Indeed. And if a law were passed banning circumcision (which is what this thread is about), then that would be against the law too. See how that works?
yes, but there is no law making circumcision against the law. Its simply a bill/proposal to make such a law.
Let's look again at that map.
what other countries do is not my concern.
Maybe we should remove your infant child's appendix too, just in case?
Why? If it doesn't bother him or cause him injury, and until it becomes a health problem, it doesn't need to be removed
A foreskin on a child can cause problems both health (from birth) related and psychological (as they grow up).
You sound like one of these dog breeders who tries to justify tail docking on the grounds that it prevents the tail being damaged in later life - completely ignoring the squillions of dogs of non-docked breeds, among whom tail injuries are quite uncommon.
I'm against tail cutting on dogs. Since a tail to a dog is as important as a leg on a human being.
a foreskin on a male child isn't important.
The first part of that is quite disturbing, actually. The second part - for goodness sake, how on earth do 95% of British guys ever get through the day, I wonder!
I've dated a couple of British guys. They were both circumcised.
Yes. Every man I've dated has never thought about their circumcised penis in the way "damn, I'm circumcised, my parents screwed me over"
Do you think any man you meet who feels that way will tell you?
Yes. Every serious relationship I've had, where children became a topic of discussion (I want to have them) I always bring up circumcision (sorry it's important to me). None of the men I've dated had an issue with it.
Do you dismiss the torment of the men who have gone public and confessed they feel this way?
Where is that link to the "torment of the men who have gone public"> Where is your case study? Where is that poll?
Removing a part of the body is a mutilation, whatever. Redefining the word to make yourself feel better doesn't change that.
Then my parents are guilty of mutilating me for removal of skin that caused me problems, on the advice of a doctor. They had no permission from me to do so.
Should I now sue my parents and the doctor that performed the surgery for something that I'm glad is now gone?
Shall I sue every Ear piercing place for what they are doing to children everyday? I had my ears pierced when I was four months old. Shall I sue my parents for putting holes in my earlobes?
Shall I sue every hair cutting/salon for cutting children's hair?
So you're saying that your opinion trumps everything.
No my opinions are for me. What you do to your own child is not my concern.
You have the right to chop bits off someone else's body based only on your opinion.
I have the right to remove something I consider to be a potential health problem for my son.
Again, you don't want to do circumcision on your son, that IS YOUR right to do so.
It is also my right to have it performed on my son.
Any limit to which bits you want to chop off? Maybe the little toe will get injured some day. Maybe it will make shoes hard to fit. Maybe you think feet look more elegant with only four toes.
Slippery slope.
Circular argument. If circumcision is against the law, then that procedure will also be in that category.
Not circular at all. Cirucmcision isn't illegal (and by the looks of it the bill will not go through).