Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I know you have used it - which is rather my point in mentioning it.

Personally I prefer to use labels which are meaningful in their context, so in a thread say about religious practises I might use the word "circumcision" to refer to male genital mutilation since that would be appropriate in such context. However when we are actually discussing the procedure of circumcision itself I prefer to use a phrase that is more accurate so that's why "male genital mutilation" is an appropriate term in this thread.

http://www.medterms.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=2739 said:
Circumcision: Surgery that removes the foreskin (the loose tissue) covering the glans of the penis. Circumcision may be performed for religious or cultural reasons, or health reasons. Newborn circumcision diminishes the risk for cancer of the penis and lowers the risk for cancer of the cervix in sexual partners. It also decreases the risk of urinary tract infections and lowers the risk of sexually transmitted diseases, including especially HIV.

The Latin "circum-" means around (or about). Circumcision is, literally, a cutting around. Circumcision dates back to prehistoric times. It is one of the oldest surgical operations known to have been performed by people.

http://mw4.m-w.com/dictionary/circumcised said:
Definition of CIRCUMCISE

transitive verb
1
: to cut off the foreskin of (a male) or the prepuce of (a female)
2
: to cut off all or part of the external genitalia and especially the clitoris and labia minora of (a female)
— cir·cum·cis·er noun

That is VERY specific. It is the cutting off of the male foreskin, and the female prepuce in definition number one.

Let's look at "mutilation" once again, this time with Merriam Webster only:

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mutilate said:
Definition of MUTILATE

transitive verb
1
: to cut up or alter radically so as to make imperfect <the child mutilated the book with his scissors>
2
: to cut off or permanently destroy a limb or essential part of : cripple
— mu·ti·la·tion noun
— mu·ti·la·tor noun
See mutilate defined for Engli

Not so specific. Mutilation can range anywhere form a child using a scissors on paper, to circumcision.

But you say "male genital mutilation." Again, according to definition number two, it says rather vaguely: "to cut off or permanently destroy a limb or essential part of: cripple."

Well, we all know circumcision certainly doesn't CRIPPLE someone. You could say "it destroys" part of the penis. But the rest of the definition of "mutilation" makes the term too broad for efficient communication, when you ask the question: "Do you think it's ok to mutilate a child's penis?"


Interestingly the phrase "genital mutilation" really does seem a stumbling block for some folk but only when it is applied to such procedures being carried out on males - they are quite happy to use it when applied to female genital mutilation. In my view that struggling to accept an accurate description demonstrates the cognitive dissonance that is felt when condemning one but not the other.

This doesn't apply to me, since I have yet to use the term "female genital mutilation." I am always, and only strictly, using the term "female circumcision."

I am truly not trying to be an ass. I truly do want to understand what is so bad about using the proper terminology? Why use terminology that is more vague, rather than terminology that is more specific? I honestly see no difference between saying "circumcision" in this discussion, compared to a doctor saying "right femoral artery" when discussing a blockage in a blood vessel.

I do kind of honestly and quite frankly liken people using the terminology "genital mutilation" to Holocaust deniers using the term "holohoax," because by using that term, it makes it seem as though they think they have something to prove, and are struggling. The media uses vague terminology as well, as do poorly-done surveys when asking a question. It is called "framing," and introduces too much bias.
 
Actually, this is probably why my diocese (The Diocese of Scranton. In Pennsylvania,) does it. I never sat in on any of the meetings with the priest, while he talked to parents about circumcision. So I dunno what exactly is said. I just remember the parish I grew up was big into doing circumcisions.
.
I'm really gonna pay a lot of attention about sex talk from a priest.
Shurley I will.
They've received an education on sex beginning with the Malleus Malifacorum, written by celibates for other celibates... at least they're celibate until the law catches up with them, and charges them with sex crimes.
 
I do kind of honestly and quite frankly liken people using the terminology "genital mutilation" to Holocaust deniers using the term "holohoax," because by using that term, it makes it seem as though they think they have something to prove, and are struggling.

So you, who believe stabbing babies in the name of religion is morally acceptable, are comparing everyone who disagrees with you to Holocaust deniers? Is that a variant on Godwin's Law?

Dave
 
You're kidding right?

Anyway these circumcision threads always blow up. I think the feelings are particularly strong on both sides. Those that are intact are grabbing their junk and feeling like they are going to throw up over the idea of someone cutting on them. Those who are cut are desperate to convince themselves and the world that they haven't been damaged. Very strong emotions on both sides.

Personally I don't feel parents have the right to decide this for their children therefore I am in favor of a ban. When the child is old enough they can decide for themselves. How this stance could be considered anything but the default is a mystery to me.

Kidding? Why would I be kidding?

As for the scenario about "those who are cut are desperate to convince themselves and the world they have not been damaged" seems to be slightly on the trollish side of a statement.

Those who are "cut" aren't desparate about anything. Not that I am aware of. I know I certainly am not.

What I AM desperate, is to keep people out of the business of the decisions that parents make for their children. Parents certainly have the right to decide. You may be of the OPINION that they don't, which is fine. But you are wrong if you try to claim it as fact.

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/456472_5
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parental_consent
 
And it is their Constitutional right to think that. And nobody, not you, not the government, can tell them to think otherwise.

Yes I can.

Hey, religious people. God did not tell you to cut off people's skin. Stop thinking that. You're nuts.
 
And it is their Constitutional right to think that. And nobody, not you, not the government, can tell them to think otherwise.
Is it also peoples' Constitutional right to follow Deuteronomy 21:18? Or is that a religiously mandated imperative that should be prohibited by law?
 
Last edited:
The First Amendment does not have the meaning you attach to it. If there is a secular reason for a law, this is not overridden by a religious objection; rather, the secular reason overrides the religious objection. This is the point that you have repeatedly shown either an inability or a disinclination to grasp.

In the context of a discussion about passing a ban, the Constitutional (in this case, religious) aspect still must be considered. I don't think you seem to understand that. People SHOULD be talking about the First Amendment when discussing a law. Even though a law may have secular reasons for passing, doesn't mean we cannot talk about the religious reasons for not passing it. Like the so-called "anti-burka law" that was passed in France a few months ago. If a law were on the docket that keeps people from covering their faces for a secular reasons (identification of bank robbers), certainly the topic of Muslims' rights to wear a burka as part of their religion most certainly should be considered. Despite the fact that there is a secular reason to pass a law.

IF a law passes, someone sues because they feel their Constitutional rights have been violated (I wouldn't doubt this would happen pretty damned quickly in San Fran if it does get passed,) the court will then review the case. And more than quite a few times throughout the history of the US, the Supreme Court overrules a law that gets passed, because it violates some aspect of the Constitution, such as religion, free speech, right to bear arms, freedom of press, and etc.



By definition, removing a part of the body violates the integrity of the body. Integrity, as in "The quality or condition of being whole or undivided; completeness." Religious or not, this is not a matter of viewpoint.

You said "violate," not "integrity." I know it is a matter of viewpoint, which is exactly my point. A matter of viewpoint is not a reason to ban something. Just because you view something one way, doesn't mean people don't view it differently. Personal opinions on such shouldn't matter when deciding whether a law is justifiable or not.



By removing the cost of a completely unnecessary procedure. I'm amazed that anybody could be stupid enough to suggest that not doing circumcisions would cost more than doing them.

Apparently you must not know how bad the American health care system is, then. :D

In any case, that wasn't the argument. The argument was against lawsuits....adding more tort....to a health system that is already over-loaded, and over-taxed with tort to the point that the system is crippled because of it.



That will, of course, be a major factor in enforcing the law. Doctors who refuse to carry out illegal procedures do not need to insure themselves against the results of carrying out those illegal procedures. Therefore, no additional malpractice insurance is needed for doctors who observe the law.

Theoretically that is how you would think it works. Unfortunately, it doesn't work that way realistically.

IRL, the more excuses you add for lawsuits, typically the higher insurance premiums will rise. It doesn't matter whether or not any individual doctor decides not to perform an illegal procedure. Insurance companies will view it as an additional risk that some doctors might perform an illegal procedure if it is already widely practiced, and for religious purposes.



It won't allow more lawsuits, because malpractice lawsuits are already allowed. If circumcisions are illegal, then any lawsuits against doctors in respect of malpractice surrounding circumcision will be more easily resolved, because fault has already been established against the doctor. Therefore, the cost of lawsuits will be reduced.

How won't it allow for more lawsuits? If a new thing is illegal, it gives more chances for lawsuits and potentially criminal charges and fines being brought against the practitioner. It wouldn't necessarily be "more easily resolved" either. Doctors could very well fight a decision, if they are so inclined. and just because fault is more readily established, does not mean the costs of the penalty against the doctor will be less, which doesn't make much sense. Because if there is no financial penalty against doctors for performing a procedure currently, it is mathematically impossible for a financial penalty to be "less than zero," once a ban passes.



As has been repeatedly explained to you and you have repeatedly refused to acknowledge, the practice is becoming less common and is only rarely done for religious purposes.

It hasn't been pointed out that it is "rarely done for religious purposes." It has been pointed out that it isn't as widely practiced for religious purposes as I originally though.

But no matter how widespread or rare the practice is done for religious purposes, the fact of the matter is, it is still done for religious purposes. Minorities have equal rights under the law too.

5 and 6 I won't bother to reply to. Protecting the weakest in society should not be avoided because of the inconvenience of punishing those who infringe the relevant laws.

Dave

Fair enough. But I still think that in reality, repeat offenders may still end up in prison. The US is a prison-happy nation. Even more so than china. :eek:
 
It's meant to protect them, for example, against having bits cut off their bodies against their will.

It is also meant to protect parent's rights to rear their children up as well.



No, I said "making an incision". An incision can be made by slicing or by stabbing.

True. I can accept it is immoral, then. Still shouldn't be banned, because of the religious aspect. And to keep society out of private affairs.


If someone else witnessed a father stabbing his newborn baby in the arm with a scalpel, would you say that criminal charges were impossible because the parents had not instigated them? Or would you admit that a baby has the same protection of law, even against its parents, as any other member of society?

Please note that there have been depressingly many cases of parents being prosecuted for assaults on their own children.

You are creeping back into the realm of using more extreme hypotheticals.

In the case of doing undue harm to a child, yes it should be a criminal act. But we are not talking about undue harm. We are talking about a religious practice which will not affect the life of the person. (At this point, I would say we may have to agree to disagree. I think we have pretty mcuh finally met at the middle here.)



And there's the special pleading fallacy again. Because just simply cutting a bit off the end of someone's penis for no reason doesn't make any sense, and is just dumb.

But the entire point is, circumcision is not for "no reason." You may think it is in your non-religious, atheistic mind. But in the minds of those who have a right to practice a religion how they want, it's a perfectly reasonable act.

OK, on to the next question. Do you think it should be illegal to stab a baby in the arm if your religion says you have to do it?

Already been over this with the earlobe thing, which was an even more difficult question than this. I ended up saying "I would find the cutting off of earlobes to be strange and repugnant, but so long as the earlobe serve no function, and does not affect any aspect of the kids life at all, and is a religious practice, who am I to say it shouldn't be done? It ain't my kid, and ain't my religion. They have the First Amendment same as I do." Paraphrased, of course.

Actually, that one isn't worth asking, because you've already answered it. You've said that, if your religion says it's OK, you should be allowed to stab a baby in the arm. I'll let everyone else in the thread form their own conclusions on the moral condition of someone who can make a statement like that.

You said it, not me. And nice twist of words. Because you originally didn't say "stab," first of all. And just the way you state it, was framed in such a way as to produce a negative image in someone's mind, taking it out of context with such a particular choice of words.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Framing_(social_sciences) ;)

Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman have shown that framing can affect the outcome (ie. the choices one makes) of choice problems, to the extent that several of the classic axioms of rational choice do not hold.[6] This led to the development of prospect theory as an alternative to rational choice theory.[7].


Let me just remind you what you said.



So you honestly believe that stabbing a baby in the arm obviously isn't a criminal action if your religion says it's OK.

Do I really need to say any more?

Dave

Originally, you said "incision." Now you use the word "stabbing." I do believe this is the same problem as using the word "mutilation," which can mean anything from one extreme to another.

If a religious view were to "stab" a kid in an arm, yes it should be illegal. If they were to perform a certain "incision" into an arm, no it should not. It all depends on the severity. "Stabbing" is too broad a term to determine anything about the severity of said religious practice.
 
So you, who believe stabbing babies in the name of religion is morally acceptable, are comparing everyone who disagrees with you to Holocaust deniers? Is that a variant on Godwin's Law?

Dave

Now you're just plain trolling. You are now scratching and clawing at anything, going so far as to take things out of context, and place words in my mouth that I did not speak. Or rather, words on the screen I did not type. Would have been better to criticize what is written, rather than speculate on what I say.
 
Basically, you know this mutilation is a bad idea, yet your priest is hell-bent on cutting your child's willie.
You are conflicted.
Consider the lack of benefit to the child.
And the motives of the priest.
 
IRL, the more excuses you add for lawsuits, typically the higher insurance premiums will rise. It doesn't matter whether or not any individual doctor decides not to perform an illegal procedure. Insurance companies will view it as an additional risk that some doctors might perform an illegal procedure if it is already widely practiced, and for religious purposes.

Surely any insurance company would take the opportunity to refuse to pay out on the basis that the circumcision was illegal. I can't believe insurance companies will voluntary insure doctors against performing illegal operations. :eek:
 
Is it also peoples' Constitutional right to follow Deuteronomy 21:18? Or is that a religiously mandated imperative that should be prohibited by law?

I highly suggest you go back and read this entire thread, instead of jumping into the middle of a conversation after that horse has been thoroughly and completely mashed apart, and ground up in a meat grinder. :mad::rolleyes::eye-poppi:jaw-dropp:covereyes:boggled:
 
Basically, you know this mutilation is a bad idea, yet your priest is hell-bent on cutting your child's willie.
You are conflicted.
Consider the lack of benefit to the child.
And the motives of the priest.

:rolleyes: I said I was on the fence a long time ago, and still am about the idea of the actual act of circumcision. I couldn't care one way or the other whether a parent decides to have it done or not.

What I do care about is the Constitution. I dunno about people from other countries, but Americans take this one particular document form our history to heart.
 
Surely any insurance company would take the opportunity to refuse to pay out on the basis that the circumcision was illegal. I can't believe insurance companies will voluntary insure doctors against performing illegal operations. :eek:

I have no idea how insurance works. Even less so about mal-practice insurance. I have no idea what is in the contract that doctors sign when they get the insurance, and whether or not they have to pay out for illegal operations. So I give you a point there.

The question now becomes: Are insurance companies held liable to pay out, or does it depend on what insurance company it is, and what they include in there coverage? Are there insurance companies that specify they can refuse claims for doctors who performed an illegal operation? I honestly have no idea how it works.

I assume for something as wide-spread as circumcision, the cannot really be enforced over night. They would probably have to specify a certain date for when the practice must end. I am sure there would be a lawsuit in court the very next day if a ban got passed anyway.
 
Basically, you know this mutilation is a bad idea, yet your priest is hell-bent on cutting your child's willie.
You are conflicted.
Consider the lack of benefit to the child.
And the motives of the priest.


I don't know that we've been shown any evidence that the priest is hell-bet on doing anything. All we've seen is Nihilianth ignorantly asserting that circumcision is normal Christian practice, in flagrant disregard of the Council of Jerusalem and actual practice down the ages, and then revealing that his church no longer prohibits it and IF a parent asks the priest he won't tell them not to do it.

This is purely a local, social custom, which Nihilianth has misinterpreted as being religious and universal.

Rolfe.
 
There's a tribe who initiates boys into manhood by splitting their penis right down the underside from the outside to the urethra. Nothing is removed, would you call that mutilation?

I know a couple uncut guys, they're very happy their parents didn't decide to alter their genitals without their consent.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom