Nihilianth
Illuminator
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2011
- Messages
- 3,851
I'm not talking about benefitting the state or society I am talking about benefitting the children. (Wow! Misanthropic as I am I never thought I'd say that!)
Ummm....by society, that includes the babies.

Nor will I.
Umm. ok then. Reasons for the ban, please, other than your own subjective idea that you "mutilate" them?
The word "disagree" is wrong.
So.....you DON'T disagree with circumcision then?
Good job that's not mine. And a good job you're not a lawyer because you'd be thrown out of any court in the country too. Certainly any law firm.
Umm...ok.
No, I don't. Keeping autistic children under the stairs is bad. Mutilating children for no good reason is bad too. Very simple.
Of course it is. I never said otherwise. We were talking about circumcision. You still have to outline, and provide evidence, of specifically how, and why the state would benefit from the ban, and how it would help society, because that is how the Supreme Court operates when dealing with Constitutional issues.
It's not subjective. It is highly demonstrative. In fact, I can't think of very many more obvious forms of mutilation. You CUT a piece of flesh off a child. In what doolally universe do you live in that that is not mutilation?
Yes, it is. Have you not read any of my myriads posts and specific definitions of the term "mutilation," and just how subject it can be? Come on, I provided plenty of examples in here already. I also provided examples of how dishonest it is to use the term "mutilation," since it is ambiguous enough to twist however you want it.
I can't? Or you can't? And who says I can't? Aren't you being all subjective about it?
Nobody can. It is not unlike saying "it is a fact that chocolate is good." No. It is NOT good. I love chocolate myself, and think people who hate it are strange. But I cannot state it as fact.
If you say so. But this is question begging. Courts of law presumably must have subjective standards. How can you say that "mutilation" is both subjective and legally objective without begging the question. The point is we are saying that even if courts of law agree with you we think they are wrong to do so.
It is question-begging. Courts of law do look at precision. The more precises you can be with your terminology, the better chance you have of winning a case. Of course, there is flexibility in a court of law when it comes to subjectivity. But the courts prefer objective, precise terminology where accepted.
I have no idea why "circumcision" is such a hard word to use. It is no different than a surgeon using the term "suture," or a scout using the term "four-seam fastball." They are both precise terminologies used in their respective fields for the purposes of clarity and communication.
Then I'll cut the judge's cock off and ask him if he objects. Let's see him waggle his jaunty eyebrows after that.
Rofl!
Well now we know you have lost the argument and resorting to "burn the village to save the village" logic. You don't consider it mutilation if you saw off a kid's genitals with a cheese grater? Presumably you'd argue that the judge will wiggle his eyebrows if I was before him on charges of burning off your genitals with a blowtorch. Mutilation is, you see, all subjective. So who are we or you or anyone to say what it is. You'll be thrown out of court even trying to make your case.
I was merely saying how wording can make a huge difference. If you were come into a court of law with evidence that someone was "mutilated," the judge should certainly know exactly HOW that person was mutilated.
If one were to tell the judge "the child's penis was mutilated!" the judge should naturally ask "in what way?" Judges also have the right to request that correct terminology be used once it is established whether or not it was mutilated with a cheese grater, or by circumcision.