Ban circumcision in San Fran???

What I always find quite strange in these threads is that those that support male genital mutilation (and who live in a culture in which the practice is considered OK) use the same reasoning and give the same reasons as those that support female genital mutilation (who live in a culture in which the practice is considered OK).

I think it demonstrates an example of cognitive dissonance.

I don't think anyone in this thread has suggested "mutilating" anyone's genitals is ok. So this has nothing to do with the thread at all.

We have said, ad nauseum, that parents should be allowed to have the choice on whether to circumcise newborn males, but not females. Why? This doesn't sound consistent.

Well, it doesn't have to be "consistent," as female circumcision can have a devastating impact on the functioning of the female genitals. Whereas, the removal of the foreskin from a penis doesn't impair/impact the penis in any way. Just like we don;t have to be consistent in giving parents the right to have a newborn's arm removed, as this would severely impact the lifestyle of the individual.

Same with protecting religious freedom. We don't have to be "consistent" in allowing everyone to pray as they will, as opposed to not allowing people to sacrifice humans.

Same with freedom of speech. We don't have to be consistent when it comes to allowing people to speak out against the government, because we outlaw people from saying "fire!" in crowded movie theaters, and from writing anything libelous or speaking slanderous things.
 
It isn't. A newborn child isn't able to make a decision. that's why parents make that decision for them.

Yes. It is. It is the right of your parents to choose what happens to your body vs. your right to make the decision yourself.

The integrity of a person's body should be maintained as far as possible until they can choose what happens to it.
 
i didn't want braces when I was 11. but my parents forced them on me.

it was not a medical neccessity. I could have lived a very long life, even without braces.

should we take that right away from parents? 11 year old Bobby doesn't want braces, so he doesn't have to get them?


...oh, and to put these braces on, they ripped 4 teeth out of my mouth. those teeth will never grow back.

again, I didn't want this surgery, but it was done anyways.
 
Not one person in this thread has said you can't choose to be circumcised, what some people have argued is that the choice should be yours and not made on your behalf by someone else.

That was exactly the argument I was talking about all along that people have been making. I was referring to it as the "choice" argument.

This is a fairly weak argument, because parents make choices for their kids all the time, when they are unable to make their own choices. Like how they should raise their kids. Children have no choice in what house, city/town, state or country they can live in. They have no choice for what school they can go to. All of those "choices" that are taken from them, will severely impact their lives in far more positive or negative ways than a simple circumcision ever will.
 
parents often force their children to take growth hormones, if they doc. thinks they may stay very short. i don't think kids like this shot.

shall we take away the right of parents to force their kids to take growth hormones, have adult teeth removed, have braces installed on their mouth for 4 years, etc etc?

what about a child born with 6 fingers on one hand? should it be illegal for a parent to have that extra finger removed?

what about sexual reconstructive surgery done on newborns who have the beginning of a penis? it does happen sometimes, and doctors remove it to form a normal sized clitoris. should that be illegal too?
 
Last edited:
Beat me to it. Nihilianth should withdraw the contention that it is a Catholic custom. Somehow I don't expect it.

Somehow you would be wrong, because I already have, to a certain extent.

The Catholic diocese I grew up in, in the 80s and 90s at least, did many, many circumcisions as a religious practice.

and the Vatican has no official stance on it any longer.
 
"Daddy, daddy, I don't want to go to Church!!!!!"

"sorry Bobby, but you are going to Church, you are going to sit and listen to the Priest, you are going to take the Sacrament and drink the wine, and thats it!!!!!!"

...should such a situation be illegal?
 
If you read back through the conversation I had with Childless Empress, she had a similar hypothetical question. I think I answered her question to her full satisfaction. There is no need to constantly throw out many different hypotheticals.


After your answer, in which you basically told me that you are fine with my hypothetical cult which cuts off earlobes of babies, I stated that our conversation ends there because I see no common ground for further discussion.
 
When I was pregnant with my son, I conducted a survey of every male I knew (many of them online, in a large gaming community). After the inevitable guffaws, most of the guys cooperated, sharing with me whether they were circumcised, and whether they'd have wanted to or not.

I was quite surprised at the results: over half were circumcised, and the overwhelming majority (whether they'd been circumcised or not) felt that it shouldn't be the parents' choice, but should be left to the guy himself.

There were several men who responded that they didn't have very much sensation there, or that they suffered some level of pain due to nerve endings being exposed and chafing against clothing.

We ended up not circumcising our son (my husband is English, and it's apparently not very common over there, and he was adamant that we not mutilate our child. I'd just wanted to see how tough it would be for an uncircumcised child to grow up with that "stigma", thus my survey).

Nerve endings being exposed, and chafing? Heh, I should like to know from whom they were circumcised. I've never had that problem. And judging from the number of sports I have played, thinking back on all those games and practices, I doubt any of the other athletes had the same problem either. I would bet a good half of them were circumcised. Unless I happened to have played in all those games in which nobody was circumcised other than myself. And I never experienced any undue discomfort while running for several miles for football and soccer practice, cross-country biking half way across the state and back, and all those baseball games.

In any case, I was a virgin up until I got married. The very first time I have ever had sex in my life, it felt WONDERFUL. Not only that, but she ended up getting pregnant, with twins on the way! (We just found out about the twins a week ago! :D )

It would be interesting to see a professional survey done.
 
There were several men who responded that they didn't have very much sensation there, or that they suffered some level of pain due to nerve endings being exposed and chafing against clothing.

I'm sorry, but this is total crap.

:p

i have never had any issues, nonewhatsoever, with Mr. Winky.

nor has any guy I have ever known, who was a Jew and obviously circumcised.

as for sex? its great. amazing. fantastic. best thing in the world.

i think these men, if true....probably had some nut doctor.
 
Last edited:
You still haven't applied the Lemon Test I gave you in my link. :p

Oh I have, in fact.

I'll provide the lemon test, to show you just where and how it is a matter of subjective opinion.

First, the statute must have a secular legislative purpose;

It CAN pass here, I can give you that.

second, its principal or primary effect must be one that neither advances nor inhibits religion;

Unfortunately, the primary effect would be prohibiting practicing Jews, Christians, and Muslims. This fails.

finally, the statute must not foster "an excessive government entanglement with religion."

This fails even more miserably, because you would have a lot of upset people on your hands that the government excessively for entangled in their religious affairs.

just because you do not believe in God, or have any religious faith, doesn't mean those that do's views are any less important than yours. The First Amendment was meant to protect you from being forced to worship, and it protects religious people from being forced to give up their sacred ways.

(Please, don't get into the whole issue of "but what about <insert extreme religious practice which violates another citizen's rights here> That horse has long been beated to death, and completely mutilated to the point where it would be unrecognizable as anything that might as lived. :) We are not taking about such extreme behaviors. )
 
Things that are medically reconstructive or corrective should not be forbidden, no. Circumcision does not fall into this category.

Not only that, but she ended up getting pregnant, with twins on the way! (We just found out about the twins a week ago! :D )
.
Congrats and good luck!
 
After your answer, in which you basically told me that you are fine with my hypothetical cult which cuts off earlobes of babies, I stated that our conversation ends there because I see no common ground for further discussion.

:rolleyes:

You're the one that came up with a ridiculous, off-the-wall, hypothetical. I agree, it wouldn't be cool to cut off earlobes of children. But what I think is an offensive thing, doesn't mean it should be banned.

I made the caveat that the cutting off of earlobe would have all of the exact same circumstances of circumcision. IF that were true, then good luck passing a ban. It should be protected under the First Amendment.

Ah! you say. Before you finish that sentence, once again, the caveat is: IT MUST HAVE ALL THE SAME EFFECTS, RELIGIOUS PRACTICES, AND SO ON, AS THE CIRCUMCISION THING.
 
Things that are medically reconstructive or corrective should not be forbidden, no. Circumcision does not fall into this category.


Congrats and good luck!

Thanks! :D

And for the record, we don't really plan on circumcising either of them when they are born, as far as I know, assuming they are boys. (We are keeping it secret until the Big Day arrives!) But I'll make sure I talk to her about it, so we have a decision rather quickly.
 
Yeah. "Tradition". We went over this.

Which had nothing to do with that little side tidbit, except to say that in reality, despite the whole "hanging onto tradition" fallacy, it would indeed, be much easier to pass a law against a new-established custom, as opposed to an old one that has been around for centuries, and a very significant portion of the population practices it.

Don;t tell me it would be just as easy to ban circumcision, as it would be to ban the cutting off of earlobes.

Ah! But the caveat was: Earlobe cutting has every single thing, and is perfectly comparable to circumcision. Including longevity. Well then, in reality, it would be just as hard to pass a ban against earlobe cutting, as it would circumcision.

Not saying it is necessarily RIGHT that it would be harder to ban a long-held tradition. But that is the REALITY of the situation. Old habits die hard, ya know.
 
Putting words in my mouth much!? Holy geez! You have got to be kidding me!

Well, bud. You made a claim. Time for you to back it up. Show a spot where I said the specific words "so you can get into heaven."

And take it out of context, I WILL call you out on it.

I think this puts your credibility at an all-time low now.

Rolfe busted you there, Nihilianth.
 
Nihilianth;6950071... I would only speak with Darat said:
.
OH Boy!
The rest of us can say snarky things, and he'll never know!
I bet he never was brave enough to re-buckle his knicker-bockers -below- the knee!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom