Nihilianth
Illuminator
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2011
- Messages
- 3,851
What I always find quite strange in these threads is that those that support male genital mutilation (and who live in a culture in which the practice is considered OK) use the same reasoning and give the same reasons as those that support female genital mutilation (who live in a culture in which the practice is considered OK).
I think it demonstrates an example of cognitive dissonance.
I don't think anyone in this thread has suggested "mutilating" anyone's genitals is ok. So this has nothing to do with the thread at all.
We have said, ad nauseum, that parents should be allowed to have the choice on whether to circumcise newborn males, but not females. Why? This doesn't sound consistent.
Well, it doesn't have to be "consistent," as female circumcision can have a devastating impact on the functioning of the female genitals. Whereas, the removal of the foreskin from a penis doesn't impair/impact the penis in any way. Just like we don;t have to be consistent in giving parents the right to have a newborn's arm removed, as this would severely impact the lifestyle of the individual.
Same with protecting religious freedom. We don't have to be "consistent" in allowing everyone to pray as they will, as opposed to not allowing people to sacrifice humans.
Same with freedom of speech. We don't have to be consistent when it comes to allowing people to speak out against the government, because we outlaw people from saying "fire!" in crowded movie theaters, and from writing anything libelous or speaking slanderous things.