Ban circumcision in San Fran???

again, my opinion, my choice to make as a parent.

Parents make decisions about their children every day from they day they are born, without the consent of their children.
Removal of skin that serves no purpose to anyone or any male is not a problem in my book.


And now, would you care to address the actual question I asked. Is there any limit you think should be set to your right to lop bits off someone else's body to suit your personal aesthetic preferences, just because he's your son?

You've said, in your opinion, you are should be allowed to lop of a particular part of an infant's body, because you think it serves no purpose. Despite there being (a) well documented cases of infants dying as a result of such operations, and (b) well documented cases of men bitterly regretting that their parents had mutilated them in this way.

But that's OK, because in your opinion you should be allowed to do that to someone, just because he's your son.

I'm just trying to establish if you think there should be any limit to what you're allowed to do to your son's body without his consent.

Rolfe.
 
again, my opinion, my choice to make as a parent.

Parents make decisions about their children every day from they day they are born, without the consent of their children.
Removal of skin that serves no purpose to anyone or any male is not a problem in my book.

don't like circumcision? you have the choice of not having it be performed on your son.

Don't like circumcision? You have the choice of not having it be performed on you.

Oh wait... i guess you don't.

Nice that we have this thing called choice in this country. This whole argument to me, sound like anti-abortionists trying to take away choices for pregnant females.
That is the exact opposite of true. The argument is about giving people the right to decide what to do with their own bodies.
 
You are forgiven, of course. I have done far worse than that in this thread. I just get upset when people want to just ban something on the whim, without explaining why, other than they don't like something.

I think it far better to practice governmental restraint, than to have society impose their will on people without very good reason to do so.

In this case, it appears a ban on circumcision could potentially do more harm than good. When banning something, you must give some very good reasons to do so, backed up with real evidence. Superficial arguments that "well, there are some people who do it outside of religious reasons," is not good enough of a reason to ban a practice.

You are being somewhat disingenuous here. (That's a polite way of saying you are deliberately and dishonestly misrepresenting the arguments which have been offered)
People have not wanted to ban something on a whim without explaining why other than they don't like it. You have chosen to ignore what has been said.
 
You are being somewhat disingenuous here. (That's a polite way of saying you are deliberately and dishonestly misrepresenting the arguments which have been offered)
People have not wanted to ban something on a whim without explaining why other than they don't like it. You have chosen to ignore what has been said.

The only thing you have provided of any worth, is that of "taking away the choice from the kid who is being circumcised."


But that doesn't seem to be an overwhelming thing on the mens' lives who have it done later in life.

You, on the other hand, seem to be ignoring the rights of parents to raise their kids how they want.
 
Nice that we have this thing called choice in this country.


Yeah, isn't it great that boys have the choice whether or not they want to be circumcised....

Oh wait.....

This whole argument to me, sound like anti-abortionists trying to take away choices for pregnant females.


Really? To me, your argument sounds like someone forcing someone else to have something done to their body whether they like it or not.

I had extra skin grow in an area that was covered by my clothes, but became bothersome when I got into sports. The skin could have been removed when I was a baby, my parents chose not to. As soon as I got into sports, the skin became bothersome and got infected numerous times. The doctor said it would be best to remove it.


Etc. We get the picture. Now would you like to look again at that map Childlike Empress posted. Huge swathes of the Earth with less than 20% of males circumcised. Very low proportion indeed in some countries. Even countries with big hauls of Olympic medals.

Do you really think these countries are populated by males who cant do sport because this "extra skin" is bothering them?

And while we're at it, "extra skin"? You're talking about a normal body part here, with a function. You might as well call your little toe a "growth".

Rolfe.
 
You, on the other hand, seem to be ignoring the rights of parents to raise their kids how they want.


"How they want"? So if a heroin-addict parent wants to raise a child on heroin, they should have that right? If a criminal parent wants to raise a child as a cat-burglar, they should have that right?

Or are there boundaries to this "right" you think you have?

Then again, you're not talking about "raising" a child, you're talking about lopping bits off his body without his consent.

Rolfe.
 
The only thing you have provided of any worth, is that of "taking away the choice from the kid who is being circumcised."


But that doesn't seem to be an overwhelming thing on the mens' lives who have it done later in life.

You, on the other hand, seem to be ignoring the rights of parents to raise their kids how they want.
If you can find where I mentioned 'taking away the choice', I would appreciate it.
I have forgotten that.
 
Wow. Nice one there. Just when I had some respect for you, it had to dissolve away. I am quite saddened by this. :(
What's wrong? Is this not the way you feel? To argue the contrary would lead to some interesting results. Again, if you would like me to, I'll illustrate this point logically.

Ummm....ok, so the First Amendment is just a piece of garbage then, worth nothing more than to wipe out behinds with???
Stay focused, here. The First Amendment does not dictate morality (the way things should be). It dictates what is and is not illegal.

No. Absolutely nothing to do with circumcision.
Slow down. I never said this was a case about circumcision. I said that this was a case about a conflict between state actions in regards to one's religious practices. In this situation, the state won.

You go off on a tangent about how there are currently no laws on the books. Of course, this is a thread over whether or not there should be laws. Your point was that if there were, they would be struck down by the Supreme Court. I have shown that this is most certainly not the case.

Oh, but you can claim child-abuse, can't you? Well, not really, as there is no real evidence for harm to the child.

I'm really shocked that we're still on this point. If someone were to stick a sewing needle through your groin, would it be the case, or would it not, that you have been harmed?

By the way, illustrate to me why it is immoral to slice a baby's foot with a knife.
 
And now, would you care to address the actual question I asked. Is there any limit you think should be set to your right to lop bits off someone else's body to suit your personal aesthetic preferences, just because he's your son?

You're building a slippery slope argument. There are laws already in place for the injury or removal or body parts that is against the law. Circumcision isn't against the law.

Removing skin that serves no purpose to an adult male and may lead to other issues (constant erections, premature ejaculation, health issues) - both physical and psychological is worth the 10 seconds of pain, that my newborn son will not remember going through.

Aesthetic to me as an adult. Health reasons for me as a parent.

You've said, in your opinion, you are should be allowed to lop of a particular part of an infant's body, because you think it serves no purpose. Despite there being (a) well documented cases of infants dying as a result of such operations, and (b) well documented cases of men bitterly regretting that their parents had mutilated them in this way.
I've never met a man who was "bitterly regretting that their parents had mutilated them in this way". ---- care to link to a case study or poll to support this?

All men that I've date who were circumcised, NEVER THOUGHT ABOUT IT. They lived their entire life not caring that a piece of skin was missing from their penis, SO IT NEVER BOTHERED THEM.


I dont consider it mutilation. Again, removing extra skin to me is not mutilation. I had extra skin, and it was removed, not mutilation and I am glad that its gone (btw, my parents never asked me to have it removed. they went on the advice of the doctor to have it removed).

But that's OK, because in your opinion you should be allowed to do that to someone, just because he's your son.
Yes he's my child. I will determine what's best for his health as the law allows me to. I believe circumcision leads to a much healthier life for male children/



I'm just trying to establish if you think there should be any limit to what you're allowed to do to your son's body without his consent.

Rolfe.
Again slippery slope. There are laws already in place to removal or body parts that is against the law.



also a point that you have missed entirely:

Every male that I've dated who was circumcised has never thought twice about it. It isn't exactly a subject that is on the top of their minds.



What they were missing since birth, isn't something that grown male adults will think about since it doesn't even cross their minds.

The only time I see this as an issue is when new parent(s) is suddenly presented with a form from the hospital to give permission for the procedure to be done.
 
Last edited:
That is the exact opposite of true. The argument is about giving people the right to decide what to do with their own bodies.


It isn't. A newborn child isn't able to make a decision. that's why parents make that decision for them.
 
"How they want"? So if a heroin-addict parent wants to raise a child on heroin, they should have that right? If a criminal parent wants to raise a child as a cat-burglar, they should have that right?

Or are there boundaries to this "right" you think you have?

Then again, you're not talking about "raising" a child, you're talking about lopping bits off his body without his consent.

Rolfe.

You're wasting your time. He doesn't see his children as people. He sees them as his property. People with little in their lives cling to this sense of heady power that comes with being a parent. Those of us that have other things in our lives and normal, healthy egos tend to see our children as individual people for whose welfare we are responsible.
 
Last edited:
...snip...

Removing skin that serves no purpose to an adult male and may lead to other issues (constant erections, premature ejaculation, health issues) - both physical and psychological is worth the 10 seconds of pain, that my newborn son will not remember going through.

A

..snip..

It does serve a purpose.
 
Last edited:
I don't think you know what a slippery slope argument is.

A small event would lead down a path to other encompassing events.

Like allowing gays to marry would lead way to allowing men/women marrying children, or their pet animals.

The argument I'm seeing is that by allowing circumcision, would lead the way to allowing parents in removing or injuring a child in other ways.

What am I missing?
 
It does serve a purpose.

Not that I've seen or heard. Maybe a bit more stimulation, but what else does it provide beyond being physically unattractive to some people?

Again, a good friend of mines had Adult Circumcision. That foreskin brought him untold embarrassment. He wished his parents had him circumcised when he was a newborn.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom