The same could be said for cutting people ears... That still don't make it a good argument. Any mutilation of part of a body , even if that body part is not functionally relevant to the being, is still an adult imposing its choice and mutilating a kids, and the kid later on being unable to reverse the choice the adult made. And that is the point.
We aren't talking about mutilating anything. We are talking about circumcision here. This is a major semantics issue, as I have already pointed out.
If you cannot use the proper terminology, or take me up on my compromise over this issue, I will continue to say this.
You have freedom of speech and brainwashing your kid with your religion.
Oh so now parents are not allowed to teach their kids how to behave? They have no right to raise their kids how they want within the law? This is one of the lamest things I have read yet in this thread. Sorry, but I am being quite frank with this, and insist this is a poor argument.
But as soon as you mutilate their body, you are on the same level as female circumcision folk in north Africa (which by the way majorly do it as a cultural things, much less as a forbid-girl-getting-pleasure things).
So then, how about we just do away with the first amendmen and the justice system altogether, and just have a dictatorial system where everything you do can arbitrarily be illegal? That sound good?
No. It doesn't. The PROBLEM is, you are so fixated on trying to compare an extreme situation directly with a benign situation. This is one of the biggest logical fallacies throughout the entire thread, it is amazing. And it keeps being purported.
If you insist on either legalizing female circumcision (which is NOTHING like male circumcision, as far as the risks involved) for consistency-sake, then we must therefore conclude that we should legalize yelling "FIRE!" in a crowded theater, or lying in a court of law in order to remain consistent with allowing people to say whatever it is they want.
Sorry, but the world is not black-and-white. You CAN allow freedom of speech, but outlaw certain speech. You CAN allow freedom of religion, and outlaw some religious practices. You CAN allow universal suffrage, but keep criminals from voting. You CAN allow the right to bear arms, but outlaw some arms.
Where people get the idea that you are being inconsistent by allowing one thing within the confines of the Constitution, but not allowing something else is being inconsistent, I have no idea. Perhaps an extensive study of history, and the law is in due order.