Ban circumcision in San Fran???

please don't insult my intelligence.

its indeed an analogy. a ridiculously poor one, motivated by anti-Semitism.

:jaw-dropp I can't believe you just did it again!!! You not only insulted a Mod, but now your flinging more of your unsupported accusations of Anti-Semitism. And you wonder why so many people are afraid to speak out against injustice.

GB
 
You like "parental rights", I do not.

The 'right' of parents to disfigure and mutilate their children with impunity is apparently so important that if the child grows up disliking, hating even, the fact that his parents decided to circumcise him we're supposed to think this is acceptable since the wellbeing and wants of the child is, as we can clearly see, strictly an afterthought compare to the need to appease religious delusions and conform to cultural norms.

Strangely i disagree.
 
It's good to know that there are Jewish people who are not wedded to cruel bronze-age superstitions. Which of course I knew already, as I have many Jewish colleagues who are prepared to speak out against barbaric slaughter methods.

This is what really makes the difference of course. The victim mentality is so strong in some people even today that they cry oppression even when what is actually happening is that their own high-handed and oppressive behaviour is being challenged. When others who could be in the same position raise their voices on the side of mercy and kindness, things begin to change.

Rolfe.

Yes it's a crying shame. Fundy Christians play the victim/martyr card all the time too...Oh no...Its' a war against Christmas.

This seems to be a serious problem with Religious Zealots all the time now.

GB
 
Last edited:
now, does anyone have anything.....from a renowned medical institution or agency in the West, that says that circumcision causes more bad than good..and should be discouraged if not made illegal?


Yes, the Royal Dutch Medical Association:
http://knmg.artsennet.nl/Diensten/k...rapeutic-circumcision-of-male-minors-2010.htm

The official viewpoint of KNMG and other related medical/scientific organisations is that non-therapeutic circumcision of male minors is a violation of children’s rights to autonomy and physical integrity. Contrary to popular belief, circumcision can cause complications – bleeding, infection, urethral stricture and panic attacks are particularly common. KNMG is therefore urging a strong policy of deterrence. KNMG is calling upon doctors to actively and insistently inform parents who are considering the procedure of the absence of medical benefits and the danger of complications.

There are good reasons for a legal prohibition of non-therapeutic circumcision of male minors, as exists for female genital mutilation.

Since the Dutch have no history of circumcision, unlike Americans or even the British, they are more likely to examine the issue objectively.
 
Whilst I am in the corner, I will toss this out there. Many on the pro-circumcision side will refer to phimosis as a legitimate medical reason for the procedure. Not only does the "remove something at birth in anticipation of future injury" line of though not comply with our treatment of the gall-bladder, appendix, or tonsils, but when approached from another angle it also comes up short. When looked at from the point of view of comparative solutions to the specific problem, this is the result:

Since 1991, boys needing surgery for tight nonretractile foreskin have been offered a choice of preputial plasty or circumcision, providing that there is no clinical evidence of preputial scarring. We compared two similar groups of 50 boys that underwent each procedure, through our routine audit and questionnaires sent to their parents. Of the boys with circumcisions, 20% required an overnight stay after the operation; 14% had anesthetic complications, and 6% required reoperation because of bleeding. Only 8% of patients with preputial plasty had an overnight stay, and no bleeding was observed. Parental assessment of both operations showed that morbidity was significantly less and of shorter duration for the preputial plasty group. Two patients in the preputial plasty group (4%) had recurrent narrowing of the foreskin caused by scarring and contraction of the incision. Parents were pleased with the long-term results of both procedures. This simple alternative to circumcision is easy to perform and allows full mobilization of the foreskin, preserving its function and providing an excellent cosmetic result. (J Pediatr Surg 1994 Apr;29(4):561-3)

Linky.

Indeed, this frame of reference issue can be applied to other problems to which circumcision is a proposed solution. If one was worried about STDs, would you want circumcision, which in some studies in some regions show some reduced likelihood, or wear a condom, which I think we are all familiar with. The condom is not only a non-invasive alternative, it trumps it is effectiveness and number of things it protects, including child support payments :p .

These doctors summarize the issue most efficiently:

Routine neonatal circumcision: a controversy

Neonatal circumcision, widely practiced in the USA, has been advocated to reduce the incidence of penile and uterine cervical carcinoma and sexually transmitted diseases including HIV, but the evidence is equivocal and does not support mass involuntary circumcision. On the other hand, urinary tract infections though rare in male infants are more common in the uncircumcised boy. But about 100 neonates would need to be circumcised to reduce the risk of urinary tract infection in one boy. We do not therefore advocate neonatal circumcision. If it is carried out it is contraindicated in the premature, those who are ill or who have bleeding disorders or in the presence of congenital anomalies especially hypospadias.

Linky.

Halt... I feel as if millions of posts suddenly cried out in terror and were suddenly silenced. Now I will never be able to ask him about his anti-Western bias :( .
 
when did I call you an anti-Semite?

post the link.

and if I did, how was it hypocritical of me? are you calling me an anti-Semite?


now, as a Jew, are you offended by Rolfe's clearly anti-Semitic comments?

How about HERE:
cirumcision is an important part of our faith & culture.

why do you hate Jews & Judaism?

I'm Jewish, why do you hate me for insisting that non-consenting person's have the right to not have bits of their anatomy chopped off.

GB

You are one of the most dishonest debaters I've ever had the displeasure of arguing with.

Hey everyone, look at what Thunder did:


That's right! he edited out his hate filled venom and put in a smiley face after the fact.



circumcision is an important part of Judaism. why do you hate Judaism?

I don't! That's a remarkable accusation to sling at someone who is Jewish.

GB

And by the way, I think Rolfe is awesome! Why do you keep falsely accusing everyone you hate of Anti-Semitism?

GB
 
Here's a film that, IMHO, helps to shed more light (of understanding) vs. heat (of flame wars) on the subject.

NOT SAFE FOR WORK:
http://www.cutthefilm.com/Cut_Website/The_Film.html

Covered additional points -- worth watching if you have time.

I second this, this movie is worth watching. And for those in the US and parts of Canada, I'll tell you that the director is doing a US tour and screening the movie in about 20 US and Canadian cities this fall. I believe you can find the link to the tour dates on the film website, if not I'll post a link for it. The film will be screened and than a Q&A will follow it should be really interesting.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, when did you announce to JREF that you were a Jew? Are we supposed to read your mind?

and when, did I call you an anti-Semite? what was the context of the accusation?

post the link.

I bet you thought you could get away with dishonestly editing out your first post in which you falsely accused me of being an anti-Semite, and to which I responded that I was Jewish.

GB
 
Thank you, you explained my position better than I did. It's religious woo, and not harmless either.

It's uncannily similar to the medical committees who give homoeopathy a free pass because they feel it's not PC to be seen to oppose "integrative medicine".

Rolfe.

Yes! Thank You. :)

GB
 
Interestingly, the BMA is much less mealy mouthed about circumcision for medical purposes:


http://www.bma.org.uk/ethics/consen...cision2006.jsp#Circumcisionformedicalpurposes

So circumcision should only be used for medical purposes as a very last resort and is very rarely indicated. But if the parents just want it done for no medical reason.... well that's just fine.

:rolleyes:

It's a statement which really demonstrates cognitive dissonance but they all do that, most can be broken down to say, there is really no medical reason to perform in most cases but do it anyway if you want. It's shocking really, if there no medical reason (which they all say) that should be the end of it.
 
How, pray tell, other than tribal traditions and religious dogma, is having your foreskin cut off benign or beneficial?

An "Anti-Semite", in many cases, is any person disagreeing with a given policy or tradition by Jews or Israel.

Thunder: I'll have a Coke, please.
Waitress: We only have Pepsi!
Thunder: Anti-Semite!

Exactly! I guess I'm the only one allowed to call out Israelis on their oppression of the Palestinians...No...wait....I know what's coming next.

I'm obviously a Self-Hating Jew. :rolleyes: Come on Thunder! When are going to launch another baseless attack on my character? :p

GB
 
Last edited:
are you, or are you not...going to provide a link to where I supposedly called you an anti-Semite?


or is this just a dishonest claim. I wonder.

You really aren't keeping up with the pace of this thread are you! Oh wait, you did, you went back and dishonestly edited out your attack after the fact.


GB
 
Thunder, do you believe that it is immoral for an adult to be deprived of his foreskin without medical necessity and without his consent? Should adults have the right to deprive other adults of their foreskin without medical necessity and without their consent?
You said you would answer this, I'm trying to help you not lie.

edit- whoops lol good riddance.
 
Last edited:
and your dishonesty is noted, as you simply disregard ANY and ALL evidence and professional opinions/views...from HIGHLY respected and regarded Western medical agencies and organizations, simply because they disagree with you...

My goodness, Thunder is still accusing people of being dishonest...
What a hypocritical person he is
 
Thunder, do you believe that it is immoral for an adult to be deprived of his foreskin without medical necessity and without his consent? Should adults have the right to deprive other adults of their foreskin without medical necessity and without their consent?
You said you would answer this, I'm trying to help you not lie.

*Cough*.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom