Nihilianth
Illuminator
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2011
- Messages
- 3,851
You need not worry about me playing debate games. That's not how I roll.
I'm pretty sure this is how you felt, but I just wanted to be absolutely clear.
What you are saying then, is that "it is a religious practice" is insufficient grounds for the permissibility of an action. This is a fine stance to take, and I agree with it. However, what is your reasoning for the performance of circumcision?
Wow. Nice one there. Just when I had some respect for you, it had to dissolve away. I am quite saddened by this.
Uh oh. Someone doesn't have an argument.
Ummm....ok, so the First Amendment is just a piece of garbage then, worth nothing more than to wipe out behinds with???
If need be, I am more than happy to illustrate your errors through logical syllogism.
Big words there, for a big guy.
As per your question regarding the Constitution: Yes, I am familiar with it. More importantly, I am familiar with its application in regards to this subject. The ruling you should familiarize yourself with is Employment Division v. SmithWP. This is a case where a man's unemployment benefits were denied because he got busted on drug charges, even though they were a necessary part of his religion. Obviously we're not talking about unemployment benefits, but the same principles that applied to his case apply to this one.
No. Absolutely nothing to do with circumcision.
For one, this case was far more complicated than circumcision. It went back-and-forth between state and federal supreme courts. Even the courts didn't think this was such a black-and-white issue.
But with circumcision, there are no laws in place which contradict the practice. Whereas, anti-drug laws were passed, but states were recognizing Native Americans' rights to use peyote, since it is a part of their religion. This is why the case was ping-ponging between state and federal courts. They had to make a very difficult decision based on drug laws, and religious rights.
Circumcision is even more cut-and-dried than that. There are no laws against a religious practice that does very little, if any, harm to a child. There are no laws against parents upbringing their children in their religion. Nothing.
Oh, but you can claim child-abuse, can't you? Well, not really, as there is no real evidence for harm to the child.