Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Many of the persecutors of the Jews throughout history, have indeed banned circumcision. From the Assyrian Greeks, to the Romans.

Just sayin'.
 
Insurance? What about the right of others in the insurance pool not to be contributing to an act of barbarity?

Bloody well pay for it out of pocket.

Rolfe.
.
I wonder if insurance would cover elective cosmetic surgery like that?
 
Many of the persecutors of the Jews throughout history, have indeed banned circumcision. From the Assyrian Greeks, to the Romans.

Just sayin'.


I'd rather make shechita slaughter illegal unless it's preceded by stunning the animal, personally.

But posturing about "persecution" when the subject is lopping body parts off a helpless infant is beyond disgraceful.

Rolfe.
 
I'd rather make shechita slaughter illegal unless it's preceded by stunning the animal, personally.

totally!!!!!!!

they have no problem with kosher slaughter done without any stunning of the animal, or any painkiller whatsoever...but they wanna harrass us for removing useless forskin?

strange priorities these folks have.
 
Monogamy with one partner all the time...
Where at is the exposure to HIV/STD?
Issac Asimov died of HIV, from a contaminated blood transfusion during an operation
And I kinda think he was circumcised... which is no protection against that source.
Toilet seats and door knobs seem to be the other "well-known" sources for STD problems.
 
totally!!!!!!!

they have no problem with kosher slaughter done without any stunning of the animal, or any painkiller whatsoever...but they wanna harrass us for removing useless forskin?

strange priorities these folks have.


Don't flatter yourself.

A is worse than B does not imply that B is acceptable.

Rolfe.
 
What's wrong? Is this not the way you feel? To argue the contrary would lead to some interesting results. Again, if you would like me to, I'll illustrate this point logically.

Stay focused, here. The First Amendment does not dictate morality (the way things should be). It dictates what is and is not illegal.

Slow down. I never said this was a case about circumcision. I said that this was a case about a conflict between state actions in regards to one's religious practices. In this situation, the state won.

You go off on a tangent about how there are currently no laws on the books. Of course, this is a thread over whether or not there should be laws. Your point was that if there were, they would be struck down by the Supreme Court. I have shown that this is most certainly not the case.


By the way, illustrate to me why it is immoral to slice a baby's foot with a knife.

This entire post completely turned the entire conversation on it's head. I will go back real quick, and post EXACTLY, VERBATIM, what you had asked, and how I answered. ETA coming up.


I Am Scum said:
Nihilianth, before we go any further, I want to get something cleared up. Do you agree with either of the following statements:

1. If an action is done for religious reasons, that action cannot lead to criminal charges (according to the constitution)
2. If an action is done for religious reasons, that action should not lead to criminal charges.
I'm really shocked that we're still on this point. If someone were to stick a sewing needle through your groin, would it be the case, or would it not, that you have been harmed?

I directly answered those questions the very first time you asked those questions. Why you make me repeat myself, I have no clue.:

Nihilianth said:
Before I go on to answer this question in a rather breathy manner, are you an American who is familiar with the Constitution, and the various exceptions to freedoms given therein because of case law as written and handed down by the Supreme Court?

If not, then I think a discussion about that would be forth coming. I ask this, because answering you questions your questions, as stated above, in a simple "yes/no" fashion would not be accurate in any way. Those are rather dishonest questions to ask, which would yield dishonest answers.

however, the second question I can sum up rather quickly, if I may:

If an action is done for religious reasons, that action should not lead to criminal charges.

The short answer: Not necessarily, they shouldn't.

Long answer: There are many exceptions to this, of course, such as human sacrifice.

But like I said before, in order to get a better, more clear understanding of the problem, one would need to do a little digging in American history, historical case laws, precedents, traditions, religious practices, and so forth. Which is exactly why this issue of banning circumcision is such a sticky topic, and is unlikely to ever pass, nor should it. And why the health organizations exercise such caution in advising doctors to give unbiased information about the benefits and risks of circumcision, in order to allow families to make informed decisions on their own. The health organizations do not want to get into the subject of stepping on people's religious and cultural practices, especially if there is a lack of any real solid evidence for the risks and benefits that doctors are advised to talk about to parents.

You cannot ask "yes-no" questions in such a complex issue, in which there are many, any factors involved.

You snipped my entire post, then purposely lied to twist my words around. I thought you said you don't play games? Anyway, this is the post where you completely lost me, and lost much credibility and respect you had in my mind:

I'm pretty sure this is how you felt, but I just wanted to be absolutely clear.

I Am The Scum said:
What you are saying then, is that "it is a religious practice" is insufficient grounds for the permissibility of an action. This is a fine stance to take, and I agree with it. However, what is your reasoning for the performance of circumcision?

Professional job, parroting the pathetic job the media does in twisting words, and completely taking things out of context.

Do you want to ask those exact questions again? This time, we can start over from the first quote, if you like. I just ask that you play by fair rules, without using any low tactics of twisting words around.

More ETA: copy-pasted a line of conversation in order to record the terrible practice of twisting words around.
 
Last edited:
A is worse than B does not imply that B is acceptable.

Rolfe.

no, but the fact they are focusing on B rather than A, says a lot about their priorities and concerns.

its like saying: "hmm...should we end the Holocaust first, or stop the use of CFC's and protect the Ozone Layer? yeah, looks like we're gonna take care of the Ozone hole first".

see? ridiculous priorities.
 
Last edited:
If you can find where I mentioned 'taking away the choice', I would appreciate it.
I have forgotten that.

If you haven't mentioned that, then I apologize and recant that statement. I know that others have made that argument.
 
And now for the rest of the post:

Scum said:
Stay focused, here. The First Amendment does not dictate morality (the way things should be). It dictates what is and is not illegal.

The courts decide whether laws are constitutional or unconstitional whether or not they are challenged. The Constitution is written to protect certain rights the framers of the document thought were important to a civilized democratic society.

Slow down. I never said this was a case about circumcision. I said that this was a case about a conflict between state actions in regards to one's religious practices. In this situation, the state won.

They did, but just barely. Do you know how long it took the courts to decide the issue? The state court couldn't decide on their own, so they sent it to the SC. The SC sent it back to the state, because they couldn't decide, and left it up to the state to do so. Once again, the state couldn;t decide a SECOND time, and sent it back up. In the end, the SC ruled in favor, because, and here is the kicker:

It was already illegal under other laws!

The problem was, the SC was making a decision about one particular instance of a Native American suing the state over getting fired due to drug use. It wasn't making a decision upon the specific anti-drug laws in effect, because those weren't the laws being challenged.

Now, the difference with the circumcision issue, is that IF the ban does get passed, people will challenge the ban directly. The courts then have to decide whether the ban is unconstitutional or not if that particular ban gets challenged directly.


You go off on a tangent about how there are currently no laws on the books. Of course, this is a thread over whether or not there should be laws. Your point was that if there were, they would be struck down by the Supreme Court. I have shown that this is most certainly not the case.

You failed to understand that one particular person was suing over the violation of a first amendment right. They weren't suing to have a law that was already in place to be overturned.


By the way, illustrate to me why it is immoral to slice a baby's foot with a knife.

Illustrate what that question has to do with circumcision, and how it will not affect the baby's life whatsoever.

If you read back through the conversation I had with Childless Empress, she had a similar hypothetical question. I think I answered her question to her full satisfaction. There is no need to constantly throw out many different hypotheticals.
 
Not even close to being true. And your attack is unappreciated or warranted.

I see children as precious human beings. I want to make their life less complicated and without any stigmas that can be generated by the public.

Many of us are not parents yet. so no "power" is in this. Its about issues that are religious in context and also based in health.

I believe that circumcision provides an added health benefit to a male child.

You may not think so. That is your opinion.


Again, YOU don't like it, tHEN don't have it done to your child.

Leave the rest of us, who choose to have it performed the freedom to do SO.

A little advice:

I would only speak with Darat, Scum, Empress, and that kiwi person....I think I am forgetting one more person....as they don;t seem to be trolling all that much. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom