Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I'm not talking about benefitting the state or society I am talking about benefitting the children. (Wow! Misanthropic as I am I never thought I'd say that!)

Ummm....by society, that includes the babies. :boggled:



Nor will I.

Umm. ok then. Reasons for the ban, please, other than your own subjective idea that you "mutilate" them?



The word "disagree" is wrong.

So.....you DON'T disagree with circumcision then? :confused:



Good job that's not mine. And a good job you're not a lawyer because you'd be thrown out of any court in the country too. Certainly any law firm.

Umm...ok.



No, I don't. Keeping autistic children under the stairs is bad. Mutilating children for no good reason is bad too. Very simple.

Of course it is. I never said otherwise. We were talking about circumcision. You still have to outline, and provide evidence, of specifically how, and why the state would benefit from the ban, and how it would help society, because that is how the Supreme Court operates when dealing with Constitutional issues.



It's not subjective. It is highly demonstrative. In fact, I can't think of very many more obvious forms of mutilation. You CUT a piece of flesh off a child. In what doolally universe do you live in that that is not mutilation?

Yes, it is. Have you not read any of my myriads posts and specific definitions of the term "mutilation," and just how subject it can be? Come on, I provided plenty of examples in here already. I also provided examples of how dishonest it is to use the term "mutilation," since it is ambiguous enough to twist however you want it.



I can't? Or you can't? And who says I can't? Aren't you being all subjective about it?

Nobody can. It is not unlike saying "it is a fact that chocolate is good." No. It is NOT good. I love chocolate myself, and think people who hate it are strange. But I cannot state it as fact.



If you say so. But this is question begging. Courts of law presumably must have subjective standards. How can you say that "mutilation" is both subjective and legally objective without begging the question. The point is we are saying that even if courts of law agree with you we think they are wrong to do so.

It is question-begging. Courts of law do look at precision. The more precises you can be with your terminology, the better chance you have of winning a case. Of course, there is flexibility in a court of law when it comes to subjectivity. But the courts prefer objective, precise terminology where accepted.

I have no idea why "circumcision" is such a hard word to use. It is no different than a surgeon using the term "suture," or a scout using the term "four-seam fastball." They are both precise terminologies used in their respective fields for the purposes of clarity and communication.

Then I'll cut the judge's cock off and ask him if he objects. Let's see him waggle his jaunty eyebrows after that.

Rofl! :D



Well now we know you have lost the argument and resorting to "burn the village to save the village" logic. You don't consider it mutilation if you saw off a kid's genitals with a cheese grater? Presumably you'd argue that the judge will wiggle his eyebrows if I was before him on charges of burning off your genitals with a blowtorch. Mutilation is, you see, all subjective. So who are we or you or anyone to say what it is. You'll be thrown out of court even trying to make your case.

I was merely saying how wording can make a huge difference. If you were come into a court of law with evidence that someone was "mutilated," the judge should certainly know exactly HOW that person was mutilated.

If one were to tell the judge "the child's penis was mutilated!" the judge should naturally ask "in what way?" Judges also have the right to request that correct terminology be used once it is established whether or not it was mutilated with a cheese grater, or by circumcision.
 
I wouldn't support the right of parents to stick a bloody big plate through their children's lips. You apparently would though what with parent's rights being one-size-fits-all in your world.

uh...no. but keep trying, you'll get there someday.



..or not.
 
uh...no. but keep trying, you'll get there someday.



..or not.

What happened to the ole "I support parents' rights!" thing?

You can't even define parents' rights. If you can't be bothered to do that then instead of relaxing and having a consistent and coherent position you have to do this foolish jitterbug all over the place making up arbitrary reasons for why you support X but not on any genuine principled grounds. Just because.
 
What happened to the ole "I support parents' rights!" thing?

You can't even define parents' rights. If you can't be bothered to do that then instead of relaxing and having a consistent and coherent position you have to do this foolish jitterbug all over the place making up arbitrary reasons for why you support X but not on any genuine principled grounds. Just because.

are you finished?

:p
 
The problem is, you are using logic that deals only with "yes/no," "up/down," "Left/right." That is not how the decision-making process works when dealing with Constitutional issues. You have far more variables than that, and most of those variables are subjective, making the situation even more complicated.

If I ever have to go to court, I will explain to the judge that my detention is unconstitutional, but I can't explain why, because logic does not apply to the constitution. What do you think his reply will be?

You have come to conclusions on the application of constitutional law. Can you please explain to me how you came to these conclusions without using logic?

I Am The Scum said:
NOTE: If you say it is not true, that is not the same thing as saying that actions done for religious reasons should always be punished, or even sometimes be punished.
That's a contradiction in your logic then.

You have absolutely no clue what you're talking about.

Several times, I have pointed out that if I am unclear in anything I have stated, that I would be willing to explain further. Not once have you taken up my offer. On one occasion, you responded sarcastically. I was going to explain the overall error in reasoning behind your "argument," but Dave beat me to it.

This is a classic example of the special pleading fallacy.

Exactly.

We can't ban circumcision because it's religious. But we can ban the amputation of ears, even if it is religious. Well that's different because circumcision doesn't diminish the function of the penis, and slicing off ears does. Well, I can't tell the difference, anyways. After all, a sample size of one is more than adequate. But if you want to ban circumcision, then that's just your subjective opinion, and you're only one person. Get your hands off me, oppressor! Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to carve up my infant.

Is this an adequate summary of the pro-circumcision side?
 
no, I do support parental rights. and apparently, YOU do not.

I don't support parental rights, a child is not the property of its parents. A parent has obligations and a legal duty in many countries to ensure that the child's rights are upheld.
 
Why is it biased?

It is biased, because you want only half of an equation. You leave the differences out, which is equally as important as the similarities.

I am forming a principle. It may be ill-conceived but you, or Thunder, have to show me what it is.

I already have. You only asked for similarities. Which is perfectly fine. I jsut merely pointed out that you were forgetting the other half of the equation.

Let's forget FGM if you wish and I'll just ask YOU the question since Thunder won't answer:

Why is it acceptable to harm your child and cause permanent damage when there are no known intended benefits (particularly medical) and possible (slightly significant) harm involved?

First, I can accept the terminology of "FGM," and "MGM," if the caveat is that we are still specifically talking about circumcision, and nothing else that can happen to fall under the term "mutilation."

Now,

1. There are no reliable evidence pointing towards the benefits and risks of male circumcision.

2. Permanent damage is also a bit of a touchy phrase to use. The argument about how the foreskin is frequently used, but I find it incredibly hard to believe this is more than just a tiny little tidbit that doesn't really matter at all. Therefore, the "damage" seems nothing more severe than a child receiving a scar on his knee after falling off a bike a couple of year earlier.

3. You still have the very thorny issue of the First Amendment.

4. You have another thorny issue of parents having the right to decide for their child to have an operation performed.

5. You also have to demonstrate that physical benefits outweigh the spiritual, religious "benefits" that people believe they may obtain from the practice.

Just because you deem something unacceptable for your own child, doesn't necessarily mean it is unacceptable to another. Like my earlier point in the thread about Susy's mom thinks that it is inappropriate that Jen's mom allows her daughter to stay out past 8PM at the age of 12. Who is to say what is appropriate or not for another person's child?

You also have to deal with post number 527, or whatever, where someone posted about what that one law professor from Golden Gate University.
 
Your missing the point entirely.





The problem is, you are using logic that deals only with "yes/no," "up/down," "Left/right." That is not how the decision-making process works when dealing with Constitutional issues. You have far more variables than that, and most of those variables are subjective, making the situation even more complicated.

1. It's 'you're', not 'your'.
2. Do you know what 'irony' means'?
3. Do you know what 'rhetorical' means? As in, 'that was a rhetorical question'.
4. I have corrected part of your post.
5. Seriously, (refer to #2 above) are you actually Humpty Dumpty?
 
That wouldn't work. But a school could have a rule that only assigned reading can be brought to and studied in school, and disallow any non-curriculum book as a distraction to the school's educational mission.
And then Bibles couldn't be brought to school, or Lord of the Rings novels, or any other book. And the fact that the Bibles are Bibles wouldn't make any difference.
So: prohibiting Bibles, probably not okay. Prohibiting all books (including Bibles), probably okay. The point being that the fact that the book happens to be a Bible (or that the bonfire or the circumcision happens to be part of a religious ritual) does not exempt it from a law that would otherwise apply to it.

hhmm.... interesting point. The banning of all books would be way too much of a thorny issue, and would likely end up in a MAJOR disruption of the education system, as parents and students alike would be beyond angry and upset. Even if it isn't over religious books specifically, it would still be completely, and totally wrong for schools to ban students from bringing in books of any kind.

I retract that comparison.
 
Doesn't mean sex is any less enjoyable. I ask you the same question: How would you know the sensitivity level if you have never been circumcised?

Not having a foreskin, you have no way of arriving at your conclusion in sentence 1.
How do you know the sensitivity level if you have been circumcised?

Your reasoning is faulty.
 
The fact that you have to ask that makes it clear that it is you that is considering non-secular purposes, and not the government looking to prohibit this medical practice. The fact that the government doesn't need to know this to prohibit it is very favorable to its ability to do so.

I have to ask that question, or else you cannot compare it to circumcision.

The number one argument for allowing circumcision is this:

"It is a religious rite used by many, many religious folks around the USA. The First Amendment protects the right of people to freely worship. It must not prohibit, nor advance the cause of religion."

Once that argument is brought up, the Court must take the religion issue into serious consideration, as it is a serious part of the Constitution.

If you want to make a parallel hypothetical, you must have this very, very important component in the hypothetical that is part of the original debate. Considering the religion aspect is perhaps the most important point, it is entirely necessary for me to ask: "Does it have anything to do with religion?"
 
It is biased, because you want only half of an equation. You leave the differences out, which is equally as important as the similarities.

Read the rest.


I already have. You only asked for similarities. Which is perfectly fine. I jsut merely pointed out that you were forgetting the other half of the equation.

Repeating yourself doesn't make you more interesting. The reverse in fact.

First, I can accept the terminology of "FGM," and "MGM," if the caveat is that we are still specifically talking about circumcision, and nothing else that can happen to fall under the term "mutilation."

That's just silly. I didn't even say "MGM" and yet you want to adopt it as long as MGM doesn't stand for "male genital mutilation". You MUST be trolling by saying that.

Now,

1. There are no reliable evidence pointing towards the benefits and risks of male circumcision.

Meaning that at best it is pointless, medically speaking. (Though it is very clear that any putting a child under surgery risks infection.)

2. Permanent damage is also a bit of a touchy phrase to use. The argument about how the foreskin is frequently used, but I find it incredibly hard to believe this is more than just a tiny little tidbit that doesn't really matter at all. Therefore, the "damage" seems nothing more severe than a child receiving a scar on his knee after falling off a bike a couple of year earlier.

It's not a "touchy phrase". It is demonstrable.

3. You still have the very thorny issue of the First Amendment.

No, I don't. Stop throwing up dust.

4. You have another thorny issue of parents having the right to decide for their child to have an operation performed.

I want to cut off my child's buttocks. Do I have the right? No. Of course not. What a stupid question!

5. You also have to demonstrate that physical benefits outweigh the spiritual, religious "benefits" that people believe they may obtain from the practice.

In what world do I have to do that? How do you measure "spiritual benefits"? Is this kid going to be blessed with a halo once deprived of his foreskin?

Just because you deem something unacceptable for your own child, doesn't necessarily mean it is unacceptable to another. Like my earlier point in the thread about Susy's mom thinks that it is inappropriate that Jen's mom allows her daughter to stay out past 8PM at the age of 12. Who is to say what is appropriate or not for another person's child?

Are you kidding? Okay, I want to dip my child in acid. Who are you to say I can't?

You also have to deal with post number 527, or whatever, where someone posted about what that one law professor from Golden Gate University

Is it too hallowed to be repeated in a pithy manner or does pithiness somehow rob it of its sophistry?
 
The first amendment and religious freedom are perfectly compatible with letting people do their own religion, as long as they don't practice any medical operation which are irreversible on their kid.

WHY ? When the kid grow up, he could very well decide he does not belong to that culture or religion. Too late kiddo ! Your parent decided for you, and it is forever it won't grow back.

The problem is you are so fixated as seeing it as benign , that you miss the whole point : parent doing irreversible operation on their children, operation which are medically unnecessary.

By this same argument, shouldn't we disallow parents to put braces on their kids to eliminate crooked teeth or gaps?
Here we have a medically-unnecessary, irreversible operation done for no good medical reason. Of course, if the kid wants to have the teeth corrected later in life, it's typically more difficult, more expensive, less effective and socially less accepted -- but by your argument, shouldn't kids have the choice as to whether their smile should grow naturally or be artificially mangled according to someone else's aesthetics?
 
I think I shall. I am quite uninformed about female circumcision and the risks, and benefits (if any) it may have. ...
quite a few things
Myself, I cannot make any informed decisions as to whether or not it is alright, without some extensive research on the topic.

Another correction needed.
 
I have to ask that question, or else you cannot compare it to circumcision.

The number one argument for allowing circumcision is this:

"It is a religious rite used by many, many religious folks around the USA. The First Amendment protects the right of people to freely worship. It must not prohibit, nor advance the cause of religion."

And what I'm telling you is that that argument fails. If we can prohibit a medical operation for reasons that have nothing to do with religion, the fact that it is also a burden on a religious rite doesn't suddenly make the prohibition inappropriate.
In other words, if there's a good reason having nothing to do with religion to prohibit X, we can prohibit X whether or not it will impact someone's ability to include X in a religious ritual.
The fact that we can come to our conclusion about the nature of X without even knowing its religious significance is very helpful in demonstrating that the purpose of the prohibition is secular, and not persecuting religion.
 
<snip>

Derailment alert:

This has nothing to do with the discussion at all, and was not meant to be taken that way. And for your information, I do think it is wrong to allow school-lead prayer, unless it is organized by the student body itself and gives other students to option to stay out if they wish. (My high school had the "May Pole" prayer session each year, which was organized by the students themselves, where they would hold hands around the flag pole, and pray is a large circle.)


Christian students? (Perhaps an unwarranted assumption.)

There is something deliciously incongruous about the idea of young Christians worshiping at a maypole.

At school.

Maybe right after their Abstinence Only class?

This is where comparative religion courses might have come in handy. For the parents as well as the youngsters.

I am reminded of Spider Robinson's suggestion that "God is an iron".
 
Err..this isn't the Spanish Inquisition we are talking about here. :p

In an alternative universe it might well be considered similar to say, "I want to cut of the bit of skin on the tip of my child's penis."

People would think, "Are you QUITE mad?"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom