Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Whatever the rest of your arguments, this is simply not true, and will not be made true by repetition. Only in a very small minority of cases is the motivation for circumcision a religious one, and if it were judged harmful to another person then it would not be protected by the First Amendment any more than other, more harmful, practices.

Dave

I have yet to see a real source on this though that proves it beyond any doubt.

If the health organizations from various nations, and the WHO, talk about exercising caution in advising doctors to remain unbiased when giving information about the circumcision process due to "cultural and religious practices," how is this not a common theme when discussing the First Amendment?
 
Well, bud. You made a claim. Time for you to back it up. Show a spot where I said the specific words "so you can get into heaven."

While I don't think you actually used those words, you have been portraying circumcision as an action mandated by Christian faith, rather than - as you have now admitted is in fact the case - one that is not specifically forbidden to those of Christian faith. As such, it is no more a Christian religious observance than eating pork.

Dave
 
You don't know much about it, but you insist it's necessary for entry into heaven?

Bald-faced lies, that I would like to see a mod have these claims be stricken from all of your posts about what I have said, and have not said.

Are you trolling, or something?

Circumcision is not and never has been part of Roman Catholic practice. Any RC priest who is advocating circumcision on religious grounds needs to go have a word with the Pope.

Rolfe.


Too bad the Pope will say nothing about the rightness or wrongness of the decision for any priest to speak about circumcision. The Church keeps a neutral stance on the issue.
 
I have yet to see a real source on this though that proves it beyond any doubt.

A real source that the First Amendment does not protect any and all instances of religiously mandated infliction of harm on others? If you need a source for that, your understanding of law must be remarkably superficial.

If the health organizations from various nations, and the WHO, talk about exercising caution in advising doctors to remain unbiased when giving information about the circumcision process due to "cultural and religious practices," how is this not a common theme when discussing the First Amendment?

Irrelevant, mostly. The vast majority of circumcisions, as we have seen already, are not religiously motivated, and are thus not protected by the First Amendment. The remainder are only protected insofar as they do not violate other laws; angrysoba gave suttee as an example, which violates the law against murder.

Dave
 
You need not worry about me playing debate games. That's not how I roll.

Long answer: There are many exceptions to this, of course, such as human sacrifice.

I'm pretty sure this is how you felt, but I just wanted to be absolutely clear.

What you are saying then, is that "it is a religious practice" is insufficient grounds for the permissibility of an action. This is a fine stance to take, and I agree with it. However, what is your reasoning for the performance of circumcision?

The practice of circumcision is still done for the same reasons as it always has before: Religious rites.

Uh oh. Someone doesn't have an argument.

If need be, I am more than happy to illustrate your errors through logical syllogism.

As per your question regarding the Constitution: Yes, I am familiar with it. More importantly, I am familiar with its application in regards to this subject. The ruling you should familiarize yourself with is Employment Division v. SmithWP. This is a case where a man's unemployment benefits were denied because he got busted on drug charges, even though they were a necessary part of his religion. Obviously we're not talking about unemployment benefits, but the same principles that applied to his case apply to this one.

In earlier rulings, the Court had deliberated that the government could not condition access to unemployment insurance or other benefits on an individual's willingness to give up conduct required by their religion. However, the Supreme Court did not find that this principle also applied when the conduct in question is justifiably prohibited by law. For the first time in an unemployment compensation case, the Court found against the believer and for the state.

Of particular importance was the fact that the Oregon law was not directed at the Native Americans' religious practice specifically; thus, it was deemed constitutional when applied to all citizens:

"It is a permissible reading of the [free exercise clause]...to say that if prohibiting the exercise of religion is not the object of the [law] but merely the incidental effect of a generally applicable and otherwise valid provision, the First Amendment has not been offended....To make an individual's obligation to obey such a law contingent upon the law's coincidence with his religious beliefs, except where the State's interest is 'compelling' - permitting him, by virtue of his beliefs, 'to become a law unto himself,' contradicts both constitutional tradition and common sense.' To adopt a true 'compelling interest' requirement for laws that affect religious practice would lead towards anarchy."
 
Question: are there really Christians who circumcise for religious reasons? Cause the NT specifically states that only Hebrew Christians need circumcise their sons.

Yes. There are Christians who do so. Many American Roman Catholics, some Baptist groups, and anabaptists, and some Amish who split from the official Amish church.
 
Now that is very very different. You acknowledge that the RC church actively condemned circumcision at one time.

So how come it has suddenly become essential to get into heaven?

Oh wait it isn't. You merely say that the practice is no longer prohibited. That's a very long way from it being something which is a religious obligation, necessary to achieve entry into heaven, which is what you have stated.

Indeed, we all realise that many Christians of many denominations in the USA circumcise their sons. Given the high prevalence of both Christianity and circumcision in the USA it could hardly be otherwise.

However, their reasons are not and cannot be religious, because it is no part of Christian doctrine to require circumcision. Just because the RC church has ended a prohibition on the practice hardly makes it obligatory.

If Christian parents circumcise their sons, they are doing it for social reasons, not religious.

Rolfe.

Oh wait. It's a lie! I never even said the bolded! Go figure.

I didn't read past the bolded spot. Sorry, but I think you will go on my ignore list. congrats for being hte first!
 
Bald-faced lies, that I would like to see a mod have these claims be stricken from all of your posts about what I have said, and have not said.


Yes, you did say that, and you repeatedly posted that circumcision as a religious obligation within Christianity.

Too bad the Pope will say nothing about the rightness or wrongness of the decision for any priest to speak about circumcision. The Church keeps a neutral stance on the issue.


Wow, now you're getting it.

THE POPE WILL NOT TELL YOU THAT IT IS A RELIGIOUS DUTY TO HAVE YOUR CILDREN CIRCUMCISED.

Because it isn't. Not within Christianity.

Now I couldn't care less whether the RC church prohibits circumcision or not. Except, it sounds like a stupid position to take, when we all know that circumcision is sometimes medically necessary.

Can I get it through to you yet, that CIRCUMCISION IS NOT MANDATED AS PART OF CHRISTIAN PRACTICE.

If any Christian decides to circumcise his child, it is a social decision only, not a religious one.

Rolfe.
 
Yes, you did say that, and you repeatedly posted that circumcision as a religious obligation within Christianity.




Wow, now you're getting it.

THE POPE WILL NOT TELL YOU THAT IT IS A RELIGIOUS DUTY TO HAVE YOUR CILDREN CIRCUMCISED.

Because it isn't. Not within Christianity.

Now I couldn't care less whether the RC church prohibits circumcision or not. Except, it sounds like a stupid position to take, when we all know that circumcision is sometimes medically necessary.

Can I get it through to you yet, that CIRCUMCISION IS NOT MANDATED AS PART OF CHRISTIAN PRACTICE.

If any Christian decides to circumcise his child, it is a social decision only, not a religious one.

Rolfe.
.
Since you've made the lad's ignore list.... :)
 
Yes. There are Christians who do so. Many American Roman Catholics, some Baptist groups, and anabaptists, and some Amish who split from the official Amish church.


So what did the RC one do when the RC church actually condemned the practice?

Do you see where you're going with this?

There may, as I said, be small sects (heretical, I'd suggest) which have decided that circumcision is mandatory Christian practice. I say it's heretical because this actually contradicts specific biblical teaching.

But to suggest that it's accepted in any branch of the RC church that it's required to circumcise your child is absolutely ridiculous.

Rolfe.
 
HAH! I knew he would take it out of context.

That was written in the context of giving parents the right to raise their kid how they want.


Way to back-track. Show me just one religion in which circumcision is said to be necessary for entry into heaven.

Rolfe.
 
While I don't think you actually used those words, you have been portraying circumcision as an action mandated by Christian faith, rather than - as you have now admitted is in fact the case - one that is not specifically forbidden to those of Christian faith. As such, it is no more a Christian religious observance than eating pork.

Dave

I respectfully think you have my arguments about how parents should be able to raise their kids how they want in their religious practices and beliefs and the part about "it is the duty of Christians to help save people for getting into heaven," confused with using circumcision as a rite in the process of rearing the child in the said faith. Paraphrased, of course.

In any case, it doesn't change the fact that Christian, Muslims, and Jews use circumcision as a part of their religious belief system.
 
any chance the incredible pain had anything to do with the existing medical condition that neccessitated the operation?

I suppose it's possible. Given what the condition was I suppose the removal of it might have made the area very sensitive, but it's not like the condition caused the pain, if that makes sense?

Surely your doctor told you this was unusual?

Both of my boys needed to be circumcised for medical reasons, one at age 7, the other at age 8 or 9 (I forget exactly). The first had a bit of pain for the first day, and took Tylenol. The second didn't bother with the Tylenol. They both ran around and played like nothing had happened starting upon return from surgery, so even the minimal pain of the older boy was minimal.

The area was ugly and reddish for a while, and they had to apply a topical antibacterial daily. The bandages came off by themselves within a week, and the stitches dissolved shortly thereafter.

This is pretty much exactly what the pediatric urologist said would happen, except he didn't mention how godawfully unsightly the healing process would be for the first month.
No, he didn't. He actually gave me pretty heavy meds while I was in hospital and told me that it would be painful. I laughed it off when I left the hospital because I was still doped up to my eyeballs.
 
A real source that the First Amendment does not protect any and all instances of religiously mandated infliction of harm on others? If you need a source for that, your understanding of law must be remarkably superficial.

Ummm...what? If I am not mistaken, that was quoting you, when you said something about it being "harmful to others." I was asking for proof that it is, indeed, harmful.



Irrelevant, mostly.

If the health organizsations have no real findings on the benefits and risks of circumcision, and advise caution for doctors dealing with decions-making for parents on religious and cultural grounds, it is far from irrelevent. I think the health organizations opinions on the matter should be the most sufficient opinon in this case, since we are talking about "health."

The vast majority of circumcisions, as we have seen already, are not religiously motivated,

You may have posted the source, but I missed it. You cannot prove the majority of motivations of why Christians may circumcise their kids, I don't think. And certainly the Jews and Muslims do it on religious grounds as well.

and are thus not protected by the First Amendment.

Yes they are. See above.

The remainder are only protected insofar as they do not violate other laws; angrysoba gave suttee as an example, which violates the law against murder.

Dave

Suttee is not wide-practiced. Not by a long shot, and certainly not in this country. And suicide is illegal anyway. Suttee is a separate issue from circumcision, which does not violate any other laws.
 
Yeah, I'm quite proud of that. But then, we all know about the siren call of the "view post" button....

Rolfe.
.
Many of us are round-heeled with that damn button!
I gave up on Ignore long ago.. :)
 
Interesting map from the wikipedia article.

800px-Global_Map_of_Male_Circumcision_Prevalence_at_Country_Level.png
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom