Nihilianth
Illuminator
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2011
- Messages
- 3,851
This thread is not terrorized by logical fallacies at all. Nobody seriously compared torture, slavery and mutilation of female genitals as practised by african tribal societies to male circumcision. We told you that a lesser evil still isn't justified, and you failed to come up with any better justification than "tradition" for it.
Apparently you didn't read any of my posts then, other than "Traditions." And that wasn't even anywhere CLOSE to my main point, which should have been obvious from about the first 15 or so posts of mine in this thread: First Amendment.
Nobody has given any satisfactory reasons as to why this is an "evil" no matter how slight. I have heard some pretty scary terms, such as "slavery," and "human sacrifice," an all of that. Even though the point of using the word "slavery" was to show that "tradition" is not a good reason to keep something, the first time it was brought, it was compared to circumcision.
No, the only real argument I have heard from your side, is that of "choice." "It takes away the choice from the indivudual who gets circumcised."
And that is a fairly weak argument against the likes of these, which I have stated numerous, numerous times:
1. It has no adverse effects on the following:
A. Lifestyle
B. Health
C. Pleasure. (Maybe to some extent.)
D. Function.
2. It is a religious custom practiced for thousands of years, and is pretty wide-spread around the planet. It is especially important in American spiritual life for those who practice religions.
3. Religious practices are protected under the First Amendment. (human sacrifice notwithstanding, of course.
All three of those combined, gives society no right to abridge the rights of parents to choose how to raise their children in regards to religion.
Why not take my example of cutting off earlaps? Let's say my freshly founded cult believes that a higher being wants us to cut off the left earlap of our eight days old children. Is this ok? Covered by the first amendment? The only difference is that we didn't do it for thousands of years.
Your cult is "freshly founded." And cults are not protected as "religion." But it would still be a rather sticky subject to ban that new practice, if it is proven to have no adverse health and lifestyle affects.
You are correct that it isn't easy to ban such old practices, but is it wrong to try? I say no, godspeed to the San Franciscans.
It isn't wrong to ban a practice just because it is a long-held tradition, if it is proven to impede upon the rights of other human beings.
It is wrong to ban any practices for any reason if said practices are rather harmless. And long-held practices are only going to be that much harder to ban, and to justify the banning.