Ban circumcision in San Fran???

See, if you are going to ban a practice, what punishment are you going to mete out? How will you ensure there will not be any possible popular uprisings? Do you jail them? Fine them? Revoke licences of doctors and/or religious leaders who do the surgery? What punishment do you want to give in order to enforce the "ban?"

To me, it seems too unenforceable, too cumbersome, and comes too close to infringing on basic human rights as spelled out in the Constitution.


Well, i'm not familiar with the current practises in California but i can come up with measurements. If there is any public funding, stop it. Let them pay for it (with huge taxes). If parents are routinely asked if they want their boy to be circumcised, stop this practise. Let them ask and give them an educational brochure in return. And so on.

You still didn't admit that the practise itself is completely irrational.
 
I agreed with your point. But I did point out that you were wrong in attributing a certain claim to me.
I am pleased for you and the Empress. I hope you will be very happy together. ;)

:D Wow at the bolded. rofl.

The initial argument earlier in the thread, when slavery was first brought up seemed to have indicated a comparison to it.

Later on, I had said about the argument of "just because a practice is old, doesn't mean it shouldn't be banned," that it was a two-way street. I had said that just because it is an old practice doesn't mean it should. But you kept the argument going on far too long.
 
Well, i'm not familiar with the current practises in California but i can come up with measurements. If there is any public funding, stop it. Let them pay for it (with huge taxes). If parents are routinely asked if they want their boy to be circumcised, stop this practise. Let them ask and give them an educational brochure in return. And so on.

There is no public funding for circumcisions. None that I am aware of. That would also be against the separation clause.

Adding on "huge taxes" would also be against the separation clause.

Same with banning it.

Doctors can ask this question. Nothing illegal about it, nor should there be. Banning asking a simple question would be against the separation clause.

Government-sponsored borchures and campaigns would be against the separation clause as well.

If the PUBLIC wants to get together to create some brochures and try their own campaign, 100% privately funded, that is their prerogative.

But the government stay out of this issue altogether.

You still didn't admit that the practise itself is completely irrational.

I don't have to. I already provided the rationalization behind it from the POV of the religious. I am neither for, nor against circumcision in general. If a parent decides to do so, then.....meh.

What I am concerned about, is the government getting unnecessarily larger over private and religious matters. If it becomes criminalize, that is my tax-payer money going to enforcing a ban that should be decided privately amongst family members anyway. Tax-payer money which could not keep up with arresting the huge numbers of violators of the ban.

I mean, the illegal immigration, and drug enforcement problem already sucks a lot of tax-payer money out of the coffers of government as it is. Do we really need to start a new "war on society" campaign, like the infamous "War on Drugs?"

I don't think so. We have too many problems of underfunded education. Too many roads, and other infrastructure to repair.
 
I already provided the rationalization behind it from the POV of the religious.


But even if this would be true, it holds no merit here. For the reason that it's irrational and based on superstition - you didn't even manage to come up with a remotely coherent story based on superstition, remember?
 
Last edited:
How do those irrational cultists explain that God created foreskins in the first place? Was he in error? Or just another cruel joke by the scumbag? How is this rationalized?

In my book it's clear cut. *cough* People who do harm to babies private parts with sharp objects are sick in the brain. Period.

Well, obviously he invented foreskins to refute the argument from design.

Why would God do such a thing? I hear you ask.

Simple, to test our faith.

He is a loving God that merry little prankster!
 
Well, of course babies feel pain. It's hard to imagine anyone thinking otherwise in modern times. Any neonate procedure should use the same anesthesia (or equivalent, since newborns cannot always tolerate the exact same drugs). This is relevant to the discussion how? I don't recall anyone advocating for cutting without numbing first.

As for the first link in #275, well, let's just say that any paper that relies on memories recovered via hypnosis is a bit light in rigor.
 
But even if this would be true, it holds no merit here. For the reason that it's irrational and based on superstition - you didn't even manage to come up with a remotely coherent story based on superstition, remember?

*SIGH*

It is perfectly relevent here though. Their religion is just as real to them, as your science is to you. What gives your POV superiority over theirs?

When the first amendment says "freedom of religion," and how the government can neither support it, nor ban it, you are equal to the religious, under the first amendment. You have no right to tell people what they should believe, of that what they believe is an "irrelevant superstition," and their POV has no merits in a discussion about the banning of circumcision.

Based on that, for about the 5th time, there is no need for me to explain some "coherent story based on that superstition." My explanation about the problems involved in taking away a long-held practice from people who believe strongly in something, the legal issues of getting the government involved, and the non-existent health issues, is far more of an argument against the banning, than your arguments that "well, it's a superstition, therefore they shouldn't have the right to do the practice.," and other people's arguments about "choice."

I think you need to focus on MY arguments I am bringing to the table, rather than about my personal belief in some practice I couldn't care less about. It's just my belief in the First Amendment is quite strong, and there is a real danger when people begin to have the government begin creeping into it. Especially when it comes to a practice and/or belief that has nothing to do with them, and is rather benign.
 
Well, obviously he invented foreskins to refute the argument from design.

Why would God do such a thing? I hear you ask.

Simple, to test our faith.

He is a loving God that merry little prankster!

Posts like these do not contribute to the conversation, especially when said conversation has nothing to do with arguments that are based on governmental law, and societal issues. It just lowered your credibility quite a bit.
 
The justification for circumcision shortly after birth is that babies don't feel pain or do not remember pain.

A quick Googling (I'll do a bit more in depth checking when I'm more free time) reveals:

http://www.cirp.org/library/psych/chamberlain/

http://www.circumstitions.com/Pain.html

Ummm...I never heard anyone in here say babies cannot feel pain.

But certainly the individual will never remember it when they are older. And if you are trying to suggest otherwise, you are quite mistaken. Probably even more so than anyone in this thread. It is inherently impossible to remember any particular event from when you are an infant.
 
Thanks for this. Any comment Nihilanth about painless, harmless circumcisions?

Did I say they didn't feel pain? Was that part of my arguments? I think you have quite a bit of digging through this entire thread to find even one line where I specifically said "babies don't feel pain."

Oh, you didn't find it, or you can;t? I am not surprised.

So, instead of making up imaginary arguments that was never made, at least from me, how about you address all of the main points I have made that nobody answered yet? Once again, in list order for your conveneience:

1. First Amendment. (People have tried challenging this, by comparing the illegality of human sacrifice, to the banning of circumcision. They failed MISERABLY.)

2. Health issues. It doesn't seem to affect health, lifestyle, or functioning of the penis. (There was some success with this issue, and quite frankly, this is the one issue you need to stick with if you want to have any merits in an argument about banning the practice, since there is SOME risk involved. However, the risk is far less than playing sports, or walking down the street when the practice is done in a professionally clinical environment.)

3. Legal ramifications of passing said laws. e.g: Prohibition. Criminalizing no less than 50% of the American population can never good. The quality of circumcisions will decrease, thereby putting baby boys at even GREATER risks, as parents decide to evade the law, because their religion is more important to them than a secular law which contradicts itself about protecting religious freedom on the one hand, and yet banning a religious practice on the other. (This was a point that Childless Empress actually admitted is a problem.)

None of those arguments have been challenged to any great degree, except perhaps for the health issue. But even then, you seem to avoid that like the plague.

My beliefs in why God may have made a foreskin doesn't bare any consequence at all to this discussion. I am remaining neutral on that point. And for a reason: 1. I don't know, and 2. It detracts from the three main points, and many sub-points within those three.

I cannot possibly answer for those who believe in the practice, WHY they believe. I can only defend their beliefs, because they have certain inalienable rights to live a free and happy life, free from too much governmental control.
 
Last edited:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/ushealthjewsreligioncircumcision

very very interesting topic.

first of all, I think comparing circumcising 8-day old males to genital mutilation of teenage girls in Africa, is petty week.

Granted. Still, two wrongs don't make a right. Just because torturing someone to death over days or weeks is worse, somehow, than killing them unexpectedly with a shot to the back of the head doesn't make the latter not wrong.




#6. This clearly violates the separation of Church and State. Such a law would be no different than banning ritualized ear-piercing, branding, etc etc.

This completely ignores the actual philosophy behind rights and what they are, and why people have them.

You have the right, in a free country*, to do what you want with your own body and property. A baby's body is not your body, and therefore you have no right to mutilate it for ritualistic religious reasons.


That somebody can gin up a half-assed scientific rationale for it, while still doing it for the real and completely different reason is, unfortunately, how our society works with a lot of laws, and the courts support it.




* Actually, you have this right in a non-free country, too, even in a country that "voted it away democratically". Your right is violated, but still remains. That people have the physical power, or numbers (remember the vote is an abstraction of "might makes right") to violate your right does not take it away; rights are not dependent on others "granting" them to you -- it is a contradiction that they somehow have the right to grant rights to others.
 
I cannot possibly answer for those who believe in the practice, WHY they believe. I can only defend their beliefs, because they have certain inalienable rights to live a free and happy life, free from too much government control.


The baby also has inalienable rights. Among them are to not have its genitals mutilated without its consent for archaic, ritualistic religious reasons. Other people's religious reasons, not its own.
 
Well, of course babies feel pain. It's hard to imagine anyone thinking otherwise in modern times. Any neonate procedure should use the same anesthesia (or equivalent, since newborns cannot always tolerate the exact same drugs). This is relevant to the discussion how? I don't recall anyone advocating for cutting without numbing first.

As for the first link in #275, well, let's just say that any paper that relies on memories recovered via hypnosis is a bit light in rigor.

Indeed! As for the first link, it is beyond ridiculous.

The author seems to suggest that crying IS because of pain. For one, we don't know that. There are many possibilities why a baby cries: Pain is one yes, but others include

1. cold
2. hot
3. hunger
4. want their mommy
5. teething
6. gas stuck in their abdmoninals. ("burping" a baby seems to get them to stop crying quite often.)

In any case, all babies cry at birth. Is it because being born is painful to them? Quite possibly. But more important, it could be because they are scared, or trying to breath, they are cold, what have you. To attribute crying at birth to pain is beyond ridiculous. ALL babies cry when they are born. Seems to be more of a natural reaction than anything, and is the first sign of a perfectly healthy baby. A baby crying at birth is a GOOD thing. It lets us know they are ok.

Once they get wrapped up in a blanket, and placed in their mothers arm, they stop and go to sleep. They completely forget about any pain they may have experienced a few hours earlier, to never remember them ever again in their lives. Why? Because new born babies do not have a fully-fuctioning cognitive brain yet. Their long-term memory doesn't really exist yet, and their short-term memory is VERY short-term.

Also, the author cited a 29 year old woman under hypnosis. Well, hypnosis cannot be entered into evidence in a court of law, for the same reasons why parental genetic testing, and lie detector tests: That is, they are quite unreliable, and not scientifically feasible. Most real psychologists today do not use hypnosis.
 
1. First Amendment. (People have tried challenging this, by comparing the illegality of human sacrifice, to the banning of circumcision. They failed MISERABLY.)

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.The Moslem religion calls for the execution of anyone converting from Islam to any other religion. Clearly, this is illegal in the USA, therefore the right of the religious to practice their religion is not unlimited with respect to the limitations on their rights to inflict harm on other people. The removal of healthy tissue from another party with no medical justification is, by definition, harm, and should therefore be excluded from the rights secured by the First Amendment.

I would also point out that circumcisions in the USA are by no means confined to those with religious motivations, and that it appears that the majority of circumcisions are carried out due to peer pressure and habit.

2. Health issues. It doesn't seem to affect health, lifestyle, or functioning of the penis. (There was some success with this issue, and quite frankly, this is the one issue you need to stick with if you want to have any merits in an argument about banning the practice, since there is SOME risk involved. However, the risk is far less than playing sports, or walking down the street when the practice is done in a professionally clinical environment.)

However, playing sports carries benefits in terms of greater fitness and a more enjoyable lifestyle, and walking down the street is a necessary part of virtually any activity. Circumcision confers no significant benefit to offset the risks involved. This alone is sufficient justification never to carry it out in the majority of cases where no religious belief is involved.

3. Legal ramifications of passing said laws. e.g: Prohibition. Criminalizing no less than 50% of the American population can never good. The quality of circumcisions will decrease, thereby putting baby boys at even GREATER risks, as parents decide to evade the law, because their religion is more important to them than a secular law which contradicts itself about protecting religious freedom on the one hand, and yet banning a religious practice on the other. (This was a point that Childless Empress actually admitted is a problem.)

Yes, it is a problem that people will engage in criminal activity rather than abide by the law if they feel that the law is distasteful to them. (Exactly the same arguments are applicable to abortions, yet those in favour of religious freedom would gladly criminalise that practice as well. That's a tu quoque argument, and therefore not a good one.) But this argument may be extended a very small amount to a great many other areas of law without engaging in a slippery slope argument; for example, it should be considered as an argument against speed limits, which (I suspect) criminalise a great deal more than 50% of the population. And the most telling point about this argument is that it takes no account whatsoever of any benefits or losses to society as a result of changing the law; it simply raises barriers to making any commonplace activity, however repugnant, illegal if it's popular.

I cannot possibly answer for those who believe in the practice, WHY they believe. I can only defend their beliefs, because they have certain inalienable rights to live a free and happy life, free from too much governmental control.

But it is not they who are having parts of their bodies removed in order to practice their religion. Personally, I would think it more important to protect newborn babies, the most helpless and therefore the most needy of protection in our society, from unnecessary, mildly risky and mildly harmful procedures to which they can never have the freedom to withdraw consent.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom