to fail to convince me that it is right. And that this thread has gone on long enough. Should just agree to disagree, and let it die it's death.
 
Last edited:
Bahahaha.

So you're trying to compare us to racist skinheads, because we disagree with you?

Still haven't answered my questions, I notice. If you have and I missed it, please point me to your response.

I know. Someone should make up a term that says if you attempt to win the argument by falsely comparing the other side to Nazis or Hitler then you actually lose.

No what would we call it...?
 
Oh come on parky, it's obvious that's what your post about Stormfront was. Don't bother trying to obfuscate and claim it was just a post you made not linked to the discussion at all. That never works.


ETA: On a totally different and utterly off topic note, who is the guy in your avatar? I'm curious. He looks familiar.
 
Last edited:
Then why have a ban? The whole reason for opposing the ban, is because the view is that it is unconstitutional for the government and society to tell people what, and how to raise mutilate their kids, and perform religious rituals.


Fixed it for you.
 
Nobody would have a right to chop of my earlobes or circumcise me if I was brought into a hospital after a car accident unconsciously:
But what if there was a religion out there that went around circumcising unconscious people?
Honest question for Nihilianth, should that be legal?
 
Last edited:
But what if there was a religion out there that went around circumcising unconscious people?

Oh that would have to be legal. Because of the eleventh amendment, or something. It's how it works: You can't make anything illegal when a religion does it!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom