First, I would like to apologize if you have not used that word. It just is getting slung around here, without anyone giving any definition for the term, other than the ones that I, myself, have posted.
Your argument is self-contradictory. You're saying that there are no non-religious reasons to ban circumcision except for that it involves the needless removal of healthy tissue and the denial of a choice later in life. Those are the reasons I'd like to see it banned. I have no issue with people observing their chosen religion as long as they don't impose it on others by - for example - cutting off part of their bodies.
It isn't self-contradictory. The religion aspect is written directly in the Constitution, within the very first amendment. If you want to ban something that people frequently use for religious customs, the religion question will definitely come up. In which case, the Courts MUST.... absolutely IMPERATIVE....that they give this full, and unadulterated consideration of the impact that a ban or law would have on any given religion. If your more secular arguments are not good enough to limit a religious practice, then your arguments are no good.
Second of all, what are parents for, but to "impose their will" on kids? Are you suggesting that parents should not be allowed to rear their children up in their faith? That makes no sense.
The [circumcision] has no adverse affects on that person throughout their life, and it is a very common religious practice to do so.
Therefore, since parents are supposed to be the ones to make informed decisions about the health and well-being of their child, your argument that it "imposes the parent's will" on their kid will never suffice in a court. The juge will just look at you and say, "so? That's what parents are for."
So the only argument you are left with is "it takes away the choice of the individual to make for themselves that should be reserved for when they are older." This is by far your best point on that side of the debate, and I have given it many times in order to give those on your side of the debate a hint about what is really important when it comes to Constitutional rights.
The problem with the last argument is, once again, the parents have the legal right to consent for an operation that they feel is best for their child. And if religion is extremely important to them, and they believe that circumcision is extremely important, they have the right to consent to have it done, since the child is still a minor, and it is in their best interest even if not physically.
I think I speak for all of us when I say: Huh?
for the 800 MILLIONTH TIME! PLEASE, PLEASE! give me something to work with here! You had simply stated that cutting off the left ear is a religious practice, and should be allowed, and isn't a necessary part. I don't know the necessary functions of an earlobe, and am getting tired of doing all the research for people. If you simply state "cut off the earlobe," give me specifics!
Is it for a religious purpose? Does the earlobe do anything important? How might the cutting off of earlobes affect a person's health, and/or lifestyle? I am lost here. Please, please help me out here in this conversation. Don't throw a whole bunch of hypotheticals out at me without first considering the ramifications, the evidence and so forth first. So far, the most appropriate hypothetical is that of ear-peircing. Cutting off any other part of the body besides the foreskin, and (MAYBE?) the earlobe will cause undue hardships. So please, help me out here in having a constructive conversation without spinning in circles. That is all I am asking.
This is a classic example of the special pleading fallacy. When you're talking about removing the piece of tissue that you want to remove, you gloss over any harm no matter how small, and say that you've never seen any evidence that it's significant. When it's a piece of tissue that you don't want removed, you're very quick to make up excuses. If I told you that Onomatopeians have never noticed any difficulty in determining the direction a sound is coming from, having learned to cope with the altered acoustics, have not significantly greater incidence of ear infection, and experience the same generation of earwax as anybody with a complete left ear, would you then support the practice? I suspect not, because it's not the answer you want to get.
This is EXACTLY what I am asking for! More specifics. IF ALL ELSE BEING EQUAL, the Onomatopeians have exactly the same rights as anyone else. That is, if the surgery has exactly the same risks and benefits involved as circumcision, it shouldn't be banned.
So, let's look at these side-by-side:
Now, would I support the practice of cutting off the left ear? Probably not. I would think it's strange, and causes a strange deformity (my subjective opinion). Do I think the government should ban it? No.
Would I support circumcision? I am neutral on this (subjective opinion). Do I think the government should ban it? No.
There is a WORLD of difference between what you think is right or wrong in a subjective manner, and whether or not the government should ban it. I find it incredibly surprising that I have given a number of other well-known examples that ave gone completely ignored. Such as:
The Westboro Baptist Church is allowed to protest at funerals, screaming about how "GOD HATES FAGS!"
That is disgusting to the point that it makes me absolutely sick. It even made the Supreme Court justices rather upset over the practice. However, when determining issues that have to do with the Constitution, and how some rights of some people could overlap with rights of other people, you must leave your biased subjective opinion at home, and weigh in your mind how anybody could benefit from any particular ban, vs the benefits of just...letting things alone.
We have a continuum of behaviours to assess against a moral standard. One use for hypotheticals is to determine whether you're being morally consistent or not. In respect of which, I'd like to see your answers to post #584.
I understand why you use them. But the problem with this entire thread, is that the hypotheticals are not detailed enough to be conclusive in how it should be answered. People are using terms that are so ambiguous that it can be turned upside down, and all around however you answer simple yes/no questions.
ETA: Missed them. No, it has no religious purpose; it is done purely out of custom.
Dave
There is nothing in the Constitution which protects customs. Religion is specifically mentioned, however. If circumcision was completely just simply a secular custom, I would be far less inclined to continue with this conversation in defense of the custom. I would still say that it would be realistically HARDER to ban a long-held nonreligious custom than a newly established one. I would probably still lean towards not banning it, because there have to be better solutions than that. I would have to see the solutions of how to deal with Prohibition-like offenses as I have mentioned several times earlier. But I wouldn't necessarily be against a ban, either.
But the reality of circumcision is that it is a common religious rite, and is commonly thought of as a religious rite. The First Amendment protects freedom of religion. And in the context of this ENTIRE thread, I am talking about practices which do not step on other peoples' rights, or causing severe undue harm to another person.