Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I have to say, I am very suspicious that any Catholic church does circumcisions. Its one of many Jewish rites that Christianity strongly opposed early on. Did not Jesus say that "true faith" means your circumcised in your heart..and not just of the flesh?


No, it was St. Paul, as we've been discovering.

But basically you're right. Nihilianth is not a Catholic.

Ain't "view post" a bitch!

Rolfe.
 
Well, again, IANAL. But a constitutional law professor appears to disagree with you:

Yes, on the basis that there's not a legitimate state interest here. I'm not disagreeing with the professor's understanding of the law, but I think his understanding of the facts may be questionable.
 
Yes, on the basis that there's not a legitimate state interest here. I'm not disagreeing with the professor's understanding of the law, but I think his understanding of the facts may be questionable.

Okay. Thanks for that.
 
Okay. Thanks for that.

Just to clarify, the real question that will be asked here (and the place where I and the quoted professor may very well disagree), is whether the government has a valid reason (based in sound medical practice, child protection, or safety) for prohibiting operations like this.
That question is not a question about religious beliefs and practices. It doesn't matter how central the practice is to a religion, because that's not the question that we're asking.
We're asking a question about the state's interest in regulating unnecessary surgery as applied to minor children. Is circumcision harmful, and is there a good medical reason to prohibit it?
If so, then the government can regulate circumcision for non-religious reasons, ignoring its impact if any on certain religious practices. If not, then it can't.
 
If I ever have to go to court, I will explain to the judge that my detention is unconstitutional, but I can't explain why, because logic does not apply to the constitution. What do you think his reply will be?

Not the way in which you used that logic. Like I have said. There are more than two ways to go about answering a question, making your logic flawed.

You have come to conclusions on the application of constitutional law. Can you please explain to me how you came to these conclusions without using logic?

Not by asking simple yes/no questions. Life constitutes more than just binary code.

I already explained the process one must go through in order to come to any conclusion in the Constitution. It has to be far more rigorous than the process you took. Why do you think it takes months....sometimes YEARS....for the Supreme Court to hand down decisions? Why do you think there is such a tiered system of courts in the US? Simple yes/no questions in a very simple exercise in logic doesn't do anyone any justice.

The process is weighing such things as:

The rights of parents. The rights of children. The rights of society. The rights of government. The consequences of a current practice. The theoretical consequences of banning a practice, (of which there are more than a few!), the Constitution, case law, evidence. After all of these things have been gathered up and presented, then you must weigh each item in importance according to the law. Not according to morality.

What I or anyone else thinks about the morality of an act, matters not a lick when it comes to banishing the practices of any particular group of people. Why? Because our sense of morality is skewed and biased.

Actually, thinking about it further, it isn't the logical PROCESS I have a problem with. Rather, it is the specific questions you asked in your logical process that I most have a problem with.


We can't ban circumcision because it's religious. But we can ban the amputation of ears, even if it is religious. Well that's different because circumcision doesn't diminish the function of the penis, and slicing off ears does. Well, I can't tell the difference, anyways. After all, a sample size of one is more than adequate. But if you want to ban circumcision, then that's just your subjective opinion, and you're only one person. Get your hands off me, oppressor! Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to carve up my infant.

Is this an adequate summary of the pro-circumcision side?

You have come to the wrong conclusion, if you think that is anywhere near what I have said.
 
I don't support parental rights, a child is not the property of its parents. A parent has obligations and a legal duty in many countries to ensure that the child's rights are upheld.

Good luck defending the bolded.

The problem is, you are taking away the Constitutional right to upbring your children in your religion. You take away parents rights to teach the child in the fashion they deem appropriate. Parents are not some automatons to be controlled by the state in every single rule, health care issue, and so forth.

And incidentally, kids rights are not superior to their parents. And the reverse is also true.

I think another big thing you are missing when it comes to your flat-out statement that you do not support parents rights, is this:

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/456472_3

Laws that affect the minor's right to consent to medical care have been developed under the precedent of parental autonomy.[4, 11, 14] In adolescents under the age of majority who receive health care services, the American Academy of Pediatrics has a long-standing policy statement encouraging physicians and parents to include adolescents in the decision-making process, but the parental autonomy and parental right to give consent for a minor is the standard.[8]

http://www.rutherford.org/Issues/ParentsRights.asp

But the United States Supreme Court has ruled that parents have a fundamental right to control the upbringing and education of their children.
 
I think a big thing you are missing is Darat's location. Among other things.

Rolfe.
 
And what I'm telling you is that that argument fails. If we can prohibit a medical operation for reasons that have nothing to do with religion, the fact that it is also a burden on a religious rite doesn't suddenly make the prohibition inappropriate.
In other words, if there's a good reason having nothing to do with religion to prohibit X, we can prohibit X whether or not it will impact someone's ability to include X in a religious ritual.
The fact that we can come to our conclusion about the nature of X without even knowing its religious significance is very helpful in demonstrating that the purpose of the prohibition is secular, and not persecuting religion.

I understand that. But the issue that is also constantly being brought up, and which we seem to be going round in circles, is that you must provide the reasons for banning a practice that has nothing to do with religion.

In other words, you must provide overwhelming, and incontrovertible evidence that the practice in itself does serious harm to the babies in question. Which is exactly why comparisons to removing an arm for no good medical reason is not a good comparison. Because it does obvious harm that will greatly impact the life of that individual. That just happens to not be the case for circumcision.

It remains true for the "Onomatopoeians" as well, given a perfectly parallel comparison.
 
In other words, you must provide overwhelming, and incontrovertible evidence that the practice in itself does serious harm to the babies in question.

Check the case law again. The standard is not "overwhelming and incontrovertible evidence."
 
Christian students? (Perhaps an unwarranted assumption.)

There is something deliciously incongruous about the idea of young Christians worshiping at a maypole.

At school.

Maybe right after their Abstinence Only class?

This is where comparative religion courses might have come in handy. For the parents as well as the youngsters.

I am reminded of Spider Robinson's suggestion that "God is an iron".

:D I always thought it odd myself, actually. No, they call the event "See You at the Maypole!," because it is always scheduled on the first of May. They gathered around the flag in the bus loop area, and prayed. About what? I dunno. I never attended.

Later on, there would be a dance at the school held by student government.

In any case, this is off-topic. Just an interesting little side-piece, I suppose.
 
I think we humans do a pretty good job of distinguishing between things on the body that can be reasonably messed with or cut off and things that can't. I think we could take a look at other minor mutilations (clipping a bit of the labia, trimming part of the ear off, piercing lose skin or cartilage somewhere on the body) and distinguish between that and genuine mutilation (like castration, or what is done to girls in Africa). And I think it's pretty clear that circumcision objectively falls in the former category rather than the latter.

Thank you Avalon. That is all I wanted in this entire discussion. You did a good job here. This is the distinction I was trying to explain. I may have handled it quite poorly. I probably did. But this is far better, IMHO, than I did in all of my ramblings on here. :cool:
 
Name one diocese where circumcision is carried out as a religious rite? What sort of knife does the priest use? What's the name of the ceremony?

Not only do I think you are lying about this, I don't believe you are a catholic at all. If you are, you are woefully ignorant about the faith.

Of course the priest doesn't do it. A properly trained, and experienced medical surgeon does it a few days after giving birth.

And I am from the Diocese of Scranton. When one is about ready to give birth, you can go in and talk to the priest about the process of bringing the baby up in the Church. The priests are free to suggest circumcision as a possibility if the parents bring it up. It jsut happens that many new parents in the Diocese ask about it or something.

Oh, and I had religion class when I was in Catholic school up until 8th grade. There was some discussion about it in religion.
 
Anyone who posts the stars and stripes or it's variants to support an argument automatically loses it.

Lionking's Law.

I actually like that rule, because that WAS pretty obnoxious, wasn't it?

I can always delete it from that post, so it doesn't lose. :D
 
Of course the priest doesn't do it. A properly trained, and experienced medical surgeon does it a few days after giving birth.

And I am from the Diocese of Scranton. When one is about ready to give birth, you can go in and talk to the priest about the process of bringing the baby up in the Church. The priests are free to suggest circumcision as a possibility if the parents bring it up. It just happens that many new parents in the Diocese ask about it or something.

Oh, and I had religion class when I was in Catholic school up until 8th grade. There was some discussion about it in religion.


And did they mention the Council of Jerusalem, at all?

Parents bring up circumcision in conversation, and the priest says, what? "That's all right, you can if you want to, we've stopped forbidding it."

How does that make it a religious ritual?

Rolfe.
 
Just to clarify, the real question that will be asked here (and the place where I and the quoted professor may very well disagree), is whether the government has a valid reason (based in sound medical practice, child protection, or safety) for prohibiting operations like this.
That question is not a question about religious beliefs and practices. It doesn't matter how central the practice is to a religion, because that's not the question that we're asking.
We're asking a question about the state's interest in regulating unnecessary surgery as applied to minor children. Is circumcision harmful, and is there a good medical reason to prohibit it?
If so, then the government can regulate circumcision for non-religious reasons, ignoring its impact if any on certain religious practices. If not, then it can't.

Right, but the health services have no reliable evidence on the actual benefits and risks. There is no evidence that any child in the US ever dies directly because of, or as an indirect cause of, circumcision itself.

Therefore, for where there is lack of evidence or data for a claim, rights as spelled out in the Constitution takes precedence. And in the Constitution, religious practices are not to be taken away. And banning something that is widely practiced on a religious stand point is not to be taken lightly. You must bring forth real evidence, not make comparisons to flimsy hypotheticals that would end up with complete different answers, based on different variables.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom