Ban circumcision in San Fran???

http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/ushealthjewsreligioncircumcision

very very interesting topic.

first of all, I think comparing circumcising 8-day old males to genital mutilation of teenage girls in Africa, is petty week.

#1. genital mutilation of girls in Africa is to prevent them from enjoying sex.

#2. genital mutilation of girls in African is done at an age when they can clearly and vividly remember the experience, and can suffer days and days of pain due to it.

#3. Jewish & Muslim circumcision is done at a very young age. The circumcised male feels the pain for only a few seconds, and then it is gone. There is no evidence that these babies experience any pain hours....if not even minutes after the event. And there is NO evidence whatsoever, that any circumcised males remember the event. I know I sure don't, and I know that even as a young child, I had no memory of the event.

#4. There is a lot of research showing the health benefits of having a boy circumcised. Research in southern Africa showed a decrease in HIV transmission rates to the male of 50%, in circumcises males. That is no chump change.

#5. Jewish & Muslim circumcision is not done to harm the child, or punish him, contrary to female African circumcision.

#6. This clearly violates the separation of Church and State. Such a law would be no different than banning ritualized ear-piercing, branding, etc etc.

It would be one thing, if the folks in SF demanded that all baby boys receive some form of pain killer before the procedure was done, in order to dull the pain. But this is not their concern. Their concern is clearly not the pain the baby suffers, but the ritual itself..and probably even its religious nature.

Seeking to have the govt. ban a private religious act, because of its religious nature, is a violation of the 1st Amendment.

All your points are true, but here's the thing: It's still an irreversible procedure that some adult males, when they are old enough to understand what has happened to them, will resent. Nobody asked me what I wanted.

It would be unethical to circumcise an adult without his permission, but when you do it to him as a baby, then it becomes OK?
 
Thanks for addressing my point but you are definitely wrong with the "entanglement" prong. Case law uses the word "entanglement" to mean things like co-mingling of government and religions funds.

Huh. I did not know that. I never bothered to read up on it a whole lot. Well, ya learn something new every day. :)

The primary effect prong is a bit trickier than you suggest as well. One could argue that the primary effect is to prevent the mutilation of children.

As I have pointed out though, "mutilation" is a rather subjective term. There are many (such as myself and Thunder as an example in this thread) who do not consider it "mutilation." Mutilation, by it's very connotation, makes circumcision sound far worse than than it actually is.

I don't think a court of law would appreciate the use of that term either, as they prefer the more technical terms. This is the same issue I have with Holocaust deniers replacing the technical term with "holohoax" instead. But at least that term is clearer.

DISCLAIMER: I don;t intent to suggest those who use the term "mutilation" and are for the ban of circumcision to be anywhere nearly as uninformed as holocaust deniers.



For what it's worth, I'm on the fence about this topic. I find circumcision disturbing and immoral but there are lots of things I find disturbing and immoral that I wouldn't ban.

Right. And that is one of my main themes throughout this discussion. If you intend to ban something, you must provide evidence that it severely impacts the lives of other people, rather than use the "morally repugnant" argument. Case in point: The very recent victory of the Westboro Baptist Church vs. Snyder case in the SCOTUS.

I don't think the reductio ad absurdum argument is wrongheaded. We all agree that some religious behavior should be banned, even when it comes to raising children. Once you agree that a line should exist, it's just a matter of where you draw it.

This borders on the slippery slope. Even though such as argument CAN be valid, and I use the argument once in a while, I generally use this argument in a cautious manner.

Having said that, of course there must be a line that needs to be made. We have to extremes on both sides of a spectrum: One the one hand, you have the cutting of hair. On the other, you have human sacrifice. The argument with circumcision is how much closer to one side or the other it lies. Evidence for the risks and benefits of circumcision, the lifestyle and health affects it may or may not have, and so forth.

Currently, there is very little evidence that shows just how beneficial (and risky!) circumcision actually is. There is no evidence of the penis functioning any differently (men still enjoy sex quite a bit without a foreskin, despite what others may say), and it doesn't appear to make any circumcised man resentful their parents had it done to them. Most men just go about their normal daily and sexual lives. If there is no harm, there is no foul. Therefore, the religious practice shouldn't be made illegal.

When it comes to actual circumcision, I am very much neutral on the point. I couldn;t care less one way or the other what people may believe or not believe. However, my only intention in all of this, is to express my overwhlming desire to see people exercise caution in trying to get a widely-held religious practice banned, without first considering and weighing ALL of the costs and benefits which might associate with banning the practice.

I was rather foolish throughout most of this thread, getting all caught up an side-tracked on many of the finer points after those horses have been beaten to death.

In the end, nobody has come up with any solutions of how to keep the already bogged-down criminal justice system from becoming even more bogged-down. (Do people even realize just how much of our tax-payer money is going to the CJ system, and how many people we have uselessly jailed in the supposedly "freest society" in the world? The amount of money we are wasting on CJ is mind-boggling, to say the least.) I had a link to the CIA world factbook site that breaks down money spent on CJ, but have since lost it. Don;t feel like digging around atm.

People have also not addressed other problems associated with criminalizing circumcision, other than allowing spending on CJ to spiral out of control. The other issue is the example that Prohibition set.

If people felt strongly enough about drinking their alcohol (which is also used for religious purposes as well, I might remind you!) to undermine the law as severely as they did, imagine what people would do when it comes to a religious practice, and taking more decisions out of the hands of parents. Imagine little newborn baby Bobby's parents taking the child to a less well-trained surgeon with very little to no experience in circumcisions. Well, the ban did no favors for little Bobby, did it? That's what I am afraid of.

I happen to strongly dislike the idea of people and government telling parents what decisions they can and cannot make for their child, if a decision does not affect the health and well-being of said child.
 
I don't know that they shouldn't.

My dentist said I should get braces. My parents asked if I wanted them. I said, "no." Now, I like my teeth. They function perfectly well and are charmingly askew. :)

Should a parent be able to force any aesthetic procedure on a child who doesn't want it?

Yes. It is called the "right to consent" form that a parent must fill out as a legal guardian of the child when they visit a hospital, when a child is unable to make an informed decision:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informed_consent

I have no idea why I did not think of this before. This idea pretty much lays to rest all arguments concerning the rights of the parent to make an informed decision about any medical procedure in the case of a child who is unable to make a decision for him/herself. The age of consent for medical procedures, while it may vary from state-to-state, is generally between the ages of of 16 and 18. In other countries, it may be as high as 21.

the Hippocratic Oath takes care of any lame hypothetical of "but parents might have a religious duty to remove an arm for no other reason than their religion." And I am pretty sure it is illegal for any unlicensed practitioners to perform surgical procedures on anyone as well.
 
And? There are laws against polygamy, which to some Mormons affects their right to practice their religion. And those laws were found constitutional in Reynolds v. United States. Religious duty is not a suitable defence to a crime.

Most Mormons practice polygamy anyway. Do they get harassed by the state? Not really.

Although, they can only claim one mate on their taxes. This was the point of illegalizing polygamy. They would end up earning far more earned income tax credits, and would make the tax structure far more complicated, using unnecessary funds. In short, polygamists step on other peoples' rights as taxpayers.
 
I didn't ask if they are able. I know they are. I asked if they should be.

They have to be. That IS a very specific law. Age of consent for any medical procedure is age 16 in most states. (I think it is a state issue.) Otherwise, the parents and legal guardians are the ones who decide whether to do a procedure or not on a child.
 
They have to be. That IS a very specific law. Age of consent for any medical procedure is age 16 in most states. (I think it is a state issue.) Otherwise, the parents and legal guardians are the ones who decide whether to do a procedure or not on a child.

You completely missed the point. The question was not are they able to decide, but should they be able to decide.
You clearly think they are able, and should be able.
Others acknowledge that they are able but think they should not be.
At the risk of going right over your head again:
when slavery was legal, slavery was legal, but some people, while acknowledging that it was legal, thought it should not be. Others also acknowledged that it was legal, and thought it should continue to be legal.
 
Circumcision is mutilation. Period. So is ear piercing. Period. So is any sort of tattoo or other piercing. Period. Socially acceptable mutilation, but mutilation just the same. And if foreskins were so damned unhealthy, the human race would have died out long ago. It's just as painful to baby boys to get circumcised as for young girls to get circumcised. But for some reason, people are only outraged by one of them. Fact.

dictionary.com:

–verb (used with object), -lat·ed, -lat·ing.
1.
to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts: Vandals mutilated the painting.
2.
to deprive (a person or animal) of a limb or other essential part.

Definition number one is highly subjective. You consider circumcision it to be mutilation, others don't.

Definition number two definitely doesn't fit. You are not depriving anyone of a "part."

thefreedictionary.com

mu·ti·late (mytl-t)
tr.v. mu·ti·lat·ed, mu·ti·lat·ing, mu·ti·lates
1. To deprive of a limb or an essential part; cripple.
2. To disfigure by damaging irreparably: mutilate a statue. See Synonyms at batter1.
3. To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.

Again, definition one does not fit for the same reason definition two up above.

Definition two, is also highly subjective. Taking something away from a statue, does not necessarily mean you have "disfigured" it if you like it that way.

Definition three, same deal.

Wikipedia.com

Mutilation or maiming is an act or physical injury that degrades the appearance or function of any living body, usually without causing death.

Seems to suggest that mutilation is an act of doing some serious injury, that can usually cause death. This is a pretty common colloquial use of the term "mutilation."

Denniston et al. have argued that male circumcision is a form of mutilation;[5] their arguments have been criticised by Benatar and Benatar.[6

And to prove my point just how subjective it is, here are two sources linked within wiki, each with differing opinions on whether or not male circumcision is "mutilation."

Now, in order to illustrate my point:

Earlier in the thread, someone asked a highly misleading question:

"So, do you think mutilating the genitals of a baby boy is fine?"

This is a question brilliantly and conveniently posed with only a "yes," or "no" answer. And even more conveniently, the person will be satisfied with an answer that is just as misleading as the question that was posed.

If you say "not;" ("it is not fine to mutilate the penis,")you could be thinking of using a cheese grater on the thing, and completely destroying it. But the person asking the question is able to say: "Ah ha! So you think that circumcision is wrong then!" Because in his equally subjective mind, circumcision is considered "mutilation."

Now, what happens when we answer in the affirmative?

So you say "yes;" ("It is fine to mutilate the penis,") in which you could be thinking "since they are using the term "mutilation" in order to describe circumcision, I shall answer "yes."" But the person asking the question can very easily say: "Ah ha! So you think it is fine to take a cheese grater to a child's penis and completely wreck the thing, you sick bastard you!"

This is EXACTLY why using a technical term that can only mean one thing, is far more preferable to use than a more subjective, and ambiguous term that can be twisted however you want it to be twisted. And the reason why I refuse to recognize the term "mutilation" in this conversation. It has no bearing whatsoever on the subject, it is intellectually dishonest, and wastes an inordinate amount of time, making communication far more difficult than it needs to be.

I am quite surprised I had to actually go to such great lengths to explain the problems of using an ambiguous term, when the technical term is far more desirable. Maybe now we can lay this thing to rest, about "mutilation."

Before I finish this post, I have one final thing to add, if all would agree:

IF you want to use MGM ("Male Genital Mutilation,) I have absolutely no problems with just simply typing "MGM."

However, the rules of this term is going to be used exactly the same way, and will be perfectly interchangeable with, "circumcision." Because, quite frankly, I am getting sick and tired of having to write out the words "circumcision," and "mutilation" all the damned time. And I would also like us all to be on the same page without any dishonesty whatsoever.

I am willing to replace "circumcision" with "MGM." MGM will be a technical term describing circumcision ONLY. It shall not in any way, shape, or form, describe anything to do with using cheese graters, annihilating someone's arm, or throwing an entire body into a meat grinder.

Is this something we can all agree to? Yes, or no?
 
Unless you know someone, no, I'd say no man does it for religious reasons. If he belongs to a religion where it's practiced, it's generally done TO him when he's a baby. And later in life, men who are not circumcised do it for social reasons, i.e., so they don't look different or weird.

You know of men who walk around in public everywhere with their weener hanging out? :confused:
 
dictionary.com:



Definition number one is highly subjective. You consider circumcision it to be mutilation, others don't.

Definition number two definitely doesn't fit. You are not depriving anyone of a "part."

thefreedictionary.com



Again, definition one does not fit for the same reason definition two up above.

Definition two, is also highly subjective. Taking something away from a statue, does not necessarily mean you have "disfigured" it if you like it that way.

Definition three, same deal.

The definitions you provide quite clearly fit circumcision.
A part is removed. That is exactly what definition 1 says.
 
Apparently, it's time for a crash course in logic. One of the most basic rules of logic is that X is either true or false. It can't be neither, and it can't be both. That's like saying I am both left-handed and not left-handed. That makes no sense.

In this case, you are correct. However, when it comes to something that is rather subjective, like this case, it is neither black, nor white.

You could be considered "black," in that you think the practice is wrong, and it should be banned.

Someone else (Thunder) is white, in which he thinks the practice is right, and it should not be banned.

someone else may be grayish-black, in which they don't care whether it is right or wrong; they just want to ban something just for the sake of banning it.

Myself, I could be grayish-white, in which I am also neutral on the morality of it, but what I do care about is protecting parents' rights to decide for themselves what they think is best for their own kids. Not have society do it for them.

But it gets even more complicated than that, as we shall see later on in this post.

So this is why I asked you a pair of yes-or-no questions.

Is it the case that an action being done for religious reasons should not be punished by law? I submit that it is not. We can easily illustrate this point by supposing, for the sake of argument, that it is true. And here's what we conclude.

1. If an action is done for religious reasons, it should not be punished by law.
2. In some cases, Jehovah's Witnesses have denied healthcare to their dying children, for religious reasons.
C. Therefore, the actions of these people should not be punished.

Premise 1 is being accepted for the sake of argument.
Premise 2 is definitely true. I'll cite articles if necessary.
The conclusion logically follows by a method known as modus ponensWP.

But I don't believe the conclusion is true, and I don't think you do, either. To accept the premises and deny the conclusion would be illogical, so in order to stay consistent, it follows that we must deny that Premise 1 is true.

This is true. The law does not distinguish between the right of one person to worship, over the right of a child to receive proper medical care that could save their life.

This point is flawed, however, because circumcision is a benign operation that does not affect the health, lifestyle, and function of the penis, unlike the previous example of withholding medical attention. (I remember the case very very well, btw.) Apples to oranges, if you are trying to compare the two.

So it's not the case that religious basis provides sufficient grounds for the justification of an act.

I never said those words. This is logic you are coming up with yourself. I would rather state it a different way:

It is the case that religious basis CAN provide sufficient grounds for the justification of an act, so long as those grounds do not impede on another citizen's rights.

(Example: Illegal to yell "FIRE!" in a crowded theater. Your right to free speech does not supersede mine to be in a safe environment without risking my life in a stampede, just because you thought it would be funny; representing the risky behavior in the case of parents withholding vital medical treatment for their child.

Legal for Fred Phelps to show up at a soldiers funeral, and say "GOD HATES FAGS!!" as a rather benign behavior that happens to be reprehensible in a subjective way. Fred Phelps has the right to free speech, which does not violate anyone else's rights.)

Where does that leave us? With this in mind, let's look back to your argument.

1. It is not the case that if an act is done for religious reasons, that it should not be punished.

Your words, not mine. Depends on circumstance, as described above.

2. Circumcision is done for religious reasons.
C. Therefore, circumcision should not be punished.

Exactly. Because that is a very specific circumstance: That circumcision is a rather benign procedure which does not affect health, lifestyle, or functioning of the penis. Parents are also given legal right to decide what they think is best for their child when it comes to health care and religious decisions.

This conclusion does not follow. As you have previously stated, you would not except religious reasons as a justification for human sacrifice, which means that you accept premise 1 of the new argument. Given that the conclusion does not follow (which, again, I would be happy to illustrate), how does your "it's religious" reasoning apply? By your own standard, it cannot. You have no argument.

Tell that to the Supreme Court, which does this all of the time. It "picks and chooses" WHAT speech is not ok, what firearms are not allowed, who cannot vote (convicted criminals), what religious practices are not allowed.

There are exceptions to ALL of the rights in the Constitution. It just so happens that you need pretty clear justifications for WHY you want to restrict a part of the Constitution, HOW you want to go about doing it, solutions you come up with, evidence of how restricting one right for one person will protect the rights of other people, and so on and so forth.

The confines of this little exercise in logic cannot possibly fit the issues of a complex social contract between the government, and the governed. It just simply does not work that way. To be frank, to say and/or insist that it does either makes you dishonest or ignorant. :o

I know you're going to disagree with what I've said here. But don't just make wild accusations of context and whatnot. If you're going to claim I'm wrong, be prepared to point out specifically why I'm wrong, and then correct me.

The entire post above this point is the whole reason why I thought you were taking it completely out of context in my original answer to your first two questions. My answers were far more complex than your syllogistic logic exercise.

By the way, if anything I have illustrated here has been poorly communicated, or difficult to follow, ask me to explain, and I will not hesitate to do so.

I think you have explained your reasoning quite well, actually. Before, I thought you were truly trying to take my original answer to your questions out of context. Which is why I got a little annoyed, to say the least.
 
Last edited:
All your points are true, but here's the thing: It's still an irreversible procedure that some adult males, when they are old enough to understand what has happened to them, will resent. Nobody asked me what I wanted.

It would be unethical to circumcise an adult without his permission, but when you do it to him as a baby, then it becomes OK?

Yes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informed_consent
 
The definitions you provide quite clearly fit circumcision.
A part is removed. That is exactly what definition 1 says.

NICE! Read it again! This time in proper context

mu·ti·late (mytl-t)
tr.v. mu·ti·lat·ed, mu·ti·lat·ing, mu·ti·lates
1. To deprive of a limb or an essential part; cripple.
2. To disfigure by damaging irreparably: mutilate a statue. See Synonyms at batter1.
3. To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.


–verb (used with object), -lat·ed, -lat·ing.
1.
to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts: Vandals mutilated the painting.
2.
to deprive (a person or animal) of a limb or other essential part.

Key word: ESSENTIAL part.

ETA: The "disfigure" parts of the definition is, once again, rather subjective. You can break the hands off a statue, and make it even better, in your own eyes. You have therefore, made it more perfect.
 
Last edited:
delete. Accidently hit the "quote" button, rather than the "edit" button. My fault.
 
Last edited:
Ummm...what? If I am not mistaken, that was quoting you, when you said something about it being "harmful to others." I was asking for proof that it is, indeed, harmful.

By definition, the deliberate removal from the body of healthy tissue that cannot regenerate constitutes "harm". If you don't agree that randomly snipping little bits off someone's body that won't grow back is a form of harm, then I think it's your understanding of language that's the problem.

Dave
 
Last edited:
I haven't read every page in this thread, but here's my view on it.

We know why people began circumcision: religious reasons. We know why it was perpetuated in the US even though it wasn't a religious mandate: religiously-based prudishness.

That said, I am not for either and am against mutilating children in any form at any age against their will. It's one thing to make kids do things that they don't want to when we KNOW it is in their best interest, like eat broccoli and do homework. Circumcision is NOT one of those things. It's one thing to pierce a girl's ears if she asks to have it done when she's old enough to know what it is and comprehend that she has to take care of it to heal. Circumcision is NOT one of those things either.

There is no medical basis for it. At most it is aesthetic, and people would think it ridiculous to give a baby a nose job so how is this any different?
 
Somehow you would be wrong, because I already have, to a certain extent.

The Catholic diocese I grew up in, in the 80s and 90s at least, did many, many circumcisions as a religious practice.

and the Vatican has no official stance on it any longer.


Well, we seem to have abandoned the contention that circumcision is essential in order to enter heaven, which has to be an advance.

The RC church having "no official stance" on circumcision any longer means that they have stopped banning it!!!! They do not encourage it or mandate it, it is not a religious obligation, never has been, and is in no way necessary for a Catholic to be a good Catholic.

If your Catholic diocese was carrying out circumcision as a religious practice, then they had fallen into heresy, it's that simple.

That you were entirely unaware of that until you participated in this thread, entering with the fixed opinion that circumcision was a religious practice in Christianity, speaks volumes.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom