Ban circumcision in San Fran???

This bit's important, otherwise the figures don't seem to make sense.




The stats quoted are percentages of the 66 cases where there were complications. Out of nearly 20,000 infants, that gives the 0.34%.

Not odds I'd fancy, for a procedure of purely ritual significance. But then, what do I know, I'm not a Jew I'm a Christian, and

WESTERN CHRISTIANS DON'T DO CIRCUMCISION AS A RELIGIOUS RITUAL.

Rolfe.

Yeah, but I was too lazy to copy/paste that part. At some point, folks either click on links or they don't. ;)

I was a Jew. I'm female and have no children, and no longer have the ability to reproduce. But I would never have subjected a son to the procedure. No way, no how. And I've attended the rite (Brit milah) several times.
 
The cirp.org page carries a wealth of information. You should read the page on Foreskin Sexual Function, Nihilianth. Happy to report from the statistics page:

The United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) released new statistics at the International AIDS 2010 conference in Vienna, Austria, that were obtained from SDI Health, a commercial source of medical statistics. The new statistics showed a steep drop in the number of circumcisions performed in the United States. The new data were presented by Charbel E. El Becheraoui, a CDC researcher.

The CDC data, reported by the New York Times, showed that the incidence of circumcision declined from 56 percent in 2006 to 32.5 percent in 2009. According to these statistics, non-circumcision or genital integrity has become the normal condition among newborn boys in the United States.
 
That's the source I found as well. I would give some consent to some regulations on ritualistic circumcisions.

Why would you want to regulate ritualistic circumcisions?

It seems that you are interfering with both the First Amendment and with parental rights!

Given that these are two major planks of your argument you seem to be defeating your own argument.

Probably, I wouldn't vote for any measure myself. But I am thinking of such regulations as: Having a licensed practicing surgeon present, and all necessary precautions must be taken during the ceremony.

Why would you need a surgeon present? Does MGM...er...circumcision pose any risks?
 
Here's the problem I'm having with the thread at this point:

The (let's call them) Pro-Circers keep saying that "circumcision doen't impede on penile functionality" but I'm not convinced. Yes, a circumcised penis works, but how do you know it works as well as it would if it were uncircumcised? Considering that we're talking about a procedure done at days of age, there is are before and after studies. Anything that would be a before and after study would have to be done on an adult, and that would defeat the purpose of the study.
 
Someone earlier in this thread posted the figures (and no, I'm not going to dive back into the mess looking for it) that approx. 115 males died from circ. complications every year. That's 115 too many, as far as I'm concerned.

in the entire planet Earth?
 
There is nothing in the Constitution which protects customs. Religion is specifically mentioned, however. If circumcision was completely just simply a secular custom, I would be far less inclined to continue with this conversation in defense of the custom. I would still say that it would be realistically HARDER to ban a long-held nonreligious custom than a newly established one. I would probably still lean towards not banning it, because there have to be better solutions than that. I would have to see the solutions of how to deal with Prohibition-like offenses as I have mentioned several times earlier. But I wouldn't necessarily be against a ban, either.

But the reality of circumcision is that it is a common religious rite, and is commonly thought of as a religious rite. The First Amendment protects freedom of religion. And in the context of this ENTIRE thread, I am talking about practices which do not step on other peoples' rights, or causing severe undue harm to another person.

Circumcision was introduced outside the Jewish community in America for reasons concerned primarily with perceived improvements in hygeine and suppression of masturbation. This is fairly well documented. And the limits of the protection afforded by the First Amendment have been explained to you ad nauseam; if there is an acceptable secular purpose for the law banning a practice, then the law is constitutional regardless of the religious nature of the practice. And circumcision, by your own admission, removes the right from an individual to decide whether or not to be circumcised, and causes undue harm by the dictionary definition of the word "harm".

So, let's get back to those questions. Do you consider it morally acceptable to make a quarter-inch incision in the forearm of a newborn baby, using a sterile scalpel, for no religious or medical reason whatsoever?

Dave
 
Last edited:
in the entire planet Earth?

USA, I assume. I found a number somewhere that estimated 117, but made the case that accurate numbers are hard to come by. It further assumed that the real numbers were underreported.

I can't judge the quality of that site, if anyone cares I'll try to dig out the link again.
 
The statistics Childlike Empress posted about the reduction in the popularity of circumcision in the USA are interesting. If well over half US boys are now uncircumcised, where does this leave the "I intend to mutilate my newborn baby boy so he won't be embarrassed or feel 'different' when he's older" argument?

Regarding the aesthetics, like so much else, it seems to be societal in context and very much in the eye of the beholder. The ancient Greeks (according the the wiki article) regarded a circumcised penis as repulsive.

Nihilianth is a laugh a minute. It's been shown time and time again that his religion does not practise ritual circumcision, or indeed circumcision for religious purposes at all. He seems to live in a society where circumcision is chosen for social and cultural reasons, among people connected to a Christian denomination which does not promote circumcision. Nevertheless he posts on and on about how it's acceptable if it's done "for religious reasons".

Judging by the number and range of the posts he isn't responding to, he now seems to have over half the posters in the thread on ignore.

Rolfe.
 
By this same argument, shouldn't we disallow parents to put braces on their kids to eliminate crooked teeth or gaps?
Here we have a medically-unnecessary, irreversible operation done for no good medical reason. Of course, if the kid wants to have the teeth corrected later in life, it's typically more difficult, more expensive, less effective and socially less accepted -- but by your argument, shouldn't kids have the choice as to whether their smile should grow naturally or be artificially mangled according to someone else's aesthetics?

Tooth growing in all direction have medical impact. I did not get a brace, I got an surgical operation later. So it is not a good argument, because the brace are not for the aesthetic, but also for the real danger of having teeth growing haywire disturbing your normal chewing or in my case mouth openning activity.
 
That's the source I found as well. I would give some consent to some regulations on ritualistic circumcisions. Probably, I wouldn't vote for any measure myself. But I am thinking of such regulations as: Having a licensed practicing surgeon present, and all necessary precautions must be taken during the ceremony.

To be pedantic, you wouldn't need a surgeon for that. Pretty much any MD can be trained to take care of such a minor operation.

USA, I assume. I found a number somewhere that estimated 117, but made the case that accurate numbers are hard to come by. It further assumed that the real numbers were underreported.

I can't judge the quality of that site, if anyone cares I'll try to dig out the link again.

This might be the study that the annual rates of death in the US from male circumcision come from.

It only links to the abstract, unfortunately, and I am no fit judge of medical studies.

http://www.mensstudies.com/content/b64n267w47m333x0/?p=488e687276f346699601a0275fc5827b&pi=2

This is the paper I mentioned last page, and like I've said, it's total nonsense. The author compares female and male infant mortality, and assumes that the relatively higher male mortality is entirely due to circumcision. The real numbers are far lower.
 
:rolleyes: "Too involved?" In circumcision? Really? How many times in my life have I talked about circumcision? Certainly I have used that word probably no less than 100 times more often here, than I have ever used it up to this point combined. So there goes that accusation.

You are in a culture where circumcision , is so much viewed as normal, that you were done it even if you are catholic, catholic which normally DO NOT do circumcision. That is what was meant with too involved. You are unable to think of your own cultural box.

I don't prefer any other term. What is so hard to say "circumcision?" Is that somehow a scary term that doesn't express your subjective disgust of the act well enough? Does it help your arguments to constantly use alternative terms that are too ambiguous for simple yes/no questions to be anything other than a lie? And why do you insist on constantly bringing up female circumcision, if you do not provide any evidence whatsoever that it is equally as safe, and equally as risky as male circumcision?

1) *YOU* keep going back to specific name of circumcision but the fact is that it is a medically unnecessary removal of perfectly healthy and functional tissue. That make it a mutilation in my book. A mutilation is the removal of perfectly healthy and functional tissue. Does not matter it is only a small bit.
2) if you had no people on ignore you would have read on type 1A or type 1B female circumcision


This affects you and that kid....how exactly?

People cutting other people arm don't affect me either. But that is not a suffisent reason to let other people do it to their kids.

Perhaps you want to do a whole survey yourself, specifying your methods, and publishing the results in a peer-reviewed journal about how many men wish to have it taken back, and how badly it affected their lives? Or at least, find me such a survey.

Such survey has already been done on people having it removed at adulthood. There are a lot of confounding factor because the surgery is complicated, but the bottom line is that the pleasure was lower *after* the removal. Still no conclusion can be done due to the predominance of the confounding factor.

Parents have the right to consent for children under 16. They have the right to raise their kid up in their religion. The fixation of the benign part, is to keep people from saying "it isn't right to surgically remove an arm for religious reasons."

It does not matter if it is begnin. Removal of the ear is also begnin. Would you allow it ? The bottom line is that it is medically unnecessary, and frankly not done for the reason you think it was done, as repeated to you over and over. maybe you should do your own research as to why circumcision came to be so widespread in the US ?

hint for you : catholic don't do circumcision for religious reason, but out of cultural reason.

The right of consent is limited, and no you can't do anything you want on your kid.


There is no functionality being removed. And your morals are not any one else's morals. If you want your 12 year old daughter in by 5PM, doesn't mean other parents have to follow suit.

There is functionality removed. Pleasuring functionality. You can live without it, but that does not mean it is a useless bit of skin. The ear lobe is also without functionality. Shall i remove yours ?

Personally, I find it morally unacceptable that people seem to think they have some God-given right to step in on how parents are raising their children, and tell them "you're doing it wrong!" :rolleyes:

I find it unacceptable that some individual out of aesthetic, religious or even cultural reason think they have the right to do irreversible unnecessary surgery on their children. The children have a human given right to have their body left intact until they allowed as adult to do whatever aesthetic or cultural modification they wish.

Nope. Never said that, either. What I am saying is, the parents have the right to consent to an operation that is to be done on their child, and they have the right to raise their child how they wish, and must be done under a medical surgeon who has taken the Hypocratic Oath.

Sure they ahev the right to consent but it should be only if the operation is necessary since the child cannot ask for it himself. Note the word in bold.

you keep saying that parent should be allowed any aesthetic or cultural surgical removal as long as the tissue is non vital. I say the children should be the one left with the choice as adult.

And i am glad you confuse patriotism with cultural stubbornness.

Be glad that slavery is now forbidden in the US, otherwise person like you would support it out of "patriotism".
 
Be glad that slavery is now forbidden in the US, otherwise person like you would support it out of "patriotism".

right, cause the circumcision of 8-day old baby boys is the same as a lifetime in brutal slavery.

:cool:
 
right, cause the circumcision of 8-day old baby boys is the same as a lifetime in brutal slavery.

:cool:


Because one thing is worse than another thing, it does not therefore follow that this other thing is either good or acceptable.

Rolfe.
 
Here's the problem I'm having with the thread at this point:

The (let's call them) Pro-Circers keep saying that "circumcision doen't impede on penile functionality" but I'm not convinced. Yes, a circumcised penis works, but how do you know it works as well as it would if it were uncircumcised? Considering that we're talking about a procedure done at days of age, there is are before and after studies. Anything that would be a before and after study would have to be done on an adult, and that would defeat the purpose of the study.

That argument is only made, because of the equally flawed argument that is being made about "it is harmful."

The thing I have said many many times in this thread, is that there is a huge lack of evidence showing the risks and benefits involved. If, whatever evidence IS out there, does not satisfy the health organizations, arguments and questions about the functionality of the penis doesn't hold much water.

I can tell you, however, that sex still feels great, and I was able to have not one, but TWO, babies on the way. And I am far from the only one.

In other words, it functions perfectly fine. No problems. Those who are trying to tell me otherwise are terribly misinformed.
 
In other words, it functions perfectly fine. No problems. Those who are trying to tell me otherwise are terribly misinformed.

It has been pointed out to you that there is substantial evidence that circumcision diminishes the sensitivity of the penis. I am not saying that it makes the penis go completely numb and removes all feeling whatsoever.

Do you deny that feeling pleasure is a function of the penis?

The thing I have said many many times in this thread, is that there is a huge lack of evidence showing the risks and benefits involved.

I have the following argument to propose (here I go with that darn logic stuff again):

1. If an action inflicts pain on an infant, and that action serves no substantial benefit, then it is immoral.
2. Circumcision inflicts pain and provides no substantial benefit.
C. Therefore, circumcision is immoral.

#1 is pretty obvious, and you've already conceded #2 (unless you're denying that circumcision is painful). So would you agree that circumcision is immoral?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom