Ban circumcision in San Fran???

maybe because its 800,000,000 times easier to do it when you are only 8 days old?

I am very very glad, that my parents had my circumcised when I was a baby.

having to do it when I was 18, would have been one major pain in the butt.

In fact, this is something of an argument against circumcision is it not?

No one in their right mind would agree to it.

No one would do it if they had the choice.
 
Circumcision is mutilation. Period. So is ear piercing. Period. So is any sort of tattoo or other piercing. Period. Socially acceptable mutilation, but mutilation just the same. And if foreskins were so damned unhealthy, the human race would have died out long ago. It's just as painful to baby boys to get circumcised as for young girls to get circumcised. But for some reason, people are only outraged by one of them. Fact.
 
maybe because its 800,000,000 times easier to do it when you are only 8 days old?

When 'you' are only 8 days old 'you' neither do it nor choose to have it done.
And it is certainly easier to do it to an 8 day old baby: he has absolutely no option.
 
so, NO men do it for religious reasons?

Oh maybe they do. God commands them to chop off a bit of penis and so they do. If it is a command though, then it isn't really a choice.

I suppose there are large numbers of people who go in for all kinds of "body sculpting", peircings, masochism, so I really can't rule it out.

Are you saying there are large numbers of men who do it out of choice?
 
so, NO men do it for religious reasons?
Unless you know someone, no, I'd say no man does it for religious reasons. If he belongs to a religion where it's practiced, it's generally done TO him when he's a baby. And later in life, men who are not circumcised do it for social reasons, i.e., so they don't look different or weird.
 
It's just as painful to baby boys to get circumcised as for young girls to get circumcised. But for some reason, people are only outraged by one of them. Fact.

once again, male circumcision and female genital mutilation are NOT the same thing. comparing the two is a willfull or unintentional act of great ignorance.
 
When 'you' are only 8 days old 'you' neither do it nor choose to have it done.
And it is certainly easier to do it to an 8 day old baby: he has absolutely no option.

again, if we can ban forced circumcision on infants, than we can ban forced braces and tooth extraction on teenagers.

I look forward to you writing your local councilman to get the law passed.
 
once again, male circumcision and female genital mutilation are NOT the same thing. comparing the two is a willfull or unintentional act of great ignorance.

The two are obviously not the same. One is done to females. The other is done to males.

What is important, however, is the similarities. I think people have already listed these but they are essentially:

No apparent medical benefit derives from either even though both are painful and both are effectively permanent.

Only in rare cases does an adult consent to such an operation largely because it is too painful and usually there are no medical benefits.

Your other examples, vaccines, haircuts, dental work don't fall into the same categories. In other words female genital mutilation does have more in common with male circumcision than the analogies you keep throwing up so you are not in a position to lecture anyone about bad analogies.
 
The two are obviously not the same. One is done to females. The other is done to males.

What is important, however, is the similarities. I think people have already listed these but they are essentially:

No apparent medical benefit derives from either even though both are painful and both are effectively permanent.

Only in rare cases does an adult consent to such an operation largely because it is too painful and usually there are no medical benefits.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female...res:_World_Health_Organization_categorization

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_genital_cutting#Medical_consequence

why don't you do a little light reading, before you make such ignorant statements.
 

You could at least present an argument instead of a few Wikipedia links and expect me to construct the argument for you.

I had often assumed that there was some hard evidence that there were medical benefits to circumcision but I can't find any substantial basis for this. On the contrary it seems there is no medical consensus on this.

So, Thunder, what are the proven medical benefits to male circumcision?
 
Professional job, parroting the pathetic job the media does in twisting words, and completely taking things out of context.

Apparently, it's time for a crash course in logic. One of the most basic rules of logic is that X is either true or false. It can't be neither, and it can't be both. That's like saying I am both left-handed and not left-handed. That makes no sense.

So this is why I asked you a pair of yes-or-no questions. Is it the case that an action being done for religious reasons should not be punished by law? I submit that it is not. We can easily illustrate this point by supposing, for the sake of argument, that it is true. And here's what we conclude.

1. If an action is done for religious reasons, it should not be punished by law.
2. In some cases, Jehovah's Witnesses have denied healthcare to their dying children, for religious reasons.
C. Therefore, the actions of these people should not be punished.

Premise 1 is being accepted for the sake of argument.
Premise 2 is definitely true. I'll cite articles if necessary.
The conclusion logically follows by a method known as modus ponensWP.

But I don't believe the conclusion is true, and I don't think you do, either. To accept the premises and deny the conclusion would be illogical, so in order to stay consistent, it follows that we must deny that Premise 1 is true.

So it's not the case that religious basis provides sufficient grounds for the justification of an act. Where does that leave us? With this in mind, let's look back to your argument.

1. It is not the case that if an act is done for religious reasons, that it should not be punished.
2. Circumcision is done for religious reasons.
C. Therefore, circumcision should not be punished.

This conclusion does not follow. As you have previously stated, you would not except religious reasons as a justification for human sacrifice, which means that you accept premise 1 of the new argument. Given that the conclusion does not follow (which, again, I would be happy to illustrate), how does your "it's religious" reasoning apply? By your own standard, it cannot. You have no argument.

I know you're going to disagree with what I've said here. But don't just make wild accusations of context and whatnot. If you're going to claim I'm wrong, be prepared to point out specifically why I'm wrong, and then correct me.

By the way, if anything I have illustrated here has been poorly communicated, or difficult to follow, ask me to explain, and I will not hesitate to do so.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom