Again, no comparison was made between slavery and circumcision.
The point was about the reason for continuing circumcision. It was claimed that because it has been a custom for a long time, it should continue. Using that logic, slavery should have continued because it had been a custom for a long time.
But it's not a good reason.
The example of human sacrifice you also failed to grasp. It had been argued that the first amendment protects people's right to practise their religion, hence banning circumcision of infants went against the 1st amendment. To be consistent, human sacrifice would also be protected since the 1st amendment protects people's right to practise their religion.
I know all of this. I read that about 800 times now. But you have failed to show why it isn't a two-way street.
Just because long-standing traditions such as slavery has been banned, does not mean that other long-standing traditions should be banned.
I know your agenda, in using slavery as a long-standing tradition, when you could very easily have used Christmas trees instead. You see, you were "framing" bias. There was no need in bringing in "slavery." You could simply have stated "There is no reason to keep long-standing traditions if it harms someone."
In any case, the comparison WAS made, many many many posts earlier, way back about page three or so. You just turned it into an argument for "traditions" in general.
And if a long-standing tradition does not harm to someone, no reason to ban it.
Now, onto something quite a bit more laughable:
The example of human sacrifice you also failed to grasp. It had been argued that the first amendment protects people's right to practise their religion, hence banning circumcision of infants went against the 1st amendment. To be consistent, human sacrifice would also be protected since the 1st amendment protects people's right to practise their religion.
Again.....bah. I dunno if I should post this again. I HAD ALREADY ANSWERED THIS.
I don't even know where to even restart.
1. Male circumcision is not the same as human sacrfice Logical fallacy.
2. Just because something is a right, doesn;t give people unlimited rights in that scope
IF IT VIOLATES THE RIGHTS OF OTHER PEOPLE.
If you want consistency, then perhaps we should just totally strike out the constitution altogether, and just go straight to a dictatorship. Because the free speech is not "consistent" either. You cannot yell "fire" in a crowded theater. Case law.
You cannot teach ID in scientific classrooms. Case law.
You cannot stuff 3,000 people into a small bar or other venue. Case law.
You cannot own firearms without a licesnse (Second Amendment.) Case law.
You cannot own a tank. Case law. (I think? I dunno if it is a case law or not, but you certainly are not allowed to own a tank, despite the second Amendment. rofl.)
Shall I go on?
Listen. I dunno if you are American or not. But you have to understand basic American law before you can even BEGIN to make such an argument!