Ban circumcision in San Fran???

you are more than welcome to report anyone who fails to fully comply with the laws of Shechita, which includes a quick and pain-free death.


It is impossible to deliver a quick or pain-free death by that barbarous method. Anyone who thinks so is deluded.

All you have to do, Thunder, to make the procedure entirely acceptable, is to use a captive bolt pistol on the animal immediately before starting. That's all.

You will eat meat from cattle with ear tags in. You will eat meat from cattle which are castrated. You don't consider the cut of the slaughter procedure itself to be a "blemish". But you will deny the animal the oblivion of the captive bolt because that, unlike ear piercings or castration, is a "blemish".

So don't come to me and talk about your hypocritical "laws" that pretend something is quick and pain-free when it isn't. Go and watch some slaughtering. Go and watch some infants being circumcised, if you haven't already.

Rolfe.
 
And you will note that I didn't criticize you for any of that. You know why? Because that was legitimate argument.



Evidently you DO care about who does it, or you wouldn't have even mentioned the prevalence of Jewish doctors. If this claim of yours is to be believed, then the fact that their Jewish doesn't make it any different than if they had been athiest, or druid, or whatever.

And the obvious fact is I'm NOT calling your posts antisemitic because you attacked circumcision. I called your posts antisemitic because you DID, in fact, try to single out people for criticism because they're Jewish. So I frankly DON'T believe this claim of yours that you don't care who does it, because you're acting like you care a lot.

No she didn't!

She called out the doctors who are afraid of being called Anti-Semitic by people like you if they stop allowing Religious Woo to influence their policies and violate their Hippocratic Oaths.

GB
 
No, Rolfe. You don't get to post antisemitic posts and get a free pass. This isn't about you objecting to circumcision. NONE of my criticism of you is about your opposition to circumcision. The fact that you're portraying my criticism as being about circumcision allows you to pretend to be the victim, but that's a lie. I didn't call your posts antisemitic until, well, they started to actually be antisemitic.

But it's obviously Okay for Thunder to accuse ME, A Jew, of being Anti-Semitic.

GB
 
No she didn't!

She called out the doctors who are afraid of being called Anti-Semitic by people like you if they stop allowing Religious Woo to influence their policies and violate their Hippocratic Oaths.

GB


Thank you, you explained my position better than I did. It's religious woo, and not harmless either.

It's uncannily similar to the medical committees who give homoeopathy a free pass because they feel it's not PC to be seen to oppose "integrative medicine".

Rolfe.
 
prove it.



prove it.



prove it.



wow, you seem to be suggesting that the only reason a Gentile doctor would declare male-baby circumcision benign or beneficial, is due to fear of being called an anti-Semite. yikes.

You called me Anti-Semitic. Prove it!

GB
 

#1. The letter discusses none of the possible advantages of circumcision. This puts their impartiality & objectivity into question.

#2. The letter incorrectly states that Jews circumcise their sons "by the 7th day of life". This is incorrect.

#3. The letter supposedly quotes the Talmud, without any reference as to the book, chapter, or verse. Nevermind the highly unusual nature of a medical organization taking religious dogma into account. It should be utterly irrelevent to their findings and views.

#4. The letter was written almost 20 years ago. Got anything a little more recent, say..from during the Bush Administration??

#5. The letters quotes documents from 1960 and 1989. This is 2011.
 
Last edited:
who's...playing the victim??

you've already stated several times that you are being falsely accused of anti-Semitism, that I have ignored all of your posts..etc etc.


Why shouldn't she? You falsely accused me, a JEW, of being Anti-Semitic.

GB
 
You called me Anti-Semitic. Prove it!

lol.

do you have a link to this post? are you just gonna keep yelling this as a baseless claim.

:D






.....btw, as a Jew, are you not offended by Rolfe's clearly anti-Semitic comments about Jewish doctors?
 
Last edited:
wow, you seem to be suggesting that the only reason a Gentile doctor would declare male-baby circumcision benign or beneficial, is due to fear of being called an anti-Semite.
How, pray tell, other than tribal traditions and religious dogma, is having your foreskin cut off benign or beneficial?

But it's obviously Okay for Thunder to accuse ME, A Jew, of being Anti-Semitic.
An "Anti-Semite", in many cases, is any person disagreeing with a given policy or tradition by Jews or Israel.

Thunder: I'll have a Coke, please.
Waitress: We only have Pepsi!
Thunder: Anti-Semite!
 
Last edited:
You've been playing the victim card this whole thread, when the only victims are the non-consenting persons' who are getting bits chopped off of their anatomies.

are you, or are you not...going to provide a link to where I supposedly called you an anti-Semite?


or is this just a dishonest claim. I wonder.
 
#1. The letter discusses none of the possible advantages of circumcision. This puts their impartiality & objectivity into question.

#2. The letter incorrectly states that Jews circumcise their sons "by the 7th day of life". This is incorrect.

#3. The letter supposedly quotes the Talmud, without any reference as to the book, chapter, or verse. Nevermind the highly unusual nature of a medical organization taking religious dogma into account. It should be utterly irrelevent to their findings and views.

#4. The letter was written almost 20 years ago. Got anything a little more recent, say..from during the Bush Administration??

#5. The letters quotes documents from 1960 and 1989. This is 2011.

Translation: I will ignore this because it contradicts my certainty
 
and your dishonesty is noted, as you simply disregard ANY and ALL evidence and professional opinions/views...from HIGHLY respected and regarded Western medical agencies and organizations, simply because they disagree with you...


..and because they surely are dominated by Jews or have a minority of intimidating, threatening Jews.

these tactics are 100% analogous to the crap we get in the 9-11 CT section, by Truthers.

Or they're 100% analogous to you falsely accusing people of Anti-Semitism.

GB
 
I never thought I'd be accusing a Mod of a strawman, but I am right now.

Strawman.


this, is what the MBA really says:

The Association has no policy on these issues. Indeed, it would be difficult to formulate a policy in the absence of unambiguously clear and consistent medical data on the implications of the intervention. As a general rule, however, the BMA believes that parents should be entitled to make choices about how best to promote their children’s interests



the MBA, 100% believes that the decision of whether or not to perform a baby-male circumcision, should be left to the PARENTS.

Did you just insult a Mod? :eye-poppi

GB
 
How do you know that Rolfe isn't Jewish like me, and thus feels free to level this charge?

You accused ME, a JEW, of being Anti-Semitic, without any evidence to support your insults! :mad:

Where was your evidence when you hypocritically called me Anti-Semitic? :mad::mad:

Why am I not surprised to find you supporting someone who hurls unfounded accusations, like accusing ME, a JEW, Anti-Semitic..

But it's obviously Okay for Thunder to accuse ME, A Jew, of being Anti-Semitic...

You called me Anti-Semitic. Prove it!

Why shouldn't she? You falsely accused me, a JEW, of being Anti-Semitic.

Or they're 100% analogous to you falsely accusing people of Anti-Semitism.

kindly provide evidence of me calling you an anti-Semite.
 
we are talking about removing a baby's foreskin, not slaughtering a cow.

do you understand the difference?

And, as I already stated, the BMA, AAP, and NIH would be violating their Hyppocratic oath, by suggesting that circumcision should be left to the parents to decide, if they had any thought that the procedure might cause more harm than good.

are you suggesting these organizations violate their oath willy nilly?

I am!!!

GB
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom