Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Of course the priest doesn't do it.

Why "of course"?

As far as I know, in Judaism it is a purely religious ceremony carried out by the clergy.

A properly trained, and experienced medical surgeon does it a few days after giving birth.
Is a priest present at all?

And I am from the Diocese of Scranton. When one is about ready to give birth, you can go in and talk to the priest about the process of bringing the baby up in the Church. The priests are free to suggest circumcision as a possibility if the parents bring it up. It jsut happens that many new parents in the Diocese ask about it or something.
Or something?

How would you even know about it at all? Is there a newsletter?

Interestingly enough, all of this only tells me that there is no religious requirement whatsoever: It only comes up*if* the couple even asks. Not only does the church not require the circumcision, it is also not promoting or advertising it.

If I was interested in further stories you made up I'd ask what the priests would respond in that talk when even asked.
 
Last edited:
Right, but the health services have no reliable evidence on the actual benefits and risks. There is no evidence that any child in the US ever dies directly because of, or as an indirect cause of, circumcision itself.

There is no lack of evidence that circumcision causes pain and suffering to children.
 
Check the case law again. The standard is not "overwhelming and incontrovertible evidence."

I haven't found the footing of where a bill comes into play, but here is the wiki article on how the Supreme Court handles a case when something is already written into law:

Prudential limits—the principles of justiciability

Before deciding a constitutional question, the Supreme Court may consider whether the court can avoid the constitutional question by basing its decision on a non-constitutional issue at dispute. For example, if a federal statute is on shaky constitutional footing but has been applied to the challenging party in a manner that does not implicate the basis for the constitutional claim, the Supreme Court will not decide whether the statute might be unconstitutional if it were applied differently. Or, when reviewing a decision of a state's highest court, the Court may avoid the constitutional question if the state court's decision is based on an independent and adequate state-law grounds.

Federal courts consider other doctrines before allowing a lawsuit to go forward:

* Actual dispute - the lawsuit concerns a "case or controversy" under the meaning of Article III, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution

* Standing - the party bringing the suit must have (1) a particularized and concrete injury, (2) a causal connection between the complained-of conduct and that injury, and (3) a likelihood that a favorable court decision will redress the injury

* Ripeness - a party will lack standing where her case raises abstract, hypothetical or conjectural questions.


* Mootness - a party is seeking redress over a case that no longer has a basis for dispute, though there are limited exceptions

* Political question - the issues raised in the suit are unreviewable because the Constitution relegates it to another branch of government.

Consistent with these doctrines, the Court considers itself prohibited from issuing advisory opinions where there is no actual case or controversy before them.(See Muskrat v. United States, 219 U.S. 346 (1911)). These doctrines, because they apply to all federal cases whether of constitutional dimension or not, are discussed separately in the article on federal jurisdiction.

(Real quick: RIPENESS! That's the term I was looking for throughout this entire thing! Too many people were basing too much of their arguments on "Ripeness." My point still stands about a party lacking standing in the eyes of the judge when using abstract terminology (mutilation, as opposed to circumcision), hypotheticals (far too many of them in this thread!!) and conjectural questions, which scum was trying to play with me.)

In any case, the courts do, indeed, try to decide upon a case without Constitutional standing first.

When I have time later, I will look up the process of trying to ban a practice where it is as ambiguous as it seems, and how any Congress (state or federal) handles that situation.

ETA: Linky http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_constitutional_law
 
Thank you Avalon. That is all I wanted in this entire discussion. You did a good job here. This is the distinction I was trying to explain. I may have handled it quite poorly. I probably did. But this is far better, IMHO, than I did in all of my ramblings on here. :cool:

So you are now agreeing that circumcision is mutilation, but a minor mutilation compared to others. Nobody has argued otherwise.
What has been argued is: 1. that any mutilation should not be done, without good medical reason, without the consent of the subject.
2. 8 day old babies cannot give that consent,
3. therefore they should not be subjected to the procedure.

See how logic works?
You clearly disagree with #1, but only for some minor mutilations and only for religious reasons. You seem to oppose the removal of ear lobes and the slicing of arms, which are just as minor as circumcision, and possibly more so.
 
(Real quick: RIPENESS! That's the term I was looking for throughout this entire thing! Too many people were basing too much of their arguments on "Ripeness." My point still stands about a party lacking standing in the eyes of the judge when using abstract terminology (mutilation, as opposed to circumcision), hypotheticals (far too many of them in this thread!!) and conjectural questions, which scum was trying to play with me.)

It's pretty funny how badly you're misunderstanding this part.

HINT: If a circumcision ban did pass, those opposing the ban would need to demonstrate that they have standing to challenge the ban.
 
Of course the priest doesn't do it. A properly trained, and experienced medical surgeon does it a few days after giving birth.

And I am from the Diocese of Scranton. When one is about ready to give birth, you can go in and talk to the priest about the process of bringing the baby up in the Church. The priests are free to suggest circumcision as a possibility if the parents bring it up. It jsut happens that many new parents in the Diocese ask about it or something.

Oh, and I had religion class when I was in Catholic school up until 8th grade. There was some discussion about it in religion.

But you said it was a catholic rite and that the diocese "does" it. Backpedal noted.

Now will you at least acknowledge that it is not a catholic practice; that circumcision of (at least) catholic babies is not protected by the First Amendment. There might be a way of moving forward in this debate if you concede this.
 
Read up a little bit about that Kellogg guy and how the anglo blokes ended up without foreskins. Inventive character. Cornflakes and peanut butter, eh? This was an interesting read.

"It (self abuse) lays the foundation for consumption, paralysis and heart disease. It weakens the memory, makes a boy careless, negligent and listless. It even makes many lose their minds; others, when grown, commit suicide.... Don't think it does no harm to your boy because he does not suffer now, for the effects of this vice come on so slowly that the victim is often very near death before you realize that he has done himself harm. It is worthy of note that many eminent physicians now advocate the custom of circumcision..."

(Mary R. Melendy, MD, The Ideal Woman - For Maidens, Wives and Mothers, 1903.)


Straight from Arus808's bookshelf, eh? Vast health benefits indeed.

cirp.org said:
In America, foreskins were not rare at the time circumcision was introduced into widespread practice. Paradoxically, then, the understanding of the intact male organ at that time was somewhat greater than it is today. (In particular, it never would have been possible to promote circumcision on the basis that it was "necessary for hygienic reasons"---this came later, when doctors themselves were mostly circumcised men.)

Further, in proposing circumcision as a preventative against self-abuse, physicians of the day understood very well that male masturbation involves stimulation of the foreskin. However they were incorrect in assuming that, by reducing the pleasure, masturbation itself could be reduced or eliminated.
 
Meet the man behind SF's proposed circumcision ban
(...)
Schofield argues that since female genital mutilation was banned under federal law in 1996, practicing male circumcision violates the equal protection clause.

So who is Schofield? He won't say much other than that he's a 58-year-old who used to work for a "major hotel chain." He lives with his partner near Buena Vista Park, and they have no children. His Facebook page notes he's a fan of "The WHOLE Network", "Bring Back Saving Penises" and "Catholics Against Circumcision." But don't bother asking whether he had the procedure done himself.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/blogs/cityinsider/detail?entry_id=77266

From his web page:

The latest figures indicate that 90% of Bay Area infants leave the hospital after birth intact. Your support will help us to reach the vast majority of voters in San Francisco who already understand the necessity of this legislation.
 
from his site:

Welcome to the San Francisco MGM Bill website

Your support will help us to protect ALL infants and children in San Francisco from the pain and harm caused by forced genital cutting. Damage ranges from excruciating pain, nerve destruction, loss of normal, natural and functional tissue, infection, disfigurement and sometimes death

yeah, how many times do male circumcisions in the USA lead to the death of the child?

.00000000001%?
 
I haven't found the footing of where a bill comes into play, but here is the wiki article on how the Supreme Court handles a case when something is already written into law:



(Real quick: RIPENESS! That's the term I was looking for throughout this entire thing! Too many people were basing too much of their arguments on "Ripeness." My point still stands about a party lacking standing in the eyes of the judge when using abstract terminology (mutilation, as opposed to circumcision), hypotheticals (far too many of them in this thread!!) and conjectural questions, which scum was trying to play with me.)

In any case, the courts do, indeed, try to decide upon a case without Constitutional standing first.

When I have time later, I will look up the process of trying to ban a practice where it is as ambiguous as it seems, and how any Congress (state or federal) handles that situation.

ETA: Linky http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_constitutional_law

... I have absolutely no idea what you're trying to say there, or how it relates to my post that you replied to. Could you please try again?
 
can we all at least agree that male circumcision is severely less damaging and dangerous than "female circumcision"?

can we at least do that?
 
... I have absolutely no idea what you're trying to say there, or how it relates to my post that you replied to. Could you please try again?

To me, the ripeness section indicates that one cannot claim standing because a law might affect them. For example, if a new law mandated that all people who write with their left hand pay a fine of 50 bucks for each infraction, I (a left-handed person) could not challenge the law on the basis that, although I have not been forced to pay a fine at this point, it is likely that I will have to do so in the future.

Though I may be misunderstanding this.
 
can we all at least agree that male circumcision is severely less damaging and dangerous than "female circumcision"?

can we at least do that?

No. I have seen no compelling evidence that the long-term effects are very different. It is commonly believed that they are, but I have seen evidence that this is nothing more than a misconception.

Now, if you have evidence to indicate otherwise, I'm willing to listen.
 
To me, the ripeness section indicates that one cannot claim standing because a law might affect them. For example, if a new law mandated that all people who write with their left hand pay a fine of 50 bucks for each infraction, I (a left-handed person) could not challenge the law on the basis that, although I have not been forced to pay a fine at this point, it is likely that I will have to do so in the future.

Though I may be misunderstanding this.

I'm familiar with the concept of ripeness. I have no idea how it relates to my challenging of his evidence standard.
 
can we all at least agree that male circumcision is severely less damaging and dangerous than "female circumcision"?

can we at least do that?


99074d54b459448e8.gif
 
Should someone be allowed to lop a bit off the penis of his new-born son?

Only if my tribe is also allowed to inflict facial scars on our infant sons on the grounds that -

It doesn't affect function as an adult male.
Infants handle the procedure better than adults.
It looks good.
There's a low medical risk.
Our deity requested it.
 
Only if my tribe is also allowed to inflict facial scars on our infant sons on the grounds that -

It doesn't affect function as an adult male.
Infants handle the procedure better than adults.
It looks good.
There's a low medical risk.
Our deity requested it.

I honestly have no issue with this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom