
"Too involved?" In circumcision? Really? How many times in my life have I talked about circumcision? Certainly I have used that word probably no less than 100 times more often here, than I have ever used it up to this point combined. So there goes that accusation.
You are in a culture where circumcision , is so much viewed as normal, that you were done it even if you are catholic, catholic which normally DO NOT do circumcision. That is what was meant with too involved. You are unable to think of your own cultural box.
I don't prefer any other term. What is so hard to say "circumcision?" Is that somehow a scary term that doesn't express your subjective disgust of the act well enough? Does it help your arguments to constantly use alternative terms that are too ambiguous for simple yes/no questions to be anything other than a lie? And why do you insist on constantly bringing up female circumcision, if you do not provide any evidence whatsoever that it is equally as safe, and equally as risky as male circumcision?
1) *YOU* keep going back to specific name of circumcision but the fact is that it is a medically
unnecessary removal of
perfectly healthy and
functional tissue. That make it a mutilation in my book. A mutilation is the removal of perfectly healthy and functional tissue. Does not matter it is only a small bit.
2) if you had no people on ignore you would have read on type 1A or type 1B female circumcision
This affects you and that kid....how exactly?
People cutting other people arm don't affect me either. But that is not a suffisent reason to let other people do it to their kids.
Perhaps you want to do a whole survey yourself, specifying your methods, and publishing the results in a peer-reviewed journal about how many men wish to have it taken back, and how badly it affected their lives? Or at least, find me such a survey.
Such survey has already been done on people having it removed at adulthood. There are a lot of confounding factor because the surgery is complicated, but the bottom line is that the pleasure was lower *after* the removal. Still no conclusion can be done due to the predominance of the confounding factor.
Parents have the right to consent for children under 16. They have the right to raise their kid up in their religion. The fixation of the benign part, is to keep people from saying "it isn't right to surgically remove an arm for religious reasons."
It does not matter if it is begnin. Removal of the ear is also begnin. Would you allow it ? The bottom line is that it is medically unnecessary, and frankly not done for the reason you think it was done, as repeated to you over and over. maybe you should do your own research as to why circumcision came to be so widespread in the US ?
hint for you : catholic don't do circumcision for religious reason, but out of cultural reason.
The right of consent is limited, and no you can't do anything you want on your kid.
There is no functionality being removed. And your morals are not any one else's morals. If you want your 12 year old daughter in by 5PM, doesn't mean other parents have to follow suit.
There is functionality removed. Pleasuring functionality. You can live without it, but that does not mean it is a useless bit of skin. The ear lobe is also without functionality. Shall i remove yours ?
Personally, I find it morally unacceptable that people seem to think they have some God-given right to step in on how parents are raising their children, and tell them "you're doing it wrong!"
I find it unacceptable that some individual out of aesthetic, religious or even cultural reason think they have the right to do irreversible unnecessary surgery on their children. The children have a
human given right to have their body left intact until they allowed as adult to do whatever
aesthetic or cultural modification they wish.
Nope. Never said that, either. What I am saying is, the parents have the right to consent to an operation that is to be done on their child, and they have the right to raise their child how they wish, and must be done under a medical surgeon who has taken the Hypocratic Oath.
Sure they ahev the right to consent but it should be only if the operation is necessary since the child cannot ask for it
himself. Note the word in bold.
you keep saying that parent should be allowed any aesthetic or cultural surgical removal as long as the tissue is non vital. I say the children should be the one left with the choice as adult.
And i am glad you confuse patriotism with cultural stubbornness.
Be glad that slavery is now forbidden in the US, otherwise person like you would support it out of "patriotism".