Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Does it have a religious purpose?



You need to answer my question first, before I can finish with the rest of this post.

You don't have to know the purpose of the procedure to answer the question but if you have to ask 'does it have a religious purpose', I'm guessing your answer is 'yes'
Was that really difficult to understand?
 
Exactly. Which is why it seems to be either a diocese-by-diocese, or a parish-by-parish thing. Some parishes, like the one I grew up in, frequently does circumcision. The Vatican has nothing to say about circumcision RIGHT NOW (I am not talking about centuries, upon centuries in the past! This is 2011, not 1400!!) whether it is right or wrong. They just simply do not care. And some parishes in the Catholic Church do practice it.

Which parish? Who did the cutting?
 
In an alternative universe it might well be considered similar to say, "I want to cut of the bit of skin on the tip of my child's penis."

People would think, "Are you QUITE mad?"

I think we humans do a pretty good job of distinguishing between things on the body that can be reasonably messed with or cut off and things that can't. I think we could take a look at other minor mutilations (clipping a bit of the labia, trimming part of the ear off, piercing lose skin or cartilage somewhere on the body) and distinguish between that and genuine mutilation (like castration, or what is done to girls in Africa). And I think it's pretty clear that circumcision objectively falls in the former category rather than the latter.
 
Exactly. Which is why it seems to be either a diocese-by-diocese, or a parish-by-parish thing. Some parishes, like the one I grew up in, frequently does circumcision. The Vatican has nothing to say about circumcision RIGHT NOW (I am not talking about centuries, upon centuries in the past! This is 2011, not 1400!!) whether it is right or wrong. They just simply do not care. And some parishes in the Catholic Church do practice it.


I'm tired of asking for citations for this.

If Nihilianth's community "practises circumcision" this is a social thing, not a religious thing. Any priest caught telling his parishioners that circumcision was an essential part of Christianity or Roman Catholicism would be cruising for a severe dose of disciplining.

Nihilianth's earlier passionate assertions of the central part of circumcision to the Christian faith have been shown to be completely wrong. Might I suggest he's wrong about the rest of it, and there are no parishes in the Catholic Church which practise it as a religious rite?

Rolfe.
 
Exactly. Which is why it seems to be either a diocese-by-diocese, or a parish-by-parish thing. Some parishes, like the one I grew up in, frequently does circumcision. The Vatican has nothing to say about circumcision RIGHT NOW (I am not talking about centuries, upon centuries in the past! This is 2011, not 1400!!) whether it is right or wrong. They just simply do not care. And some parishes in the Catholic Church do practice it.

Name one diocese where circumcision is carried out as a religious rite? What sort of knife does the priest use? What's the name of the ceremony?

Not only do I think you are lying about this, I don't believe you are a catholic at all. If you are, you are woefully ignorant about the faith.
 
First, I would like to apologize if you have not used that word. It just is getting slung around here, without anyone giving any definition for the term, other than the ones that I, myself, have posted.

Your argument is self-contradictory. You're saying that there are no non-religious reasons to ban circumcision except for that it involves the needless removal of healthy tissue and the denial of a choice later in life. Those are the reasons I'd like to see it banned. I have no issue with people observing their chosen religion as long as they don't impose it on others by - for example - cutting off part of their bodies.

It isn't self-contradictory. The religion aspect is written directly in the Constitution, within the very first amendment. If you want to ban something that people frequently use for religious customs, the religion question will definitely come up. In which case, the Courts MUST.... absolutely IMPERATIVE....that they give this full, and unadulterated consideration of the impact that a ban or law would have on any given religion. If your more secular arguments are not good enough to limit a religious practice, then your arguments are no good.

Second of all, what are parents for, but to "impose their will" on kids? Are you suggesting that parents should not be allowed to rear their children up in their faith? That makes no sense.

The [circumcision] has no adverse affects on that person throughout their life, and it is a very common religious practice to do so.

Therefore, since parents are supposed to be the ones to make informed decisions about the health and well-being of their child, your argument that it "imposes the parent's will" on their kid will never suffice in a court. The juge will just look at you and say, "so? That's what parents are for."

So the only argument you are left with is "it takes away the choice of the individual to make for themselves that should be reserved for when they are older." This is by far your best point on that side of the debate, and I have given it many times in order to give those on your side of the debate a hint about what is really important when it comes to Constitutional rights.

The problem with the last argument is, once again, the parents have the legal right to consent for an operation that they feel is best for their child. And if religion is extremely important to them, and they believe that circumcision is extremely important, they have the right to consent to have it done, since the child is still a minor, and it is in their best interest even if not physically.


I think I speak for all of us when I say: Huh?

for the 800 MILLIONTH TIME! PLEASE, PLEASE! give me something to work with here! You had simply stated that cutting off the left ear is a religious practice, and should be allowed, and isn't a necessary part. I don't know the necessary functions of an earlobe, and am getting tired of doing all the research for people. If you simply state "cut off the earlobe," give me specifics!

Is it for a religious purpose? Does the earlobe do anything important? How might the cutting off of earlobes affect a person's health, and/or lifestyle? I am lost here. Please, please help me out here in this conversation. Don't throw a whole bunch of hypotheticals out at me without first considering the ramifications, the evidence and so forth first. So far, the most appropriate hypothetical is that of ear-peircing. Cutting off any other part of the body besides the foreskin, and (MAYBE?) the earlobe will cause undue hardships. So please, help me out here in having a constructive conversation without spinning in circles. That is all I am asking.



This is a classic example of the special pleading fallacy. When you're talking about removing the piece of tissue that you want to remove, you gloss over any harm no matter how small, and say that you've never seen any evidence that it's significant. When it's a piece of tissue that you don't want removed, you're very quick to make up excuses. If I told you that Onomatopeians have never noticed any difficulty in determining the direction a sound is coming from, having learned to cope with the altered acoustics, have not significantly greater incidence of ear infection, and experience the same generation of earwax as anybody with a complete left ear, would you then support the practice? I suspect not, because it's not the answer you want to get.

This is EXACTLY what I am asking for! More specifics. IF ALL ELSE BEING EQUAL, the Onomatopeians have exactly the same rights as anyone else. That is, if the surgery has exactly the same risks and benefits involved as circumcision, it shouldn't be banned.

So, let's look at these side-by-side:

Now, would I support the practice of cutting off the left ear? Probably not. I would think it's strange, and causes a strange deformity (my subjective opinion). Do I think the government should ban it? No.

Would I support circumcision? I am neutral on this (subjective opinion). Do I think the government should ban it? No.

There is a WORLD of difference between what you think is right or wrong in a subjective manner, and whether or not the government should ban it. I find it incredibly surprising that I have given a number of other well-known examples that ave gone completely ignored. Such as:

The Westboro Baptist Church is allowed to protest at funerals, screaming about how "GOD HATES FAGS!"

That is disgusting to the point that it makes me absolutely sick. It even made the Supreme Court justices rather upset over the practice. However, when determining issues that have to do with the Constitution, and how some rights of some people could overlap with rights of other people, you must leave your biased subjective opinion at home, and weigh in your mind how anybody could benefit from any particular ban, vs the benefits of just...letting things alone.

We have a continuum of behaviours to assess against a moral standard. One use for hypotheticals is to determine whether you're being morally consistent or not. In respect of which, I'd like to see your answers to post #584.

I understand why you use them. But the problem with this entire thread, is that the hypotheticals are not detailed enough to be conclusive in how it should be answered. People are using terms that are so ambiguous that it can be turned upside down, and all around however you answer simple yes/no questions.

ETA: Missed them. No, it has no religious purpose; it is done purely out of custom.

Dave

There is nothing in the Constitution which protects customs. Religion is specifically mentioned, however. If circumcision was completely just simply a secular custom, I would be far less inclined to continue with this conversation in defense of the custom. I would still say that it would be realistically HARDER to ban a long-held nonreligious custom than a newly established one. I would probably still lean towards not banning it, because there have to be better solutions than that. I would have to see the solutions of how to deal with Prohibition-like offenses as I have mentioned several times earlier. But I wouldn't necessarily be against a ban, either.

But the reality of circumcision is that it is a common religious rite, and is commonly thought of as a religious rite. The First Amendment protects freedom of religion. And in the context of this ENTIRE thread, I am talking about practices which do not step on other peoples' rights, or causing severe undue harm to another person.
 
And what I'm telling you is that that argument fails. If we can prohibit a medical operation for reasons that have nothing to do with religion, the fact that it is also a burden on a religious rite doesn't suddenly make the prohibition inappropriate.
In other words, if there's a good reason having nothing to do with religion to prohibit X, we can prohibit X whether or not it will impact someone's ability to include X in a religious ritual.
The fact that we can come to our conclusion about the nature of X without even knowing its religious significance is very helpful in demonstrating that the purpose of the prohibition is secular, and not persecuting religion.

Well, again, IANAL. But a constitutional law professor appears to disagree with you:

Post 527

Further quote:

"It's not Constitutional. It would be a violation of the First Amendment right to Freedom of Religion -- religions like Judaism that require [circumcision] as an essential part of the belief system."
(...)
Doesn't City Attorney Dennis Herrera know this? Doesn't he realize that, should the circumcision ban pass, he's facing a dog of a legal case he almost certainly can't win (and no shortage of lawyers and litigants happy to file suit)? That can be answered two ways: A. Yes, and; B. He's not saying.

Herrera told SF Weekly that, not only can he not offer legal opinions on potential pending legislation, he's also not allowed to say whether anyone within government requested his advice on the matter.

Keane, however, is willing to go out on a limb that Herrera has told our elected officials the circumcision ban doesn't make the cut.

"I'm sure Herrera's office has advised the Board of Supervisors that this would not be Constitutional," says the dean emeritus. "But that's protected under attorney-client privilege."


Again, IANAL.





(And personally, I think it's barbaric)
 
So when you say you believe in parental rights, you don't actually mean it.

sure I do.

but incase angrysoba asks, no....I do not believe that parents should have the right to dip their children in molten lava, impale them with infected needles, or give them thousands of papercuts and cover them with lemon juice & alchohol.
 
Last edited:
The religion aspect is written directly in the Constitution, within the very first amendment. If you want to ban something that people frequently use for religious customs, the religion question will definitely come up.


I'd love to be a fly on the wall when someone tries to make a case that circumcision is a "religious custom" in Roman Catholicism.

Second of all, what are parents for, but to "impose their will" on kids? your argument that it "imposes the parent's will" on their kid will never suffice in a court. The juge will just look at you and say, "so? That's what parents are for."


You're up for selling the brat to clean chimneys, then?

I am talking about practices which do not step on other peoples' rights, or causing severe undue harm to another person.


You're admitting it causes harm, then? You just think that your (non-religiously-mandated) social whim makes it "not undue"?

Rolfe.
 
Firstly my foreskin is pretty functional thank you. You may never ever know it, but it is quite sensible and part of foreplay, but that info you will never really know it. So mutilation it is.

You prefer another term ? Medically Unnecessary operation. And as such SO is female circumcision. You might not like the comparison,. but basically it is BOTH the same nature of the operation. You are just too involved in a culture which practice it regularly.

:rolleyes: "Too involved?" In circumcision? Really? How many times in my life have I talked about circumcision? Certainly I have used that word probably no less than 100 times more often here, than I have ever used it up to this point combined. So there goes that accusation.

I don't prefer any other term. What is so hard to say "circumcision?" Is that somehow a scary term that doesn't express your subjective disgust of the act well enough? Does it help your arguments to constantly use alternative terms that are too ambiguous for simple yes/no questions to be anything other than a lie? And why do you insist on constantly bringing up female circumcision, if you do not provide any evidence whatsoever that it is equally as safe, and equally as risky as male circumcision?




Read what I quoted instead of boiling like milk : I said parent are free to brainwash their kid, as per law, so your rant is uncalled for.

I'll go back and look, but I don't think you had that word in there.

The first amendment and religious freedom are perfectly compatible with letting people do their own religion, as long as they don't practice any medical operation which are irreversible on their kid.

This affects you and that kid....how exactly?

WHY ? When the kid grow up, he could very well decide he does not belong to that culture or religion. Too late kiddo ! Your parent decided for you, and it is forever it won't grow back.

Perhaps you want to do a whole survey yourself, specifying your methods, and publishing the results in a peer-reviewed journal about how many men wish to have it taken back, and how badly it affected their lives? Or at least, find me such a survey.

The problem is you are so fixated as seeing it as benign , that you miss the whole point : parent doing irreversible operation on their children, operation which are medically unnecessary.

Parents have the right to consent for children under 16. They have the right to raise their kid up in their religion. The fixation of the benign part, is to keep people from saying "it isn't right to surgically remove an arm for religious reasons."

*ALL* those right are individual right. But we are speaking of a situation where *some individual* (parent) impose some irreversible medical operation , unnecessary , on somebody else (their children).

Parents have the right to consent to a surgical procedure for their child. They have the right to rear their children up in their religion. And removing a piece of foreskin isn't some total, outrageous, life-changing operation.

It is morally unacceptable for me to allow some unnecessary medical operation on a child, operation which definitively remove functionality from the child, even if that functionality they can live without.

There is no functionality being removed. And your morals are not any one else's morals. If you want your 12 year old daughter in by 5PM, doesn't mean other parents have to follow suit.

Personally, I find it morally unacceptable that people seem to think they have some God-given right to step in on how parents are raising their children, and tell them "you're doing it wrong!" :rolleyes:

And this is where you are totally "blocking". The operation be it called a mutilation or an unnecessary medical operation, is medically unnecessary.

Not spiritually. It isn't unnecessary.


For me an individual (the child) right to his own body, goes above the right of the parents to cut part of it. What *YOU* are essentially saying is that the right of the child to have an intact body, is trumped by the right of the parent to make all unnecessary operation they wish.


And this is an irreconcilable opinion.

Nope. Never said that, either. What I am saying is, the parents have the right to consent to an operation that is to be done on their child, and they have the right to raise their child how they wish, and must be done under a medical surgeon who has taken the Hypocratic Oath.

Now, I hope we are finished with taking things too far out of context.

I am glad i live in a culture where medical surgical removal is only usually done when medically needed.

And I am glad I live in a society that has "certain inalienable right," written into a government document that is held dearly by the government, and the governed alike.

usa-comments-1022.gif
 
sure I do.

but incase angrysoba asks, no....I do not believe that parents should have the right to dip their children in molten lava, impale them with infected needles, or give them thousands of papercuts and cover them with lemon juice & alchohol.

You claim to believe in parental rights, then list things a parent should not have the right to do.
And you can't see any dissonance there?
I think you mean you believe in some parental rights.
 
Anyone who posts the stars and stripes or it's variants to support an argument automatically loses it.

Lionking's Law.
 
I wonder if there is a limit to how many posters you can put on ignore?

Soon, it's just going to be a private conversation between him and Parky.

And I have Parky on ignore! :D

Rolfe.
 
Name one diocese where circumcision is carried out as a religious rite? What sort of knife does the priest use? What's the name of the ceremony?

Not only do I think you are lying about this, I don't believe you are a catholic at all. If you are, you are woefully ignorant about the faith.

I have to say, I am very suspicious that any Catholic church does circumcisions. Its one of many Jewish rites that Christianity strongly opposed early on. Did not Jesus say that "true faith" means your circumcised in your heart..and not just of the flesh?
 
What did Jesus teach about circumcision and circumcisers?

Jesus spoke about circumcision in the Temple in Jerusalem (John 7:14).
Moses therefore gave unto you circumcision; (not because it is of Moses, but of the fathers;) and ye on the sabbath day circumcise a man. If a man on the sabbath day receive circumcision, that the law of Moses should not be broken; are ye angry at me, because I have made a man every whit whole on the sabbath day? Judge not according to the appearance, but judge righteous judgment.
(John 7:22-24, King James Version)


http://www.cirp.org/pages/cultural/glass2/
​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom