Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Yes! It's Shocking! :eye-poppi

I can't believe that such a highly respected and an otherwise august Publication would support chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.


I can. I have a highly respected and otherwise august professional body that supports (or at least prints weasel words which mean it dos not oppose) animals having their throats cut and left to bleed to death over minutes while fully conscious.

I know the drill.

Rolfe.
 
I have a highly respected and otherwise august professional body that supports (or at least prints weasel words which mean it dos not oppose) animals having their throats cut and left to bleed to death over minutes while fully conscious.

we are talking about removing a baby's foreskin, not slaughtering a cow.

do you understand the difference?

And, as I already stated, the BMA, AAP, and NIH would be violating their Hyppocratic oath, by suggesting that circumcision should be left to the parents to decide, if they had any thought that the procedure might cause more harm than good.

are you suggesting these organizations violate their oath willy nilly?
 
Last edited:
Yes. I think cutting a baby's prepuce off just because you want to impose your "parental rights" is worse than cutting the throat of an animal and leaving it to bleed to death, kicking and struggling and conscious.

Rolfe.
 
I never thought I'd be accusing a Mod of a strawman, but I am right now.

Strawman.


this, is what the MBA really says:

The Association has no policy on these issues. Indeed, it would be difficult to formulate a policy in the absence of unambiguously clear and consistent medical data on the implications of the intervention. As a general rule, however, the BMA believes that parents should be entitled to make choices about how best to promote their children’s interests


the MBA, 100% believes that the decision of whether or not to perform a baby-male circumcision, should be left to the PARENTS.


Do you even read what people post? Professor Yaffle posted about how circumcisions were not justified for medical reasons. This post of yours verifies that. Where's the strawman?
 
I knew this was coming. I didn't know when, or by who. But I knew this would eventually rear its ugly head.



yep, here we go. now its all just a Jewish-doctor conspiracy. in both the USA and Britain.

whether its kosher slaughter regulations, or circumcision, these Jewish folks just keep imposing their way of life upon the apologetic Gentiles.

;)

Yes! It's Horrific that so many of my own people still support Barbaric Bronze Age practices! :mad:

My mother would never do that today. She actually apologized to me when she signed the petition.

GB
 
It's good to know that there are Jewish people who are not wedded to cruel bronze-age superstitions. Which of course I knew already, as I have many Jewish colleagues who are prepared to speak out against barbaric slaughter methods.

This is what really makes the difference of course. The victim mentality is so strong in some people even today that they cry oppression even when what is actually happening is that their own high-handed and oppressive behaviour is being challenged. When others who could be in the same position raise their voices on the side of mercy and kindness, things begin to change.

Rolfe.
 
are you seriously suggesting I should not follow the VERY experienced and VERY professional advise & opinions, of the NIH, BMA, AAP, and the New England Journal of Medicine? who should I follow instead?

JREF novices?

sorry, but here at JREF...we stick with the professionals.

we....at least some of do.

Yes! And it's horrifying that every-bloody-one of us on this thread (except you), who would normally stick with the professionals, have been forced to conclude that Medical Organizations are allowing Religious Woo to influence their policies and to violate their Hippocratic Oathes.

GB
 
Thunder, if you justify your intention to mutilate your new-born son by saying you do it because you are a Jew, then any opposition to your stance is by definition going to be a criticism of Jewish culture.

Get over it.

Rolfe.
 
Yes. I think cutting a baby's prepuce off just because you want to impose your "parental rights" is worse than cutting the throat of an animal and leaving it to bleed to death, kicking and struggling and conscious.

you are more than welcome to report anyone who fails to fully comply with the laws of Shechita, which includes a quick and pain-free death.
 
Thunder, if you justify your intention to mutilate your new-born son by saying you do it because you are a Jew, then any opposition to your stance is by definition going to be a criticism of Jewish culture.

no, but if someone argues that EVERY Western institution or agency that comes in favor of or ambivilent on ...male-baby circumcision, does so because they suffer from Jew-dominance or Jew-pressure, I WILL label that as anti-Semitism.

now, do you have ANY report or study from a well-respestected medical organization or agency, that feels that circumcision does more harm than good and should be discouraged or even banned?
 
Last edited:
This post stinks of antisemitism not because you're criticizing circumcision or shechita, but because you're stereotyping a whole class of people in a negative manner, solely on the basis of their religion. Hell, you even try to justify it on the basis of a stereotype that you state is a stereotype. Go figure that that would raise some hackles.

Plus, of course, this criticism is entirely content-free. Nothing in this post actually addresses the merit or demerits of circumcision. Your post is really just about Jews, and how they're spreading their awful influence surreptitiously. Those doctors can't be trusted because they're Jewish. Or more precisely, because they might be Jewish, since you don't even know. Again, go figure that that might rub people the wrong way.

You opened yourself up for accusations of antisemitism. Your preemptory defense doesn't get you off the hook on this one.


How do you know that Rolfe isn't Jewish like me, and thus feels free to level this charge?

GB
 
Originally Posted by Rolfe
My entire point is that (some, one or two) Jewish doctors on these committees tend to approach the issue from the same viewpoint we have become all too familiar with from Thunder's posts, and that they don't get the vigorous opposition they should get, because they're afraid of being branded anti-Semitic.


prove it.


Originally Posted by Rolfe
I pointed out that when people with Thunder's outlook get into a position of authority in the medical profession (and in politics), they tend to promote these views. And that such is the fear of being attacked as anti-Semitic, they often don't get the vigorous opposition they should experience.


prove it.


Originally Posted by Rolfe
You think you get a free pass to do what you like, because anyone who points out the evil in what you are doing can be vilified as anti-Semitic.


prove it.
 
you accused there four VERY esteemed and VERY professional organizations, of having the views they do simply because they are probably filled with Jews. and if they are not filled with Jews, then the Jews that are there have threatened to label anyone who questions them on these issues, an anti-Semite.

you argue this, with no evidence. just mere speculation. and then you add in this BS about kosher-slaughter rituals, as if that has ANYTHING to do with the thread.

don't act all shocked if someone accuses you of anti-Semitism, when you CHOOSE to express anti-Semitism.

You accused ME, a JEW, of being Anti-Semitic, without any evidence to support your insults! :mad:

Don't throw stones in Glass Houses!

GB
 
what evidence do you have that these four organizations have the view that they do on circumcision, do to dominance by Jews, or threats of accusations of anti-Semitism, from a minority of Jewish doctors?

where is your evidence?

Where was your evidence when you hypocritically called me Anti-Semitic? :mad::mad:

GB
 
Where was your evidence when you hypocritically called me Anti-Semitic?

when did I call you an anti-Semite?

post the link.

and if I did, how was it hypocritical of me? are you calling me an anti-Semite?


now, as a Jew, are you offended by Rolfe's clearly anti-Semitic comments?
 
Last edited:
Why am I not surprised to find you supporting someone who hurls unfounded accusations, like accusing ME, a JEW, Anti-Semitic, and then cries like a baby when he gets his feelings hurt?

I'm sorry, when did you announce to JREF that you were a Jew? Are we supposed to read your mind?

and when, did I call you an anti-Semite? what was the context of the accusation?

post the link.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom