Ban circumcision in San Fran???

...snip...

I for one will have the procedure done on my son, because I feel there vast health benefits with the procedure.
No therapy needed on my part. Im grounded enough to understand the implications and disadvantages of circumcision (you think that I didn't do the research?). I will still have it performed on my son.

I am absolutely certain that you have not done adequate research given the highlighted part of your post above. But by all means show me the studies that have concluded their are "vast health benefits" and I'll accept that you have done your research.
 
My last post because this is always a heated issue:

The bill will not pass

and if in the odd chance it does, it'll be met with a ton of challenges based on US Constitutional violations and First Amendment rights issues.


San Fran isn't the first city to propose such a law, and it will not be the last.
 
yes, but there is no law making circumcision against the law. Its simply a bill/proposal to make such a law.


Exactly. You've indicated that so far as mutilating your child goes, you feel the boundary sits at what the law allows. This is no argument at all for not shifting where the law puts the boundary, It's completely circular. If the law passes, then circumcision will also be illegal, so the boundary has changed.

How about if it changed the other way, to allow female genital mutilation? Would you be quite happy to allow fathers to carry that out if they felt it was the best thing for their daughters?

what other countries do is not my concern.


You are entirely missing the point. You keep insisting that there are health benefits to circumcision, and implying that uncircumcised boys will have such an uncomfortable time they will demand to be circumcised as adults. Experience in other countries demonstrates this simply is not true.

A foreskin on a child can cause problems both health (from birth) related and psychological (as they grow up).


See above. You are talking nonsense.

I'm against tail cutting on dogs. Since a tail to a dog is as important as a leg on a human being.

a foreskin on a male child isn't important.


In your opinion.

Then my parents are guilty of mutilating me for removal of skin that caused me problems, on the advice of a doctor. They had no permission from me to do so.

Should I now sue my parents and the doctor that performed the surgery for something that I'm glad is now gone?


Not if you're glad it's gone. But if you were old enough to understand, and were not asked for permission, then someone was guilty of malpractice.

Shall I sue every Ear piercing place for what they are doing to children everyday? I had my ears pierced when I was four months old. Shall I sue my parents for putting holes in my earlobes?


Not if you're happy to have pierced ears, obviously.

However, I don't believe parents should be allowed to pierce the ears of four-month-old children either.

Shall I sue every hair cutting/salon for cutting children's hair?


What was that about slippery slopes? I must have missed that bit.

No my opinions are for me. What you do to your own child is not my concern.


What? OK, I think he has a nice treble voice. I reckon he could make a bomb as an adult soprano.

I have the right to remove something I consider to be a potential health problem for my son.


Since it is not against the law, strictly speaking, you are correct. The question is, should you have the right to lop bits off your son's body without his consent, because of a superstitious belief about "health problems". Or simply your own personal aesthetic?

Again, you don't want to do circumcision on your son, that IS YOUR right to do so.

It is also my right to have it performed on my son.

Not circular at all. Cirucmcision isn't illegal (and by the looks of it the bill will not go through).


Indeed, it IS your right - but should it be? Probably the bill will not go through. (If they can't get a bill through on mandatory pre-stunning at slaughter, then this one probably doesn't have much hope.)

That leaves the question of whether it should go through entirely unaddressed.

Rolfe.
 
Sounds like you would need to run a survey, asking men who have been circumcised whether they care or not.

I know I certainly don't. Even when I was bordering on agnosticism several years ago. And there is no evidence that having a foreskin makes sex more pleasurable, unless you want to provide some here, since you basically make that claim in the first sentence of the quote.

In any case, you opinion is still wrong, according to the first amendment. This ban in SF will never pass. If it somehow does, it will be challenged immediately in the court of law, and the ban will summarily be struck out by said court.

You have no basis for argument in this case. It is open-shut.

When I was pregnant with my son, I conducted a survey of every male I knew (many of them online, in a large gaming community). After the inevitable guffaws, most of the guys cooperated, sharing with me whether they were circumcised, and whether they'd have wanted to or not.

I was quite surprised at the results: over half were circumcised, and the overwhelming majority (whether they'd been circumcised or not) felt that it shouldn't be the parents' choice, but should be left to the guy himself.

There were several men who responded that they didn't have very much sensation there, or that they suffered some level of pain due to nerve endings being exposed and chafing against clothing.

We ended up not circumcising our son (my husband is English, and it's apparently not very common over there, and he was adamant that we not mutilate our child. I'd just wanted to see how tough it would be for an uncircumcised child to grow up with that "stigma", thus my survey).
 
My last post because this is always a heated issue:

The bill will not pass

and if in the odd chance it does, it'll be met with a ton of challenges based on US Constitutional violations and First Amendment rights issues.


San Fran isn't the first city to propose such a law, and it will not be the last.


So you will not be providing any evidence of these "vast health benefits" you have researched.
 
and for health reasons
That is my belief. My opinion. You will never change my mind on this issue and arguments against circumcision will never disuade me from having it performed on my child.

I don't believe in Female circumcision.


Entirely a matter of faith, then.

And you demand the right to impose this faith-based mutilation on your child.

I have much more respect for Jewish parents, who at least acknowledge the faith and cultural basis.

Rolfe.
 
then I'll be sure to have my child in a state or hospital that isn't banned from performing the procedure. Even it means to go to another country to do so.


So you are prepared to have something done to your child that is against the law in your state.

Where do you draw the line then? That's what I've been asking all along.

Rolfe.
 
Beat me to it. Nihilianth should withdraw the contention that it is a Catholic custom. Somehow I don't expect it.


It may be a social custom in the Catholic community where he lives. But if his priest is telling the congregation it is a religious requirement, then the priest needs to go and have a word with the Pope about that, I think.

Rolfe.
 
And some procedures should be done without consent of the child. I believe this is one of them.

Having known someone who chose to go through Adult circumcision and wishing his parents had it done when he was a newborn is more than enough testimony for me to rely on.


Faith-based position again.

And then the single anecdote story again. I know someone who was really sick with appendicitis. Maybe I should just have my infant daughter's appendix removed, just in case....

Rolfe.
 
So you will not be providing any evidence of these "vast health benefits" you have researched.


Just to answer your question:
http://www.auanet.org/content/guidelines-and-quality-care/policy-statements/c/circumcision.cfm

http://www.aafp.org/online/en/home/clinical/clinicalrecs/circumcision.html

The evidence indicates that neonatal circumcision prevents UTIs in the first year of life with an absolute risk reduction of about 1% and prevents the development of penile cancer with an absolute risk reduction of less than 0.2%. The evidence suggests that circumcision reduces the rate of acquiring an STD, but careful sexual practices and hygiene may be as effective.



Again, I said I researched that their are advantages and also risks for circumcision.
 
That is my belief. My opinion. You will never change my mind on this issue and arguments against circumcision will never disuade me from having it performed on my child.

Hi. You must be new to the JREF. You probably wouldn't like it here.
 
I was relating my issues with uncircumcised penises. I dont find them sexually appealing.


Which should have no bearing at all on whether you get to lop bits off a helpless infant. Because you find it sexually unappealling.

Blech.

I for one will have the procedure done on my son, because I feel there vast health benefits with the procedure.


Emotion-based, as well as faith-based? How about some evidence of these vast health benefits? Got any? Any at all?

No therapy needed on my part. Im grounded enough to understand the implications and disadvantages of circumcision (you think that I didn't do the research?). I will still have it performed on my son.


So long as you realise your position is faith-based and emotion based, and is forcing your own personal aesthetic opinions on an infant who has no say in the matter.

And we've already noted that you would still do it if it was against the law.

Meh.

Rolfe.
 
You are forgiven, of course. I have done far worse than that in this thread. I just get upset when people want to just ban something on the whim, without explaining why, other than they don't like something.

I think it far better to practice governmental restraint, than to have society impose their will on people without very good reason to do so.

In this case, it appears a ban on circumcision could potentially do more harm than good. When banning something, you must give some very good reasons to do so, backed up with real evidence. Superficial arguments that "well, there are some people who do it outside of religious reasons," is not good enough of a reason to ban a practice.

As evidence, when it came to drug use, Native Americans using peyote and getting fired form their jobs, even the courts have quite a hard time with this issue, even though drug use itself is illegal under normal circumstances.

It will only be that much harder to ban something which doesn't already contradict another specific law. Especially when the practice is done under religious purposes, which is protected by the First Amendment.

You still haven't applied the Lemon Test I gave you in my link. :p
 
My last post because this is always a heated issue:


Bye. Don't let the door hit you on the way out.

The bill will not pass

and if in the odd chance it does, it'll be met with a ton of challenges based on US Constitutional violations and First Amendment rights issues.


I expect you're right, indeed. If they can't pass a bill to outlaw ritual slaughter without pre-stunning they have little hope of this one. That has nothing at all to do with whether or not you should be allowed to mutilate a newborn infant, of course.

Rolfe.
 
Outlawing circumcision, or genital mutilation of your child is too large a step.
But, preventing that savagery from being done in a public funded hospital should be OK.
I wouldn't care for my tax dollars to support a religious barbarity with no rational reason for it to exist in the 21st Century being inflicted on the child.
Get your insurance to pay for it.
 

Second link doesn't work from me and the first link does not support your claim that there are "vast health benefits" - a claim that came from your claimed research into male genital mutilation.
 


Have you actually read what you just posted? A whole 1% reduction in the risk of something quite uncommon in infants anyway, and no mention of any benefit after the first year of life. And a whole 0.2% (God give me strength!) reduction in the risk of something else which is pretty uncommon.

And another benefit that can be easily achieved by washing yourself properly.

And that's without even checking out whether this work has been published by people with an agenda.

Goodness, my idea about having my child's appendix removed "just in case" is looking more sensible by the minute. I wonder why the doctors don't recommend that to everyone?

Rolfe.
 
Outlawing circumcision, or genital mutilation of your child is too large a step.
But, preventing that savagery from being done in a public funded hospital should be OK.
I wouldn't care for my tax dollars to support a religious barbarity with no rational reason for it to exist in the 21st Century being inflicted on the child.
Get your insurance to pay for it.


Insurance? What about the right of others in the insurance pool not to be contributing to an act of barbarity?

Bloody well pay for it out of pocket.

Rolfe.
 
and for health reasons
That is my belief. My opinion. You will never change my mind on this issue and arguments against circumcision will never disuade me from having it performed on my child.

I don't believe in Female circumcision.

You will never change your mind, even if there is compelling evidence that your beliefs are wrong? I find that gobsmackingly stupid.
Why don't you believe in female circumcision? It's aesthetically pleasing and serves as a prophylactic.
 
That is my belief. My opinion. You will never change my mind on this issue


Well, that's refreshingly frank, anyway.

If mindblowingly irresponsible when we're talking about unnecessary cosmetic surgery on a neonate.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom