Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Has anybody made the point that actions can be banned on purely non-religious grounds, even if some religions require you to engage in these actions?
We can ban bonfires on environmental/safety grounds, even if it interferes with proper Beltaine celebrations.
We can ban the unlicensed killing of healthy animals on sanitary or humanitarian grounds, even if it interferes with ritual sacrifices.
We can ban genital mutilation on child protection / safety grounds, even if it interferes with ritual circumcision.
The First Amendment is not a barrier to nondiscriminatory laws with a genuine secular purpose.
 
So, as I suspected, I'm having a discussion with someone who's not a big fan of that whole logic thing.

black... white... grayish-black... grayish-white...

This is all nonsense. There is no "half-truth" in logic. (there is fuzzy logic, but I really need to keep this simple, here, and it doesn't apply anyways)

Jim is left-handed. If I say, "Jim is ambidextrous," am I saying something that is half-true? No. I'm saying something that is completely false. There is no middle ground. Formally, this is known as the law of excluded middleWP.

So I'm going to ask again. Take the following statement:

If an action is done for religious reasons should not be punished by law.

Is this true, or is it not?

If you say it's true, then you have to accept that religious sacrifice is acceptable in the eyes of the law. I'm not asking a tough question here.

NOTE: If you say it is not true, that is not the same thing as saying that actions done for religious reasons should always be punished, or even sometimes be punished.

By the way, you're getting really hung up on the word "harm." Let's just phrase it this way: Do you believe it is acceptable to inflict pain on children with insufficient reason? If so, what do you find to be sufficient reason? Aesthetics? Religion? Tradition? Medical?
 
comparing male circumcision to female genital mutilation, is a gross exaggeration and pretty ignorant.

try reading about what happens to these girls.

Come on Thunder, come on Thunder. Here's how I compared them:

What is important, however, is the similarities. I think people have already listed these but they are essentially:

No apparent medical benefit derives from either even though both are painful and both are effectively permanent.

Then you gave me links to the health problems caused from FGM which wasn't what I pointed out. I pointed out:

What is important, however, is the similarities. I think people have already listed these but they are essentially:

No apparent medical benefit derives from either even though both are painful and both are effectively permanent.

Then I think I asked you for the medical consensus health benefits of male circumcision and I am still waiting for it.

So what are the benefits?
 
Pretty much, it appears. Not hard to find out, either. Nihilianth didn't bother.




So it appears. I didn't know that. I was in Egypt about six weeks ago and met lots of Coptic Christians (one of them even gave me a holy picture as a keepsake), but somehow, it didn't come up in conversation....

Rolfe.

Thanks Rolfe! :)
 
Has anybody made the point that actions can be banned on purely non-religious grounds, even if some religions require you to engage in these actions?
We can ban bonfires on environmental/safety grounds, even if it interferes with proper Beltaine celebrations.
We can ban the unlicensed killing of healthy animals on sanitary or humanitarian grounds, even if it interferes with ritual sacrifices.
We can ban genital mutilation on child protection / safety grounds, even if it interferes with ritual circumcision.
The First Amendment is not a barrier to nondiscriminatory laws with a genuine secular purpose.

Yes. Wildy mentioned Reynolds v. United StatesWP. I mentioned Employment Division v. SmithWP. Nihilianth didn't like these because they weren't about circumcision, and thus, in his mind, do not apply. Apparently, in his world, case law applies to that one specific case only and nothing else.
 
Then I think I asked you for the medical consensus health benefits of male circumcision and I am still waiting for it.

So what are the benefits?

err....its your request. you research it.

I do not believe that circumcision should not be banned, due to its possible medical benefits. male circumcision is a relatively benign medical procedure that appears to cause little to no significant harm to one's sexual health....contrary to female genital mutilation which often destroys a woman's sexual health.
 
About logic...

I seem to remember there are troubling cases when it comes to the law of excluded middle.

i.e "The King of France is bald"

I believe it can be resolved by premising each proposition with "It is the case that..." and "It is not the case that..."

Just thought I'd point that out. In fact, it may be more complicated than that.
 
Has anybody made the point that actions can be banned on purely non-religious grounds, even if some religions require you to engage in these actions?

I think so.

Without trying to derail too much, if I understand correctly the use of cannabis is part of the Rastafarian religion. But that action is illegal in the UK as it the drug is classified as a Class B substance under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971.
 
err....its your request. you research it.

I do not believe that circumcision should not be banned, due to its possible medical benefits. male circumcision is a relatively benign medical procedure that appears to cause little to no significant harm to one's sexual health....contrary to female genital mutilation which often destroys a woman's sexual health.

In other words you cannot cite any health benefits to male circumcision and won't present evidence for it. In fact, you even say it may cause some significant harm but because it causes less significant harm to a person's sexual health than female genital mutilation you support it.

Well, dipping an infants limbs and torso in strong acid may cause more significant harm to an infant's sexual health that even female genital but does that mean that the latter should therefore be acceptable?
 
The skin removed has nerve endings and experiences sensations. Its removal impairs those sensations, as they can no longer be felt at all. So there's an impairment, meaning that there is harm.

You lose.

Dave

I beg to differ, as someone who has been circumcised. It is still quite sensative.

And that is hardly the proper use of the term "impairment." Shall I post that definition as well?

Wiki: Several different connotations of the word.

Impairment may refer to:

A medical condition that leads to disability

In accounting, a downward revaluation of fixed assets

In health, any loss or abnormality of physiological, psychological, or anatomical structure or function, whether permanent or temporary. Identifying impairments that contribute to a functional problem for a patient is a key factor for a health professional to determine appropriate treatment.

A classification of poor water quality for a surface water body under the U.S. Clean Water Act

The first definition of impairment says about "disability." Well, the thing sure has hell aint' disable. Me's gots some twins on teh way! :D

Second connotation has to do with running a business.

Third one has to do with loss of anatomical function. This is interesting. However, putting it into proper context, it mentions about how it is important for health professionals to identify an "impairment that contributes to a functional problem for a patient."

I doubt that you can fit the removal of the foreskin into the context as used above as a "functional problem." Just the way that sentence is stated, it would appear they are talking about actual serious problems, that can or does cause a disability.

Freedictionary:

im·pair (m-pâr)
tr.v. im·paired, im·pair·ing, im·pairs
To cause to diminish, as in strength, value, or quality: an injury that impaired my hearing; a severe storm impairing communications.

Well, the neither the strength, the value, nor the quality of the penis is diminished in any way. Those are all, once again, subjective terms. The example sentence given, an injury impaired my hearing, and a severe storm impaired communications, would likewise suggest the term is used in rather more severe cases.
 
Has anybody made the point that actions can be banned on purely non-religious grounds, even if some religions require you to engage in these actions?
We can ban bonfires on environmental/safety grounds, even if it interferes with proper Beltaine celebrations.
We can ban the unlicensed killing of healthy animals on sanitary or humanitarian grounds, even if it interferes with ritual sacrifices.
We can ban genital mutilation on child protection / safety grounds, even if it interferes with ritual circumcision.
The First Amendment is not a barrier to nondiscriminatory laws with a genuine secular purpose.

I do remember when I was an A-level student of American Politics in Haywards Heath being shown some of the "wacky" things that go on in the US.

One of them was a newspaper article about a prisoner (I think!) who had requested a Satanic altar and robes to perform Satan-worshipping ceremonies on particular days as part of his First Amendment rights.

There followed some jocular sentences about how he wouldn't be allowed a goat for ritual sacrifice (or, and I may have imagined this bit, virgins to impregnate).

I remembered thinking, well is there or isn't there freedom of religion in the US?

The other one I mentioned in this thread already is suttee (or Sati). I think that no US court would accept that practice on religious grounds.
 
Nowhere does it say it allows you to impose YOUR free speech over the body of your baby. Actually I am pretty sure that if somebody started mutilating female genitalia , the law would smack them down hard. And if not, then it is morally wrong, and would also allow female genital mutilation as well as many other type of mutilation.

baby might not be adult, but they have human right too.

If anyone mutilated anyone, the law would slap them down hard.

Circumcision, on the other hand, is perfectly legal.

Now, I never said anything about FREE SPEECH trumping a baby's body. I was saying FREEDOM OF RELIGION is what is at stake here. And for that, please see post number 527.
 
I beg to differ, as someone who has been circumcised. It is still quite sensative.

Don't be ridiculous. Of course your foreskin isn't sensitive; it isn't even there. And how can you know what it would have felt like, given that you've never had one?

Well, the neither the strength, the value, nor the quality of the penis is diminished in any way.

You have no way of knowing this, since your parents denied you the ability to find out.

Dave
 
In other words you cannot cite any health benefits to male circumcision and won't present evidence for it.

dude....is it my claim that male circumcision has any benefits???

why the heck should I prove a claim that I never made???

lololol!!! try again buddy.

In fact, you even say it may cause some significant harm but because it causes less significant harm to a person's sexual health than female genital mutilation you support it.

dude....you are really really stretching here. I said male circumcision appears to cause little to no significant harm. I was being generous.

Well, dipping an infants limbs and torso in strong acid may cause more significant harm to an infant's sexual health that even female genital but does that mean that the latter should therefore be acceptable?

that's our angrysoba!!! :p

btw, I also heard shooting someone in the head causes less harm than female genital mutilation. ;)
 
...snip...

The RC church having "no official stance" on circumcision any longer means that they have stopped banning it!!!! They do not encourage it or mandate it, it is not a religious obligation, never has been, and is in no way necessary for a Catholic to be a good Catholic.

If your Catholic diocese was carrying out circumcision as a religious practice, then they had fallen into heresy, it's that simple.

...snip...

Curiously in some African countries the cultures that carry out genital mutilation are divided across Roman Catholics and Protestants (such as Anglicans), if I recall correctly it is usually the RCers being the ones that carry it out. Of course that is a good example of the maxim "correlation does not mean causation" they don't carry out genital mutilation because they are RCers. I mention it because it's one of those interesting little quirks that show up in different cultures that I always find quite fascinating.
 
The same could be said for cutting people ears... That still don't make it a good argument. Any mutilation of part of a body , even if that body part is not functionally relevant to the being, is still an adult imposing its choice and mutilating a kids, and the kid later on being unable to reverse the choice the adult made. And that is the point.

We aren't talking about mutilating anything. We are talking about circumcision here. This is a major semantics issue, as I have already pointed out.

If you cannot use the proper terminology, or take me up on my compromise over this issue, I will continue to say this.

You have freedom of speech and brainwashing your kid with your religion.

Oh so now parents are not allowed to teach their kids how to behave? They have no right to raise their kids how they want within the law? This is one of the lamest things I have read yet in this thread. Sorry, but I am being quite frank with this, and insist this is a poor argument.

But as soon as you mutilate their body, you are on the same level as female circumcision folk in north Africa (which by the way majorly do it as a cultural things, much less as a forbid-girl-getting-pleasure things).

So then, how about we just do away with the first amendmen and the justice system altogether, and just have a dictatorial system where everything you do can arbitrarily be illegal? That sound good?

No. It doesn't. The PROBLEM is, you are so fixated on trying to compare an extreme situation directly with a benign situation. This is one of the biggest logical fallacies throughout the entire thread, it is amazing. And it keeps being purported.

If you insist on either legalizing female circumcision (which is NOTHING like male circumcision, as far as the risks involved) for consistency-sake, then we must therefore conclude that we should legalize yelling "FIRE!" in a crowded theater, or lying in a court of law in order to remain consistent with allowing people to say whatever it is they want.

Sorry, but the world is not black-and-white. You CAN allow freedom of speech, but outlaw certain speech. You CAN allow freedom of religion, and outlaw some religious practices. You CAN allow universal suffrage, but keep criminals from voting. You CAN allow the right to bear arms, but outlaw some arms.

Where people get the idea that you are being inconsistent by allowing one thing within the confines of the Constitution, but not allowing something else is being inconsistent, I have no idea. Perhaps an extensive study of history, and the law is in due order.
 
dude....is it my claim that male circumcision has any benefits???

why the heck should I prove a claim that I never made???

lololol!!! try again buddy.



dude....you are really really stretching here. I said male circumcision appears to cause little to no significant harm. I was being generous.



that's our angrysoba!!! :p

btw, I also heard shooting someone in the head causes less harm than female genital mutilation. ;)

So, to reiterate what I said:

The two [male and female circumcision] are obviously not the same. One is done to females. The other is done to males.

What is important, however, is the similarities. I think people have already listed these but they are essentially:

No apparent medical benefit derives from either even though both are painful and both are effectively permanent.

When I said this you said, I was ignorant "dude" or some other Thunderism.

But now you have shown you completely agree.

Let's say it again:

No apparent medical benefit derives from either even though both are painful and both are effectively permanent.

I think that's a pretty good rule of thumb for not allowing it. What is your problem with that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom