Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Likewise, the ban would forbid the gentiles as well as the Jews from circumcising their infant sons.

You are aware, are you not, that many non-jews and non-Muslims circumcise their baby boys? So, yes you are right. Nobody would be able to do it, whether for superstitious or any other eason.
 
You have no idea what 'logical fallacy' means, do you?
#1 on your list is the only one which has remotely been compared to male circumcision.
Less use of inappropriate emoticons,a nd more reading for comprehension might be a good idea.

Oh, I read it, and comprehended it alright. Your arguments would have been far better without the use of examples of slavery, female circumcision, human sacrifice, and torture. :)
 
In other words, you have no basis of your arguments for banning male circumcision, other than "choice" for the newborn child. And that "choice" is not that big a deal, because no children is ever given any major choices in life for the first 18 - 20 years of their life, if their parents insist on taking proper care of that child.

You seem to be confusing me with someone else.
 
You are wrong. Nobody has said anything that could be interpreted as 'what about slavery', or compared it to male circumcision. Again, the point was that tradition is a bad reason for doing something. You need to come up with a better reason for cutting bits off babies.
Really, did nothing change while I was out burning branches?

I think you need to go back and read post number 215, which is a direct quote from Beth, which I have also addressed in the whole "tradition" thing.

A long-established cultural tradition is neither easy to ban, nor should it be, just because someone can somehow compare it to slavery being banned.
 
You have presented a false dichotomy (there's a genuine logical fallacy for you)
One does not have to choose between the evils one opposes.

For as much time and effort as you put into arguing over this, it sure as heck seems that way.
 
Oh, I read it, and comprehended it alright. Your arguments would have been far better without the use of examples of slavery, female circumcision, human sacrifice, and torture. :)

Again, no comparison was made between slavery and circumcision.
The point was about the reason for continuing circumcision. It was claimed that because it has been a custom for a long time, it should continue. Using that logic, slavery should have continued because it had been a custom for a long time.
But it's not a good reason.
The example of human sacrifice you also failed to grasp. It had been argued that the first amendment protects people's right to practise their religion, hence banning circumcision of infants went against the 1st amendment. To be consistent, human sacrifice would also be protected since the 1st amendment protects people's right to practise their religion.
 
If I go back through all your posts, will I find 'I think' before every statement of fact you have made?

Probably not. But then again, I never made any unsupported claims, either. In fact, I made very few claims. I was merely fending off many of the logical fallacies that this thread has been terrorized with, and trying to point out the POV of those who are religious, in order to illustrate how and why it is protected under the First Amendment. And also how it is none of your business whether or not someone should be circumcised.

I have also admitted mistake I have made in the few claims I made. Such as the "sensitivity differences," which was disproven by a study that someone posted on page 5. And about how many Christians practice circumcision. (The entire Catholic community of where I am from practices circumcision, and so I assumed it was a common practice in Catholicism. A bad assumption, apparently.)
 
Probably not. But then again, I never made any unsupported claims, either. In fact, I made very few claims. I was merely fending off many of the logical fallacies that this thread has been terrorized with, and trying to point out the POV of those who are religious, in order to illustrate how and why it is protected under the First Amendment. And also how it is none of your business whether or not someone should be circumcised.

One unsupported claim which is seared into my brain is that the foreskin is not part of the penis. And another is that cutting bits off a human body is not mutilation.
Many of the 'logical fallacies' you claimed are not logical fallacies.
You are selective about which religious practices should be protected by the first amendment, aren't you?
Is there anything which is 'my business'? Please provide a list so I know my place.
 
Again, no comparison was made between slavery and circumcision.
The point was about the reason for continuing circumcision. It was claimed that because it has been a custom for a long time, it should continue. Using that logic, slavery should have continued because it had been a custom for a long time.
But it's not a good reason.
The example of human sacrifice you also failed to grasp. It had been argued that the first amendment protects people's right to practise their religion, hence banning circumcision of infants went against the 1st amendment. To be consistent, human sacrifice would also be protected since the 1st amendment protects people's right to practise their religion.

I know all of this. I read that about 800 times now. But you have failed to show why it isn't a two-way street.

Just because long-standing traditions such as slavery has been banned, does not mean that other long-standing traditions should be banned.

I know your agenda, in using slavery as a long-standing tradition, when you could very easily have used Christmas trees instead. You see, you were "framing" bias. There was no need in bringing in "slavery." You could simply have stated "There is no reason to keep long-standing traditions if it harms someone."

In any case, the comparison WAS made, many many many posts earlier, way back about page three or so. You just turned it into an argument for "traditions" in general.

And if a long-standing tradition does not harm to someone, no reason to ban it.

Now, onto something quite a bit more laughable:

The example of human sacrifice you also failed to grasp. It had been argued that the first amendment protects people's right to practise their religion, hence banning circumcision of infants went against the 1st amendment. To be consistent, human sacrifice would also be protected since the 1st amendment protects people's right to practise their religion.

Again.....bah. I dunno if I should post this again. I HAD ALREADY ANSWERED THIS.

I don't even know where to even restart.

1. Male circumcision is not the same as human sacrfice Logical fallacy.

2. Just because something is a right, doesn;t give people unlimited rights in that scope IF IT VIOLATES THE RIGHTS OF OTHER PEOPLE.
If you want consistency, then perhaps we should just totally strike out the constitution altogether, and just go straight to a dictatorship. Because the free speech is not "consistent" either. You cannot yell "fire" in a crowded theater. Case law.

You cannot teach ID in scientific classrooms. Case law.

You cannot stuff 3,000 people into a small bar or other venue. Case law.

You cannot own firearms without a licesnse (Second Amendment.) Case law.

You cannot own a tank. Case law. (I think? I dunno if it is a case law or not, but you certainly are not allowed to own a tank, despite the second Amendment. rofl.)

Shall I go on?

Listen. I dunno if you are American or not. But you have to understand basic American law before you can even BEGIN to make such an argument!
 
These are contradictory statements. Are you really Humpty Dumpty in disguise?

Do you even know what Agnosticism mean? I GUESS it would have been accurate to say that I am an "Agnostic Theist." There, that better? I still fall under Agnosticism, regardless.
 
One unsupported claim which is seared into my brain is that the foreskin is not part of the penis. And another is that cutting bits off a human body is not mutilation.

I amended the first part to "it is not a part of functioing" for the penis.

The second one I already commented about 50 times. Your inability to read and comprehend is not my fault.

Many of the 'logical fallacies' you claimed are not logical fallacies.

Yes they were.

You are selective about which religious practices should be protected by the first amendment, aren't you?

And you don;t know much about American law, do you? you also have no idea the vast oceans of differences between human sacrifice and circumcision, do you?


Is there anything which is 'my business'? Please provide a list so I know my place.

Having an opinion on whatever you want an opinion on is your business. Interfering into the affairs of good parents who happen to hold sacred their religious views, is none of your business.
 
the problem is, you HAVE YET to demonstrate any of the bolded! Especially the "child abuse" part.

The difference between you and I, is that I state my opinions in the form of an opinions. You have stated your opinion in the form of a fact.

When you state an opinion in the form of a fact ("It is mutilation!") you better be prepared for some back-up to show your "fact" to be false.

In the case of calling it "mutilation," I have demonstrated this.

If you said "I think it is mutilation," then you are using a subjective opinion that cannot be dismissed.

But if you say "It IS mutilation," then you get this as a rebuttle:



Definition number three is a very subjective definition, and so when you say "I am of the opinion that it is mutilation," is covered under definition three, and you would be correct.

And here, you avoided addressing any of the points I presented, choosing instead to embark on another sidetrack. Your entire post is a red herring. It's also a red herring comprising mostly of lies and poor attempts at semantic quibbles, but I've no interest in those. If you can't respond to what people say, fine - just be aware that no matter how many times you claim to have won a debate, it won't make you look smarter.
 
And here, you avoided addressing any of the points I presented, choosing instead to embark on another sidetrack. Your entire post is a red herring. It's also a red herring comprising mostly of lies and poor attempts at semantic quibbles, but I've no interest in those. If you can't respond to what people say, fine - just be aware that no matter how many times you claim to have won a debate, it won't make you look smarter.

Semantics can matter, quite a bit. It is called "framing the question." I refuse to answer questions, based on your definitions of technical terminology.

In this case, you are replacing the word "circumcision" with the word "genital mutilation."

It is not unlike holocaust deniers replacing the word "Holocaust" with the word "holohoax." It is intellectually dishonest, ambiguous, and begs the question. Except with holohoax, we know exactly what they mean, so we can at least hold some semblance of a conversation it them.
 
Semantics can matter, quite a bit. It is called "framing the question." I refuse to answer questions, based on your definitions of technical terminology.

In this case, you are replacing the word "circumcision" with the word "genital mutilation."

It is not unlike holocaust deniers replacing the word "Holocaust" with the word "holohoax." It is intellectually dishonest, ambiguous, and begs the question. Except with holohoax, we know exactly what they mean, so we can at least hold some semblance of a conversation it them.

I'm having a hard time believing you're not just trolling, now. Complaining about me "framing the question" in way that displeases you, and comparing me to a holocaust denier in the same post?

Well, Poe's law and all that, since there's unlikely to be anyone reading the thread by this point who still takes you seriously, and it's clear you have no intent of attempting to actually discuss the issue, I'll bow out here. Have fun.
 
folks, please read this description of the results & side-effects of female genital mutilation, and THEN tell me that its the same as male circumcision. Clearly, there is just no comparison.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_genital_cutting#Medical_consequence


WARNING- THE FOLLOWING TEXT IS BRUTAL

Among practising cultures, FGC is most commonly performed between the ages of four and eight, but can take place at any age from infancy to adolescence. Prohibition has led to FGC going underground, at times with people who have had no medical training performing the cutting without anaesthetic, sterilisation, or the use of proper medical instruments. The procedure can lead to death through shock from excessive bleeding. The failure to use sterile medical instruments may lead to infections.

Other serious long term health effects are also common. These include urinary and reproductive tract infections, caused by obstructed flow of urine and menstrual blood, various forms of scarring and infertility. Epidermal inclusion cysts may form and expand, particularly in procedures affecting the clitoris. These cysts can grow over time and can become infected, requiring medical attention such as drainage.[37] The first episode of sexual intercourse will often be extremely painful for infibulated women, who will need the labia majora to be opened, to allow their partner access to the vagina. This second cut, sometimes performed by the partner with a knife, can cause other complications to arise.

A June 2006 study by the WHO has cast doubt on the safety of genital cutting of any kind.[1] This study was conducted on a cohort of 28,393 women attending delivery wards at 28 obstetric centers in areas of Burkina Faso, Ghana, Kenya, Senegal and The Sudan. A high proportion of these mothers had undergone FGC. According to the WHO criteria, all types of FGC were found to pose an increased risk of death to the baby (15% for Type I, 32% for Type II, and 55% for Type III). Mothers with FGC Type III were also found to be 30% more at risk for cesarean sections and had a 70% increase in postpartum haemorrhage compared to women without FGC.

Estimating from these results, and doing a rough population estimate of mothers in Africa with FGC, an additional 10 to 20 per thousand babies in Africa die during delivery as a result of the mothers having undergone genital cutting.
 
Last edited:
Probably not. But then again, I never made any unsupported claims, either. In fact, I made very few claims. I was merely fending off many of the logical fallacies that this thread has been terrorized with, and trying to point out the POV of those who are religious, in order to illustrate how and why it is protected under the First Amendment. And also how it is none of your business whether or not someone should be circumcised.


This thread is not terrorized by logical fallacies at all. Nobody seriously compared torture, slavery and mutilation of female genitals as practised by african tribal societies to male circumcision. We told you that a lesser evil still isn't justified, and you failed to come up with any better justification than "tradition" for it.

Why not take my example of cutting off earlaps? Let's say my freshly founded cult believes that a higher being wants us to cut off the left earlap of our eight days old children. Is this ok? Covered by the first amendment? The only difference is that we didn't do it for thousands of years.

You are correct that it isn't easy to ban such old practices, but is it wrong to try? I say no, godspeed to the San Franciscans.
 
I'm having a hard time believing you're not just trolling, now. Complaining about me "framing the question" in way that displeases you, and comparing me to a holocaust denier in the same post?

I am only comparing you in the same vein as Holocaust deniers like to use loaded terms.

No, you are not the same as a Holocaust denier. You are far more intelligent than that. But it is a shame to see someone with vastly more intelligence using even more ambiguous terminology than the deniers do.

Well, Poe's law and all that, since there's unlikely to be anyone reading the thread by this point who still takes you seriously, and it's clear you have no intent of attempting to actually discuss the issue, I'll bow out here. Have fun.

Good for you. If can use correct terminology, as I have said, then perhaps the conversation could have gone a little smoother. I would have hoped you took the hint that I wasn't too terribly sure, when you were doing all that framing, using incorrect terminology with a biased connotation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom