Circumcision is mutilation. Period. So is ear piercing. Period. So is any sort of tattoo or other piercing. Period. Socially acceptable mutilation, but mutilation just the same. And if foreskins were so damned unhealthy, the human race would have died out long ago. It's just as painful to baby boys to get circumcised as for young girls to get circumcised. But for some reason, people are only outraged by one of them. Fact.
dictionary.com:
–verb (used with object), -lat·ed, -lat·ing.
1.
to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts: Vandals mutilated the painting.
2.
to deprive (a person or animal) of a limb or other essential part.
Definition number one is highly subjective. You consider circumcision it to be mutilation, others don't.
Definition number two definitely doesn't fit. You are not depriving anyone of a "part."
thefreedictionary.com
mu·ti·late (mytl-t)
tr.v. mu·ti·lat·ed, mu·ti·lat·ing, mu·ti·lates
1. To deprive of a limb or an essential part; cripple.
2. To disfigure by damaging irreparably: mutilate a statue. See Synonyms at batter1.
3. To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.
Again, definition one does not fit for the same reason definition two up above.
Definition two, is also highly subjective. Taking something away from a statue, does not necessarily mean you have "disfigured" it if you like it that way.
Definition three, same deal.
Wikipedia.com
Mutilation or maiming is an act or physical injury that degrades the appearance or function of any living body, usually without causing death.
Seems to suggest that mutilation is an act of doing some serious injury, that can usually cause death. This is a pretty common colloquial use of the term "mutilation."
Denniston et al. have argued that male circumcision is a form of mutilation;[5] their arguments have been criticised by Benatar and Benatar.[6
And to prove my point just how subjective it is, here are two sources linked within wiki, each with differing opinions on whether or not male circumcision is "mutilation."
Now, in order to illustrate my point:
Earlier in the thread, someone asked a highly misleading question:
"So, do you think mutilating the genitals of a baby boy is fine?"
This is a question brilliantly and conveniently posed with only a "yes," or "no" answer. And even more conveniently, the person will be satisfied with an answer that is just as misleading as the question that was posed.
If you say "not;" ("it is not fine to mutilate the penis,")you could be thinking of using a cheese grater on the thing, and completely destroying it. But the person asking the question is able to say: "Ah ha! So you think that circumcision is wrong then!" Because in his equally subjective mind, circumcision is considered "mutilation."
Now, what happens when we answer in the affirmative?
So you say "yes;" ("It is fine to mutilate the penis,") in which you could be thinking "since they are using the term "mutilation" in order to describe circumcision, I shall answer "yes."" But the person asking the question can very easily say: "Ah ha! So you think it is fine to take a cheese grater to a child's penis and completely wreck the thing, you sick bastard you!"
This is EXACTLY why using a technical term that can only mean one thing, is far more preferable to use than a more subjective, and ambiguous term that can be twisted however you want it to be twisted. And the reason why I refuse to recognize the term "mutilation" in this conversation. It has no bearing whatsoever on the subject, it is intellectually dishonest, and wastes an inordinate amount of time, making communication far more difficult than it needs to be.
I am quite surprised I had to actually go to such great lengths to explain the problems of using an ambiguous term, when the technical term is far more desirable. Maybe now we can lay this thing to rest, about "mutilation."
Before I finish this post, I have one final thing to add, if all would agree:
IF you want to use MGM ("Male Genital Mutilation,) I have absolutely no problems with just simply typing "MGM."
However, the rules of this term is going to be used exactly the same way, and will be perfectly interchangeable with, "circumcision." Because, quite frankly, I am getting sick and tired of having to write out the words "circumcision," and "mutilation" all the damned time. And I would also like us all to be on the same page without any dishonesty whatsoever.
I am willing to replace "circumcision" with "MGM." MGM will be a technical term describing circumcision ONLY. It shall not in any way, shape, or form, describe anything to do with using cheese graters, annihilating someone's arm, or throwing an entire body into a meat grinder.
Is this something we can all agree to? Yes, or no?