Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Of course not. Now address the analogy, please. Does the fact one wrong is less evil than another make it not evil? Or make it Ok to do?

The law does not dictate morality. You think something is evil, doesn't mean someone else does. Terrible reason to ban something. Which is why we have a process in law which determines the rights of the people, which rights are in consideration, and actions of one individual as "protected" under the Constitution, can affect the rights of another individual, also protected under the Constitution.

Yes it does.

No it doesn't. :D


Re-defining mutilation as not-mutilation does not make it so. You are mutilating the sex organs of someone else without their consent. This is ethically wrong, even if God exists and God says it's ok.

I've already given a breathy reason why the term "mutilation" cannot be used, when there is a more technical term that is more precise. You introduce too much ambiguity when you ask the question: "Do you thin it's ok to mutilate a child's genitals?" That is misleading, and dishonest. As no matter how you answer, you can twist it your own way in your conclusion. I refuse to play that game of entrapment in words.

Besides, this dirty tactic only lessens our already limited ability to communicate on a forum. Best to just accept my compromise I proposed earlier.


I don't deny it isn't a radical change to the past. However, that it has been done historically doesn't mean it isn't wrong.

I can certainly agree with this! But that doesn't change the reality that passing a ban on a long-held tradition will be easy.

If it's wrong to mutilate a part of someone's body without their permission, it's wrong.

I can neither agree, nor disagree with this statement. The term "mutilation" is too ambiguous, because I know that you include "circumcision" with something really horrible, such as cheese grating, and meat grinding. (Remember, the law does not dictate morality! Just because circumcision being "less evil," doesn't mean people view it as evil at all.)


Half-assed arguments such as "esthetics" and meager medical benefits are touted as brand new rationale to support circumcision precisely to strip the religious background of it, which becomes less and less defensible.

That is what I am talking about. Do you understand, now, even if you do not agree?

Yes, I do understand now, and I thank you for taking the time to clear it up.

However, just because some people want to try to come up with some rationale for lessening the religion argument, doesn't mean the Supreme Court should ignore those who do use it for religious purposes. My example of this happening, is a bunch of atheists bringing in Bible, in order to lessen the religious argument of allowing students to bring in their own Bibles since it seems more secular. This does not mean those students who do bring them in for religious reasons cannot use the First Amendment as a defense, and the courts cannot uphold the students' rights.



I suggest you go learn what "inalienable" and inherent "endowed by their Creator" means. Rights are not dependent on others granting them to you -- how did they get this mysterious, awesome power? Why did you allow them to have it, even especially on a philosophical level?

You seem to suffer from the insensate concept, so popular, that vox populi vox dei, that everything is justified by and for simple popular vote.


That most certainly is not the basis of the US concept of freedom and laws. Many of the checks and balances in the US Constitution are oriented against thwarting the blowing winds of political passion, to slow down massive changes that could occur because of sudden outrages and charismatic demagogues.[/quote]

I don't even remember what "rights" you were talking about in the first quote anymore. You had mentioned "people even in non-free countries have this right too. Even in countries where they voted it away democratically."

Hence the possibility for change on this issue of circumcision. Even stripped of its religious origins, you do not have the right to mutilate someone else's body without their permission.

You are right. You do not have the right to mutilate anyone, anywhere, for any reason. But you do have the right to circumcise your own child. So this entire point doesn't mean a thing, and has nothing to do with the discussion.


Not helping your case any, immediately after talking about slavery and so on being popular, once.

You took that out of context. I used the words "in any case," to start off the sentence. The courts are only one branch of government. The people still have the right to redress grievances. This is the beauty of the American system of government. If a bill passes through Congress, is signed by the President, it can then be challenged in the court. If the court upholds that law, the people have the right to petition Congress to have the bill smacked back out. It happened once. Prohibition is a great example of this happening.


You have the right to life, which includes the right to your body, which includes the right to not have that body mutilated against your will.

I agree. But too bad this has nothing to do with taking away the parents' right to circumcise their son, since it is their religious custom to do so.

Please expound at length how my "ramblings" are misunderstanding this issue.

I apologize for this rude behavior.
 
I think he must have everyone on ignore, who pointed out that St. Paul clearly described circumcision as mutlation.

Rolfe.
 
That's such a ridiculous example as to be utterly absurd. The test of whether a law can ban a religious practice, as has been stated earlier in the thread, is not whether the practice may also be undertaken for non-religious reasons; it is whether the law is intended to fulfil some other purpose than religious discrimination. In your case, the law would very obviously fail, because a law banning anybody from bringing copies of the Bible into a school very obviously had no other purpose than limiting freedom of religious expression.

AH! But the same could be said about banning circumcision! There are no other good reasons to do so, other than your subjective opinion that it somehow "mutilates" a baby, or takes a choice out of the life of the person later on. The latter argument is, of course, the stronger of the two.

Now, let's make up a slightly different example. Suppose the Onomatopeian religion requires that the left ear is removed from all babies at birth. There is, however, a law prohibiting the surgical removal of the left ear of a baby because it constitutes unnecessary harm and confers no physical benefit. In this case, the purpose of the law is unconnected with religious expression, therefore the law is not proscribed by the First Amendment.

The same is true, of course, of any hypothetical law prohibiting the surgical removal of the foreskin.

Dave

The problem with this hypothetical, is that the cutting of off the left ear could constitute far more harm than cutting off the foreskin. For instance, without the ear, earwax couldn't build up as much, preventing hearing-loss during extended periods of loudness. The inner ear probably could get infected much easier throughout the lifetime of the individual, due to a hole going directly into the ear, as opposed to having something there diminish the amount of bacteria. It also harms the persons ability to determine from which direction a sound is coming from, as the ear lobe is necessary for proper acoustics.

Nope, a much better example would be piercing someone's ear or nose for religious reasons. but nobody seems satisfied with that comparison either, simply because pierced ears can close up, and is not permanent.

In the end, we only have the one issue of circumcision to deal with. Not 800 thousand hypotheticals.
 
But too bad this has nothing to do with taking away the parents' right to circumcise their son, since it is their religious custom to do so.


It has everything to do with it. But that's not the point. Whose case are you arguing here, since it has been clearly shown that it is not your religious custom to do that?

Rolfe.
 
I believe in human rights. The human right not to have something done to you against your will.

Do you support the right of parents to sell their children into slavery?

Rolfe.
 
What on earth? Nobody is banned from bringing Bibles to school, Christians and non-Christians alike. You can bring a Bible to school, even if you believe it is a religiously mandated activity.

It's a hypothetical, and illustrates my point that, just because someone does a certain custom for non-religious reasons, is no excuse to for the law to circumvent people who do that same practice for very specific religious purposes.





Are you one of those people who sees the ban on school-lead prayer as "kicking God out of shcool?" Has the basis behind your entire argument been a push back against the "atheist horde?"


Derailment alert:

This has nothing to do with the discussion at all, and was not meant to be taken that way. And for your information, I do think it is wrong to allow school-lead prayer, unless it is organized by the student body itself and gives other students to option to stay out if they wish. (My high school had the "May Pole" prayer session each year, which was organized by the students themselves, where they would hold hands around the flag pole, and pray is a large circle.)
 
Let's say some atheistic group got together, and began to bring Bibles into public schools. They could very easily turn around and say "Nobody should be allowed to bring a Bible to school, even for their own reading, because there are people who bring them in for non-religious purposes as well! Therefore, it should be banned because it would keep the non-religious from bringing them in as well, and is not going against any creed."

That wouldn't work. But a school could have a rule that only assigned reading can be brought to and studied in school, and disallow any non-curriculum book as a distraction to the school's educational mission.
And then Bibles couldn't be brought to school, or Lord of the Rings novels, or any other book. And the fact that the Bibles are Bibles wouldn't make any difference.
So: prohibiting Bibles, probably not okay. Prohibiting all books (including Bibles), probably okay. The point being that the fact that the book happens to be a Bible (or that the bonfire or the circumcision happens to be part of a religious ritual) does not exempt it from a law that would otherwise apply to it.
 
Last edited:
Nihilianth, I have a couple of question for you.

(1) Is it morally acceptable to take a sterile scalpel and make a quarter-inch incision in the forearm of a newborn baby, without using anaesthetic, knowing that this will have no physical benefit to that baby?

Does it have a religious purpose?

If your answer to this is "yes", please explain in detail exactly why you find this to be an acceptable procedure.

If it is "no":

(2) Does this procedure constitute "harm"?

Depending on your reply, please explain:

(2a) If this procedure does not consitute "harm", why is it morally unacceptable?
(2b) If this procedure does constitute "harm", given that this wound will heal, why does it not constitute "harm" to carry out a similar procedure on the end of the penis, which will not heal?

Dave

You need to answer my question first, before I can finish with the rest of this post.
 
I believe in parental rights.

Nice dodge. (And no you don't, by the way. You support circumcision. Not "parental rights" which is a meaningless phrase and most likely a fudge along the lines of Republicans in the South saying, "We want states' rights!" We all know what that kind of mealy-mouthing means.).

Rights to do what?

Could I cut off one of my child's fingers for religious reasons?

You DO believe in parent's rights to pierce their children's ears. You MUST DO. You HAVE TO after what you've said so far. Even if that piercing causes infections.

You must know that needlessly cutting a child's foreskin necessarily increases their endangerment to infection.
 
Last edited:
I'm tickled pink by Nihilianth's worrying away at the "religious purpose", when we've shown that the practice is not part of his religion, and if his co-religionists do it, it is for secular purposes and not religious.

So if it was banned for all but religious purposes, he wouldn't be allowed to do it. Good luck with showing any court that circumcision is mandated by Roman Catholic doctrine!

Rolfe.
 
Does it have a religious purpose?

The fact that you have to ask that makes it clear that it is you that is considering non-secular purposes, and not the government looking to prohibit this medical practice. The fact that the government doesn't need to know this to prohibit it is very favorable to its ability to do so.
 
thank you.

and by the way folks, St. Paul made it no longer compulsary for Christians to circumcise their sons. Only Hebrew Christians (Jews who convert to Christianity), need do that.

there is NO compulsion in the NT, for Christian men to be circumcised.

Exactly. Which is why it seems to be either a diocese-by-diocese, or a parish-by-parish thing. Some parishes, like the one I grew up in, frequently does circumcision. The Vatican has nothing to say about circumcision RIGHT NOW (I am not talking about centuries, upon centuries in the past! This is 2011, not 1400!!) whether it is right or wrong. They just simply do not care. And some parishes in the Catholic Church do practice it.
 
AH! But the same could be said about banning circumcision! There are no other good reasons to do so, other than your subjective opinion that it somehow "mutilates" a baby, or takes a choice out of the life of the person later on. The latter argument is, of course, the stronger of the two.

Your argument is self-contradictory. You're saying that there are no non-religious reasons to ban circumcision except for that it involves the needless removal of healthy tissue and the denial of a choice later in life. Those are the reasons I'd like to see it banned. I have no issue with people observing their chosen religion as long as they don't impose it on others by - for example - cutting off part of their bodies.

And while you're getting touchy about people putting words into your mouth, maybe you'd like to remind me where I used the word "mutilates".

The problem with this hypothetical, is that the cutting of off the left ear could constitute far more harm than cutting off the foreskin. For instance, without the ear, earwax couldn't build up as much, preventing hearing-loss during extended periods of loudness.

I think I speak for all of us when I say: Huh?

The inner ear probably could get infected much easier throughout the lifetime of the individual, due to a hole going directly into the ear, as opposed to having something there diminish the amount of bacteria. It also harms the persons ability to determine from which direction a sound is coming from, as the ear lobe is necessary for proper acoustics.

This is a classic example of the special pleading fallacy. When you're talking about removing the piece of tissue that you want to remove, you gloss over any harm no matter how small, and say that you've never seen any evidence that it's significant. When it's a piece of tissue that you don't want removed, you're very quick to make up excuses. If I told you that Onomatopeians have never noticed any difficulty in determining the direction a sound is coming from, having learned to cope with the altered acoustics, have not significantly greater incidence of ear infection, and experience the same generation of earwax as anybody with a complete left ear, would you then support the practice? I suspect not, because it's not the answer you want to get.

Nope, a much better example would be piercing someone's ear or nose for religious reasons. but nobody seems satisfied with that comparison either, simply because pierced ears can close up, and is not permanent.

Which is why I would be opposed, but less so, to such a practice.

In the end, we only have the one issue of circumcision to deal with. Not 800 thousand hypotheticals.

We have a continuum of behaviours to assess against a moral standard. One use for hypotheticals is to determine whether you're being morally consistent or not. In respect of which, I'd like to see your answers to post #584.

ETA: Missed them. No, it has no religious purpose; it is done purely out of custom.

Dave
 
Nice dodge. (And no you don't, by the way. You support circumcision. Not "parental rights"

no, I do support parental rights. and apparently, YOU do not.

You DO believe in parent's rights to pierce their children's ears. You MUST DO. You HAVE TO after what you've said so far. Even if that piercing causes infections.

yes, I support the right of parents to pierce their child's ears, even thou it is possible that this may become infected.

You must know that needlessly cutting a child's foreskin necessarily increases their endangerment to infection.

applying make-up or perfume can lead to an allergic reaction.

......I still think parents should have the right to do it to their kids.
 
NICE! Read it again! This time in proper context

mu·ti·late (mytl-t)
tr.v. mu·ti·lat·ed, mu·ti·lat·ing, mu·ti·lates
1. To deprive of a limb or an essential part; cripple.
2. To disfigure by damaging irreparably: mutilate a statue. See Synonyms at batter1.
3. To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.


–verb (used with object), -lat·ed, -lat·ing.
1.
to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts: Vandals mutilated the painting.
2.
to deprive (a person or animal) of a limb or other essential part.

Key word: ESSENTIAL part.

ETA: The "disfigure" parts of the definition is, once again, rather subjective. You can break the hands off a statue, and make it even better, in your own eyes. You have therefore, made it more perfect.

I did read it in context.
Of the 5 definitions you offer, 'essential' is not an essential part of 3 of them.
If you are going to lecture me on definitions, at least get it right.
You really are going through contortions to claim that mutilation is not mutilation.
It would be more honest to just say, yes, it is mutilation, but it's not a serious enough mutilation to stop it being done to non-censenting people.
 
We aren't talking about mutilating anything. We are talking about circumcision here. This is a major semantics issue, as I have already pointed out.

If you cannot use the proper terminology, or take me up on my compromise over this issue, I will continue to say this.

Firstly my foreskin is pretty functional thank you. You may never ever know it, but it is quite sensible and part of foreplay, but that info you will never really know it. So mutilation it is.

You prefer another term ? Medically Unnecessary operation. And as such SO is female circumcision. You might not like the comparison,. but basically it is BOTH the same nature of the operation. You are just too involved in a culture which practice it regularly.

Oh so now parents are not allowed to teach their kids how to behave? They have no right to raise their kids how they want within the law? This is one of the lamest things I have read yet in this thread. Sorry, but I am being quite frank with this, and insist this is a poor argument.

Read what I quoted instead of boiling like milk : I said parent are free to brainwash their kid, as per law, so your rant is uncalled for.


So then, how about we just do away with the first amendmen and the justice system altogether, and just have a dictatorial system where everything you do can arbitrarily be illegal? That sound good?

The first amendment and religious freedom are perfectly compatible with letting people do their own religion, as long as they don't practice any medical operation which are irreversible on their kid.

WHY ? When the kid grow up, he could very well decide he does not belong to that culture or religion. Too late kiddo ! Your parent decided for you, and it is forever it won't grow back.

The problem is you are so fixated as seeing it as benign , that you miss the whole point : parent doing irreversible operation on their children, operation which are medically unnecessary.

Sorry, but the world is not black-and-white. You CAN allow freedom of speech, but outlaw certain speech. You CAN allow freedom of religion, and outlaw some religious practices. You CAN allow universal suffrage, but keep criminals from voting. You CAN allow the right to bear arms, but outlaw some arms.

*ALL* those right are individual right. But we are speaking of a situation where *some individual* (parent) impose some irreversible medical operation , unnecessary , on somebody else (their children).

It is morally unacceptable for me to allow some unnecessary medical operation on a child, operation which definitively remove functionality from the child, even if that functionality they can live without.

And this is where you are totally "blocking". The operation be it called a mutilation or an unnecessary medical operation, is medically unnecessary.


For me an individual (the child) right to his own body, goes above the right of the parents to cut part of it. What *YOU* are essentially saying is that the right of the child to have an intact body, is trumped by the right of the parent to make all unnecessary operation they wish.


And this is an irreconcilable opinion.

I am glad i live in a culture where medical surgical removal is only usually done when medically needed.
 
Last edited:
no, I do support parental rights. and apparently, YOU do not.

Depends on what they have the rights to do.


yes, I support the right of parents to pierce their child's ears, even thou it is possible that this may become infected.

I'd happily see it banned.

applying make-up or perfume can lead to an allergic reaction.

......I still think parents should have the right to do it to their kids.

Make-up and perfume isn't mutilation. I wouldn't support the right of parents to stick a bloody big plate through their children's lips. You apparently would though what with parent's rights being one-size-fits-all in your world.

[/QUOTE]
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom