So it's a matter, not of absolutes, but of drawing the line - as, indeed, it always will be when there are contradictions between legal principles. Clearly, killing another person is not legal even when one's religion mandates one to do so. Equally clearly, for example, placing a red mark using eradicable dye on a child's forehead is too trivial to be of any concern. The criteria I personally would use to draw the line are those of harm, benefit and reversibility. Circumcision is irreversible - a circumcised man can never choose not to have been circumcised - confers minimal benefit, and may be construed as mild harm. On balance, it seems to me that it should not be done.
I don't care if you don't think it should be done. That's fine. I am not trying to convince you otherwise. I just aim to see people exercise restraint in calling for the banning of something which even the various health organizations say should be a choice made by the parents. The potential harm in passing a ban, may far outweigh any benefits of the ban. Parents will probably continue to have their kids be circumcised, but will be under less clinical conditions than they currently are practiced in. This is a very real concern.
As for religious practices, as far as I'm aware only the Jewish faith specifically mandates circumcision. I'm open to correction, but as far as I'm aware it's a grey area in Islam and even more so in Christianity.
I dunno much about religions in general. I just know how my particular community practices. And as a Roman Catholic, the Church frequently performs circumcisions in the parishes my parents attended in the city I grew up in. Probably is more of a diocese thing.
I have yet to meet any man who talks about circumcision at all. It's not something that readily comes up in conversation. But this is no more than anecdotal evidence; the fact that people are not publicly decrying the fact that they have been denied a choice does not imply that that choice should be denied to others.
It seriously is not that big a deal. I agree, nobody talks about their circumcision. Probably because they don;t really carry any deep-seated resentment that they were circumcised. Or because it might be inappropriate for public discussion. In any case, I just don't see why it is such a deal to ban the practice, especially if could potentially cause more harm than good.
The First Amendment is no obstacle, if circumcision is viewed as committing harm to a minor, and given that the majority of circumcisions are not in fact carried out for religious reasons.
I am not sure where you get the source for the bolded. I may have missed that somehwere in the thread.
In any case, as I have said before, just because some people may do it "just because," doesn't mean that it isn't still protected under the First Amendment. With that reasoning, people could purposely bring a Bible to school for non-religious reasons, and call for the banning of Bibles because not all people who bring them in are religious.
The fact that it is a very common religious practice, and is associated with religion, is what protects it in the First Amendment.
Peer pressure includes, for example, parents having their children circumcised because it's seen as the normal thing to do. From the Wikipedia article on the
history of male circumcision:
Again, just because people do it for other purposes other than religion, doesn't mean it cannot still be protected under the First Amendment as a religious practice.
I'm not entirely happy with the idea that religion carries an automatic exclusion from the requirement not to harm others needlessly, but I suspect that only a religious exclusion would allow a law to pass.
First, you have to prove that it causes harm. The health organizations say there is a lack of evidence for this one point that keeps rearing its ugly head.
That being the case, due ot the First Amendment, and the lack of evidence for "harm done" you would need "religious reasons" to be excused in order to pass some sort of ban. That is only natural.
From the same Wikipedia article, there is a reference to:
1 in 6000 is not a good death rate for a procedure with no reasonable justification.
first, where did he get those numbers? Second, look at where, and when you are talking about. England specifically? 1942 - 1947? This is in the midst of WWII, and more specifically, during the Battle of Britain, and the aftermath. Durng this time in this particular location, I find it hard to beleive a number of things:
That the actual cause of death for newborns from circumcision specifically at a time that was 60 years ago, and during the most chaotic time period in a chaotic location, when the health organizations say there is not enough data today to determine the risks involved.
I think you're overstating the popularity of circumcision. In Britain in 1949, circumcision was removed from the list of procedures available free of charge under the National Health Service. Circumcision rates rapidly dropped to less than 1%, because nobody wanted to pay for it.
1949? sorry, but I don;t think that what happened 50 years ago is all that relevant. In any case, circumcisions are rarely "free of charge," anyway. Typically the parents' health insurance covers it, I do believe. I dunno much about that, so I probably shouldn't make any claims here.
In any case, it wasn't banned. And over the last 50 years, it would appear that circumcision in England has made quite a bit of a resurgence, if the "less than 1% in 1949" is true. .
http://www.circinfo.net/rates_of_circumcision.html
If one in 6,000 is dead, I would consider that alone cause for serious concern.
Dave
1 in 6,000? From 1942-1947? In England?
1. Where ever those numbers came from, I sure would love to see the extensive research that went into this project.
2. You talking about WWII England, and comparing it to 2011 USA. Certainly it is nowhere NEAR 1 in 6,000 who die from circumcision. If that were the case, there would still be hundreds of deaths each year from circumcision. A number that is totally unsupported, with no evidence. The health organizations seem to think otherwise.
In fact, estimates are closer to about .4 - .6% in which complication occur. That doesn't mean death, and the research that went into this, said those numbers are still quite uncertain.