Ban circumcision in San Fran???

#3. Jewish & Muslim circumcision is done at a very young age. The circumcised male feels the pain for only a few seconds, and then it is gone. There is no evidence that these babies experience any pain hours....if not even minutes after the event. And there is NO evidence whatsoever, that any circumcised males remember the event. I know I sure don't, and I know that even as a young child, I had no memory of the event.
.

Hi, I'm a male who was circumcised for medial reasons while I was in primary school (no, I won't tell you what in thread, yes, they were valid) and I can tell you now that I was in absolute blinding pain for weeks. It was total agony, to the point where I had to wear a sports cup stuffed full of padding so the affected area didn't touch my underwear, let alone my trousers.

While it's entirely possible that babies feel less pain, or the pain fades quicker, the procedure itself causes absolute blinding agony. I've experienced quite a few painful things, including being kicked and hit in that area before, and absolutely nothing compares to the pain I felt after my operation.
 
Hi, I'm a male who was circumcised for medial reasons while I was in primary school (no, I won't tell you what in thread, yes, they were valid) and I can tell you now that I was in absolute blinding pain for weeks. It was total agony, to the point where I had to wear a sports cup stuffed full of padding so the affected area didn't touch my underwear, let alone my trousers.

While it's entirely possible that babies feel less pain, or the pain fades quicker, the procedure itself causes absolute blinding agony. I've experienced quite a few painful things, including being kicked and hit in that area before, and absolutely nothing compares to the pain I felt after my operation.

any chance the incredible pain had anything to do with the existing medical condition that neccessitated the operation?
 
My maternal grandparents first child died from Septicaemia after circumcision, why they did it I don't know, this is Leeds, UK 1920's no religious affiliation.

My father apparently wanted to have my older brother circumcised when he was born but my mother put her foot down and I think this saved all us brothers from having it done......

.....if you're watching Mam, me and my foreskin thank you..
 
Thanks for that. Is this the James/Paul debates? Is it accurate enough to refer to them this way?


I'm not a knowledgeable enough theologian to answer that, technically. However, Christ was in his lifetime very much against meaningless ritual and pointless ordinances. The disciples were always in trouble for "breaking the Sabbath". Christ spoke about ending such things as dietary restrictions, which is why Christians don't keep kosher kitchens. It was all about being spiritually right, and not relying on outward form or observance.

This is the argument which seems to have prevailed as regards circumcision. It was specifically decided that non-Jewish converts to Christianity should not be required to be circumcised. At what point those who had come from within the Jewish community stopped circumcising their children I don't know, but I think it was pretty early.

Nihilianth is talking nonsense. No mainstream Christian denomination regards circumcision as a pre-requisite for entry into heaven. He may be a member of a small breakaway sect with non-orthodox beliefs, but he's certainly NOT talking about Christianity as such.

Rolfe.
 
So it's a matter, not of absolutes, but of drawing the line - as, indeed, it always will be when there are contradictions between legal principles. Clearly, killing another person is not legal even when one's religion mandates one to do so. Equally clearly, for example, placing a red mark using eradicable dye on a child's forehead is too trivial to be of any concern. The criteria I personally would use to draw the line are those of harm, benefit and reversibility. Circumcision is irreversible - a circumcised man can never choose not to have been circumcised - confers minimal benefit, and may be construed as mild harm. On balance, it seems to me that it should not be done.

I don't care if you don't think it should be done. That's fine. I am not trying to convince you otherwise. I just aim to see people exercise restraint in calling for the banning of something which even the various health organizations say should be a choice made by the parents. The potential harm in passing a ban, may far outweigh any benefits of the ban. Parents will probably continue to have their kids be circumcised, but will be under less clinical conditions than they currently are practiced in. This is a very real concern.

As for religious practices, as far as I'm aware only the Jewish faith specifically mandates circumcision. I'm open to correction, but as far as I'm aware it's a grey area in Islam and even more so in Christianity.

I dunno much about religions in general. I just know how my particular community practices. And as a Roman Catholic, the Church frequently performs circumcisions in the parishes my parents attended in the city I grew up in. Probably is more of a diocese thing.



I have yet to meet any man who talks about circumcision at all. It's not something that readily comes up in conversation. But this is no more than anecdotal evidence; the fact that people are not publicly decrying the fact that they have been denied a choice does not imply that that choice should be denied to others.

It seriously is not that big a deal. I agree, nobody talks about their circumcision. Probably because they don;t really carry any deep-seated resentment that they were circumcised. Or because it might be inappropriate for public discussion. In any case, I just don't see why it is such a deal to ban the practice, especially if could potentially cause more harm than good.



The First Amendment is no obstacle, if circumcision is viewed as committing harm to a minor, and given that the majority of circumcisions are not in fact carried out for religious reasons.

I am not sure where you get the source for the bolded. I may have missed that somehwere in the thread.

In any case, as I have said before, just because some people may do it "just because," doesn't mean that it isn't still protected under the First Amendment. With that reasoning, people could purposely bring a Bible to school for non-religious reasons, and call for the banning of Bibles because not all people who bring them in are religious.

The fact that it is a very common religious practice, and is associated with religion, is what protects it in the First Amendment.



Peer pressure includes, for example, parents having their children circumcised because it's seen as the normal thing to do. From the Wikipedia article on the history of male circumcision:

Again, just because people do it for other purposes other than religion, doesn't mean it cannot still be protected under the First Amendment as a religious practice.

I'm not entirely happy with the idea that religion carries an automatic exclusion from the requirement not to harm others needlessly, but I suspect that only a religious exclusion would allow a law to pass.

First, you have to prove that it causes harm. The health organizations say there is a lack of evidence for this one point that keeps rearing its ugly head.

That being the case, due ot the First Amendment, and the lack of evidence for "harm done" you would need "religious reasons" to be excused in order to pass some sort of ban. That is only natural.



From the same Wikipedia article, there is a reference to:



1 in 6000 is not a good death rate for a procedure with no reasonable justification.

first, where did he get those numbers? Second, look at where, and when you are talking about. England specifically? 1942 - 1947? This is in the midst of WWII, and more specifically, during the Battle of Britain, and the aftermath. Durng this time in this particular location, I find it hard to beleive a number of things:

That the actual cause of death for newborns from circumcision specifically at a time that was 60 years ago, and during the most chaotic time period in a chaotic location, when the health organizations say there is not enough data today to determine the risks involved.



I think you're overstating the popularity of circumcision. In Britain in 1949, circumcision was removed from the list of procedures available free of charge under the National Health Service. Circumcision rates rapidly dropped to less than 1%, because nobody wanted to pay for it.

1949? sorry, but I don;t think that what happened 50 years ago is all that relevant. In any case, circumcisions are rarely "free of charge," anyway. Typically the parents' health insurance covers it, I do believe. I dunno much about that, so I probably shouldn't make any claims here.

In any case, it wasn't banned. And over the last 50 years, it would appear that circumcision in England has made quite a bit of a resurgence, if the "less than 1% in 1949" is true. . http://www.circinfo.net/rates_of_circumcision.html

If one in 6,000 is dead, I would consider that alone cause for serious concern.

Dave

1 in 6,000? From 1942-1947? In England?

1. Where ever those numbers came from, I sure would love to see the extensive research that went into this project.

2. You talking about WWII England, and comparing it to 2011 USA. Certainly it is nowhere NEAR 1 in 6,000 who die from circumcision. If that were the case, there would still be hundreds of deaths each year from circumcision. A number that is totally unsupported, with no evidence. The health organizations seem to think otherwise.

In fact, estimates are closer to about .4 - .6% in which complication occur. That doesn't mean death, and the research that went into this, said those numbers are still quite uncertain.
 
Hi, I'm a male who was circumcised for medial reasons while I was in primary school (no, I won't tell you what in thread, yes, they were valid) and I can tell you now that I was in absolute blinding pain for weeks. It was total agony, to the point where I had to wear a sports cup stuffed full of padding so the affected area didn't touch my underwear, let alone my trousers.

Surely your doctor told you this was unusual?

Both of my boys needed to be circumcised for medical reasons, one at age 7, the other at age 8 or 9 (I forget exactly). The first had a bit of pain for the first day, and took Tylenol. The second didn't bother with the Tylenol. They both ran around and played like nothing had happened starting upon return from surgery, so even the minimal pain of the older boy was minimal.

The area was ugly and reddish for a while, and they had to apply a topical antibacterial daily. The bandages came off by themselves within a week, and the stitches dissolved shortly thereafter.

This is pretty much exactly what the pediatric urologist said would happen, except he didn't mention how godawfully unsightly the healing process would be for the first month.
 
It is a mutilation, Nihilianth. So is ear piercing, come to that. Just because the term makes you uncomfortable, doesn't mean you get to re-define the English language.

Rolfe.

I've already defined the term "mutilation" and provided a link to wiki, and the Free Dictionary definition earlier in this thread.

"Mutilation" is too general a term, and you are using the intellectually dishonest practice of "framing" questions, when you ask "So you think genital mutilation is OK to perform on newborns?"

Those are loaded statements and questions that do not define the term "mutilation." It is ambiguous, and not specific enough to separate the ideas of throwing a human body into a meat grinder, from circumcision. They are both "mutilations," which makes it a "framed" term in a biased manner, meant only to cause confusion.

We are talking specifically about "circumcision." Not the broad topic of "mutilation."

And ear-piercing is even further from the proper term of mutilation than circumcision! At least with a pierced ear, it grows back, and the hole goes away rather quickly.

In any case, I am done arguing that point. If you cannot use the proper terminology, then you have no part in this discussion.
 
The fact that it is a very common religious practice, and is associated with religion, is what protects it in the First Amendment.

Whatever the rest of your arguments, this is simply not true, and will not be made true by repetition. Only in a very small minority of cases is the motivation for circumcision a religious one, and if it were judged harmful to another person then it would not be protected by the First Amendment any more than other, more harmful, practices.

Dave
 
Your opinion. Other people differ.




Your opinion. Other people differ.




Your opinion. Other people differ.




Your opinion. Other people differ.




Your opinion. Other people differ.




Your opinion. Other people differ.




Your opinion. Other people differ.




Your opinion. Other people differ.




That is quite obviously complete nonsense.




I don't know what minority sect you are a member of, but please stop saying "Christians" perform circumcision for religious purposes. They do not.




Your opinion. Other people differ.

Rolfe.

EXACTLY!!!! You FINALLY got the point in this entire discussion! Jeez, welcome to the thread! Man, oh man.

The entire debate is nothing but opinions. Other people differ. Which is exactly why a ban is uncalled for! Thank you! :)
 
I dunno much about religions in general. I just know how my particular community practices. And as a Roman Catholic, the Church frequently performs circumcisions in the parishes my parents attended in the city I grew up in. Probably is more of a diocese thing..


You don't know much about it, but you insist it's necessary for entry into heaven?

Are you trolling, or something?

Circumcision is not and never has been part of Roman Catholic practice. Any RC priest who is advocating circumcision on religious grounds needs to go have a word with the Pope.

Rolfe.
 
And it would be a wrong guess.

There was a debate in the early Christian church regarding whether people from Gentile backgrounds should be circumcised when converting to Christianity. The decision was no, and so it has remained ever since. I couldn't exclude the existence of some minority sect that has decided to go the other way on this one, but since biblical times, Christians have very definitely not circumcised.

Rolfe.

Wrong. The Catholic Church condemned it for a long time. But has since recanted on the condemnation of Catholics circumcising. Now, many many Roman Catholics go about the business of circumcision. It appears to be on a diocese-by-diocese basis in the USA.

And many non-deominational Christians carry on the practice as well. Epsecially within the United States.

And it matters about the US as opposed to the rest of the world, because the OP is about San Francisco.
 
EXACTLY!!!! You FINALLY got the point in this entire discussion! Jeez, welcome to the thread! Man, oh man.

The entire debate is nothing but opinions. Other people differ. Which is exactly why a ban is uncalled for! Thank you! :)


Why do I get the feeling you're ignoring my posts, and choosing one where you think you can "win" by wilfully misunderstanding me?

Your opinion is only opinion. You are repeatedly stating as fact things which are very definitely your own personal take on the matter. Try taking on board the fact that many people see circumcision as barbaric mutilation of a helpless infant, and deal with it.

You see female circumcision as barbaric, and unjustifiable. I think you need to realise that many people are of much the same opinion as regards male circumcision, and stop being so dismissive of their point of view.

Rolfe.
 
Question: are there really Christians who circumcise for religious reasons? Cause the NT specifically states that only Hebrew Christians need circumcise their sons.
 
Wrong. The Catholic Church condemned it for a long time. But has since recanted on the condemnation of Catholics circumcising. Now, many many Roman Catholics go about the business of circumcision. It appears to be on a diocese-by-diocese basis in the USA.

And many non-deominational Christians carry on the practice as well. Epsecially within the United States.

And it matters about the US as opposed to the rest of the world, because the OP is about San Francisco.


Now that is very very different. You acknowledge that the RC church actively condemned circumcision at one time.

So how come it has suddenly become essential to get into heaven?

Oh wait it isn't. You merely say that the practice is no longer prohibited. That's a very long way from it being something which is a religious obligation, necessary to achieve entry into heaven, which is what you have stated.

Indeed, we all realise that many Christians of many denominations in the USA circumcise their sons. Given the high prevalence of both Christianity and circumcision in the USA it could hardly be otherwise.

However, their reasons are not and cannot be religious, because it is no part of Christian doctrine to require circumcision. Just because the RC church has ended a prohibition on the practice hardly makes it obligatory.

If Christian parents circumcise their sons, they are doing it for social reasons, not religious.

Rolfe.
 
Nihilianth, before we go any further, I want to get something cleared up. Do you agree with either of the following statements:

1. If an action is done for religious reasons, that action cannot lead to criminal charges (according to the constitution)
2. If an action is done for religious reasons, that action should not lead to criminal charges.

Before I go on to answer this question in a rather breathy manner, are you an American who is familiar with the Constitution, and the various exceptions to freedoms given therein because of case law as written and handed down by the Supreme Court?

If not, then I think a discussion about that would be forth coming. I ask this, because answering you questions your questions, as stated above, in a simple "yes/no" fashion would not be accurate in any way. Those are rather dishonest questions to ask, which would yield dishonest answers.

however, the second question I can sum up rather quickly, if I may:

If an action is done for religious reasons, that action should not lead to criminal charges.

The short answer: Not necessarily, they shouldn't.

Long answer: There are many exceptions to this, of course, such as human sacrifice.

But like I said before, in order to get a better, more clear understanding of the problem, one would need to do a little digging in American history, historical case laws, precedents, traditions, religious practices, and so forth. Which is exactly why this issue of banning circumcision is such a sticky topic, and is unlikely to ever pass, nor should it. And why the health organizations exercise such caution in advising doctors to give unbiased information about the benefits and risks of circumcision, in order to allow families to make informed decisions on their own. The health organizations do not want to get into the subject of stepping on people's religious and cultural practices, especially if there is a lack of any real solid evidence for the risks and benefits that doctors are advised to talk about to parents.

You cannot ask "yes-no" questions in such a complex issue, in which there are many, any factors involved.
 
Question: are there really Christians who circumcise for religious reasons? Cause the NT specifically states that only Hebrew Christians need circumcise their sons.


Precisely. As I said, there may be some obscure sect somewhere that has decided on circumcision as a religious obligation, though I haven't heard of it. As you rightly observe, Christian doctrine specifically DOES NOT require circumcision.

Nihilianth doesn't seem to know much about his own religion. And he seems to think that ending a prohibition on a practice turns it into a religious duty, essential for entry into heaven.

Rolfe.
 
I'm not a knowledgeable enough theologian to answer that, technically. However, Christ was in his lifetime very much against meaningless ritual and pointless ordinances. The disciples were always in trouble for "breaking the Sabbath". Christ spoke about ending such things as dietary restrictions, which is why Christians don't keep kosher kitchens. It was all about being spiritually right, and not relying on outward form or observance.

This is the argument which seems to have prevailed as regards circumcision. It was specifically decided that non-Jewish converts to Christianity should not be required to be circumcised. At what point those who had come from within the Jewish community stopped circumcising their children I don't know, but I think it was pretty early.

Nihilianth is talking nonsense. No mainstream Christian denomination regards circumcision as a pre-requisite for entry into heaven. He may be a member of a small breakaway sect with non-orthodox beliefs, but he's certainly NOT talking about Christianity as such.

Rolfe.

Putting words in my mouth much!? Holy geez! You have got to be kidding me!

Well, bud. You made a claim. Time for you to back it up. Show a spot where I said the specific words "so you can get into heaven."

And take it out of context, I WILL call you out on it.

I think this puts your credibility at an all-time low now.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom