Nihilianth
Illuminator
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2011
- Messages
- 3,851
I know you have used it - which is rather my point in mentioning it.
Personally I prefer to use labels which are meaningful in their context, so in a thread say about religious practises I might use the word "circumcision" to refer to male genital mutilation since that would be appropriate in such context. However when we are actually discussing the procedure of circumcision itself I prefer to use a phrase that is more accurate so that's why "male genital mutilation" is an appropriate term in this thread.
http://www.medterms.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=2739 said:Circumcision: Surgery that removes the foreskin (the loose tissue) covering the glans of the penis. Circumcision may be performed for religious or cultural reasons, or health reasons. Newborn circumcision diminishes the risk for cancer of the penis and lowers the risk for cancer of the cervix in sexual partners. It also decreases the risk of urinary tract infections and lowers the risk of sexually transmitted diseases, including especially HIV.
The Latin "circum-" means around (or about). Circumcision is, literally, a cutting around. Circumcision dates back to prehistoric times. It is one of the oldest surgical operations known to have been performed by people.
http://mw4.m-w.com/dictionary/circumcised said:Definition of CIRCUMCISE
transitive verb
1
: to cut off the foreskin of (a male) or the prepuce of (a female)
2
: to cut off all or part of the external genitalia and especially the clitoris and labia minora of (a female)
— cir·cum·cis·er noun
That is VERY specific. It is the cutting off of the male foreskin, and the female prepuce in definition number one.
Let's look at "mutilation" once again, this time with Merriam Webster only:
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mutilate said:Definition of MUTILATE
transitive verb
1
: to cut up or alter radically so as to make imperfect <the child mutilated the book with his scissors>
2
: to cut off or permanently destroy a limb or essential part of : cripple
— mu·ti·la·tion noun
— mu·ti·la·tor noun
See mutilate defined for Engli
Not so specific. Mutilation can range anywhere form a child using a scissors on paper, to circumcision.
But you say "male genital mutilation." Again, according to definition number two, it says rather vaguely: "to cut off or permanently destroy a limb or essential part of: cripple."
Well, we all know circumcision certainly doesn't CRIPPLE someone. You could say "it destroys" part of the penis. But the rest of the definition of "mutilation" makes the term too broad for efficient communication, when you ask the question: "Do you think it's ok to mutilate a child's penis?"
Interestingly the phrase "genital mutilation" really does seem a stumbling block for some folk but only when it is applied to such procedures being carried out on males - they are quite happy to use it when applied to female genital mutilation. In my view that struggling to accept an accurate description demonstrates the cognitive dissonance that is felt when condemning one but not the other.
This doesn't apply to me, since I have yet to use the term "female genital mutilation." I am always, and only strictly, using the term "female circumcision."
I am truly not trying to be an ass. I truly do want to understand what is so bad about using the proper terminology? Why use terminology that is more vague, rather than terminology that is more specific? I honestly see no difference between saying "circumcision" in this discussion, compared to a doctor saying "right femoral artery" when discussing a blockage in a blood vessel.
I do kind of honestly and quite frankly liken people using the terminology "genital mutilation" to Holocaust deniers using the term "holohoax," because by using that term, it makes it seem as though they think they have something to prove, and are struggling. The media uses vague terminology as well, as do poorly-done surveys when asking a question. It is called "framing," and introduces too much bias.



