Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Someone mentioned having a foreskin during sex is like allowing your penis to fall asleep, and be sorta numb. I would think that would actually deaden the feeling of sex.

Quite the reverse in fact. You'll never know, though, will you?
 
All that this is proving is that you don't understand the First Amendment. Once again, it gives no protection to religious acts against laws that are framed with a secular purpose. There is therefore no Consitutional protection other than that against laws that are specifically intended to discriminate against a particular religion. The question of "exchange of freedoms" does not arise.

A law may pass. But once it does, the question of the First Amendment will certainly arise, and the Supreme Court usually will rule in favor of the plaintiff, if no benefits to society can be proven. once again, just because some, or many people practice something other than for religious purposes, doesn't mean that those who practice it specifically for religious purposes, cannot claim violation of their First Amendment.

In other words, look at the Smith case someone posted a long while back. That was a case in which a Native American sued for their religious right to smoke peyote, and getting fired and denied unemployment for doing the drug. The law was passed for secular reasons, and the VAST majority of people did drugs for secular reasons. And someone still sued over First Amendment, and the courts had a tough time of making a decision. In the end, it was decided that society benefits from denying Smith the case.

But since the First Amendment never came up when it was passed, as far as I know, it was much easier to pass it. With circumcision, the issue of First Amendment was brought up almost instantaneously when San Fran put the ban law on the docket, before it has even come up for a consideration to be voted upon.

But since you've shown repeatedly that you're incapable of understanding this point, I suppose we'll have to let it pass.

Apparently, you are quote mistaken with this. It appears you are looking into it too deeply. I can still be against the law getting passed, if I think it violates a Constitutional right. What if there were a secular reason to keep people from covering their face? Like in France, which just recently passed a law about that? But this isn't France. It is wrong to be against such a law, if I think it violates someone's constitutional right of religion? Hardly, I should think. Or else, laws would be getting passed which violates all sorts of constitutional rights.


At last. OK, so you're admitting it is not morally acceptable to carry out this procedure without religious or medical reasons. You'll note, however, that this incision will heal completely and will not lead to any significant impairment of any function. Would you then deny that a circumcision done without religious reasons, which, whether or not it impairs function, will not heal completely, is even less morally acceptable?

Dave

I can accept this, yes. I wouldn't necessarily care one way or the other. But I can accept it. Unfortunately, that is not the case though. So I have no idea where you are going with this.
 
I was having a chat with my mother this morning as we talking about this and my mother said that circumcision in our home town when she was younger was broadly dependent on which denomination you belong to. So the Protestant lot didn't and the Catholics did. I wonder if this arose because of the reasons circumcision was introduced in recent times in countries like the USA and the UK (i.e. as a way to control male masturbation). In my view in the UK the RCers tended to be the ones much more interested in preaching about preventing sex in all its permutations bar one, so perhaps they pushed the idea more to their congregations?

Actually, this is probably why my diocese (The Diocese of Scranton. In Pennsylvania,) does it. I never sat in on any of the meetings with the priest, while he talked to parents about circumcision. So I dunno what exactly is said. I just remember the parish I grew up was big into doing circumcisions.
 
Good luck with trying to find legal support for carrying out circumcision as a religious requirement of Roman Catholicism.

Hint: you'll lose.

Rolfe.
 
Actually, this is probably why my diocese (The Diocese of Scranton. In Pennsylvania,) does it. I never sat in on any of the meetings with the priest, while he talked to parents about circumcision. So I dunno what exactly is said. I just remember the parish I grew up was big into doing circumcisions.

Probably something like "This procedure will stop young Nihilianth wanking himself blue when he gets older". You are probably a victim of religious sexual repression.
 
If you are so concerned about using the right words why do you not keep correcting people who say "female circumcision"?

I never corrected anyone for saying "female circumcision." In fact, I have used that term quite extensively throughout.

My question is, why aren't you concerned about using the correct terminology? Or why do you not see the problems associated with the terminology?

If someone earlier had not tried asking this question:

"Do you think genital mutilation of a baby boy is ok?" I probably wold not have been so insistent on using the correct terminology.

Do you at all so any problems with that question? I am just wondering. I would seriously like as good communication as we can possibly get. That is all I am concerned about.
 
I can accept this, yes. I wouldn't necessarily care one way or the other. But I can accept it. Unfortunately, that is not the case though. So I have no idea where you are going with this.

OK, so we've established that, all other things being equal, circumcision is morally less acceptable than stabbing a baby in the arm with a sterile scalpel. Now, do you think it should be a criminal offence to stab a baby in the arm with a sterile scalpel, and do you think that it is a criminal offence?

Dave
 
But since the First Amendment never came up when it was passed, as far as I know, it was much easier to pass it. With circumcision, the issue of First Amendment was brought up almost instantaneously when San Fran put the ban law on the docket, before it has even come up for a consideration to be voted upon.

This is not the way it works. There is no judicial review necessary for a bill to become a law. Didn't you watch Schoolhouse Rock?
 
I never corrected anyone for saying "female circumcision." In fact, I have used that term quite extensively throughout.

My question is, why aren't you concerned about using the correct terminology? Or why do you not see the problems associated with the terminology?

...snip...

I know you have used it - which is rather my point in mentioning it.

Personally I prefer to use labels which are meaningful in their context, so in a thread say about religious practises I might use the word "circumcision" to refer to male genital mutilation since that would be appropriate in such context. However when we are actually discussing the procedure of circumcision itself I prefer to use a phrase that is more accurate so that's why "male genital mutilation" is an appropriate term in this thread.

Interestingly the phrase "genital mutilation" really does seem a stumbling block for some folk but only when it is applied to such procedures being carried out on males - they are quite happy to use it when applied to female genital mutilation. In my view that struggling to accept an accurate description demonstrates the cognitive dissonance that is felt when condemning one but not the other.
 
1. The benefit that members of that society do not have healthy tissue, that cannot regenerate, unnecessarily removed from their bodies.
2. The freedom to maintain the integrity of one's own body, outweighing the freedom to violate the integrity of another person's body.
3. A fine, and the automatic assumption of liability in any resulting civil actions.
4. By making it clear that the law protects even the weakest in society, in the person of a newborn baby.
5. Since the immediate result of the ban would be that doctors would cease offering to carry out the practice, it's unlikely that there would be many offenders, and most of these could be sanctioned by a fine. However, in any case, the inconvenience of punishing offenders should not be a consideration in determining what actions should be illegal.
6. Since few, if any, incarcerations are envisaged, this question is irrelevant.

How are you getting on with determining the relative morality of circumcision, which won't heal up, with an unnecessary incision in the forearm, which will?

Dave

1. Secular reason. First Amendment question will still be raised, because it is not viewed as "unnecessarily removing" the skin.

2. Religious view: It does not violate the body. How does the baby's rights outweigh the parents to decide what is best for that baby?

3. A.How do you deal with a health care system that is the most expensive system by GDP in the world?
B. What about the already insane mal-practice insurance levels of practicing physicians....any doctor really?
C. How does allowing more lawsuits in the health system coincide with reducing health care costs, mainly tort reform? Tort is something which we are trying desperately to reduce. (Number three can open up a whole other can of worms.)

4. The law already does a good job of that. Unfortunately, handing out fines to new parents and doctors for performing a common practice that is done for religious purposes will only garner more disrespect for the law.

5. Not necessarily true. A likely hypothesis, and one that would probably be true. However, I think that the "inconvenience of punishing someone" for something that is not that big a deal, and is performed for religious purposes should be taken into consideration. May new laws that are debated in government, are all about how law-enforcement should enforce the law. How it should be funded. And whether or not the efforts of enforcing the law would yield a positive result in reducing an activity. This is especially true in the CJ system in the US. Terribly inefficient.

6. What about repeat offenders? You just keep fining them? Usually in the US, eventually you get progressively more severe punishments for every time you break the same law. When it comes to drugs, there's the "three strike" rule, which is BS. Too many misdemeanors can eventually land you in the slammer.
 
That's one of the weirdest things I've read on JREF. It's possibly born of blind ignorance about how sex happens with uncircumcised men, but definitely weird.

I thought so as well at the time. It's in one of the first ten pages, I think.
 
Quite the reverse in fact. You'll never know, though, will you?

Nope. But is it something which affects my life? Not at all. Again, you would need to do a survey to find out just how many uncircumcised men actually care one way or the other.

Seems to me, whoever came up with the idea of the ban in the OP, probably should have done some high-level research, and surveys. It just doesn't seem too well thought-out.
 
2. Religious view: It does not violate the body. How does the baby's rights outweigh the parents to decide what is best for that baby?

You're kidding right?

Anyway these circumcision threads always blow up. I think the feelings are particularly strong on both sides. Those that are intact are grabbing their junk and feeling like they are going to throw up over the idea of someone cutting on them. Those who are cut are desperate to convince themselves and the world that they haven't been damaged. Very strong emotions on both sides.

Personally I don't feel parents have the right to decide this for their children therefore I am in favor of a ban. When the child is old enough they can decide for themselves. How this stance could be considered anything but the default is a mystery to me.
 
OK, so we've established that, all other things being equal, circumcision is morally less acceptable than stabbing a baby in the arm with a sterile scalpel.

Yup. But the law the law isn't meant to enforce morality. It is meant to protect people and society, and their rights.

Now, do you think it should be a criminal offence to stab a baby in the arm with a sterile scalpel, and do you think that it is a criminal offence?

Dave

Now your saying "stab" the baby with a sterile scalpel. I should think stabbing would be a criminal offense. Earlier you said "slicing." In either case, if the parents press criminal charges, then yes, it should be a criminal offense. Otherwise, how would the law know? Someone would have to press charges.

In any case, just simply stabbing or slicing someone with a sterile scalpel for no reason doesn't make any sense, and is just dumb. If they did it for a religious reason, then obviously it isn't a criminal action. If they did it just to do it then sure.
 
This is not the way it works. There is no judicial review necessary for a bill to become a law. Didn't you watch Schoolhouse Rock?

Where did I say that? This is what I did say, with the context added:

me said:
But since the First Amendment never came up when [drug laws were] passed, as far as I know, it was much easier to pass [them]. With circumcision, the issue of First Amendment was brought up almost instantaneously when San Fran put the ban law on the docket, before it has even come up for a consideration to be voted upon.

And indeed, it has come up. Since it has come up, it will be much harder to pass, because people like to consider First Amendment issues themselves before allowing a law to go through. What does this have to do with judicial review?
 
1. Secular reason. First Amendment question will still be raised, because it is not viewed as "unnecessarily removing" the skin.

The First Amendment does not have the meaning you attach to it. If there is a secular reason for a law, this is not overridden by a religious objection; rather, the secular reason overrides the religious objection. This is the point that you have repeatedly shown either an inability or a disinclination to grasp.

2. Religious view: It does not violate the body.

By definition, removing a part of the body violates the integrity of the body. Integrity, as in "The quality or condition of being whole or undivided; completeness." Religious or not, this is not a matter of viewpoint.

3. A.How do you deal with a health care system that is the most expensive system by GDP in the world?

By removing the cost of a completely unnecessary procedure. I'm amazed that anybody could be stupid enough to suggest that not doing circumcisions would cost more than doing them.

B. What about the already insane mal-practice insurance levels of practicing physicians....any doctor really?

That will, of course, be a major factor in enforcing the law. Doctors who refuse to carry out illegal procedures do not need to insure themselves against the results of carrying out those illegal procedures. Therefore, no additional malpractice insurance is needed for doctors who observe the law.

C. How does allowing more lawsuits in the health system coincide with reducing health care costs, mainly tort reform? Tort is something which we are trying desperately to reduce. (Number three can open up a whole other can of worms.)

It won't allow more lawsuits, because malpractice lawsuits are already allowed. If circumcisions are illegal, then any lawsuits against doctors in respect of malpractice surrounding circumcision will be more easily resolved, because fault has already been established against the doctor. Therefore, the cost of lawsuits will be reduced.

4. The law already does a good job of that. Unfortunately, handing out fines to new parents and doctors for performing a common practice that is done for religious purposes will only garner more disrespect for the law.

As has been repeatedly explained to you and you have repeatedly refused to acknowledge, the practice is becoming less common and is only rarely done for religious purposes.

5 and 6 I won't bother to reply to. Protecting the weakest in society should not be avoided because of the inconvenience of punishing those who infringe the relevant laws.

Dave
 
Yup. But the law the law isn't meant to enforce morality. It is meant to protect people and society, and their rights.

It's meant to protect them, for example, against having bits cut off their bodies against their will.

Now your saying "stab" the baby with a sterile scalpel. I should think stabbing would be a criminal offense. Earlier you said "slicing."

No, I said "making an incision". An incision can be made by slicing or by stabbing.

In either case, if the parents press criminal charges, then yes, it should be a criminal offense. Otherwise, how would the law know? Someone would have to press charges.

If someone else witnessed a father stabbing his newborn baby in the arm with a scalpel, would you say that criminal charges were impossible because the parents had not instigated them? Or would you admit that a baby has the same protection of law, even against its parents, as any other member of society?

Please note that there have been depressingly many cases of parents being prosecuted for assaults on their own children.

In any case, just simply stabbing or slicing someone with a sterile scalpel for no reason doesn't make any sense, and is just dumb.

And there's the special pleading fallacy again. Because just simply cutting a bit off the end of someone's penis for no reason doesn't make any sense, and is just dumb.

OK, on to the next question. Do you think it should be illegal to stab a baby in the arm if your religion says you have to do it?

Actually, that one isn't worth asking, because you've already answered it. You've said that, if your religion says it's OK, you should be allowed to stab a baby in the arm. I'll let everyone else in the thread form their own conclusions on the moral condition of someone who can make a statement like that.

Let me just remind you what you said.

If they did it for a religious reason, then obviously it isn't a criminal action.

So you honestly believe that stabbing a baby in the arm obviously isn't a criminal action if your religion says it's OK.

Do I really need to say any more?

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom