Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Circumcision was introduced outside the Jewish community in America for reasons concerned primarily with perceived improvements in hygeine and suppression of masturbation.quote]

Doesn't matter. They can still claim religious freedom and protections.

And the limits of the protection afforded by the First Amendment have been explained to you ad nauseam;

No, they have not. There were many examples (far too many!) of hypotheticals, what-ifs, and terrible comparison. I mean, at one point, someone tried comparing removing an arm from a child, to cutting off a piece of skin! I mean, come on!

In any case, I have explained ad naseum, that of course there are limitations in the Constitution. That is true of every freedom afforded to us! For example, you cannot yell fire in a crowded theater, despite the First Amendment. Doesn't mean you can take away the right to criticize what a corporation does just because you can take away the right to yell "FIRE!" which is exactly what people are doing in their ridiculous comparisons in this thread. Slippery slope argument at it's finest, if you ask me.

To be fair, I have yet to see you make such a terrible comparison, so you're fine. :)

if there is an acceptable secular purpose for the law banning a practice, then the law is constitutional regardless of the religious nature of the practice.

Right. But the law banning the practice also must protect other freedoms of other people, and society must benefit from said law. In other words, you cannot have an equal exchange of freedoms, calling for the banning of a practice that is Constitutionally protected. I just don't see the two argument presented here as coming close to equaling parents right of consent, and freedom of religion. And certainly society doesn't really benefit from such a ban. If anything, it can be shown that society would be terribly hurt by the ban.

And circumcision, by your own admission, removes the right from an individual to decide whether or not to be circumcised, and causes undue harm by the dictionary definition of the word "harm".

The first part, yes. That is exactly what I am saying, and is one of the only legitimate arguments you have on your side. But it's still rather weak, because minors don't have a right to say "no" to an operation under a certain age. That's the parent's right. When they get a little older where they can actually speak well enough even though they are still under age, it is encouraged that the child takes part in the decision process as well.

The second part, I never said "it causes undue harm." Harm, in the definition I provided, is a pretty subjective term. And certainly, removing a flab of skin doesn't cause UNDUE harm.

So, let's get back to those questions. Do you consider it morally acceptable to make a quarter-inch incision in the forearm of a newborn baby, using a sterile scalpel, for no religious or medical reason whatsoever?

Dave

No. Not really. There is no reason to do such an incision, so long as it has nothing to do with religious or medical reasons.
 
Again I ask:

can we at least all agree that female genital mutilation is MUCH more dangerous and damaging than male circumcision?
 
To be pedantic, you wouldn't need a surgeon for that. Pretty much any MD can be trained to take care of such a minor operation.

True. So long as the person is trained and competent in doing the procedure. They should therefore, have some sort of license to perform the operation. I see no problem with such a regulation.
 
They are both on the evil scale, even if one is much more evil than the other.

lesser evil is still evil.

no, male circumcision is not "evil".

"Evil" suggests maliscious or sadistic intent. "Evil" suggests an intent to cause harm.

Jews and Muslims do not circumcise their baby boys in order to cause them harm.

.....that is, unless you are a Jew-hater and a Muslim-hater, and think we cut foreskin for reasons of schadenfreude.
 
Last edited:
no, male circumcision is not "evil".

"Evil" suggests maliscious or sadistic intent. "Evil" suggests an intent to cause harm.

Jews and Muslims do not circumcise their baby boys in order to cause them harm.

.....that is, unless you are a Jew-hater and a Muslim-hater, and think we cut foreskin for reasons of schadenfreude.

Hell is paved with good intention.

One can do evil without malicious intention, without intending to do harm, ETA: by perpetuating an harmful act without malicious intention for example.

Muslims MOSTLY do not circumcise their baby girls in order to cause them harm (it is actually mostly a social act, only in minority of the case the "prevent girl having pleasure" is cited).

but it still does.

I can find many more example if you wish.

ETA: Oh, and by the way it is I think quite well documented that in the USA historically it was done to prevent pleasuring masturbation in boy. So here you go : evil.
 
Last edited:
Right. But the law banning the practice also must protect other freedoms of other people, and society must benefit from said law. In other words, you cannot have an equal exchange of freedoms, calling for the banning of a practice that is Constitutionally protected.

All that this is proving is that you don't understand the First Amendment. Once again, it gives no protection to religious acts against laws that are framed with a secular purpose. There is therefore no Consitutional protection other than that against laws that are specifically intended to discriminate against a particular religion. The question of "exchange of freedoms" does not arise.

But since you've shown repeatedly that you're incapable of understanding this point, I suppose we'll have to let it pass.

Dave Rogers said:
So, let's get back to those questions. Do you consider it morally acceptable to make a quarter-inch incision in the forearm of a newborn baby, using a sterile scalpel, for no religious or medical reason whatsoever?
No. Not really. There is no reason to do such an incision, so long as it has nothing to do with religious or medical reasons.

At last. OK, so you're admitting it is not morally acceptable to carry out this procedure without religious or medical reasons. You'll note, however, that this incision will heal completely and will not lead to any significant impairment of any function. Would you then deny that a circumcision done without religious reasons, which, whether or not it impairs function, will not heal completely, is even less morally acceptable?

Dave
 
...snip...

hint for you : catholic don't do circumcision for religious reason, but out of cultural reason.

The right of consent is limited, and no you can't do anything you want on your kid.

...snip...

I was having a chat with my mother this morning as we talking about this and my mother said that circumcision in our home town when she was younger was broadly dependent on which denomination you belong to. So the Protestant lot didn't and the Catholics did. I wonder if this arose because of the reasons circumcision was introduced in recent times in countries like the USA and the UK (i.e. as a way to control male masturbation). In my view in the UK the RCers tended to be the ones much more interested in preaching about preventing sex in all its permutations bar one, so perhaps they pushed the idea more to their congregations?
 
Again I ask:

can we at least all agree that female genital mutilation is MUCH more dangerous and damaging than male circumcision?

No as it depends on exactly what you mean by female genital cutting; it covers a much broader range of procedures whilst male genital cutting in countries like the USA & the UK is only used to describe one type of mutilation.
 
You are in a culture where circumcision , is so much viewed as normal, that you were done it even if you are catholic, catholic which normally DO NOT do circumcision. That is what was meant with too involved. You are unable to think of your own cultural box.

That would only be true if something were done to me everyday, or something I have thought long and hard about, and is the very fabric of my cultural identity. Like apple pie, baseball, or the Constitution.

Circumcision has honestly only crossed my mind maybe a handful of times in my life. And then I never really dwelt on it whatsoever.



1) *YOU* keep going back to specific name of circumcision but the fact is that it is a medically unnecessary removal of perfectly healthy and functional tissue. That make it a mutilation in my book. A mutilation is the removal of perfectly healthy and functional tissue. Does not matter it is only a small bit.

Making several words bolded and repeating them doesn't make the word "mutilation" any less ambiguous. The problem, for about the 50th time, is that is that, according to your subjective definition, "mutilation" can be anywhere from a minor pinprick, up to total, and absolute annihilation of a body.

The reason why I am so insistent on using the technical, and clinical term is simply because someone earlier had asked the yes/no rhetorical question "so, you think mutilation is ok then?"

And you never answered my question. What is so wrong about using a technical term that shouldn't have any biased meaning? What are you afraid of? It shouldn't be any worse than a pitcher calling for a cutting fastball, or a mechanic asking someone to hand them a 3/4 inch monkey wrench.

2) if you had no people on ignore you would have read on type 1A or type 1B female circumcision

They were being less than mature, constantly asking too many hypotheticals, and refusing to recognize where and how those situations they were proposing were wrong. It was simply easier to just put them on ignore, rather than waste my time.

People cutting other people arm don't affect me either. But that is not a suffisent reason to let other people do it to their kids.

No, but that is not what we are talking about. We are talking about a Constitutional issue. Just because you find something morally repugnant, doesn't mean we shouldn't consider the full scope of the situation, and it should be banned. Look up the recent Supreme Court victory for the disgusting Fred Phelps clan.


Such survey has already been done on people having it removed at adulthood. There are a lot of confounding factor because the surgery is complicated, but the bottom line is that the pleasure was lower *after* the removal. Still no conclusion can be done due to the predominance of the confounding factor.

There is no conclusion, because you cannot do a before/after study. Correlation is not causation. It is merely a strong indication that there is a loss in "some" feeling. But there is no indication that there is no loss of feeling during the act of sex, which is what matters most.

Someone mentioned having a foreskin during sex is like allowing your penis to fall asleep, and be sorta numb. I would think that would actually deaden the feeling of sex.



It does not matter if it is begnin. Removal of the ear is also begnin. Would you allow it ?

I've already answered that question three times.

The bottom line is that it is medically unnecessary, and frankly not done for the reason you think it was done, as repeated to you over and over. maybe you should do your own research as to why circumcision came to be so widespread in the US ?

Once again, it does not matter how many people may do it for other reasons, or no reason at all. The fact of the matter is, there are people who can still sue and claim damages for violations of their First Amendment rights if a ban gets passed.

hint for you : catholic don't do circumcision for religious reason, but out of cultural reason.

This is why I put them on ignore. Hint for you: It happens in my diocese.

The right of consent is limited, and no you can't do anything you want on your kid.

Ummm....what? The right of consent is not limited. What are you talking about? And nobody ever said "you can do what you want to your kid." nice try. Another reason why I have three people on ignore.




There is functionality removed. Pleasuring functionality. You can live without it, but that does not mean it is a useless bit of skin. The ear lobe is also without functionality. Shall i remove yours ?

This is just dumb. Sorry, but it is. Once again, there is no conclusive evidence showing the first part is true. And the second part was just plain dumb.



I find it unacceptable that some individual out of aesthetic, religious or even cultural reason think they have the right to do irreversible unnecessary surgery on their children. The children have a human given right to have their body left intact until they allowed as adult to do whatever aesthetic or cultural modification they wish.

I also find it unacceptable that some individual group goes out to soldier's funerals, and yell "GOD HATES FAGS!" when the family only gets one chance at peacefully burying their young son. Does that mean we just take away the First Amendment right of free speech, just because we find it morally repugnant?

Sure they ahev the right to consent but it should be only if the operation is necessary since the child cannot ask for it himself. Note the word in bold.

yeah, I see the bold. And have no idea why it is bolded.

you keep saying that parent should be allowed any aesthetic or cultural surgical removal as long as the tissue is non vital. I say the children should be the one left with the choice as adult.

Cultural and aesthetic surgery is not protected under the First Amendment. I have no idea why you keep using those words. I am defending the First Amendment, which has nothing to do with culture or aesthetics. Hint: Google "First Amendment."

And i am glad you confuse patriotism with cultural stubbornness.

Be glad that slavery is now forbidden in the US, otherwise person like you would support it out of "patriotism".

Ummm....what? Non sequitur if I ever heard one.
 
My parents were told by their doctor to circumcise for sanitation reasons -- reducing the risk of infection.
My parents have also informed me that, as the medical consensus has changed, their choice today might be different.
 
My parents were told by their doctor to circumcise for sanitation reasons -- reducing the risk of infection.
My parents have also informed me that, as the medical consensus has changed, their choice today might be different.

I can well believe that, we can see that even today it is still a common myth.
 
Again I ask:

can we at least all agree that female genital mutilation is MUCH more dangerous and damaging than male circumcision?

Which type of FGM? Is Type 1a which is only the removal of the clitoral hood much more dangerous and damaging then male circumcision?
 
...snip...

The reason why I am so insistent on using the technical, and clinical term is simply because someone earlier had asked the yes/no rhetorical question "so, you think mutilation is ok then?"

...snip...

If you are so concerned about using the right words why do you not keep correcting people who say "female circumcision"?
 
It has been pointed out to you that there is substantial evidence that circumcision diminishes the sensitivity of the penis. I am not saying that it makes the penis go completely numb and removes all feeling whatsoever.

Do you deny that feeling pleasure is a function of the penis?

I understand what you are saying. No, I do not deny that pleasure is a function of the penis. (Actually, pleasure is a function of the brain, not the penis. The function of the penis is to send the pleasure signals to our brain, and to make more babies. But no need to get technical, I guess.)

I do not intend to ever talk about the function of the penis, but people keep bringing it up, and so I keep saying: The fact of the matter is, there is no indication that pleasure is diminished during the act of sex. It may be more pleasurable during foreplay. But no evidence that it is during the peak of sexual activity.

Even so, sex is still pretty damned pleasurable. Do you deny that it is still intensely pleasurable for those who have been circumcised?



I have the following argument to propose (here I go with that darn logic stuff again):

1. If an action inflicts pain on an infant, and that action serves no substantial benefit, then it is immoral.
2. Circumcision inflicts pain and provides no substantial benefit.
C. Therefore, circumcision is immoral.

#1 is pretty obvious, and you've already conceded #2 (unless you're denying that circumcision is painful). So would you agree that circumcision is immoral?

I sit on the fence about the moral issue of circumcision. And certainly I have never said otherise when it comes to pain. In fact, I never commented on that, because I KNOW it causes pain. Intense pain. Even if it is anesthetized. But for a newborn, the pain goes away pretty quickly, and is forgotten just as quickly, never to be remembered. (Never a good excuse to inflict pain, I admit.)

But as for morality is concerned, that is not what the courts will decide on if it does get passed. In fact, if that is your main argument, the Courts will wonder how such a law got passed to begin with, and will be struck down. It is incredibly difficult, if not impossible, to pass a law based solely on morality now.

Also, you want to talk about benefits of the law? How about we cover each aspect? You seem to want to focus questions at me all of the time, when I am not the one that wants a ban to be passed. Rather, questions should be focused the other way:

Many issues I have here, most of which I will probably forget te place in this post, but have been asked, but conveniently avoided like the plague:

1. What benefits TO SOCIETY do you propose a ban will have?
2. What freedoms to an individual do you propose will be greater than the freedom taken from another individual?
3. What punishment do you plan on implementing if the ban gets violated?
4. How does this foster respect for the law?
5. If criminalized, where do you propose jailing offenders? Or do we dip into educational and infrastructure funds just to build more jails?
6. Do you know the fraction of inmates who are there rightfully for violent crimes? ("War on Drugs" problem. Prohibition as a historical example.)

The point is, no ban can ever pass, if these basic questions remain unanswered. Thus far, questions 1, 3, 4, 5, and 6 keep getting ignored. It is very important you establish many more reasons than have been given here. So far, the only reasonable reason for the ban, is that of the question over "who should decide?" about circumcision. That is something the courts should handle if someone gets sued over this law. But you must pass the ban, before it ever gets that far.
 
They are both on the evil scale, even if one is much more evil than the other.

lesser evil is still evil.

Doesn't matter if you view it as evil. Other people don't. That is not the purpose of law and order anyway.

I view the WBC as an evil group. But I wouldn't dream of taking away their Freedom of Speech.
 
Thunder;6955493 Jews and Muslims do not circumcise their baby boys in order to cause them harm. [/quote said:
I'm sure they don't mean to, but they do nonetheless. The benefits of the foreskin are well understood, it isn't a useless piece of skin as some are suggesting. Take a look at this, Thunder. What do you think?
 
Many issues I have here, most of which I will probably forget te place in this post, but have been asked, but conveniently avoided like the plague:

1. What benefits TO SOCIETY do you propose a ban will have?
2. What freedoms to an individual do you propose will be greater than the freedom taken from another individual?
3. What punishment do you plan on implementing if the ban gets violated?
4. How does this foster respect for the law?
5. If criminalized, where do you propose jailing offenders? Or do we dip into educational and infrastructure funds just to build more jails?
6. Do you know the fraction of inmates who are there rightfully for violent crimes? ("War on Drugs" problem. Prohibition as a historical example.)

1. The benefit that members of that society do not have healthy tissue, that cannot regenerate, unnecessarily removed from their bodies.
2. The freedom to maintain the integrity of one's own body, outweighing the freedom to violate the integrity of another person's body.
3. A fine, and the automatic assumption of liability in any resulting civil actions.
4. By making it clear that the law protects even the weakest in society, in the person of a newborn baby.
5. Since the immediate result of the ban would be that doctors would cease offering to carry out the practice, it's unlikely that there would be many offenders, and most of these could be sanctioned by a fine. However, in any case, the inconvenience of punishing offenders should not be a consideration in determining what actions should be illegal.
6. Since few, if any, incarcerations are envisaged, this question is irrelevant.

How are you getting on with determining the relative morality of circumcision, which won't heal up, with an unnecessary incision in the forearm, which will?

Dave
 
Someone mentioned having a foreskin during sex is like allowing your penis to fall asleep, and be sorta numb. I would think that would actually deaden the feeling of sex.

That's one of the weirdest things I've read on JREF. It's possibly born of blind ignorance about how sex happens with uncircumcised men, but definitely weird.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom