Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Look folks, I consider male circumcision to be relatively benign. I have never met a man who was unhappy about his penis, because of it. I have never met a girl who was unhappy about circumcised penises.

From what I understand, male cirumcision and female genital mutilation simply do not compare in any way, as far as pain, side effects, danger, and future sexual activity is concerned.

You're probably right.

But haircuts and vaccines don't compare to male circumcision either.

Those who make daft comparisons have no right to make daft comparisons, say I.
 
I thought this was part of the original covenant between Israel and their god? Didn't Jesus supposedly do a new deal with Christians? is this mentioned as a condition for worship in the NT?
.
In the bloody explanations of how to commit genocide in the OT, circumcision is mentioned as a means to disable the male population of an attacked town, which accepts the idea in lieu of a long term battle, and, the passages state.. "...at the third day, when the pain is the greatest, rush in and kill everyone".
 
.
In the bloody explanations of how to commit genocide in the OT, circumcision is mentioned as a means to disable the male population of an attacked town, which accepts the idea in lieu of a long term battle, and, the passages state.. "...at the third day, when the pain is the greatest, rush in and kill everyone".

book, chapter, and verse....please.
 
book, chapter, and verse....please.
.
Deuteronomy?
Been decades since I've tossed my babble into the local landfill, but that did stick in my headbone.
Genesis, chapter 34.
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Genesis+34&version=NIV
.
"24 All the men who went out of the city gate agreed with Hamor and his son Shechem, and every male in the city was circumcised.

25 Three days later, while all of them were still in pain, two of Jacob’s sons, Simeon and Levi, Dinah’s brothers, took their swords and attacked the unsuspecting city, killing every male. 26 They put Hamor and his son Shechem to the sword and took Dinah from Shechem’s house and left. 27 The sons of Jacob came upon the dead bodies and looted the city where[c] their sister had been defiled. 28 They seized their flocks and herds and donkeys and everything else of theirs in the city and out in the fields. 29 They carried off all their wealth and all their women and children, taking as plunder everything in the houses. "
 
Last edited:
A belief that something is necessary does not make it necessary.

Yes it does. The government and society cannot dictate what you believe.

Medical necessity would refer to a procedure that you need to continue living normally. Religious necessity might refer to a practice that you "need" to go to heaven when you die.

They aren't even remotely comparable.

You are correct. They aren't remotely comparable. Getting into heaven when you die is far more important than what happens in this life, since it is eternal.

See, the previous two sentences has a point. You cannot understand a Jews' deeply held beliefs too well, for you are so stuck on your atheistic views on science.

As for my own views, to clarify, don't matter in this conversation at all. I already stated I am circumcised myself, and was raised in a Christian household. I still believe in God, but I personally am more agnostic than anything else. I find your total commitment to your atheistic scientific views to be equally laughable as you may find someone else's equally religious views.

That is to say, I find your lack of even trying to understand that the religious people of this world's belief system is incredibly strong, Perhaps stronger than your atheistic views, to be your downfall in this conversation. The reason being, is because the government protect both atheistic, and religious views alike. The government, and indeed society, really has no right to ban a religious practice that is not harmful to the child in any way.

In other words, I think that your total commitment to your own POV is blinding you from realizing just how bad it would be if the government would ban circumcision. There would be all kinds of political and criminal fallout from this. You would turn literally millions of Americans (as many as 70%!!) into criminals if you had it your way. That is not good. Not good at all.

Sorry, but the only real "point" that you have, is the lack of choice on the part of the individual getting circumcised. But I have shown in this thread that:

1. It doesn't affect any aspect of that person's life at all.
2. Most circumcised males could care less about whatever "choice" was taken from them.
3. Political fallout would be enormous.
4. Criminalizing up to 70% of the American public is probably not a good idea.
5. Getting into the territory of banning a religious practice is probably likewise not a good idea, if only because the First Amendment protects religion.

All of those reasons vs your "taking a choice from the individual."

In conclusion:

The scales tip heavily against you. The ban likely will not pass. And if it happens to pass, it will likely be immediately challenged in court, and overturned by the judges.
 
Why does the reason the parent's chose for ear piercing their babe matter? Is it any of our business why they chose to do so?

If you're making an argument by analogy - in this case, arguing that male circumcision is okay because some people pierce the ears of their children - then whether or not the situations are actually analogous does matter.

But outside the context of the post, I'd say no - I don't need to know why some parents want to circumcise their children or pierce their ears, as long as they aren't allowed to do it.
 
For someone who gets so riled up with (what you mistakenly thought to be) a comparison of slavery and circumcision, you're pretty quick to equivocate voicing an opinion that it's wrong to cut pieces off babies to a century-long war effort costing countless lives, motivated by religious reasons.

Do you honestly believe people shouldn't be allowed to criticize religious practices if there are still larger problems around? That we aren't allowed to call for outlawing of a form of child abuse as long as worse forms exist?

In case you weren't aware of it, that is an actual logical fallacy.

I have no trouble speaking up against more than one bad thing at once. I'm certainly not going to accept a mild form of mutilation just because there are worse things happening.

the problem is, you HAVE YET to demonstrate any of the bolded! Especially the "child abuse" part.

The difference between you and I, is that I state my opinions in the form of an opinions. You have stated your opinion in the form of a fact.

When you state an opinion in the form of a fact ("It is mutilation!") you better be prepared for some back-up to show your "fact" to be false.

In the case of calling it "mutilation," I have demonstrated this.

If you said "I think it is mutilation," then you are using a subjective opinion that cannot be dismissed.

But if you say "It IS mutilation," then you get this as a rebuttle:

mu·ti·late (mytl-t)
tr.v. mu·ti·lat·ed, mu·ti·lat·ing, mu·ti·lates
1. To deprive of a limb or an essential part; cripple.
2. To disfigure by damaging irreparably: mutilate a statue. See Synonyms at batter1.
3. To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.

Definition number three is a very subjective definition, and so when you say "I am of the opinion that it is mutilation," is covered under definition three, and you would be correct.
 

Well, ok then. This is fair. I can retract my statements about "how it must feel." But I don't think it makes a whole lot of difference either way, considering uncircumcised men will never know what it's like to be circumcised, and circumcised men will never know what it's like to have a foreskin.

In either case, it doesn't diminish the function of the penis. And it still feels pretty damned good to ejaculate without the foreskin. lol.
 
Harming them with sharp objects is neighter loving nor healthy. You aren't remotely able to come up with a rational or even religious reason, that's why you avoid my question. All you have to justify this barbaric practise is "tradition". Now, better stop it today than tomorrow. Would that make your religion any less "pure"? No, it wouldn't. You would only be more welcome among civilized society.

It is loving, if it were truly your belief system. I don;t have to come up with any rational reasons why God created the foreskin, because I am rather "neutral" on the whole religious view thing. I am Agnostic. I still believe in God, but am far from being a fanatic. I accept all scientific findings, but refuse to discount God from the equation.

Having said that, you have not addressed my points of protecting religious freedoms and practices in this country. Therefore, your question about why God made the foreskin does not concern me. You should ask someone who is more religious than I.

I aim only to defend the right to practice religion, and to present the views of what those religious people have, and just how strongly(impossible to convey!) they truly believe in God, and the "proper" way in which to raise their children based on this strong belief, and as parents making decisions for the well-being of their child.
 
Last edited:
Logical fallacies galore!!! My gawds, does it NEVER end!? :boggled::rolleyes:

For about the hundredth time, male circumcision does not equate to the following:

1. Female circumcision
2. human sacrifice
3. Slavery
4. Torture
5. Sacrifice of newborns.

Anything else that needs to be added to the list? :eek::rolleyes:

You have no idea what 'logical fallacy' means, do you?
#1 on your list is the only one which has remotely been compared to male circumcision.
Less use of inappropriate emoticons,a nd more reading for comprehension might be a good idea.
 
I don't know of any christians in the Uk that do this as far as I'm aware its a purely Jewish custom other than for medical reasons and is purely cultural in the USA instigated by Kellog to prevent self gratification...it didn't work. As for no loss of sensitivity what do you think the foreskin is there for? could it be to protect the sensitive end of the penis? so removing said protection will have what effect? I'd say logic would dictate that any friction,wear will desensitize the skin in similar fashion to manual work does the hands or going barefoot. Sorry but mutilation is mutilation no matter how you twist it.

I may be wrong about how many Christians in the rest of the world practice circumcision. But it is an important part of many Christian families.

The rest I already addressed.
 
Why does the reason the parent's chose for ear piercing their babe matter? Is it any of our business why they chose to do so?



While I would agree with you on any new proposals of that type, I think it is reasonable to carve out an exception for various long standing cultural traditions that are widely practiced. We don't allow female mutilation in this country because it is NOT a long standing cultural tradition here and we aren't about to such a harmful practice start up in our society. Things like piercings, tattoos and circumcision are all among those things I consider to be "not my business" with regards to how other people raise their children. While I may not agree with their choices, I don't think they should be forbidden from continuing such practices.



I don't agree with the 'Period.' sentiment. I think it is reasonable to carve out an exception for various long standing cultural traditions that are widely practiced in a society.



And this is why I think the ban is a bad idea. This attitude really bothers me. It is an attempt to right a perceived wrong with a far more serious and damaging wrong.



No, it doesn't make it right. But it does it make it reasonable to be legal.



The law in its infinite majesty . . .forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets and to steal bread" - Anatole France.


Likewise, the ban would forbid the gentiles as well as the Jews from circumcising their infant sons.

Huh. Thread in a nutshell. :)

I think this thread has pretty much run it's course. 9 PM already! Been at this for like 4 or 5 hours today! :jaw-dropp
 
People are constantly bringing up "what about slavery? What about this? What about that?" Seems to be very inconsistent with comparing it to male circumcision
You are wrong. Nobody has said anything that could be interpreted as 'what about slavery', or compared it to male circumcision. Again, the point was that tradition is a bad reason for doing something. You need to come up with a better reason for cutting bits off babies.
Really, did nothing change while I was out burning branches?
 
So, that one baby is more important in your fanatical religious persecution crusade than the dozen other babies whom die from smoke-related causes?
....Seems to me, that for those who are so concerned about the welfare of babies, they are wasting their time trying to ban religious practices, rather than going out and banning mothers from being able to smoke altogether.

You have presented a false dichotomy (there's a genuine logical fallacy for you)
One does not have to choose between the evils one opposes.
 
I thought this was part of the original covenant between Israel and their god? Didn't Jesus supposedly do a new deal with Christians? is this mentioned as a condition for worship in the NT?

Interesting question.

See, most Christians believe that if you truly believe in Jesus, then Jesus spoke at length about the OT. And if he spoke at length about the OT and didn't refute anything, but rather confirmed the OT, then the OT must be true. Therefore, Christians believe they are upholding the old Jewish laws and traditions, as symbolized by circumcision.

Obviously, according to the Catholic church, it is not at all a requirement. Indeed, the Catholics used to denounce circumcision on the grounds that it violated the perfect male body, and served no purpose fr uphold OT laws. Christ came to forgive us our sins, and the old OT laws were not meant for us to do such things as animal sacrifice any longer.

And so, with modern-day Christians, they just simply stick with the practice of circumcision, because it holds a lot of symbolism to them. Which is their right.

I hope I summed it up well enough, without being too inaccurate. I was going off of what my wife's family has said on the subject. (They are RELIGIOUS! Lemme tell ya! lol.)
 
You should not state your opinion as fact the way you just did. You can say "I think cutting off bits for superstitious reasons is unreasonable." But you didn't say the words "I think." You said "It is." Which is factually incorrect.

If I go back through all your posts, will I find 'I think' before every statement of fact you have made?
 
.
Many stories say there are few medical provisions available where the ceremony is most common.
And, it is intended to demean the woman.

If done in a clinical, and controlled environment, does it do any extraneaous harm? I am against doing it soley for the purposes of demeaning the woman. unfortunately, that would have to be proven.
.

.
Used to be Catholic.
Uncircumcised.
Don't know any circumcised Catholics.... except for my nephew.
His mother had him cut about a week after his birth.
Why, I don't know.
It is not a normal Catholic procedure.
Most often, the rationalization here is to make retention of STDs less common.
The reason is to add a distinctive mark to the kid.
Something that is not reversible.
It's done for control, as are just about every procedure with religious connotations.
Other than the potential effect on transmission of STDs, there is no reason to cut a kid.

and none of that addressed my quesions about female circumcision. All the rest has been addressed quite exhaustively in this thread.
 
If you're making an argument by analogy - in this case, arguing that male circumcision is okay because some people pierce the ears of their children - then whether or not the situations are actually analogous does matter.

But outside the context of the post, I'd say no - I don't need to know why some parents want to circumcise their children or pierce their ears, as long as they aren't allowed to do it.

And you have no business or right to dictate that. Thankfully.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom