Ban circumcision in San Fran???

This thread is not terrorized by logical fallacies at all. Nobody seriously compared torture, slavery and mutilation of female genitals as practised by african tribal societies to male circumcision. We told you that a lesser evil still isn't justified, and you failed to come up with any better justification than "tradition" for it.

Apparently you didn't read any of my posts then, other than "Traditions." And that wasn't even anywhere CLOSE to my main point, which should have been obvious from about the first 15 or so posts of mine in this thread: First Amendment.

Nobody has given any satisfactory reasons as to why this is an "evil" no matter how slight. I have heard some pretty scary terms, such as "slavery," and "human sacrifice," an all of that. Even though the point of using the word "slavery" was to show that "tradition" is not a good reason to keep something, the first time it was brought, it was compared to circumcision.

No, the only real argument I have heard from your side, is that of "choice." "It takes away the choice from the indivudual who gets circumcised."

And that is a fairly weak argument against the likes of these, which I have stated numerous, numerous times:

1. It has no adverse effects on the following:
A. Lifestyle
B. Health
C. Pleasure. (Maybe to some extent.)
D. Function.

2. It is a religious custom practiced for thousands of years, and is pretty wide-spread around the planet. It is especially important in American spiritual life for those who practice religions.

3. Religious practices are protected under the First Amendment. (human sacrifice notwithstanding, of course. :rolleyes:)

All three of those combined, gives society no right to abridge the rights of parents to choose how to raise their children in regards to religion.

Why not take my example of cutting off earlaps? Let's say my freshly founded cult believes that a higher being wants us to cut off the left earlap of our eight days old children. Is this ok? Covered by the first amendment? The only difference is that we didn't do it for thousands of years.

Your cult is "freshly founded." And cults are not protected as "religion." But it would still be a rather sticky subject to ban that new practice, if it is proven to have no adverse health and lifestyle affects.

You are correct that it isn't easy to ban such old practices, but is it wrong to try? I say no, godspeed to the San Franciscans.

It isn't wrong to ban a practice just because it is a long-held tradition, if it is proven to impede upon the rights of other human beings.

It is wrong to ban any practices for any reason if said practices are rather harmless. And long-held practices are only going to be that much harder to ban, and to justify the banning.
 
Folks I know we all like to say our piece but why not do as Darth suggested and read some of the other discussions about this topic, if for no other reason than you will find the older threads full of links and references so you can get the facts.

While I am grateful that you and I can agree on this, it appears that our plea for reason got the shaft on this one.










(But not the tip, obviously. I am so going to Hell for that one ...)
 
Why did God create foreskins, Nihilianth?

A worthwhile question.

Probably to protect the head of the penis.

Why was the covenant made with Abraham to trip the tip?

To show everyone else

A) how tough these dudes are
b) to make them different
c) not sure
d) no clue
e) it's a mystery
 
Your cult is "freshly founded." And cults are not protected as "religion." But it would still be a rather sticky subject to ban that new practice, if it is proven to have no adverse health and lifestyle affects.


Ok, i guess our conversation ends here. If moving this out of your reality tunnel and presenting the earlap on a silver plate doesn't change your mind, then we certainly have very different opinions about what the duty of a state and the freedom of a religion/cult are.
 
I also forgot to mention, that if people had their way, a good 50% of all Americans would be criminalized. Making a criminal justice system that has already reach critical mass, to begin to break down. (We can;t even deal with the number of illegal immigrants. How you propose to deal with the number of....illegal religious practices.....I have no idea!)

Many, many of those parents who want to circumcise their kids, will find ways to do so anyway. More than likely under less than ideal situations. Thereby, putting infant boys in REAL danger, making situation you set out to do in banning the practice, much, much worse.

Basically, it would be exactly the same reason why Prohibition failed. The law couldn't deal with the number of "criminals." The respect for the law plummeted like crazy. And the situation of trying to "clean up" America by banning alcohol, only made it many times worse, as crime became overwhelmingly rampant, as well as alcoholism.

Sometimes, using the power of government to end certain practices, is less than the ideal solution.
 
Ok, i guess our conversation ends here. If moving this out of your reality tunnel and presenting the earlap on a silver plate doesn't change your mind, then we certainly have very different opinions about what the duty of a state and the freedom of a religion/cult are.

Are people in here even Americans? If not, do you know much about American case laws, and civic government? Because it would appear not.

Since the Op is based in an American city, it falls under American jurisdiction. And because it falls under American jurisdiction, American case laws would suffice in this argument.

http://www.icsahome.com/infoserv_articles/hominik_david_cultsi_in_american_society.htm

Review this real quick, and get back to me.

Now, as for your "earflap" argument (You never even defined the term "earlap," whether you just mean the lower part, the upper part, or the entire thing.)

If you just found a new religion which cuts off "earlaps," whatever your definition for this term, you can be investigated by the federal government as a cult. You can, of course, win a court case under First Amendment rights against the government. And if your only "violation" in regards to how you treat your members, is by cutting off "earlaps" of a baby who is only a couple of days old, the federal government would have a tough time on their hands, justifying their position. Especially if you prove exactly what your procedures were for removing said "earlaps," and that it would not adversely affect the health and lifestyle of the individual in question. (Which is decidedly false, IRL.)

Just because you do not like something, does not mean it should be illegal.
 
Last edited:
I'm very, very amused by the reactions both for and against circumcision.

All I'm saying is that for a liberal, inclusive city, San Fransisco sure bans a ****load of ****.
 
I'm very, very amused by the reactions both for and against circumcision.

All I'm saying is that for a liberal, inclusive city, San Fransisco sure bans a ****load of ****.

that's because they are leaving Liberalism behind and moving towards Progressive Authoritarianism.
 
Review this real quick, and get back to me.


Not "even" american. One mans cult is another mans religon, like one mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter. An earlap is the seemingly useless fleshy part down at your ears, other translations offered to me are "earlobe" and "tip of the ear". I would argue that cutting this off is comparable but slighty less harmfull than cutting off the foreskin.

I accept your prohibition argument to a degree. Apparently they want to throw people in jail for it, which would indeed criminalize a huge part of the population. But in tendency, do everything to ban this barbaric practise from the dark ages.
 
Not "even" american. One mans cult is another mans religon, like one mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter. An earlap is the seemingly useless fleshy part down at your ears, other translations offered to me are "earlobe" and "tip of the ear". I would argue that cutting this off is comparable but slighty less harmfull than cutting off the foreskin.

I can certainly accept this point of view! But it remains the same situation as cutting off the foreskin, if it is even less harmful. (BTW, I don't make the definition of "cult." To me, it is a rather ambiguous term, anyway, and try to avoid it where/whenever possible. It is very problematic, for this very reason.)

The biggest problem with "cults," is that there have been not a few cults in the past, whose very purpose was to "troll" society, using the First Amendment as their defense.

However, unless there is some actual real abuse going on within a cult, there is nothing the US government can or should do to touch them.

I accept your prohibition argument to a degree. Apparently they want to throw people in jail for it, which would indeed criminalize a huge part of the population. But in tendency, do everything to ban this barbaric practise from the dark ages.

See, if you are going to ban a practice, what punishment are you going to mete out? How will you ensure there will not be any possible popular uprisings? Do you jail them? Fine them? Revoke licences of doctors and/or religious leaders who do the surgery? What punishment do you want to give in order to enforce the "ban?"

To me, it seems too unenforceable, too cumbersome, and comes too close to infringing on basic human rights as spelled out in the Constitution.
 
Just because long-standing traditions such as slavery has been banned, does not mean that other long-standing traditions should be banned.

I agree. And I didn't suggest it did. Since you are arguing against something I didn't say, again the rest of your post will be ignored because it is likely to be more of the same.
 
folks, please read this description of the results & side-effects of female genital mutilation, and THEN tell me that its the same as male circumcision. Clearly, there is just no comparison.

I don't think anyone has said it is the same.
 
I agree. And I didn't suggest it did. Since you are arguing against something I didn't say, again the rest of your post will be ignored because it is likely to be more of the same.

Ignore it all you like. My point still stands, and you have yet to address any of my other, more important points. You are so stuck on that one issue of "traditions," that you don;t even notice anything else that we have talked in here.

Now, Childlike Empress and I have moved on to something else.
 
I'm very, very amused by the reactions both for and against circumcision.

All I'm saying is that for a liberal, inclusive city, San Fransisco sure bans a ****load of ****.

And the funny thing is there's been much more discussion of the issue in this thread than in The City itself. In the grand scheme, this one is under the radar of the average San Franciscan, so therefore it's likely to pass.

Weird little city of mine. :)
 
I don't think anyone has said it is the same.

If it is not the same, then why bring it up?

Oh yeah, because you want to make it seem "inconsistent" with First Amendment rights protecting free exercise of religion.

In order to demonstrate why it isn't inconsistent to allow male circumcision, but not female circumcision, one must make a direct comparison between the two.

You cannot have it both ways. Making a claim that the Amendment is "inconsistent," one has to make direct comparisons between cases which are exceptions to the rule, and cases that are not. And how other rights might be infringed upon for other people if you allow one to practice something however they truly wish. Hence, the reason for human sacrifice and female circumcision to be illegal.
 
Ignore it all you like. My point still stands, and you have yet to address any of my other, more important points. You are so stuck on that one issue of "traditions," that you don;t even notice anything else that we have talked in here.

Now, Childlike Empress and I have moved on to something else.
I agreed with your point. But I did point out that you were wrong in attributing a certain claim to me.
I am pleased for you and the Empress. I hope you will be very happy together. ;)
 
Really? It's a federal offense to belong to a cult? What's the definition of cult?

Taking things out of context now? How many intellectual rules can you break?

I never said it is illegal to be in a cult. I was talking about practices which leads to investigations by the government. more specifically, Childlike Empress and I were talking about cutting off "earflaps" as a hypothetical cultic practice.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom