Thanks for this. Any comment Nihilanth about painless, harmless circumcisions?
Did I say they didn't feel pain? Was that part of my arguments? I think you have quite a bit of digging through this entire thread to find even one line where I specifically said "babies don't feel pain."
Oh, you didn't find it, or you can;t? I am not surprised.
So, instead of making up imaginary arguments that was never made, at least from me, how about you address all of the main points I have made that nobody answered yet? Once again, in list order for your conveneience:
1. First Amendment. (People have tried challenging this, by comparing the illegality of human sacrifice, to the banning of circumcision. They failed MISERABLY.)
2. Health issues. It doesn't seem to affect health, lifestyle, or functioning of the penis. (There was some success with this issue, and quite frankly, this is the one issue you need to stick with if you want to have any merits in an argument about banning the practice, since there is SOME risk involved. However, the risk is far less than playing sports, or walking down the street when the practice is done in a professionally clinical environment.)
3. Legal ramifications of passing said laws. e.g: Prohibition. Criminalizing no less than 50% of the American population can never good. The quality of circumcisions will decrease, thereby putting baby boys at even GREATER risks, as parents decide to evade the law, because their religion is more important to them than a secular law which contradicts itself about protecting religious freedom on the one hand, and yet banning a religious practice on the other. (This was a point that Childless Empress actually admitted is a problem.)
None of those arguments have been challenged to any great degree, except perhaps for the health issue. But even then, you seem to avoid that like the plague.
My beliefs in why God may have made a foreskin doesn't bare any consequence at all to this discussion. I am remaining neutral on that point. And for a reason: 1. I don't know, and 2. It detracts from the three main points, and many sub-points within those three.
I cannot possibly answer for those who believe in the practice, WHY they believe. I can only defend their beliefs, because they have certain inalienable rights to live a free and happy life, free from too much governmental control.