Ban circumcision in San Fran???

So, that one baby is more important in your fanatical religious persecution crusade than the dozen other babies whom die from smoke-related causes?

They're all equally important, which means all forms of abuse are equally worthy of being banned.

I can be anti-smoking while anti-circumcision. It's not even multi-tasking at that point. It's just being against parents doing bad things to their children.
 
Actually I am targetting nobody beacuse I live in NZ.
But it matters not a jot who does it: if it's wrong it's wrong.
Christians don't have any religious commitment to circumcision.

Source? Many Christians do have such a commitment. Catholics, for instance, which is the largest denomination in Christianity, and outnumbers all Muslim denominations combined. Who also happen to be committed to circumcision. Then you have Jews adding to all those other billions who rank as either Christian or Muslim.

Not to mention, the WHO actually promotes circumcision in Africa, because it seems to cut down on transmition of HIV.

And since you live in New Zealand, I dunno how much you can comment on the OP, which is in SF. You are certainly more than welcome to give your opinion, but the OP seems to be a case between the US First Amendment rights, and the bogus banning of a religious practice, which shows no health benefits for, or against circumcision.
 
Cutting bits off kids is barbarism.
Anyone having problems understanding this needs his attitudes examined.
It really is that simple.

This is a very subjective opinion on your own morals. You have no right to impose those morals on people who feel that circumcision is a necessary part of "being one with God."

It is kind of a stretch to say that circumcision is "barbaric." You sound almost like Glenn Beck when you say this. A political/"moral" extremist.
 
Some serious back pedalling there. You claim the 1st amendment, but only sometimes.

If it makes you happy, perhaps we should do away with the First Amendment altogether? That sound good?

The same reasoning can be applied to free speech, the press, and to assemble. It can also be applied to the Second amendment. Case law does this for us. It spells out circumstances when the rights of one person overlaps those of another.

If human sacrifice were real, it would overlap with that person's right to live. If slavery were legal, it overlaps with the slave's right to themselves.
If riding around in tanks were legal, it overlaps the rights of people to "remain safe and secure."
If packing 3,000 people into a small downtown club were legal, it overlaps those peoples' rights to be safe and secure as well.

The government has no right whatsoever to tell parents how to raise their child in a reasonable, healthy manner. And the government has no right to restrict the free exercise of religion under reasonable circumstances.

I cannot believe this must be explained in this forum. :eye-poppi

Actually, banning cutting bits off babies without good medical reason is reasonable.

No. It is not. You can never just add a law on the books that limits the free practice of religion, unless it violates another person's rights.

Cutting bits off for superstitious reasons is the unreasonable thing.

Your opinion which, according to the government and religious people, is factually incorrect.

You should not state your opinion as fact the way you just did. You can say "I think cutting off bits for superstitious reasons is unreasonable." But you didn't say the words "I think." You said "It is." Which is factually incorrect.
 
Keep rolling your eyes. You simply cannot see the point,can you?
The comparison is not between slavery and circumcision. In fact no comparison has been made. The point is that the length of time a custom has continued is irrelevant to whether that custom should continue.

And it is irrelevant for banning the said custom just because other equally as old customs have been banned.

However, a custom that is as harmless as male circumcision, benefits from the longevity of how long it has been around. Banning a long-held custom is not easy. Even one as bad as slavery. A hundred thousand men died in the US, trying to end and preserve something as morally repugnant as slavery.
 
I ignored your religious questions directed to me, because I could care less why God may have created the foreskin. I only care about preserving the First Amendment, and giving parents the freedom to raise their child however they want in a loving and healthy environment, free from prying eyes. No matter if you are Jewish, Muslim, Christian, atheist, agnostic, Buddhist, Taoist, pagan, what have you.


Harming them with sharp objects is neighter loving nor healthy. You aren't remotely able to come up with a rational or even religious reason, that's why you avoid my question. All you have to justify this barbaric practise is "tradition". Now, better stop it today than tomorrow. Would that make your religion any less "pure"? No, it wouldn't. You would only be more welcome among civilized society.
 
Last edited:
Now the penis is not genital. This just gets better and better.
Mutilation is cutting bits off. In Papua New Guinea women cut off a finger when mourning. That's mutilation. If only the first joint is cut off, it is still mutilation. If they get really carried away and chop off the whole hand, that would also be mutilation.
You don't get to redefine words to suit yourself, unless you are Humpty Dumpty

I defined the term "mutilation!!" My gawd.

Read it again:

Mutilation or maiming is an act or physical injury that degrades the appearance or function of any living body, usually without causing death.
Denniston et al. have argued that male circumcision is a form of mutilation;[5] their arguments have been criticised by Benatar and Benatar.

The wiki article even SPECIFICALLY mentions "circumcision."

Now, let us see what the Free Dictionary tells us the term "mutilation" means:

mu·ti·late (mytl-t)
tr.v. mu·ti·lat·ed, mu·ti·lat·ing, mu·ti·lates
1. To deprive of a limb or an essential part; cripple.
2. To disfigure by damaging irreparably: mutilate a statue. See Synonyms at batter1.
3. To make imperfect by excising or altering parts.

1. Circumcision certainly is not depriving of any limbs. It doesn't even cripple it. Mine works perfectly fine, and was able to get my wife pregnant with the very first shot! And it felt pretty damned good at the time as well.

2. It doesn't damage the penis "irreparably" either. It functions just as well and efficiently without the foreskin.

And number 3 is a matter of subjective opinion. You may think a penis is "imperfect" without the foreskin. Others think it is perfect without it.

Adding the word "genital" before the word "mutilation" does not alter the word "mutilation" in any way.
 
I don't know of any christians in the Uk that do this as far as I'm aware its a purely Jewish custom other than for medical reasons and is purely cultural in the USA instigated by Kellog to prevent self gratification...it didn't work. As for no loss of sensitivity what do you think the foreskin is there for? could it be to protect the sensitive end of the penis? so removing said protection will have what effect? I'd say logic would dictate that any friction,wear will desensitize the skin in similar fashion to manual work does the hands or going barefoot. Sorry but mutilation is mutilation no matter how you twist it.
 
Really? You see 8-day old girls with ear piercings, that were given to them because their parent's religion says all girls must have holes in their ears? If so, then yes, I think it should be illegal.

Why does the reason the parent's chose for ear piercing their babe matter? Is it any of our business why they chose to do so?

Yes.

A 10 year old can say "Mommy, can I get an earring?" A 10 day old baby can not. A 10 day old baby also can not say "Mommy, can I have part of my penis cut off?"

Aesthetic surgery with no practical use should not be performed on people too young to question it.

While I would agree with you on any new proposals of that type, I think it is reasonable to carve out an exception for various long standing cultural traditions that are widely practiced. We don't allow female mutilation in this country because it is NOT a long standing cultural tradition here and we aren't about to such a harmful practice start up in our society. Things like piercings, tattoos and circumcision are all among those things I consider to be "not my business" with regards to how other people raise their children. While I may not agree with their choices, I don't think they should be forbidden from continuing such practices.

In my book it's clear cut. *cough* People who do harm to babies private parts with sharp objects are sick in the brain. Period.

I don't agree with the 'Period.' sentiment. I think it is reasonable to carve out an exception for various long standing cultural traditions that are widely practiced in a society.

First off, mutilating a child is barbaric. I don't care if your religion says to do it or you're doing it because you think it looks good, it's barbaric and should be grounds for the child being removed from those parents.

And this is why I think the ban is a bad idea. This attitude really bothers me. It is an attempt to right a perceived wrong with a far more serious and damaging wrong.

Just because people have been doing it for a long time doesn't make it right.

No, it doesn't make it right. But it does it make it reasonable to be legal.

It would make it a crime for anyone to circumcize their 8 day old sons.

The law in its infinite majesty . . .forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets and to steal bread" - Anatole France.


Likewise, the ban would forbid the gentiles as well as the Jews from circumcising their infant sons.
 
.
Vaginal circumcision (clitorodectomy) is common in Islam, and older cultures, frequently seen in African societies.
Its obvious rationalization is to put women in their place.
Pregnant, barefoot and in the kitchen and ready for the male, 24/7.

Ok. But does it do irreparable harm to the woman's health? Is it riskier than a male circumcision?

More importantly, is this an Islamic nation?

Obviously, it would be illegal to do something just for the sake of putting a woman "in her place" in the USA. But if they did it for the same reasons that Jews, Christians, and Muslims themselves circumcise their boys, and it is exactly equivalent to the health "risks" as the males, then there is nothing wrong with it.
 
if that was the case, and no comparison is intended, then why not instead liken it to cooking pumpkin pie on Thanksgiving, or eating a goose for Christmas?

...why not compare it to painting Easter eggs......or dressing up on Halloween?

;)

.....clearly, slavery is brought up in order to liken circumcision of 8-day olds to something totally cruel and barbaric.

Ya see, it's called "framing." When people "frame the question," they are using biased wording, in order to control the thoughts people have on the subject being questioned.

Of course they are going to find the most repugnant examples of cultural mores and values th have been used throughout the centuries, and liken it to circumcision.

That is where this whole terrible logical fallacy falls completely flat on its face.
 
I thought this was part of the original covenant between Israel and their god? Didn't Jesus supposedly do a new deal with Christians? is this mentioned as a condition for worship in the NT?
 
You can play all sorts of games. No I cannot cite sources. Can't be bothered with someone who cannot understand such basic things. Even people getting a tooth filled sometimes die.

In other words, you have no basis of your arguments for banning male circumcision, other than "choice" for the newborn child. And that "choice" is not that big a deal, because no children is ever given any major choices in life for the first 18 - 20 years of their life, if their parents insist on taking proper care of that child.

Your second paragraph reeks of desperation. Surely you can see the difference between subjecting a child to an unecessary medical procedure and normal everyday activities where we do what we can to reduce risk. And we do ban parents from failing to restrain their children in cars.

I used a logical fallacy, yes. But suddenly I am not able to, but you are? Heh. Now I got "hypocrite" on my list of things that you sound like.

(sorry, don;t mean to be so rude, but that is how you are frankly coming off as.)

In any case, circumcising a male child is no more dangerous than allowing him to play in sports later on. It is many times less dangerous than riding in cars. Eating broccoli. (Choking hazards. I should know!! :blush:) Washing dishes....even sitting in your living room, watching TV.

We just simply cannot go around banning all decisions, because they "might" carry "some" risk. And we certainly cannot just do away with our cherished Amendments for the same reasons.
 
I have heard of men actually reversing their circumcision, by stretching the remaining skin at the base over the tip.

You have GOT to be kidding. The very fact that there are people putting themselves through something like that has to tell you something.
 
Or we could target multiple evils simultaneously.

And who are you to say that smoking is worse than mutilating babies?

HAH! Excuse me!?

I never said mutilating babies is ok, so I have no idea where you even got this to begin with.

But I am not stupid, and I know you are referring to "circumcision." Which, once again, according to the definitions of "mutilation," circumcision is not "mutilation."

So, you seriously trying to ask a rhetorical question, by saying that "smoking is not worse than circumcision?" Are you really saying this? Seriously?
Because I really want to know, so that I can laugh about this, then show this statement to some professionals that I know in the health field, one of whom happens to be my wife, and we can have a bit of a laugh about it.

In any case, smoking is clearly far worse than circumcision.
 
They're all equally important, which means all forms of abuse are equally worthy of being banned.

I can be anti-smoking while anti-circumcision. It's not even multi-tasking at that point. It's just being against parents doing bad things to their children.

And I am against people butting in parents' decisions they make for their children, as long as the children are safe, happy, secure, and healthy. None of those things violates a clinical circumcision.
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed previously moderated content in quote


Look folks, I consider male circumcision to be relatively benign. I have never met a man who was unhappy about his penis, because of it. I have never met a girl who was unhappy about circumcised penises.

From what I understand, male cirumcision and female genital mutilation simply do not compare in any way, as far as pain, side effects, danger, and future sexual activity is concerned.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ok. But does it do irreparable harm to the woman's health? Is it riskier than a male circumcision?
.
Many stories say there are few medical provisions available where the ceremony is most common.
And, it is intended to demean the woman.
.
More importantly, is this an Islamic nation?

Obviously, it would be illegal to do something just for the sake of putting a woman "in her place" in the USA. But if they did it for the same reasons that Jews, Christians, and Muslims themselves circumcise their boys, and it is exactly equivalent to the health "risks" as the males, then there is nothing wrong with it.
.
Used to be Catholic.
Uncircumcised.
Don't know any circumcised Catholics.... except for my nephew.
His mother had him cut about a week after his birth.
Why, I don't know.
It is not a normal Catholic procedure.
Most often, the rationalization here is to make retention of STDs less common.
The reason is to add a distinctive mark to the kid.
Something that is not reversible.
It's done for control, as are just about every procedure with religious connotations.
Other than the potential effect on transmission of STDs, there is no reason to cut a kid.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom