Ban circumcision in San Fran???

how about blowing up people with bombs? should we keep doing that too?

Okay, I give up.
I cannot explain it any more. I'm going out to burn the fallen branches : it's customary here, and I continue the custom not because it has been done for a long time(it has) , but because there are good reasons to do it. (there are)
 
Okay, what if female "circumcision" takes place in the US? You must support this if you are consistent.

ETA I've read that there are 10,000 girls in the US at risk of Female Genital Cutting.

If you are consistent, you wouldn't make the comparison to begin with. Far as I know, circumcising a female vagina is quite dangerous to the girl's health and well-being, and could affect the performance of having sex, and delivering a child.

Basically, my point still stands. You cannot compare circumcision to vaginal circumcision, slavery, torture, or anything that is way out in the extraordinary. REasining in here is less than stellar, and make svery little sense. These are the worst kinds of logical fallacies I have ever had the misfortune of reading. :(
 
I need some evidence for this claim. There are plenty of xtians that don't go for circumcision.

But there are plenty of Christians, Jews, and Muslims who do. And there seems to be a lack of atheists and agnostics who GO for circumcision. Therefore, you are targeting the religious. Make it illegal, throwing them in jail for practicing said religion, is called "persecution."
 
If you are consistent, you wouldn't make the comparison to begin with. Far as I know, circumcising a female vagina is quite dangerous to the girl's health and well-being, and could affect the performance of having sex, and delivering a child.

Basically, my point still stands. You cannot compare circumcision to vaginal circumcision, slavery, torture, or anything that is way out in the extraordinary. REasining in here is less than stellar, and make svery little sense. These are the worst kinds of logical fallacies I have ever had the misfortune of reading. :(

On a related note, if you stick around the forums for a while, you might learn to understand logical fallacies a lot better. But then again, Thunder does have over thirty thousand posts, so clearly it isn't foolproof.
 
They are not illegal for the same reason circumcision isn't - because a large number of people believe their personal freedoms matter more than the harm they cause to others. It's a horrible thing, and I, for one, certainly hope that in the future, we'll be able to stop parents from harming their babies, whether it be by cigarette or plastibell.

Once step at a time, my friend. One step at a time. Maybe you should target the worst of the offenders first, before you go off on your religious persecution crusade. ;)
 
Can you think of any religious practices which would not be protected by the 1st amendment? If my religion says that I need to sacrifice the first born of every family, would that practice be protected?
if not, why not?

Logical fallacies galore!!! My gawds, does it NEVER end!? :boggled::rolleyes:

For about the hundredth time, male circumcision does not equate to the following:

1. Female circumcision
2. human sacrifice
3. Slavery
4. Torture
5. Sacrifice of newborns.

Anything else that needs to be added to the list? :eek::rolleyes:
 
Once step at a time, my friend. One step at a time. Maybe you should target the worst of the offenders first, before you go off on your religious persecution crusade. ;)

Or we could target multiple evils simultaneously.

And who are you to say that smoking is worse than mutilating babies?
 
Once step at a time, my friend. One step at a time. Maybe you should target the worst of the offenders first, before you go off on your religious persecution crusade. ;)

Religious persecution???

You are just trolling now. Keep your fingers in your ears.
 
Unnecessary refers to medical need, not superstitious practice. Ditto aesthetic.

Wrong.

The government cannot dictate what people believe. Therefore, it falls under being necessary.

Just because you are an atheist and do not believe in something, doesn't make someone's else's belief any less real to them, than your non-belief.
 
Religious persecution???

You are just trolling now. Keep your fingers in your ears.

I would not be surprised at all, that if you speak to the promoters of this legislation in SF, you will find that they are very commited Atheists who see this as a sort of crusade against sky-worshippers.
 
Wrong.

The government cannot dictate what people believe. Therefore, it falls under being necessary.

Just because you are an atheist and do not believe in something, doesn't make someone's else's belief any less real to them, than your non-belief.

A belief that something is necessary does not make it necessary.

Medical necessity would refer to a procedure that you need to continue living normally. Religious necessity might refer to a practice that you "need" to go to heaven when you die.

They aren't even remotely comparable.
 
I would not be surprised at all, that if you speak to the promoters of this legislation in SF, you will find that they are very commited Atheists who see this as a sort of crusade against sky-worshippers.

So who on this thread is practicing religious persecution?
 
Spectacularly missing the point again.
The point is the reason given for continuing a practice. it was claimed the practice should continue because it has been done for a really really long time. (I think my paraphrase is correct)
If the fact that something has been done for a really really long time is good reason to continue said practice, slavery should never have been abolished, because it had continued for a really really long time.

This reasoning is a two-way street, so be careful.

Just because Practice Z was practiced for a very very long time and was banned, doesn't mean that Practice A, which was also practiced for a very very long time, should also be banned.

This is a weak argument to make, and sounds awfully close to a slippery slope. Each practice should be taken into consideration under its own merits. And a practice as old as male circumcision is well-established (like slavery was yes,) but when done in a clinically controlled environment, such as the USA, and is used as a religious practice, gives that practice quite a bit of merit.

That does not say that slavery is Ok, even if used as a religious excuse! Male circumcision is not at all comparable to slavery. And just because slavery (an old practice) was banned, doesn't give society the right to ban circumcision (another old practice.) They just are not at all parallel.
 
Once step at a time, my friend. One step at a time. Maybe you should target the worst of the offenders first, before you go off on your religious persecution crusade. ;)

For someone who gets so riled up with (what you mistakenly thought to be) a comparison of slavery and circumcision, you're pretty quick to equivocate voicing an opinion that it's wrong to cut pieces off babies to a century-long war effort costing countless lives, motivated by religious reasons.

Do you honestly believe people shouldn't be allowed to criticize religious practices if there are still larger problems around? That we aren't allowed to call for outlawing of a form of child abuse as long as worse forms exist?

In case you weren't aware of it, that is an actual logical fallacy.

I have no trouble speaking up against more than one bad thing at once. I'm certainly not going to accept a mild form of mutilation just because there are worse things happening.
 
Yup, inconsistency noted.

Could you please quote the part of the First Amendment which says that rights must be "within reason"?

uuummm...what? Did you even read what I posted? Here, I'll help us out on this one:

myself said:
That's no different than asking if I think "it would be Ok, if Aztecs were alive today, to do ritualized sacrifice of human beings."

You yourself used the argument that the First Amendment does not give religious the right to do whatever they wanted, and I agree. But male circumcision is not one and the same as human sacrifice. Far from it!

Of course the First Amendment doesn't give religions the right to do whatever it is they please all of the time. But such restrictions must be within reason. And banning male circumcision is not a reasonable thing to ban.

It doesn't say that anywhere in the Constitution. There is case-law which prohibits such practices as human sacrifice. And there is the whole morality issue as well. But those are "reasonable" restrictions to have in place. You just cannot go around sacrificing humans in a civilized society, such as ours.

If it matters any, I don't know much about female circumcision, and any adverse affects it may have. So I will not comment on this comparison, except to say if there are no adverse affects whatsoever if done in a controlled, clinical environment, and does not affect the female in having a child, giving birth, and feeling pleasure....in other words, if it is PERFECTLY comparable to male circumcision....then no, I have no problems with it.

And as noted above, I am TRYING to keep it consistent. People are constantly bringing up "what about slavery? What about this? What about that?" Seems to be very inconsistent with comparing it to male circumcision. :rolleyes:
 
The hay in my front paddock is about due for baling...

If one baby dies because of an unnecessary surgical procedure, that is one baby too many.

So, that one baby is more important in your fanatical religious persecution crusade than the dozen other babies whom die from smoke-related causes?

(Rhetorical question. I honestly don't believe you are a "fanatical religious persecutor." Just making a point that, while you are spending an awful amount of time on an internet forum posting about the merits of banning circumcision, because one or two babies out of 600,000,000 MIGHT die from some related cause to said circumcision; there are at least 12 other babies that are definitely dying from smoke-related causes.)

Seems to me, that for those who are so concerned about the welfare of babies, they are wasting their time trying to ban religious practices, rather than going out and banning mothers from being able to smoke altogether.
 
Nihilianth, no explanation from you why God created foreskins in the first place. Where can i read up on the rationalization for this practise? GlennB came up with one which was at least as valid as all others i've read, but he decided to drop it and agree with me, which wasn't an easy thing to do for him.

I ignored your religious questions directed to me, because I could care less why God may have created the foreskin. I only care about preserving the First Amendment, and giving parents the freedom to raise their child however they want in a loving and healthy environment, free from prying eyes. No matter if you are Jewish, Muslim, Christian, atheist, agnostic, Buddhist, Taoist, pagan, what have you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom