Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Oh I have, in fact.

I'll provide the lemon test, to show you just where and how it is a matter of subjective opinion.



It CAN pass here, I can give you that.



Unfortunately, the primary effect would be prohibiting practicing Jews, Christians, and Muslims. This fails.

This fails even more miserably, because you would have a lot of upset people on your hands that the government excessively for entangled in their religious affairs.

Thanks for addressing my point but you are definitely wrong with the "entanglement" prong. Case law uses the word "entanglement" to mean things like co-mingling of government and religions funds.

The primary effect prong is a bit trickier than you suggest as well. One could argue that the primary effect is to prevent the mutilation of children.

just because you do not believe in God, or have any religious faith, doesn't mean those that do's views are any less important than yours. The First Amendment was meant to protect you from being forced to worship, and it protects religious people from being forced to give up their sacred ways.

(Please, don't get into the whole issue of "but what about <insert extreme religious practice which violates another citizen's rights here> That horse has long been beated to death, and completely mutilated to the point where it would be unrecognizable as anything that might as lived. :) We are not taking about such extreme behaviors. )

For what it's worth, I'm on the fence about this topic. I find circumcision disturbing and immoral but there are lots of things I find disturbing and immoral that I wouldn't ban.

I don't think the reductio ad absurdum argument is wrongheaded. We all agree that some religious behavior should be banned, even when it comes to raising children. Once you agree that a line should exist, it's just a matter of where you draw it.
 
Last edited:
buddy, I am FAR....from mutilated.

;)


..and its spelled "circumcision". removing penile foreskin is not a religion.


Thanks for correcting my misspelling of circumcision buddy, but it's still a mutilation of body parts.
 
Thanks for correcting my misspelling of circumcision buddy, but it's still a mutilation of body parts.

how can a mutilation make something look SOOOOOOOOOOOOO GOOD??????

;)

when I was 12, I had 4 teeth removed, and then braces. the braces moved around my teeth, in a way my mouth had not intended.

do you consider this to have been a mutilation?
 
Last edited:
how can a mutilation make something look SOOOOOOOOOOOOO GOOD??????

;)

when I was 12, I had 4 teeth removed, and then braces. the braces moved around my teeth, in a way my mouth had not intended.

do you consider this to have been a mutilation?

Were you informed beforehand?
 
how can a mutilation make something look SOOOOOOOOOOOOO GOOD??????

;)

when I was 12, I had 4 teeth removed, and then braces. the braces moved around my teeth, in a way my mouth had not intended.

do you consider this to have been a mutilation?

What had your mouth intended?

Are you honestly comparing wearing braces to being circumcised?

Do your teeth look better now than before you wore braces?

Has anyone died from wearing braces?
 
Were you informed beforehand?

sure. but I had no power nor legal right to resist.

a child simply does not have the right to say "mommy, I do NOT want these teeth removed, I do NOT want braces, and I demand my constitutional and human right to refuse these procedures".
 
Are you honestly comparing wearing braces to being circumcised?

Do your teeth look better now than before you wore braces?

Has anyone died from wearing braces?

am I comparing having my parents tell me that my smile is ugly, and that I MUST have 4 teeth permanently removed through surgery, and have painful steel attached to my teeth for four and a half years....to circumcision of an 8-day-old baby boy?

you're darn right I is.

both happened without the consent of the patient. both involved surgery. both made irreversible changes to the body.
 
Last edited:
am I comparing having my parents tell me that my smile is ugly, and that I MUST have 4 teeth permanently removed through surgery, and have painful steel attached to my teeth for four and a half years....to circumcision of an 8-day-old baby boy?

you're darn right I is.

both happened without the consent of the patient. both involved surgery. both made irreversible changes to the body.

Are eight day baby boys impervious to pain?

I assume that is the argument being made here.

Or else, well, it might cause pain but I don't remember so it doesn't matter.

Perhaps that is the argument.

Which?
 
sure. but I had no power nor legal right to resist.

a child simply does not have the right to say "mommy, I do NOT want these teeth removed, I do NOT want braces, and I demand my constitutional and human right to refuse these procedures".

I don't know that they shouldn't.

My dentist said I should get braces. My parents asked if I wanted them. I said, "no." Now, I like my teeth. They function perfectly well and are charmingly askew. :)

Should a parent be able to force any aesthetic procedure on a child who doesn't want it?
 
See, that may be your opinion, but if you reside in the United States of America, that opinion is factually wrong. Please refer to the First Amendment to the United States Constitution:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

And? There are laws against polygamy, which to some Mormons affects their right to practice their religion. And those laws were found constitutional in Reynolds v. United States. Religious duty is not a suitable defence to a crime.

First Amendment wasn't meant to restrict the PARENT'S from raising their children in their own religion. It was meant to restrict the GOVERNMENT from limiting the free exercise of religions. And circumcision happens to be a major part of being Christian, Jew, or Muslim. This would be seen as being a SERIOUS violation of the First Amendment, which allows religions to operate under normal circumstances.

Circumcision isn't a major part of being a Christian. Most Christian denominations don't practice circumcision or require it as a part of their faith. This has been like that since the Council of Jerusalem around year 50.
 
I'm sorry, but this is total crap.

:p

i have never had any issues, nonewhatsoever, with Mr. Winky.

nor has any guy I have ever known, who was a Jew and obviously circumcised.

as for sex? its great. amazing. fantastic. best thing in the world.

i think these men, if true....probably had some nut doctor.

So why not wait and get it done voluntarily at 18?
 
So why not wait and get it done voluntarily at 18?

maybe because its 800,000,000 times easier to do it when you are only 8 days old?

I am very very glad, that my parents had my circumcised when I was a baby.

having to do it when I was 18, would have been one major pain in the butt.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom