Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Thunder said:
I said male circumcision appears to cause little to no significant harm. I was being generous.

Which is it? No significant harm or little significant harm?

If the former then what kind of harm does male circumcision cause?

If the latter then why should you endorse anything that causes significant harm, no matter how little, for no apparent benefit?
 
We aren't talking about mutilating anything. We are talking about circumcision here. This is a major semantics issue, as I have already pointed out.


Since he has me on ignore, would someone else like to point out to him (with links) that St. Paul declared circumcision should be properly described as mutilation?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I'm happy enough to say that parents shouldn't get their children's ears pierced and can happily say that it ticks all the relevant boxes that I earlier made about male circumcision.

The others on the list you provided are bad analogies.

Why? What does it benefit the state or society to ban such a practice? You cannot ban something, just for the sake of banning something because you disagree why something is done. That is no argument, and would immeidiately be thrown out of any court in the country.

If you want to ban something, you must outline, and provide evidence, of specifically how, and why the state would benefit from the ban, and how it would help society.

Saying "but you are taking the choice from the baby!" is not a good enough of an answer, since the parents are given legal status on the right to consent for their minor. Saying "it mutilates the baby's body!" is also a false statement, because it is subjective. You cannot take a subjective statement, and state it as fact. And "mutilation" is too ambiguous a term to be convincing in any court of law as well. The judge would likely raise his eyebrows, and ask, specifically, what type of "mutilation" is occurring. I am sure most lawyers would encourage you to use the proper technical term or phrase for what you are describing.

If you are describing taking a cheese grater and completely destroying the baby's genitals, "mutilation" still wouldn't suffice. You would need to use the more technical and specific circumstance of "using a cheese grater."
 
Perhaps an extensive study of history [....] is in due order.


And perhaps Nihilanth should start by studying his own religion, its history and practice. And law, come to that.

He appears to be woefully ignorant.

Rolfe.
 
Which is it? No significant harm or little significant harm?

If the former then what kind of harm does male circumcision cause?

If the latter then why should you endorse anything that causes significant harm, no matter how little, for no apparent benefit?

:rolleyes:

vaccines can cause harm, but we do it anyways.

all surgery, no matter how small or large, can cause harm. but we do it anyways.

male circumcision can cause harm. it rarely does, but it can. however, female genital mutilation...almost ALWAYS causes harm. and in many cases very serious harm.

and now, we are done.
 
According to some bloke called St Paul (who was, I think, named after a Catholic School I once went to)

In a late letter [Paul] warned Christians to beware of the mutilation, saying that Christians were the true circumcision because they worshipped in the Spirit of God.

http://www.blueletterbible.org/lang/...gs=G2699&t=KJV

Note that interpretation of Paul's letter to the Galatians. ".... as though he would say, keep your eye on that boasted circumcision, or to call it by its true name, concision or mutilation."
 
They have no right to raise their kids how they want within the law? This is one of the lamest things I have read yet in this thread. Sorry, but I am being quite frank with this, and insist this is a poor argument.


Indeed. As an argument against changing the law, yours doesn't even get off the starting blocks.

Rolfe.
 
Has anybody made the point that actions can be banned on purely non-religious grounds, even if some religions require you to engage in these actions?

Yes. We have had this conversation quite often throughout this thread.

Let's say some atheistic group got together, and began to bring Bibles into public schools. They could very easily turn around and say "Nobody should be allowed to bring a Bible to school, even for their own reading, because there are people who bring them in for non-religious purposes as well! Therefore, it should be banned because it would keep the non-religious from bringing them in as well, and is not going against any creed."

There are certain situations where you can ban some religious practices, but cannot ban others. Just the same as you can ban some speech, but not others. You can ban some firearms, but not others. In other words: The Constitution is not absolute, but neither should it be limited without good reason.
 
:rolleyes:

vaccines can cause harm, but we do it anyways.

all surgery, no matter how small or large, can cause harm. but we do it anyways.

male circumcision can cause harm. it rarely does, but it can. however, female genital mutilation...almost ALWAYS causes harm. and in many cases very serious harm.

and now, we are done.

Yes, but surgery and vaccines is intended to have medical benefits. Right?

Yet according to you male circumcision doesn't have medical benefits. Right?

In fact, according to you it may only do little significant medical damage. Right?

So you are the one making bad comparisons.

Why do you think vaccines and surgery are good comparisons with male circumcision given that the former two have intended health benefits and given that you've denied the health benefits of the latter?
 
Nihilianth said:
Granted. Still, two wrongs don't make a right. Just because torturing someone to death over days or weeks is worse, somehow, than killing them unexpectedly with a shot to the back of the head doesn't make the latter not wrong.

For the hundredth time, neither of those equate to circumcision.

Of course not. Now address the analogy, please. Does the fact one wrong is less evil than another make it not evil? Or make it Ok to do?











This completely ignores the actual philosophy behind rights and what they are, and why people have them.

No it doesn't

Yes it does.



You have the right, in a free country*, to do what you want with your own body and property. A baby's body is not your body, and therefore you have no right to mutilate it for ritualistic religious reasons.

There's with that "mutilation" word again. Intellectual dishonesty earns you no points. Quit calling it "mutilation." There is a separate technical term for a reason. It is called "circumcision." "Mutilation" is too ambiguous, as it can mean anything.

Re-defining mutilation as not-mutilation does not make it so. You are mutilating the sex organs of someone else without their consent. This is ethically wrong, even if God exists and God says it's ok.



In any case, it isn't about "aesthetic surgery," either. What it is about, is the parents raising the child in their home, with their traditions, and their religious beliefs. Parents have the right to circumcise their child, because that is how they want to raise him: As a Jew, Christian, or Muslim. Since it does no real harm to the individual in question, the government has no right to interfere with said religious tradition.

I don't deny it isn't a radical change to the past. However, that it has been done historically doesn't mean it isn't wrong.

If it's wrong to mutilate a part of someone's body without their permission, it's wrong.


That somebody can gin up a half-assed scientific rationale for it, while still doing it for the real and completely different reason is, unfortunately, how our society works with a lot of laws, and the courts support it.

What are you talking about? Courts support what? The First Amendment? That they most certainly do. I honestly have no idea what you wrote here, or the point you are trying to make.

Half-assed arguments such as "esthetics" and meager medical benefits are touted as brand new rationale to support circumcision precisely to strip the religious background of it, which becomes less and less defensible.

That is what I am talking about. Do you understand, now, even if you do not agree?




* Actually, you have this right in a non-free country, too, even in a country that "voted it away democratically". Your right is violated, but still remains. That people have the physical power, or numbers (remember the vote is an abstraction of "might makes right") to violate your right does not take it away; rights are not dependent on others "granting" them to you -- it is a contradiction that they somehow have the right to grant rights to others.

Wow! This is totally false. Apparently, you have no idea how a democratic republic like the United States actually works.

I think you need to have a basic Civics class at the very least before you go around saying these things. At the very very least, perhaps you should look up the term "Republic," (which is what this country is. It isn't necessarily a "Democracy." It is a Republic with Democratic values.)

I would also highly suggest you give the Constitution of the United States of America a thorough reading, and not come back until you understand each and every article written therein about the structure of the government, it's three branches, and the purposes of those branches. The purpose of the electorate, and the capacity of just what "powers" the citizens have.

I suggest you go learn what "inalienable" and inherent "endowed by their Creator" means. Rights are not dependent on others granting them to you -- how did they get this mysterious, awesome power? Why did you allow them to have it, even especially on a philosophical level?

You seem to suffer from the insensate concept, so popular, that vox populi vox dei, that everything is justified by and for simple popular vote.


That most certainly is not the basis of the US concept of freedom and laws. Many of the checks and balances in the US Constitution are oriented against thwarting the blowing winds of political passion, to slow down massive changes that could occur because of sudden outrages and charismatic demagogues.


I think you should also look up the history of the Supreme Court. SCOTUS has passed many deliberations which were really unpopular that extended rights to other peoples, such as blacks and women, when those views were in the minority. The Supreme Court upholds the law as written in the Constitution. No matter how unpopular something may be, SCOTUS is there to uphold the law as it is written, and to strike down any laws that may have been popularly written, if it is unconstitutional.

Hence the possibility for change on this issue of circumcision. Even stripped of its religious origins, you do not have the right to mutilate someone else's body without their permission.



In any case, those seeking to ban circumcision appears to be in a very small minority. Most atheists couldn't care less one way or the other. And atheists are far outnumbered by religious folks in this country. So you would lose by popular vote anyway.

Not helping your case any, immediately after talking about slavery and so on being popular, once.



Nihilianth said:
The baby also has inalienable rights. Among them are to not have its genitals mutilated without its consent for archaic, ritualistic religious reasons. Other people's religious reasons, not its own.

Where's is say those words in the Constitution? Certainly the first sentence is correct, but all the rest is just nonsensical rambling about what you know nothing of.

You have the right to life, which includes the right to your body, which includes the right to not have that body mutilated against your will.

Please expound at length how my "ramblings" are misunderstanding this issue.
 
Last edited:
Actually, no. Do you?

Rolfe.

No. I think I was asking bikerdruid why that was.

I could guess however and say that it wasn't part of canonical law but did become practiced under local pressures. Maybe it would help to know whether circumcision is practiced in Chaldean Christian culture as well.

I have heard, however that in some parts of Egypt and East Africa that female circumcision rates are HUGE and that it is not based on religion but local custom.
 
Let's say some atheistic group got together, and began to bring Bibles into public schools. They could very easily turn around and say "Nobody should be allowed to bring a Bible to school, even for their own reading, because there are people who bring them in for non-religious purposes as well! Therefore, it should be banned because it would keep the non-religious from bringing them in as well, and is not going against any creed."

That's such a ridiculous example as to be utterly absurd. The test of whether a law can ban a religious practice, as has been stated earlier in the thread, is not whether the practice may also be undertaken for non-religious reasons; it is whether the law is intended to fulfil some other purpose than religious discrimination. In your case, the law would very obviously fail, because a law banning anybody from bringing copies of the Bible into a school very obviously had no other purpose than limiting freedom of religious expression.

Now, let's make up a slightly different example. Suppose the Onomatopeian religion requires that the left ear is removed from all babies at birth. There is, however, a law prohibiting the surgical removal of the left ear of a baby because it constitutes unnecessary harm and confers no physical benefit. In this case, the purpose of the law is unconnected with religious expression, therefore the law is not proscribed by the First Amendment.

The same is true, of course, of any hypothetical law prohibiting the surgical removal of the foreskin.

Dave
 
No. I think I was asking bikerdruid why that was.

I could guess however and say that it wasn't part of canonical law but did become practiced under local pressures. Maybe it would help to know whether circumcision is practiced in Chaldean Christian culture as well.

I have heard, however that in some parts of Egypt and East Africa that female circumcision rates are HUGE and that it is not based on religion but local custom.


It's not mentioned in the wiki article about the Coptic Christianity, as far as I can see.

Rolfe.
 
Most Mormons practice polygamy anyway. Do they get harassed by the state? Not really.

Although, they can only claim one mate on their taxes. This was the point of illegalizing polygamy. They would end up earning far more earned income tax credits, and would make the tax structure far more complicated, using unnecessary funds. In short, polygamists step on other peoples' rights as taxpayers.

Wait...WHAT?


Not only do you seem to know nothing about your own religion, you also seem woefully ignorant of others! :eye-poppi
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom