Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I shall support this law as soon as they pass a similar law making it illegal to pierce the ears of young children. In fact, the only time a child should have his/her ears pierced is when he/she can sign a legal document stating that they understand the procedure about to take place and willfully engage in it.

Comparing male circumcision to ear piercing is the same dumbassery as comparing female circumcision to male circumcision. Not everything is black-and-white.

Female circumcision is definitely criminal and unspeakably cruel.

Male circumcision is wrong and unnecessary but unless it's been botched it's not a tragedy. Should it be banned? I think so. But it's just not in the same category, I'm afraid. (I declined to have my son circumcised, even though I was.) Furthermore it appears to have its origins in religion, and that itself makes it suspect at the very least, in my opinion.

Ear piercing does not even belong in this conversation. Get a grip.
 
Wow. I've been a Christian all my life, and only now do I discover that circumcision is essential in Christian doctrine for entry into heaven.

Who knew? :oldroll:

Rolfe.
 
Granted. Still, two wrongs don't make a right. Just because torturing someone to death over days or weeks is worse, somehow, than killing them unexpectedly with a shot to the back of the head doesn't make the latter not wrong.
For the hundredth time, neither of those equate to circumcision.






This completely ignores the actual philosophy behind rights and what they are, and why people have them.

No it doesn't

You have the right, in a free country*, to do what you want with your own body and property. A baby's body is not your body, and therefore you have no right to mutilate it for ritualistic religious reasons.

There's with that "mutilation" word again. Intellectual dishonesty earns you no points. Quit calling it "mutilation." There is a separate technical term for a reason. It is called "circumcision." "Mutilation" is too ambiguous, as it can mean anything.

In any case, it isn't about "aesthetic surgery," either. What it is about, is the parents raising the child in their home, with their traditions, and their religious beliefs. Parents have the right to circumcise their child, because that is how they want to raise him: As a Jew, Christian, or Muslim. Since it does no real harm to the individual in question, the government has no right to interfere with said religious tradition.


That somebody can gin up a half-assed scientific rationale for it, while still doing it for the real and completely different reason is, unfortunately, how our society works with a lot of laws, and the courts support it.

What are you talking about? Courts support what? The First Amendment? That they most certainly do. I honestly have no idea what you wrote here, or the point you are trying to make.




* Actually, you have this right in a non-free country, too, even in a country that "voted it away democratically". Your right is violated, but still remains. That people have the physical power, or numbers (remember the vote is an abstraction of "might makes right") to violate your right does not take it away; rights are not dependent on others "granting" them to you -- it is a contradiction that they somehow have the right to grant rights to others.

Wow! This is totally false. Apparently, you have no idea how a democratic republic like the United States actually works.

I think you need to have a basic Civics class at the very least before you go around saying these things. At the very very least, perhaps you should look up the term "Republic," (which is what this country is. It isn't necessarily a "Democracy." It is a Republic with Democratic values.)

I would also highly suggest you give the Constitution of the United States of America a thorough reading, and not come back until you understand each and every article written therein about the structure of the government, it's three branches, and the purposes of those branches. The purpose of the electorate, and the capacity of just what "powers" the citizens have.

I think you should also look up the history of the Supreme Court. SCOTUS has passed many deliberations which were really unpopular that extended rights to other peoples, such as blacks and women, when those views were in the minority. The Supreme Court upholds the law as written in the Constitution. No matter how unpopular something may be, SCOTUS is there to uphold the law as it is written, and to strike down any laws that may have been popularly written, if it is unconstitutional.

In any case, those seeking to ban circumcision appears to be in a very small minority. Most atheists couldn't care less one way or the other. And atheists are far outnumbered by religious folks in this country. So you would lose by popular vote anyway.
 
The baby also has inalienable rights. Among them are to not have its genitals mutilated without its consent for archaic, ritualistic religious reasons. Other people's religious reasons, not its own.

Where's is say those words in the Constitution? Certainly the first sentence is correct, but all the rest is just nonsensical rambling about what you know nothing of.
 
I shall support this law as soon as they pass a similar law making it illegal to pierce the ears of young children. In fact, the only time a child should have his/her ears pierced is when he/she can sign a legal document stating that they understand the procedure about to take place and willfully engage in it.

All sarcasm aside, apart from the fact that ear piercings can heal whereas circumcision can't, I see no reason not to enact such a law. Again, minors should not be forced to undergo risky and unnecessary surgical procedures when they are unable to consent to them.

Dave
 
Ear piercing is a mutilation too. I'd ban it in children too young to give consent also.

Hell, not just too young to give consent, but old enough to be sure they weren't being pressurised into it.

Rolfe.
 
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.The Moslem religion calls for the execution of anyone converting from Islam to any other religion. Clearly, this is illegal in the USA, therefore the right of the religious to practice their religion is not unlimited with respect to the limitations on their rights to inflict harm on other people. The removal of healthy tissue from another party with no medical justification is, by definition, harm, and should therefore be excluded from the rights secured by the First Amendment.

Best argument yet, and I applaude you for this. However, the problem is, once again, you are comparing a brutal act to something that is rather benign. It is easy to pass a law against killing someone for any reason. It is a whole other matter, and becomes a very sticky issue when you ban a practice which does very very little harm, if any, to another person, in order to raise them up in a family's religious practices.

I have yet to meet any man who talks about their circumcision, and how they regret not having a foreskin. I myself an circumcised, and I have very little trouble living a normal life, and have a a baby on the way in 6 weeks from now.

So, there is a huge challenge to passing a ban on circumcision, because of he First Amendment, and questions being raised about the rights of parents to raise their children how they want.

I would also point out that circumcisions in the USA are by no means confined to those with religious motivations, and that it appears that the majority of circumcisions are carried out due to peer pressure and habit.

Source? I've never heard of any cases of parents circumcising their kids because of peer pressure. I'm sure there are some cases like it, but I doubt it approaches anywhere near "the majority."



However, playing sports carries benefits in terms of greater fitness and a more enjoyable lifestyle, and walking down the street is a necessary part of virtually any activity. Circumcision confers no significant benefit to offset the risks involved. This alone is sufficient justification never to carry it out in the majority of cases where no religious belief is involved.

I see you added the qualifier "where no religious belief is involved." If that is a criterion, then maybe a ban wouldn't be so bad. So long as Jews, Muslims, and some Christians can continue to carry it out.

Before you added that qualifier, I was about to make a rather long-winded response about the importance of religion, and faith in something. While sports may take care of the physical bodily health, faith and spirituality has shown to have profound positive affects on the mental health of an individual. Parents wanting to raise their kids up in their own faith is a good thing, and should be encouraged. Circumcision is a major part of the process.


Yes, it is a problem that people will engage in criminal activity rather than abide by the law if they feel that the law is distasteful to them. (Exactly the same arguments are applicable to abortions, yet those in favour of religious freedom would gladly criminalise that practice as well. That's a tu quoque argument, and therefore not a good one.) But this argument may be extended a very small amount to a great many other areas of law without engaging in a slippery slope argument; for example, it should be considered as an argument against speed limits, which (I suspect) criminalise a great deal more than 50% of the population. And the most telling point about this argument is that it takes no account whatsoever of any benefits or losses to society as a result of changing the law; it simply raises barriers to making any commonplace activity, however repugnant, illegal if it's popular.

That is all well and good, but a speed limit, for example, protects other drivers and pedestrians from purposely reckless behavior. It's a reasonable restriction. A ban on circumcision, on the other hand, doesn't really protect anyone. What about the baby, you ask? Well, show me a source that says that circumcision is a major risk that puts the baby's life on the line. And it has to be a source which clearly states the numbers of babies who have died specifically from the circumcision itself, rather than from some other causes. (I would accept infections as being directly related to the circumcision.)

Where a slippery slope may be valid (I try not to use those arguments myself, but there are times when it CAN be a valid argument,) is when an issue is a rather fuzzy, grey issue. Like circumcision.

While a ban may not necessarily begin a process of outright banning religious practice, it does shift unnecessary restrictions in that direction slightly. And most religious folks, I would suspect, would find it to be a gross violation of the First Amendment, and would be a major shifting of the goal posts in the direction of loss of religious freedom.

And you still have the issue of not solving the problem. Many people would still go out and have their child circumcised, often under less than ideal situations, in less than clinical environments. Much like what happened with Prohibition, and the "War on Drugs." The result of which could be counter-productive in protecting newborns. You just put them in even greater risk, and criminalized the parents and practitioners, depending on the punishment meted out.


But it is not they who are having parts of their bodies removed in order to practice their religion. Personally, I would think it more important to protect newborn babies, the most helpless and therefore the most needy of protection in our society, from unnecessary, mildly risky and mildly harmful procedures to which they can never have the freedom to withdraw consent.

Dave

Great argument.

I think I shall restrict my posts to only respond to you. You seem to be the only one to have made a reasonable and rational post on this issue, which actually discusses the OP, and the points actually being made against banning circumcision.

However:

The parents have a strong religious belief that it is their duty, as good parents, to bring their children up in their faith. Circumcision is a cornerstone of marking a male child for who he is, and where he came from. It is a symbol of the faith of his parents, and to carry on that faith for when they pass.

It is going to be very tough to pass a ban on a religious practice that parents may feel strongly about, when they have the right to bring up the child however they wish. The movement for banning it sort of loses credibility if those involved in the banning are themselves uncircumcised atheists, if only because it makes it seem as though those people don;t care a whole lot about the child's actual health, but would rather push their own POV on the religious. In other words: It really isn't any of their business, so long as the child is perfectly happy and healthy.
 
Comparing male circumcision to ear piercing is the same dumbassery as comparing female circumcision to male circumcision. Not everything is black-and-white.

Female circumcision is definitely criminal and unspeakably cruel.

Male circumcision is wrong and unnecessary but unless it's been botched it's not a tragedy. Should it be banned? I think so. But it's just not in the same category, I'm afraid. (I declined to have my son circumcised, even though I was.) Furthermore it appears to have its origins in religion, and that itself makes it suspect at the very least, in my opinion.

Ear piercing does not even belong in this conversation. Get a grip.

The rest of the post outside the bolded is just....nevermind.

However, the bolded is EXACTLY why the First Amendment exists in the first place: It is keep people like you from telling other people what they should or should not believe in. Thank God for the US Constitution! :cool:
 
Someone's having a party and I wasn't invited.

A few times in this post I will be quoting the Wikipedia page on circumcision (with references provided). The page has pictures that are not safe for work.

For the sake of discussion, I would advise the following:

1. Do not make accusations of logical fallacies without citing what those fallacies are and how they apply. When someone makes an argument you don't like, crying "fallacy" does not constitute a rebuttal.

2. Please refrain from imagery of any kind. Some people are taking it way too literally.



I'm hoping that there are a few things we can all agree on: There are certain actions that are acceptable to perform on small children, such as cutting their hair. However, there are other actions that are unacceptable, such as amputating their arms (and not out of medical necessity). So how do we make this distinction?

There are many factors that we would include in coming to these conclusions. We would ask ourselves, does it cause harm? Is it permanent? Does it increase or decrease one's ability to function at home or in society? When we begin to answer these questions, the difference between a haircut and an amputation become obvious. Of course, I'm going with extreme examples here, but the method of inquiry remains the same over more subtle matters, as well.

So when we ask these questions on circumcision, here are our answers.

Circumcision is harmful. Let's face facts: We're talking about taking a knife to the genitals of a small child. Sometimes anesthesia is used, but most of the time it is not.

Stang, 1998, found 45% of physicians responding to a survey who circumcise used anaesthesia – most commonly a dorsal penile nerve block – for infant circumcisions.
Ref

I, for one, would find it reprehensible to slice a baby's arm with a scalpel. I see no reason why I should take the matter any less seriously when it is the child's genitals.

Circumcision is, obviously, permanent.

Circumcision decreases one's ability to function. Feeling pleasure is a function of the penis. If you disagree, you're doing it wrong. As has been pointed out already, circumcision causes decreased sensation.

So far, circumcision is failing the test. If anyone disagrees with my method of analysis, then by all means, illustrate to me why it's wrong to poke needles in a baby's foot, or amputate it's arm. If your reasons match mine, then we're on the same page.

Now, some might argue that an exception should be made. Some point out that this is a tradition. As has been pointed out, this is not a good reason to continue doing something. If something is harmful (which I have illustrated), then its status as a tradition means nothing. To argue the contrary is the appeal to traditionWP fallacy.

Some have argued that this is primarily a religious practice. This fails for the same fundamental reason as the appeal to tradition above, but on top of that, it's also false:

A 1987 study found that the most prominent reasons US parents choose circumcision were "concerns about the attitudes of peers and their sons' self concept in the future," rather than medical concerns.
Ref

Then there is the appeal to the First Amendment. If anyone is actually going this route, I would encourage you to do a little bit of research on the lemon testWP.

The Court's decision in this case established the "Lemon test", which details the requirements for legislation concerning religion. It consists of three prongs:

1. The government's action must have a secular legislative purpose;
2. The government's action must not have the primary effect of either advancing or inhibiting religion;
3. The government's action must not result in an "excessive government entanglement" with religion.

The purpose of the law is not to ostracize religious people, so #1 does not apply. I have illustrated secular reasons for the prohibition of circumcision.
#2 is also not a factor. The primary effect is the prohibition of a practice that is done for primarily non-religious reasons.
#3 has a lot to do with, for example, government funding of religious schools, so it does not apply to this discussion.

That's all I can think of right now.
 
Best argument yet, and I applaude you for this. However, the problem is, once again, you are comparing a brutal act to something that is rather benign. It is easy to pass a law against killing someone for any reason. It is a whole other matter, and becomes a very sticky issue when you ban a practice which does very very little harm, if any, to another person, in order to raise them up in a family's religious practices.

So it's a matter, not of absolutes, but of drawing the line - as, indeed, it always will be when there are contradictions between legal principles. Clearly, killing another person is not legal even when one's religion mandates one to do so. Equally clearly, for example, placing a red mark using eradicable dye on a child's forehead is too trivial to be of any concern. The criteria I personally would use to draw the line are those of harm, benefit and reversibility. Circumcision is irreversible - a circumcised man can never choose not to have been circumcised - confers minimal benefit, and may be construed as mild harm. On balance, it seems to me that it should not be done.

As for religious practices, as far as I'm aware only the Jewish faith specifically mandates circumcision. I'm open to correction, but as far as I'm aware it's a grey area in Islam and even more so in Christianity.

I have yet to meet any man who talks about their circumcision, and how they regret not having a foreskin. I myself an circumcised, and I have very little trouble living a normal life, and have a a baby on the way in 6 weeks from now.

I have yet to meet any man who talks about circumcision at all. It's not something that readily comes up in conversation. But this is no more than anecdotal evidence; the fact that people are not publicly decrying the fact that they have been denied a choice does not imply that that choice should be denied to others.

So, there is a huge challenge to passing a ban on circumcision, because of he First Amendment, and questions being raised about the rights of parents to raise their children how they want.

The First Amendment is no obstacle, if circumcision is viewed as committing harm to a minor, and given that the majority of circumcisions are not in fact carried out for religious reasons.

Source? I've never heard of any cases of parents circumcising their kids because of peer pressure. I'm sure there are some cases like it, but I doubt it approaches anywhere near "the majority."

Peer pressure includes, for example, parents having their children circumcised because it's seen as the normal thing to do. From the Wikipedia article on the history of male circumcision:

Wikipedia said:
A 1999 study reported that reasons for circumcision included "ease of hygiene (67 percent), ease of infant circumcision compared with adult circumcision (63 percent), medical benefit (41 percent), and father circumcised (37 percent)."

I would class the fourth as habit, the first and the third as peer pressure (who, exactly, told these parents that hygeine is easier? It isn't.) and the second as quite bizarre in that it's predicated on the assumption that circumcision will be carried out at some point anyway. None of these, given the evidence available, are particularly valid reasons, and more importantly none of them are religious.

I see you added the qualifier "where no religious belief is involved." If that is a criterion, then maybe a ban wouldn't be so bad. So long as Jews, Muslims, and some Christians can continue to carry it out.

I'm not entirely happy with the idea that religion carries an automatic exclusion from the requirement not to harm others needlessly, but I suspect that only a religious exclusion would allow a law to pass.

That is all well and good, but a speed limit, for example, protects other drivers and pedestrians from purposely reckless behavior. It's a reasonable restriction. A ban on circumcision, on the other hand, doesn't really protect anyone. What about the baby, you ask? Well, show me a source that says that circumcision is a major risk that puts the baby's life on the line. And it has to be a source which clearly states the numbers of babies who have died specifically from the circumcision itself, rather than from some other causes. (I would accept infections as being directly related to the circumcision.)

From the same Wikipedia article, there is a reference to:

Wikipedia said:
...Douglas Gairdner’s famous study, The fate of the foreskin, which revealed that for the years 1942–1947, about 16 children per year in England and Wales had died because of circumcision, a rate of about 1 per 6000 circumcisions.

1 in 6000 is not a good death rate for a procedure with no reasonable justification.

And you still have the issue of not solving the problem. Many people would still go out and have their child circumcised, often under less than ideal situations, in less than clinical environments. Much like what happened with Prohibition, and the "War on Drugs." The result of which could be counter-productive in protecting newborns. You just put them in even greater risk, and criminalized the parents and practitioners, depending on the punishment meted out.

I think you're overstating the popularity of circumcision. In Britain in 1949, circumcision was removed from the list of procedures available free of charge under the National Health Service. Circumcision rates rapidly dropped to less than 1%, because nobody wanted to pay for it.

The parents have a strong religious belief that it is their duty, as good parents, to bring their children up in their faith. Circumcision is a cornerstone of marking a male child for who he is, and where he came from. It is a symbol of the faith of his parents, and to carry on that faith for when they pass.

As I've said, I suspect that this is true of only a very small minority of parents, and that most have their children circumcised because it's generally considered normal to circumcise and abnormal not to.

ETA: And I see from the above post that there is additional evidence that the primary reason is not religion but peer pressure.

In other words: It really isn't any of their business, so long as the child is perfectly happy and healthy.

If one in 6,000 is dead, I would consider that alone cause for serious concern.

Dave
 
Last edited:
I still want to know which Christian sect it is that mandates circumcision, and what these guys know about getting into heaven that the rest of us don't.

Rolfe.
 
In animal husbandry there are quite a few mutilations that are carried out.

Ear tagging
Branding
Tattooing
Castration
Spaying
Vasectomy
Docking
Mulesing
Declawing
Devoicing
Gait modification of horses

I teach my students that society decides on the cost-benefit of these procedures, or perhaps rather on the "relative harm" principle. Public pressure seems to be moving against mutilations of all kinds, and pressurising for only those with clear benefits that outweigh the degree of harm to be allowed.

Debate with US and Canadian students has made it clear that these countries still tolerate and see as normal, mutilations which have been banned in Britain to no apparent detriment of anybody. Whether it's people or animals, there will always be a degree of subjectivity. It is important for all sides to be aware of that, and to make their case on the real issues, not on their opinions.

Opinions will differ as to how harmful hacking off a part of an infant's penis is. Just as they differ as to how harmful ear piercing is, or hacking off a child's clitoris. Some will see it as minor, and those who oppose it as unreasonable. Others will be horrified by the brutality.

I find it very disturbing that Nihilianth continues to present his opinion as if it were incontrovertible fact, even when he's been shown to be factually wrong on several points. Maybe he thinks this mutilation is nothing, but many people disagree, and their opinions are just as valid.

I also find it quite disturbing that he continually cites what appear to be entirely spurious religious reasons for his desire to mutilate his child. Debating with Jewish posters on this subject at least has some intellectual honesty, because circumcision has certainly been an important part of Jewish practice for thousands of years. It is however no part of Christianity, and there is no Christian doctrine which dictates that a man must be circumcised to enter Heaven. I don't know where he's getting this rubbish from.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Someone's having a party and I wasn't invited.

A few times in this post I will be quoting the Wikipedia page on circumcision (with references provided). The page has pictures that are not safe for work.

For the sake of discussion, I would advise the following:

1. Do not make accusations of logical fallacies without citing what those fallacies are and how they apply. When someone makes an argument you don't like, crying "fallacy" does not constitute a rebuttal.

I can accept these fundamental rules, so long as people don;t go around comparing apples to oranges. You have already covered that quite nicely below, which is what I wanted to end in this entire discussion.

2. Please refrain from imagery of any kind. Some people are taking it way too literally.

I think you are referring to the use of the term "mutilation" here. The problem is, that term is too ambiguous to use, in place of a more technical and specific terminology: Circumcision. "Mutilation" can mean anything, from circumcision if one wants to include that in the terminology, to using a cheese grater on bare skin, to straight up throwing a human body into a meat grinder. You see the problem with this, don't you?



I'm hoping that there are a few things we can all agree on: There are certain actions that are acceptable to perform on small children, such as cutting their hair. However, there are other actions that are unacceptable, such as amputating their arms (and not out of medical necessity). So how do we make this distinction?

Right, which is why I was calling "foul!" everytime a different situation was brought up.

I shall answer your series of questions below:

There are many factors that we would include in coming to these conclusions. We would ask ourselves, does it cause harm?

No. Not any more harm than playing sports or walking down the street. If anything, it causes less harm.

Is it permanent?

Yes. However, those who are circumcised, it doesn't affect them at all in their lives.

Does it increase or decrease one's ability to function at home or in society?

Absolutely not.

When we begin to answer these questions, the difference between a haircut and an amputation become obvious. Of course, I'm going with extreme examples here, but the method of inquiry remains the same over more subtle matters, as well.

exactly my points earlier about the falsity of bringing up barbaric examples.

So when we ask these questions on circumcision, here are our answers.

Circumcision is harmful. Let's face facts: We're talking about taking a knife to the genitals of a small child. Sometimes anesthesia is used, but most of the time it is not.

doesn't mean it is harmful.

Ref

I, for one, would find it reprehensible to slice a baby's arm with a scalpel. I see no reason why I should take the matter any less seriously when it is the child's genitals.

What you find reprehensible, doesn't mean it should be banned. Otherwise, the Westboro Baptist Church would have lost their Supreme Court case recently. Just because you don't like something, doesn't mean it is a good argument to ban it.

Circumcision is, obviously, permanent.

True. But it doesn't affect your functioning in society, or in bed.

Circumcision decreases one's ability to function. Feeling pleasure is a function of the penis. If you disagree, you're doing it wrong. As has been pointed out already, circumcision causes decreased sensation.

Not really. This is a rather untestable subjective claim. Yes, someone cited a source where they tested for it. But that had to do with actually touching it. During the act of sex, which is what really matters, the phallus comes out of the foreskin anyway. The tip is what gets sensitive. And the penis still functions perfectly as it is meat to.

So far, circumcision is failing the test.

No it didn't. You only weighed your own POV on the subject. You failed to mention what other people may think or feel about it. The test was biased.

If anyone disagrees with my method of analysis, then by all means, illustrate to me why it's wrong to poke needles in a baby's foot, or amputate it's arm. If your reasons match mine, then we're on the same page.

And here is where you contradict yourself. Earlier you had mentioned that there is a world of difference between cutting hair, and amputating an arm. A circumcision falls closer to cutting hair, than it does in amputating an arm, as it does no harm, and the penis functions perfectly fine without any real loss of sensation during the act of sex.

Now, some might argue that an exception should be made. Some point out that this is a tradition. As has been pointed out, this is not a good reason to continue doing something.

Nor is it a good reason to discontinue doing something. Long-held traditions are obviously going to be much harder to break than newly-established ones. Look at something as reprehensible as slavery as an example: (Bear with me!)

In order to ban something as bad as SLAVERY, it took no less than 100,000 American lives, and 4 long blood-soaked years. An extreme situation, yes. But that is just to prove the point that long-held traditions is not easy to ban, and makes it "more acceptable" in society than if it were a newly-established practice. Longevity is a serious part of the discussion, and cannot be discounted out of hand.

If something is harmful (which I have illustrated),

No you haven't.

then its status as a tradition means nothing. To argue the contrary is the appeal to traditionWP fallacy.

unfortunately, for this fallacy to hold water, you must prove that "times have changed" in regards to the issue:

-The past justifications for the tradition are still valid at present.

-In actuality, the circumstances may have changed; this assumption may also therefore be untrue.

The circumstances have not changed. The practice of circumcision is still done for the same reasons as it always has before: Religious rites.

In comparison to the banning of slavery, the difference was, times were changing. The rest of the world was moving on, and it clearly violated the Constitution of guaranteeing "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" for all of its citizens. And if one were born in this country, one was a citizen.

In any case, "tradition" is not even close to being a reason of keeping it in this thread anyway. the argument used for it, is to illustrate that it will be that much harder to ban the practice. You can't tell me that, just because "tradition" is a logical fallacy, it should therefore, be just as easy to ban as a newly-established practice.

Some have argued that this is primarily a religious practice. This fails for the same fundamental reason as the appeal to tradition above, but on top of that, it's also false:

How so? Of course it isn't false about religion! Jews, Muslims, and Christians do it specifically for religious purposes. If other people do it "just because," doesn't mean religious people don't do it for their religion.

And it doesn't fail "for the same reason as traditions." For one, traditions are not covered in the First Amendment. But religious practices are.

Ref

Then there is the appeal to the First Amendment. If anyone is actually going this route, I would encourage you to do a little bit of research on the lemon testWP.


The purpose of the law is not to ostracize religious people, so #1 does not apply. I have illustrated secular reasons for the prohibition of circumcision.
#2 is also not a factor. The primary effect is the prohibition of a practice that is done for primarily non-religious reasons.
#3 has a lot to do with, for example, government funding of religious schools, so it does not apply to this discussion.

#1 Does apply to allowing a ban to a certain extent. I give you that.

#2 Inhibits a religious practice. So it fails the lemon test.

#3 Definitely fails it, for the argument for circumcision will naturally arise, and will be viewed quite heavily that government is getting entangled with religious affairs.

That's all I can think of right now.

Good post. But I just wanted to add one more thing:

It must be proven that circumcision causes undue harm to infants in order to ban a religious practice. Some sources cite .2% - .6% of all newborn babies who are circumcised will have an adverse affect, such as an infection. But those sources say it is uncertain if any deaths results from a circumcision, and whether those deaths are attributable to said circumcision.

Here's the wiki article on the risks of circumcision:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_analysis_of_circumcision

If you read the positions taken by all the health organizations, one thing stands out: They most of them may not recommend it be done, but neither can they stop it, for there is lack of evidence that supports any supposed risks and/or benefits to circumcision. And they also feel it is important for the parents to make the decisions for themselves.

The health organizations of the few nations listed, as well as the WHO, are rather hesitant to ban the practice of circumcision, due to lack of evidence, and freedom of choice for the parents.

Further down in that wiki article in the section about "costs and benefits," it says thus:

wiki said:
The American Academy of Pediatrics (1999) said:
"Existing scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision. In the case of circumcision, in which there are potential benefits and risks, yet the procedure is not essential to the child's current well-being, parents should determine what is in the best interest of the child." [16]

Clarifying their statement in 2000 in response to criticism by Schoen et al.,[17] the authors explained:

The Task Force found the evidence of low incidence, high-morbidity problems not sufficiently compelling to recommend circumcision as a routine procedure for all newborn males. However, the Task Force did recommend making all parents aware of the potential benefits and risks of circumcision and leaving it to the family to decide whether circumcision is in the best interests of their child.…Circumcision falls into that group of procedures that have potential medical benefits and some risks and should be evaluated by each family in the context of their personal beliefs and values as well as their ethnic, cultural, and religious practices. The Task Force respects the role of parents as decision-makers for their newborns and recommends that physicians discuss with parents the potential benefits as well as risks of circumcision so that parents can decide whether circumcision is in the child's best interests.[18]

That is sufficient. There are no social problems in regards to circumcision whatsoever. Why fix something which ain't broken?

On the other hand, if you DO pass such a ban, you could very easily open up a whole can of worms that could cause all sorts of social problems. You would also raise a lot of other complex questions as well.

What sort of punishment should be meted out for those who violate the ban? Do we fine them? Do we jail them? How do we cover the extra added costs on the justice system in order to enforce a potentially unpopular law? What do we do about practitioners who perform the surgery? Do we yank their licences, creating an even greater need for more pediatricians in an industry that is already lacking such professionals? Do we fine them? Do we sue them? Fining and suing doctors has the additional negative side-effects of raising their mal-practice insurance. It also increases tort costs, thereby, increasing health care costs. Also, there would be less doctors willing to perform it, and those who are willing to circumvent the law, could be less professional, thereby causing increased risks to those very newborns you aimed to protect by passing a ban.

The problem is, people are so ready and willing to do whatever they can to control decision-making for parents, that they seem to lose sight of potentially major negative side-effects a ban may have on society. Before San Francisco goes about banning circumcision, I SINCERELY hope they take these concerns into consideration.
 
It is a mutilation, Nihilianth. So is ear piercing, come to that. Just because the term makes you uncomfortable, doesn't mean you get to re-define the English language.

Rolfe.
 
Circumcision is genital mutilation generated by religious/social pressures, and has no rational defenses.
 
No. Not any more harm than playing sports or walking down the street. If anything, it causes less harm.


Your opinion. Other people differ.

However, those who are circumcised, it doesn't affect them at all in their lives.


Your opinion. Other people differ.

doesn't mean it is harmful.


Your opinion. Other people differ.

But it doesn't affect your functioning in society, or in bed.


Your opinion. Other people differ.

And the penis still functions perfectly as it is meat to.


Your opinion. Other people differ.

A circumcision falls closer to cutting hair, than it does in amputating an arm,


Your opinion. Other people differ.

as it does no harm,


Your opinion. Other people differ.

and the penis functions perfectly fine without any real loss of sensation during the act of sex.


Your opinion. Other people differ.

The practice of circumcision is still done for the same reasons as it always has before: Religious rites.


That is quite obviously complete nonsense.

Christians do it specifically for religious purposes.


I don't know what minority sect you are a member of, but please stop saying "Christians" perform circumcision for religious purposes. They do not.

There are no social problems in regards to circumcision whatsoever.


Your opinion. Other people differ.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Wow. I've been a Christian all my life, and only now do I discover that circumcision is essential in Christian doctrine for entry into heaven.

Who knew? :oldroll:

Rolfe.

Well, wasn't it Abraham who cut off the end of his todger after one of his hearing-voices-in-his-head episodes and then recommended everyone else do the same because, well, the voices in his head thought it was a good idea?

I suppose if it hadn't been explicitly repudiated then maybe it would have passed on to Christianity.

This is a bit of a guess, though.
 
Well, wasn't it Abraham who cut off the end of his todger after one of his hearing-voices-in-his-head episodes and then recommended everyone else do the same because, well, the voices in his head thought it was a good idea?

I suppose if it hadn't been explicitly repudiated then maybe it would have passed on to Christianity.

This is a bit of a guess, though.


And it would be a wrong guess.

There was a debate in the early Christian church regarding whether people from Gentile backgrounds should be circumcised when converting to Christianity. The decision was no, and so it has remained ever since. I couldn't exclude the existence of some minority sect that has decided to go the other way on this one, but since biblical times, Christians have very definitely not circumcised.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
And it would be a wrong guess.

There was a debate in the early Christian church regarding whether people from Gentile backgrounds should be circumcised when converting to Christianity. The decision was no, and so it has remained ever since. I couldn't exclude the existence of some minority sect that has decided to go the other way on this one, but since biblical times, Christians have very definitely not circumcised.

Rolfe.

Thanks for that. Is this the James/Paul debates? Is it accurate enough to refer to them this way?
 
Nihilianth, before we go any further, I want to get something cleared up. Do you agree with either of the following statements:

1. If an action is done for religious reasons, that action cannot lead to criminal charges (according to the constitution)
2. If an action is done for religious reasons, that action should not lead to criminal charges.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom