Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Okay, so you do know what a slippery slope argument is. However...

The argument I'm seeing is that by allowing circumcision, would lead the way to allowing parents in removing or injuring a child in other ways.

Rolfe most certainly has not made this argument.
 
You're building a slippery slope argument. There are laws already in place to removal or body parts that is against the law.


Indeed. And if a law were passed banning circumcision (which is what this thread is about), then that would be against the law too. See how that works?

Removing skin that serves no purpose to an adult male and may lead to other issues (constant erections, premature ejaculation, health issues) - both physical and psychological is worth the 10 seconds of pain, that my newborn son will not remember going through.


Let's look again at that map.

Maybe we should remove your infant child's appendix too, just in case?

You sound like one of these dog breeders who tries to justify tail docking on the grounds that it prevents the tail being damaged in later life - completely ignoring the squillions of dogs of non-docked breeds, among whom tail injuries are quite uncommon.

Aesthetic to me as an adult. Health reasons for me as a parent.


The first part of that is quite disturbing, actually. The second part - for goodness sake, how on earth do 95% of British guys ever get through the day, I wonder!

I've never met a man who was "bitterly regretting that their parents had mutilated them in this way".

All men that I've date who were circumcised, NEVER THOUGHT ABOUT IT. They lived their entire life not caring that a piece of skin was missing from their penis, SO IT NEVER BOTHERED THEM.


You sure about that? Do you think any man you meet who feels that way will tell you? Do you dismiss the torment of the men who have gone public and confessed they feel this way?

I dont consider it mutilation. Again, removing extra skin to me is not mutilation.


Removing a part of the body is a mutilation, whatever. Redefining the word to make yourself feel better doesn't change that.

So you're saying that your opinion trumps everything. You have the right to chop bits off someone else's body based only on your opinion. Any limit to which bits you want to chop off? Maybe the little toe will get injured some day. Maybe it will make shoes hard to fit. Maybe you think feet look more elegant with only four toes.

Why not?

Yes he's my child. I will determine what's best for his health as the law allows me to. I believe circumcision leads to a much healthier life for male children/


And I believe the moon is made of green cheese. That doesn't make it so though.

You reckon 95% of the men in Britain are leading unhealthy lives?

Again slippery slope. There are laws already in place to removal or body parts that is against the law.


Circular argument. If circumcision is against the law, then that procedure will also be in that category.

Rolfe.
 
You're wasting your time. He doesn't see his children as people. He sees them as his property.

Not even close to being true. And your attack is unappreciated or warranted.

I see children as precious human beings. I want to make their life less complicated and without any stigmas that can be generated by the public.

People with little in their lives cling to this sense of heady power that comes with being a parent.
Many of us are not parents yet. so no "power" is in this. Its about issues that are religious in context and also based in health.

I believe that circumcision provides an added health benefit to a male child.

You may not think so. That is your opinion.


Again, YOU don't like it, tHEN don't have it done to your child.

Leave the rest of us, who choose to have it performed the freedom to do SO.
 
Okay, so you do know what a slippery slope argument is. However...

Rolfe most certainly has not made this argument.


Indeed not. I just want to know where he draws the line. So far I'm seeing "at what is legal", which is simply a circular argument.

Ban circumcision, and it becomes illegal. QED.

Rolfe.
 
Okay, so you do know what a slippery slope argument is. However...



Rolfe most certainly has not made this argument.


Then what is meant by suggesting this:

limit to what you're allowed to do to your son's body without his consent.


There are already limits in place through various laws about injury and harm to a child. Circumcision isn't against the law.
 
It isn't. A newborn child isn't able to make a decision. that's why parents make that decision for them.


An irrevocable decision, which the infant has no say in. For "personal aesthetic" reasons, or from some strange prophylactic reasoning to pre-empt something that probably wouldn't happen anyway.

If your child was a girl, would you go for pharonisation or clitoridectomy?

Rolfe.
 
Then what is meant by suggesting this:

There are already limits in place through various laws about injury and harm to a child. Circumcision isn't against the law.


I told you. I am trying to establish what limits you feel should be set to what you can do to an infant's body without their consent.

You say, what the law allows.

Fine. The law just banned circumcision. What's your problem?

Rolfe.
 
Not even close to being true. And your attack is unappreciated or warranted.


Well, I have to say that's how you are coming across. My child, I can do what I like to it.

I see children as precious human beings. I want to make their life less complicated and without any stigmas that can be generated by the public.


So you lop off a normal body part, just in case he might find this normal body part a "stigma"? What if it turns out to be the other way round?

Many of us are not parents yet. so no "power" is in this. Its about issues that are religious in context and also based in health.

I believe that circumcision provides an added health benefit to a male child.


Your belief is clearly not founded in fact.

Again, YOU don't like it, tHEN don't have it done to your child.

Leave the rest of us, who choose to have it performed the freedom to do SO.


Here we go again. MY child, My property, to "have things done to" at MY whim.

Rolfe.
 
An irrevocable decision, which the infant has no say in. For "personal aesthetic" reasons, or from some strange prophylactic reasoning to pre-empt something that probably wouldn't happen anyway.

If your child was a girl, would you go for pharonisation or clitoridectomy? Rolfe.


What I always find quite strange in these threads is that those that support male genital mutilation (and who live in a culture in which the practice is considered OK) use the same reasoning and give the same reasons as those that support female genital mutilation (who live in a culture in which the practice is considered OK).

I think it demonstrates an example of cognitive dissonance.
 
...snip...

Leave the rest of us, who choose to have it performed the freedom to do SO.

Not one person in this thread has said you can't choose to be circumcised, what some people have argued is that the choice should be yours and not made on your behalf by someone else.
 
I find uncircumcised penises to be ugly, and sexually unappealing.

I could draw all sorts of parallels with the things that I find sexually appealing in a woman, but they would have precisely nothing to do with the way I helped raise my daughter.
 
Indeed. And if a law were passed banning circumcision (which is what this thread is about), then that would be against the law too. See how that works?

yes, but there is no law making circumcision against the law. Its simply a bill/proposal to make such a law.

Let's look again at that map.

what other countries do is not my concern.

Maybe we should remove your infant child's appendix too, just in case?

Why? If it doesn't bother him or cause him injury, and until it becomes a health problem, it doesn't need to be removed

A foreskin on a child can cause problems both health (from birth) related and psychological (as they grow up).

You sound like one of these dog breeders who tries to justify tail docking on the grounds that it prevents the tail being damaged in later life - completely ignoring the squillions of dogs of non-docked breeds, among whom tail injuries are quite uncommon.

I'm against tail cutting on dogs. Since a tail to a dog is as important as a leg on a human being.

a foreskin on a male child isn't important.

The first part of that is quite disturbing, actually. The second part - for goodness sake, how on earth do 95% of British guys ever get through the day, I wonder!

I've dated a couple of British guys. They were both circumcised.

You sure about that?

Yes. Every man I've dated has never thought about their circumcised penis in the way "damn, I'm circumcised, my parents screwed me over"

Do you think any man you meet who feels that way will tell you?

Yes. Every serious relationship I've had, where children became a topic of discussion (I want to have them) I always bring up circumcision (sorry it's important to me). None of the men I've dated had an issue with it.

Do you dismiss the torment of the men who have gone public and confessed they feel this way?

Where is that link to the "torment of the men who have gone public"> Where is your case study? Where is that poll?

Removing a part of the body is a mutilation, whatever. Redefining the word to make yourself feel better doesn't change that.

Then my parents are guilty of mutilating me for removal of skin that caused me problems, on the advice of a doctor. They had no permission from me to do so.

Should I now sue my parents and the doctor that performed the surgery for something that I'm glad is now gone?

Shall I sue every Ear piercing place for what they are doing to children everyday? I had my ears pierced when I was four months old. Shall I sue my parents for putting holes in my earlobes?

Shall I sue every hair cutting/salon for cutting children's hair?

So you're saying that your opinion trumps everything.

No my opinions are for me. What you do to your own child is not my concern.

You have the right to chop bits off someone else's body based only on your opinion.

I have the right to remove something I consider to be a potential health problem for my son.

Again, you don't want to do circumcision on your son, that IS YOUR right to do so.

It is also my right to have it performed on my son.

Any limit to which bits you want to chop off? Maybe the little toe will get injured some day. Maybe it will make shoes hard to fit. Maybe you think feet look more elegant with only four toes.

Slippery slope.


Circular argument. If circumcision is against the law, then that procedure will also be in that category.

Not circular at all. Cirucmcision isn't illegal (and by the looks of it the bill will not go through).
 
What I always find quite strange in these threads is that those that support male genital mutilation (and who live in a culture in which the practice is considered OK) use the same reasoning and give the same reasons as those that support female genital mutilation (who live in a culture in which the practice is considered OK).

I think it demonstrates an example of cognitive dissonance.


Well, yeah. What THEY do is bad and horrible, but what WE do is so minor you're being completely unreasonable making any comparison.

Certainly I agree there's a spectrum, and female genital mutilation gets a lot worse than male gets. But that doesn't put male genital mutilation in the same class as a haircut either. Unless it's the sort of haircut Samson got.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
An irrevocable decision, which the infant has no say in. For "personal aesthetic" reasons, or from some strange prophylactic reasoning to pre-empt something that probably wouldn't happen anyway.


and for health reasons
That is my belief. My opinion. You will never change my mind on this issue and arguments against circumcision will never disuade me from having it performed on my child.

I don't believe in Female circumcision.
 
Fine. The law just banned circumcision. What's your problem?

then I'll be sure to have my child in a state or hospital that isn't banned from performing the procedure. Even it means to go to another country to do so.
 
So it's not a religious matter at all, in Christianity. Thanks for conceding that point.

Rolfe.

Beat me to it. Nihilianth should withdraw the contention that it is a Catholic custom. Somehow I don't expect it.
 
I find uncircumcised penises to be ugly, and sexually unappealing.

You will not be having sex with your son so what the hell does it matter if his penis is sexually unappealing to you - it bloody well should be sexually unappealing to you!

Also I would say a better way to deal with your problem is to seek some form of therapy that way your son can make his own choice about getting circumcised or not when he is old enough to make that decision for himself.
 
Not one person in this thread has said you can't choose to be circumcised, what some people have argued is that the choice should be yours and not made on your behalf by someone else.

And some procedures should be done without consent of the child. I believe this is one of them.

Having known someone who chose to go through Adult circumcision and wishing his parents had it done when he was a newborn is more than enough testimony for me to rely on.
 
You will not be having sex with your son so what the hell does it matter if his penis is sexually unappealing to you - it bloody well should be sexually unappealing to you!

I was relating my issues with uncircumcised penises. I dont find them sexually appealing.


I for one will have the procedure done on my son, because I feel there vast health benefits with the procedure.

Also I would say a better way to deal with your problem is to seek some form of therapy that way your son can make his own choice about getting circumcised or not when he is old enough to make that decision for himself.
No therapy needed on my part. Im grounded enough to understand the implications and disadvantages of circumcision (you think that I didn't do the research?). I will still have it performed on my son.
 
Last edited:
Well, yeah. What THEY do is bad and horrible, but what WE do is so minor you're being completely unreasonable making any comparison.

Certainly I agree there's a spectrum, and female genital mutilation gets a lot worse than male gets. But that doesn't put male genital mutilation in the same class as a haircut either. Unless it's the sort of haircut Samson got.

Rolfe.

I did forget to add the usual caveat that female genital mutilation of types above one are certainly not comparable in degree of severity to the male genital mutilation that is acceptable in countries like the USA. But type 1a certainly is a fair comparison and then we see the same reasons are given as for MGM in countries like the USA.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom