Ban circumcision in San Fran???

You need not worry about me playing debate games. That's not how I roll.



I'm pretty sure this is how you felt, but I just wanted to be absolutely clear.

What you are saying then, is that "it is a religious practice" is insufficient grounds for the permissibility of an action. This is a fine stance to take, and I agree with it. However, what is your reasoning for the performance of circumcision?

Wow. Nice one there. Just when I had some respect for you, it had to dissolve away. I am quite saddened by this. :(

Uh oh. Someone doesn't have an argument.

Ummm....ok, so the First Amendment is just a piece of garbage then, worth nothing more than to wipe out behinds with???

If need be, I am more than happy to illustrate your errors through logical syllogism.

Big words there, for a big guy. :)

As per your question regarding the Constitution: Yes, I am familiar with it. More importantly, I am familiar with its application in regards to this subject. The ruling you should familiarize yourself with is Employment Division v. SmithWP. This is a case where a man's unemployment benefits were denied because he got busted on drug charges, even though they were a necessary part of his religion. Obviously we're not talking about unemployment benefits, but the same principles that applied to his case apply to this one.

No. Absolutely nothing to do with circumcision.

For one, this case was far more complicated than circumcision. It went back-and-forth between state and federal supreme courts. Even the courts didn't think this was such a black-and-white issue.

But with circumcision, there are no laws in place which contradict the practice. Whereas, anti-drug laws were passed, but states were recognizing Native Americans' rights to use peyote, since it is a part of their religion. This is why the case was ping-ponging between state and federal courts. They had to make a very difficult decision based on drug laws, and religious rights.

Circumcision is even more cut-and-dried than that. There are no laws against a religious practice that does very little, if any, harm to a child. There are no laws against parents upbringing their children in their religion. Nothing.

Oh, but you can claim child-abuse, can't you? Well, not really, as there is no real evidence for harm to the child.
 
Interesting map from the wikipedia article.

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/79/Global_Map_of_Male_Circumcision_Prevalence_at_Country_Level.png/800px-Global_Map_of_Male_Circumcision_Prevalence_at_Country_Level.png[/qimg]

Interesting map. Not sure of the point. It just shows where the custom of circumcision is most heavily distributed. Note the differences in cultures.

Considering the US is in the middle (between 20 and 80%, which is a pretty HUGE range) it will be mighty difficult to ban circumcision.
 
What case law are you using to justify that opinion?

There isn't any real case law on it. It is not an established precedent to ban ear piercing and circumcision on infants. And quite frankly, I think it is a bit ridiculous to ban both.

Since there is no real case law on this specific topic, it just makes it that much more difficult to pass, because of the First Amendment.
 
The actual Catholic view on the process.. can't get any more recent than this...
.
"The most recent statement by the Roman Catholic Church was that of His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI:

"The Church of Antioch sent Barnabas on a mission with Paul, which became known as the Apostle's first missionary journey . . . Together with Paul, he then went to the so-called Council of Jerusalem where after a profound examination of the question, the Apostles with the Elders decided to discontinue the practice of circumcision so that it was no longer a feature of the Christian identity (cf. Acts 15: 1-35). It was only in this way that, in the end, they officially made possible the Church of the Gentiles, a Church without circumcision; we are children of Abraham simply through faith in Christ."[33]

With the exception of the commemoration of the circumcision of Jesus in accordance with Jewish practice, circumcision has not been part of Roman Catholic practice. Circumcision of the flesh was replaced by circumcision of the spirit."
.
And the Catholics condemned it officially in 1442.
(also from Google)
 
There isn't any real case law on it. It is not an established precedent to ban ear piercing and circumcision on infants. And quite frankly, I think it is a bit ridiculous to ban both.

Since there is no real case law on this specific topic, it just makes it that much more difficult to pass, because of the First Amendment.

And what legal standard does one use when determining whether or not a law should be struck down for violating the first amendment? (Hint)

Just because there has never been a case that specifically matches the facts in this circumstance doesn't mean there is no relevant case law.

Edit: Forgive my snarkiness. I get annoyed when people say "that violates the Constitution" and never explain why.
 
Last edited:
You cannot prove the majority of motivations of why Christians may circumcise their kids, I don't think.


We can certainly observe that mandatory circumcision for religious reasons would actually be heretical in mainstream Christianity.

The attitude may be "you can if you like", or indeed active prohibition, but it certainly is not an obligation. No mainstream Christian denomination requires circumcision as a religious obligation. So we can reasonably say that ordinary mainstream Christians do not circumcise their kids because they think their religion requires it.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Putting words in my mouth much!? Holy geez! You have got to be kidding me!

Well, bud. You made a claim. Time for you to back it up. Show a spot where I said the specific words "so you can get into heaven."

And take it out of context, I WILL call you out on it.

I think this puts your credibility at an all-time low now.

I could have used exactly the same words about the way you have dealt with various arguments.
 
using circumcision as a rite in the process of rearing the child in the said faith [that is, Christianity].


Would someone mind asking Nihilianth to show is where in "Christianity" circumcision is a rite in the process of raising a child in the faith?

He's still saying "Christianity", not obscure sects of the Amish or whatever, and he needs to be called on it.

Rolfe.
 
And what legal standard does one use when determining whether or not a law should be struck down for violating the first amendment? (Hint)

Just because there has never been a case that specifically matches the facts in this circumstance doesn't mean there is no relevant case law.

Edit: Forgive my snarkiness. I get annoyed when people say "that violates the Constitution" and never explain why.

You are forgiven, of course. I have done far worse than that in this thread. I just get upset when people want to just ban something on the whim, without explaining why, other than they don't like something.

I think it far better to practice governmental restraint, than to have society impose their will on people without very good reason to do so.

In this case, it appears a ban on circumcision could potentially do more harm than good. When banning something, you must give some very good reasons to do so, backed up with real evidence. Superficial arguments that "well, there are some people who do it outside of religious reasons," is not good enough of a reason to ban a practice.

As evidence, when it came to drug use, Native Americans using peyote and getting fired form their jobs, even the courts have quite a hard time with this issue, even though drug use itself is illegal under normal circumstances.

It will only be that much harder to ban something which doesn't already contradict another specific law. Especially when the practice is done under religious purposes, which is protected by the First Amendment.
 
Interesting map from the wikipedia article.

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/79/Global_Map_of_Male_Circumcision_Prevalence_at_Country_Level.png/800px-Global_Map_of_Male_Circumcision_Prevalence_at_Country_Level.png[/qimg]

So catholic Mexico and South America has low rates of circumcision? So much for that argument.
 
Not to mention Italy and Ireland....

Nihilianth has no clue what he's talking about, and I'm on ignore because I pointed that out.

Maybe someone could ask him if he intends to circumcise his son, if he has one, and if he does, to explain his reasons.

Rolfe.
 
My opinion.

The bill will be shot down for various claims using the US Constitution and First Amendment rights.


As to circumcision:

I'll gladly have my son be snipped, and I dont care what anyone else has to say. My son, I'm the parent, and I get to make the choices as to how I want my son's health to be.

I find uncircumcised penises to be ugly, and sexually unappealing.

I'm not Jewish.


ETA: I had a good friend of mines go through Adult Circumcision and he does not wish it on anyone.
 
Last edited:
I'll gladly have my son be snipped, and I dont care what anyone else has to say. My son, I'm the parent, and I get to make the choices as to how I want my son's health to be.


Is there any limit you think should be set to your right to lop bits off someone else's body to suit your personal aesthetic preferences, just because he's your son?

Rolfe.
 
Is there any limit you think should be set to your right to lop bits off someone else's body to suit your personal aesthetic preferences, just because he's your son?

Rolfe.

again, my opinion, my choice to make as a parent.

Parents make decisions about their children every day from they day they are born, without the consent of their children.
Removal of skin that serves no purpose to anyone or any male is not a problem in my book.

don't like circumcision? you have the choice of not having it be performed on your son.


Nice that we have this thing called choice in this country. This whole argument to me, sound like anti-abortionists trying to take away choices for pregnant females.


True story:
I had extra skin grow in an area that was covered by my clothes, but became bothersome when I got into sports. The skin could have been removed when I was a baby, my parents chose not to. As soon as I got into sports, the skin became bothersome and got infected numerous times. The doctor said it would be best to remove it.

The procedure if done when I was just a newborn - would have been covered under insurance as part of the birth, and I wouldn't have any memory of the pain.

I had the skin removed when I was 10 years old. It was an outpatient procedure, but I experienced pain in the area for 2 weeks following and the healing time was a lot longer than that. I couldn't participate in Swimming sports or soccer (due to falling on the operated area). The procedure was expensive.

That whole time, I wished my parents had removed the skin when I was a newborn.

Every male that I've dated who was circumcised has never thought twice about it. It isn't exactly a subject that is on the top of their minds.
 
Last edited:
again, my opinion, my choice to make as a parent.

Parents make decisions about their children every day from they day they are born, without the consent of their children.
Removal of skin that serves no purpose to anyone or any male is not a problem in my book.

don't like circumcision? you have the choice of not having it be performed on your son.


Nice that we have this thing called choice in this country. This whole argument to me, sound like anti-abortionists trying to take away choices for pregnant females.


True story:
I had extra skin grow in an area that was covered by my clothes, but became bothersome when I got into sports. The skin could have been removed when I was a baby, my parents chose not to. As soon as I got into sports, the skin became bothersome and got infected numerous times. The doctor said it would be best to remove it.

The procedure if done when I was just a newborn - would have been covered under insurance as part of the birth, and I wouldn't have any memory of the pain.

I had the skin removed when I was 10 years old. It was an outpatient procedure, but I experienced pain in the area for 2 weeks following and the healing time was a lot longer than that. I couldn't participate in Swimming sports or soccer (due to falling on the operated area). The procedure was expensive.

That whole time, I wished my parents had removed the skin when I was a newborn.

Every male that I've dated who was circumcised has never thought twice about it. It isn't exactly a subject that is on the top of their minds.

Even though I never dated any males, the bolded is exactly one of the point I espouse.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom