Ban circumcision in San Fran???

:rolleyes:

vaccines can cause harm, but we do it anyways.
That's because they A. Save lives and B. have an absolutely miniscule chance of doing any damage. As far as I'm aware only a tiny proportion of people are unable to be vaccinated and most of those have some sort of severe problem with their immune system. Given the obvious and vast benefits, this isn't a valid comparison.

all surgery, no matter how small or large, can cause harm. but we do it anyways.

Anyways isn't a word. The word you want is anyway.

Further, there are, to simplify, three kinds of surgery. Surgery done to save a life/significantly increase the quality of life, surgery done to increase the quality of life that isn't serious, and elective, usually cosmetic surgery. All three fail miserably as comparisons.

Surgery type 1 is necessary to ensure the person a healthy, continued life. Circumcision (except in cases such as mine) is not, and does not ensure anything remotely similar.

Type 2 gives a good benefit to the person receiving the surgery (for example, a hip replacement) and is pretty much always done on adults who are able to consent. As such, it fails to match circumcision on children because it provides little to no benefit and is performed on a child who cannot consent.

Type 3 again fails because this surgery is always (or should always) be performed on consenting adults who understand what the surgery is. As such, this analogy fails miserably, just as your ridiculous vaccine analogy did.

male circumcision can cause harm. it rarely does, but it can.
It's excruciatingly painful and it removes a piece of skin that may potentially be beneficial for sex permanently. Even if you can show it doesn't hurt children, and even if there is no benefit to having a foreskin, then it is still an utterly pointless procedure (again, unlike your two "analogies" above) done purely to sate the whim of a god who probably doesn't exist, and a culture that considers such an action normal.

however, female genital mutilation...almost ALWAYS causes harm. and in many cases very serious harm.
Point to someone, anyone who said they were the same. Not that they were both pointless and permanent, but that they were almost or completely the same in terms of harm done.


and now, we are done.
So, you're going to stick your fingers in your ears like usual then?

That isn't a surprise Parky. You're as predictable as a double-headed coin.
 
Let's say some atheistic group got together, and began to bring Bibles into public schools. They could very easily turn around and say "Nobody should be allowed to bring a Bible to school, even for their own reading, because there are people who bring them in for non-religious purposes as well! Therefore, it should be banned because it would keep the non-religious from bringing them in as well, and is not going against any creed."

What on earth? Nobody is banned from bringing Bibles to school, Christians and non-Christians alike. You can bring a Bible to school, even if you believe it is a religiously mandated activity.

Are you one of those people who sees the ban on school-lead prayer as "kicking God out of shcool?" Has the basis behind your entire argument been a push back against the "atheist horde?"
 
...snip...


Half-assed arguments such as "esthetics" and meager medical benefits are touted as brand new rationale to support circumcision precisely to strip the religious background of it, which becomes less and less defensible.

That is what I am talking about. Do you understand, now, even if you do not agree?

...snip...

As it was put in another thread on this topic - it's a procedure looking for a reason.
 
Nihilianth, I have a couple of question for you.

(1) Is it morally acceptable to take a sterile scalpel and make a quarter-inch incision in the forearm of a newborn baby, without using anaesthetic, knowing that this will have no physical benefit to that baby?

If your answer to this is "yes", please explain in detail exactly why you find this to be an acceptable procedure.

If it is "no":

(2) Does this procedure constitute "harm"?

Depending on your reply, please explain:

(2a) If this procedure does not consitute "harm", why is it morally unacceptable?
(2b) If this procedure does constitute "harm", given that this wound will heal, why does it not constitute "harm" to carry out a similar procedure on the end of the penis, which will not heal?

Dave
 
So, as I suspected, I'm having a discussion with someone who's not a big fan of that whole logic thing.

Your missing the point entirely.



This is all nonsense. There is no "half-truth" in logic. (there is fuzzy logic, but I really need to keep this simple, here, and it doesn't apply anyways)

The problem is, you are using logic that deals only with "yes/no," "up/down," "Left/right." That is not how the decision-making process works when dealing with Constitutional issues. You have far more variables than that, and most of those variables are subjective, making the situation even more complicated.

Jim is left-handed. If I say, "Jim is ambidextrous," am I saying something that is half-true? No. I'm saying something that is completely false. There is no middle ground. Formally, this is known as the law of excluded middleWP.

This has nothing to do with Constitutional law, and dealing with the various and many rights of the various and many people, and the rights of the state and federal governments as well. We are dealing with an issue that involves two parents, likely a team of doctors and a surgeon, religious practices that are protected by the Constitution, the rights of parents to make decisions regarding operations on their child, the rights of the parents rearing their child how they feel is best for him, the opinions that "mutilating" a baby boy is immoral, and the right of the baby boy to grow up and choose for himself whether to be circumcised or not.

We are not talking about whether Jim is left or right-handed. Or even left, right, or ambidextrous.

So I'm going to ask again. Take the following statement:

If an action is done for religious reasons should not be punished by law.

Is this true, or is it not?

This question is not possible to answer with a simple "yes/no" answer! You have Constitutional law, and the various rights of other individuals, society, and several levels of government to think about. This is exactly where your "logic" falls apart in this issue.

So, to answer your question, you have to give me a certain scenario, which can be determined against the interests of the state, society, and the individual.

If an action of a religion requires you to sacrifice a human, then yes. It should most definitely be punished by law. It violates the interest of the state, society, and the individual being sacrificed.

If an action of a religion requires you to pray on Sundays, then no. It is not punishable by law. Whom does praying on Sundays harm? Nobody. (If anything, it may be healthy for a person's pyshe.) The society, in this case, has an interest in protecting that individual's right to pray. Otherwise, we would be set back by centuries of civilized governing.

You see yet where your logic fails to apply to Constitutional law?

If you say it's true, then you have to accept that religious sacrifice is acceptable in the eyes of the law. I'm not asking a tough question here.

NOTE: If you say it is not true, that is not the same thing as saying that actions done for religious reasons should always be punished, or even sometimes be punished.

That's a contradiction in your logic then. Because earlier you used the example of asking if Jim is left-handed. If you say he is ambidextrous, then the answer should be "No." "Because there is no middle ground."

By the way, you're getting really hung up on the word "harm." Let's just phrase it this way: Do you believe it is acceptable to inflict pain on children with insufficient reason? If so, what do you find to be sufficient reason? Aesthetics? Religion? Tradition? Medical?

All three of those, to a point. Mostly for religious and medical reasons. Tradition can play some role in it, but is not a qualifier. Aesthetics is even less of a reason, but should not be outright banned. I believe that piercing a child's ear to put a tiny stud in it for aesthetic reasons is perfectly fine. I find no problem with it at all. But cutting off a child's ear, because you think it would look better, is no reason to allow it. Cutting off the foreskin of a baby's penis is fine, since it is a common religious rite, and does no more harm than piercing an ear.
 
Come on Thunder, come on Thunder. Here's how I compared them:

You biasly (is that a word?) asked for the SIMILARITIES. But failed to mention anything about the differences. The differences between male and female circumcision is what is important, not the similarities.
 
As do some Catholics [insist on circumcision], despite the arguments this does not happen within the Church. :)


Still no evidence.

Some Catholics may well circumcise their sons (in America, because it seems to be fashionable there), but THEY ARE NOT REQUIRED TO DO IT AS A RELIGIOUS OBSERVANCE, and IT IS NOT NECESSARY FOR GETTING INTO HEAVEN.

They can only do it at all because the RC church removed a ban on the practice quite recently.

And if it is happening "within the Church" as some sort of religious ceremony, then in Roman Catholic terms, this is HERESY.

Rolfe.
 
Someone's having a party and I wasn't invited.

A few times in this post I will be quoting the Wikipedia page on circumcision (with references provided). The page has pictures that are not safe for work.

Unless you're a urologist or mohel. :)
 
Yes. Wildy mentioned Reynolds v. United StatesWP. I mentioned Employment Division v. SmithWP. Nihilianth didn't like these because they weren't about circumcision, and thus, in his mind, do not apply. Apparently, in his world, case law applies to that one specific case only and nothing else.

No. I didn't like those, because they didn't deal with religious practices vs upholding something that was already a law.

There is nothing against circumcision. Whereas in the Smith case, they were doing drugs, when it was already legalized.

And I explained the entire situation ad nauseum which got conveniently ignored. I had to explain how it was far from an easy decision for the courts to decide. It went from the state SC, to SCOTUS, back to the state, and back to SCOTUS a second time.

Even though doing drugs was already illegal, they took Smith's religious rights into SERIOUS consideration. Otherwise, the case would not have ping-ponged back and forth like it did.

Circumcision has nothing to do with this, since there is no laws on the books regarding circumcision, other than some guidelines on how it must be performed.
 
You biasly (is that a word?) asked for the SIMILARITIES. But failed to mention anything about the differences. The differences between male and female circumcision is what is important, not the similarities.

thank you.

and by the way folks, St. Paul made it no longer compulsary for Christians to circumcise their sons. Only Hebrew Christians (Jews who convert to Christianity), need do that.

there is NO compulsion in the NT, for Christian men to be circumcised.
 
I do remember when I was an A-level student of American Politics in Haywards Heath being shown some of the "wacky" things that go on in the US.

One of them was a newspaper article about a prisoner (I think!) who had requested a Satanic altar and robes to perform Satan-worshipping ceremonies on particular days as part of his First Amendment rights.

There followed some jocular sentences about how he wouldn't be allowed a goat for ritual sacrifice (or, and I may have imagined this bit, virgins to impregnate).

I remembered thinking, well is there or isn't there freedom of religion in the US?

The other one I mentioned in this thread already is suttee (or Sati). I think that no US court would accept that practice on religious grounds.

The problem is, people keep thinking the First Amendment (and indeed, all right,) are either you allow every circumstance without question, or you ban all, allowing no room for a civilized Democratic society to function.

Should the Satanic Worshiper be given a robe and alter to pray to Satan while in prison? Sure, why not? Who's it hard? Should he be given an animal to sacrifice? I dunno, I am no lawyer, but I do know that animals also have rights to a certain extent, the rules in the jail is against arming any inmate with a weapon (how else would a sacrificial right be done, without a knife to slice some poor animal's throat?) and I think it is rather reasonable to deny this action anyway. Should the Satanic worshiper be given a virgin to have sex with? Only if given the prisoner has earned the right to a conjugal visit, and they personally know and have asked the virgin herself, and there is no exchange of cash. (Prostitution being illegal and all of that.)
 
Don't be ridiculous. Of course your foreskin isn't sensitive; it isn't even there. And how can you know what it would have felt like, given that you've never had one?

Doesn't mean sex is any less enjoyable. I ask you the same question: How would you know the sensitivity level if you have never been circumcised?



You have no way of knowing this, since your parents denied you the ability to find out.

Dave

Doesn't matter, because I am not missing anything, much like people in the thirties never missed playing Mass Effect 2 on the XBox 360. My life isn't any less fulfilling, and sex isn't any less enjoyable.
 
Should someone be allowed to lop a bit off the penis of his new-born son?

Sounds like a really bad thing to me, I vote no.

Rolfe.
 
Why? What does it benefit the state or society to ban such a practice?

I'm not talking about benefitting the state or society I am talking about benefitting the children. (Wow! Misanthropic as I am I never thought I'd say that!)

You cannot ban something, just for the sake of banning something

Nor will I.

because you disagree why something is done.

The word "disagree" is wrong.

That is no argument, and would immeidiately be thrown out of any court in the country.

Good job that's not mine. And a good job you're not a lawyer because you'd be thrown out of any court in the country too. Certainly any law firm.

If you want to ban something, you must outline, and provide evidence, of specifically how, and why the state would benefit from the ban, and how it would help society.

No, I don't. Keeping autistic children under the stairs is bad. Mutilating children for no good reason is bad too. Very simple.

Saying "but you are taking the choice from the baby!" is not a good enough of an answer, since the parents are given legal status on the right to consent for their minor. Saying "it mutilates the baby's body!" is also a false statement, because it is subjective.

It's not subjective. It is highly demonstrative. In fact, I can't think of very many more obvious forms of mutilation. You CUT a piece of flesh off a child. In what doolally universe do you live in that that is not mutilation?

You cannot take a subjective statement, and state it as fact.

I can't? Or you can't? And who says I can't? Aren't you being all subjective about it?

And "mutilation" is too ambiguous a term to be convincing in any court of law as well.

If you say so. But this is question begging. Courts of law presumably must have subjective standards. How can you say that "mutilation" is both subjective and legally objective without begging the question. The point is we are saying that even if courts of law agree with you we think they are wrong to do so.

The judge would likely raise his eyebrows, and ask, specifically, what type of "mutilation" is occurring. I am sure most lawyers would encourage you to use the proper technical term or phrase for what you are describing.

Then I might saw the judge's willy off and ask him if he objects. Let's see him waggle his jaunty eyebrows after that.

If you are describing taking a cheese grater and completely destroying the baby's genitals, "mutilation" still wouldn't suffice.

Well now we know you have lost the argument and resorting to "burn the village to save the village" logic. You don't consider it mutilation if you saw off a kid's genitals with a cheese grater? Presumably you'd argue that the judge will wiggle his eyebrows if I was before him on charges of burning off your genitals with a blowtorch. Mutilation is, you see, all subjective. So who are we or you or anyone to say what it is. You'll be thrown out of court even trying to make your case.
 
Last edited:
You should check out type 1 female genital cutting.

I think I shall. I am quite uninformed about female circumcision and the risks, and benefits (if any) it may have. I was just saying it is nothing like male circumcision, because nobody seems to want to post just a little piece about it when done under perfectly clinical, modern, and professional environment. And it most certainly seems as though people like AngrySobe wants to avoid the issue of the differences, and only concentrate on the similarities. Which is a problem, because he wants to only solve a problem using half of an equation.

Myself, I cannot make any informed decisions as to whether or not it is alright, without some extensive research on the topic.
 
When I said this you said, I was ignorant "dude" or some other Thunderism.

No, I said no such thing. My days of calling people names are over.

the similarities between male circumcision and female genital mutilation are minor. the differences, however....are major.

Read the thread.

....or don't. I really don't care.
 
Last edited:
You biasly (is that a word?) asked for the SIMILARITIES. But failed to mention anything about the differences. The differences between male and female circumcision is what is important, not the similarities.

Why is it biased?

I am forming a principle. It may be ill-conceived but you, or Thunder, have to show me what it is.

Let's forget FGM if you wish and I'll just ask YOU the question since Thunder won't answer:

Why is it acceptable to harm your child and cause permanent damage when there are no known intended benefits (particularly medical) and possible (slightly significant) harm involved?
 
Last edited:
Why is it acceptable to harm your child and cause permanent damage when there are no known intended benefits (particularly medical) and possible (slightly significant) harm involved?

ask the folks who do ear piercings. my sister's ears were pierced at a young age, but caused infections.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom