Ban circumcision in San Fran???

yeah, how many times do male circumcisions in the USA lead to the death of the child?

.00000000001%?

Why not find out the death and complication rate, rather than make up silly numbers.
What are you? A homeopath?
 
can we all at least agree that male circumcision is severely less damaging and dangerous than "female circumcision"?

can we at least do that?

No. Because some types of FGM involve very minor cuts and are perfectly comparable to male circumcision.
 
There are activists trying to promote very minor interventions and call them "circumcision" for females, and they are being pilloried for child abuse - even though the degree of cutting is less than in male circumcision, and it is being done to try to prevent much more radical mutilation.

Rolfe.
 
from his site:

Welcome to the San Francisco MGM Bill website

Your support will help us to protect ALL infants and children in San Francisco from the pain and harm caused by forced genital cutting. Damage ranges from excruciating pain, nerve destruction, loss of normal, natural and functional tissue, infection, disfigurement and sometimes death

yeah, how many times do male circumcisions in the USA lead to the death of the child?

.00000000001%?

Someone earlier in this thread posted the figures (and no, I'm not going to dive back into the mess looking for it) that approx. 115 males died from circ. complications every year. That's 115 too many, as far as I'm concerned.
 
Someone earlier in this thread posted the figures (and no, I'm not going to dive back into the mess looking for it) that approx. 115 males died from circ. complications every year. That's 115 too many, as far as I'm concerned.

To be fair, that paper is a load of bunk, and the actual number is far smaller, with reliable estimates somewhat lacking.

Here's
what seemed like a good dissection of the article the number (actually 117) is from - basically, it's complete nonsense.

There are other, more common complications associated with circumcision, but they seldom lead to death. There isn't really any data that suggests circumcision leads to higher mortality in the United States, and some that suggests it does not.

ETA: Here is a somewhat more reliable source for information about the medical aspect of circumcision. Of course it isn't gospel, either, but it's at least not as obviously flawed as the above paper is.
 
Last edited:
Here's a survey from Israel:

Complications of circumcision in Israel: a one year multicenter survey.

RESULTS: All the circumcisions were performed during the early neonatal period, usually on day 8 of life (according to Jewish law). in 55 cases (83%) it was part of a ritual ceremony conducted by a ritual circumciser (Mohel), while in 11 babies (17%) physicians were involved. Acute bleeding after circumcision was encountered in 16 cases (24%), which required suturing in 8. In addition, we found two cases of wound infection and one case of partial amputation of glans penis in which the circumcision was performed by a ritual circumciser. Among the late complications, the most common was excess of skin in 38 cases (57%); 5 children (7.5%) had penile torsion and 4 children (6%) had shortages of skin, phimosis and inclusion cyst. The overall estimated complication rate of circumcision was 0.34%.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15984378
 
This bit's important, otherwise the figures don't seem to make sense.

of the 19,478 males born in four major medical centers in Israel 66 had circumcision-related complications


The stats quoted are percentages of the 66 cases where there were complications. Out of nearly 20,000 infants, that gives the 0.34%.

Not odds I'd fancy, for a procedure of purely ritual significance. But then, what do I know, I'm not a Jew I'm a Christian, and

WESTERN CHRISTIANS DON'T DO CIRCUMCISION AS A RELIGIOUS RITUAL.

Rolfe.
 
Only if my tribe is also allowed to inflict facial scars on our infant sons on the grounds that -

It doesn't affect function as an adult male.
Infants handle the procedure better than adults.
It looks good.
There's a low medical risk.
Our deity requested it.
.
From these examples, the diety is kinda sick....
 

Attachments

  • scar-01.jpg
    scar-01.jpg
    57.3 KB · Views: 6
  • scar-02.jpg
    scar-02.jpg
    48.5 KB · Views: 4
It's pretty funny how badly you're misunderstanding this part.

HINT: If a circumcision ban did pass, those opposing the ban would need to demonstrate that they have standing to challenge the ban.

We aren't talking about it as if it is currently law right now. We are talking about keeping it from passing.
 
I'm thinking, never mind chimney sweep, there's not so much call for these this century.

Soprano opera singer, able to take those tricky parts in the Handel operas the counter-tenors can't hack, and the cross-dressers look so silly in.

He'll make a fortune. And since it's my right to do whatever I like to his body if I think it will be for his own good in later life, this seems like a runner.

Rolfe.
 
... I have absolutely no idea what you're trying to say there, or how it relates to my post that you replied to. Could you please try again?

Sure, np.

I wasn't really trying to say anything. I was trying to figure out what case law you were talking about, and ran across the wiki page that I posted. I then lost track of what else I was going to say, and just ended it there.

That post went rather poorly. Sorry bout that.
 
To me, the ripeness section indicates that one cannot claim standing because a law might affect them. For example, if a new law mandated that all people who write with their left hand pay a fine of 50 bucks for each infraction, I (a left-handed person) could not challenge the law on the basis that, although I have not been forced to pay a fine at this point, it is likely that I will have to do so in the future.

Though I may be misunderstanding this.

The ripeness section I was aiming towards all the myriad hypothetics being brought up in this thread, and towards the misuse of a non-technical term on ambiguous grounds.

In any case, I should instead be looking at how Congress deals with potential civil rights laws that might come up for a motion, rather than how the courts deal with laws that have already passed.

Unforutnately, I don't know the typical process Congress takes in any particular debate. I mean, about what is acceptable and what is not. I would assume hypotheticals and non-technical terms that lead to ambiguity are treated much the same way the courts do. That is, it lowers the persons standards quite a bit. I don't know the subtleties of the various state Congresses.
 
No. I have seen no compelling evidence that the long-term effects are very different. It is commonly believed that they are, but I have seen evidence that this is nothing more than a misconception.

Now, if you have evidence to indicate otherwise, I'm willing to listen.

And if it can be brought to the forefront once and for all, I would be more than willing to concede the point about inconsistency in the law. IF it is shown that female circumcision is shown to be just as benign as male circumcision in every way, and displays just as much risk.
 
Check the case law again. The standard is not "overwhelming and incontrovertible evidence."

I will address this post once again. It was my fault for suggesting what you have written here, and responded to. That was not the proper thing to say, because the ban is not law yet. There would be no reason to have such evidence.

However, I am sure that Congress (whatever Congress, whether federal, state, or city government) would have an easier time passing a ban if they had such evidence.
 
Only if my tribe is also allowed to inflict facial scars on our infant sons on the grounds that -

It doesn't affect function as an adult male.
Infants handle the procedure better than adults.
It looks good.
There's a low medical risk.
Our deity requested it.

As bizzare as such a practice, and as much as I personally would find it to be dumb, it is protected under the Constitution fas as I am concerned. And until Congress, and the Courts when challenged otherwise, I will continue to insist that you have a cultural, and more importantly, religious right to raise your kids up that way.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom