Ban circumcision in San Fran???

But what if there's a religious reason for cutting into a vagina? Be consistent here.

What if there was a religious reason for sacrificing someone?

I am being consistent. Perhaps being more consistent than you. Because I don;t know much about vaginal circumcision, I assume it is far more risky, and has far worse adverse affects on the life of a female, than a penal circumcision would.

So, here's my consistency for you:

If vaginal circumcision was exactly the same as penal circumcision, and IF there were a religion that practices it, then obviously it would be fine.

But considering neither of those qualifiers appears to hold true, you cannot compare the two, and they are not equal. Therefore, it is perfectly reasonable to say "vaginal circumcision is not ok, but penal circumcision is."
 
That's no different than asking if I think "it would be Ok, if Aztecs were alive today, to do ritualized sacrifice of human beings."

Of course the First Amendment doesn't give religions the right to do whatever it is they please all of the time. But such restrictions must be within reason. And banning male circumcision is not a reasonable thing to ban.

Some serious back pedalling there. You claim the 1st amendment, but only sometimes.
Actually, banning cutting bits off babies without good medical reason is reasonable.
Cutting bits off for superstitious reasons is the unreasonable thing.
 
It makes the penis less sensitive. Whether that loss in sensitivity diminishes pleasure is hard to address directly...but here's an idea: numb your penis and tell me if sex is less pleasurable.

um.....I am circumcised and it is far from feeling "numb".

strawman? looks like it.
 
You contradict yourself. I have a hunch I'm not the first to point this out.

I see no contradiction. Not my fault you are being ambiguous with your term "genital mutilation."

Even if you did include circumcision in your definition of "genital mutilation," you would be quite wrong. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutilation

Mutilation or maiming is an act or physical injury that degrades the appearance or function of any living body, usually without causing death.

Denniston et al. have argued that male circumcision is a form of mutilation;[5] their arguments have been criticised by Benatar and Benatar.[6]
 
Come on. This is the same dumb reasoning someone else used earlier. How can you possibly compare slavery to circumcision? That just plain sounds like you are grasping for anything in a desperate manner. Jeez. lol. :rolleyes:

Keep rolling your eyes. You simply cannot see the point,can you?
The comparison is not between slavery and circumcision. In fact no comparison has been made. The point is that the length of time a custom has continued is irrelevant to whether that custom should continue.
 
yeah? how many babies die due to circumcision every year in the USA?


and yet, its NOT illegal for a pregnant mother to drink or smoke. nor is it illegal for parents to smoke around their newborn baby. how about that.

Wow! Nice one Thunder. This one just won the thread, I think.

Instead of concentrating on banning circumcising boys, which appears to disgust atheists because religious folks have rights too, if they were so worried about the health of babies, then perhaps banning mothers from smoking and drinking alcohol while pregnant, or near a child, should be a lot more forthcoming.

But I think the problem with that, is that it would affect atheists and agnostics just as much as Muslims, Christians, and Jews.
 
Define "genital mutilation."

Under my definition that does not include circumcision of the male genital, I am against "genital mutilation."

(For the record, circumcision is not "genital mutilation," so I can only assume you aren't addressing the OP whatsoever.)

Now the penis is not genital. This just gets better and better.
Mutilation is cutting bits off. In Papua New Guinea women cut off a finger when mourning. That's mutilation. If only the first joint is cut off, it is still mutilation. If they get really carried away and chop off the whole hand, that would also be mutilation.
You don't get to redefine words to suit yourself, unless you are Humpty Dumpty
 
...
If vaginal circumcision was exactly the same as penal circumcision, and IF there were a religion that practices it, then obviously it would be fine.
...
.
Vaginal circumcision (clitorodectomy) is common in Islam, and older cultures, frequently seen in African societies.
Its obvious rationalization is to put women in their place.
Pregnant, barefoot and in the kitchen and ready for the male, 24/7.
 
The comparison is not between slavery and circumcision. In fact no comparison has been made. The point is that the length of time a custom has continued is irrelevant to whether that custom should continue.

if that was the case, and no comparison is intended, then why not instead liken it to cooking pumpkin pie on Thanksgiving, or eating a goose for Christmas?

...why not compare it to painting Easter eggs......or dressing up on Halloween?

;)

.....clearly, slavery is brought up in order to liken circumcision of 8-day olds to something totally cruel and barbaric.
 
Last edited:
That's no different than asking if I think "it would be Ok, if Aztecs were alive today, to do ritualized sacrifice of human beings."

Of course the First Amendment doesn't give religions the right to do whatever it is they please all of the time. But such restrictions must be within reason. And banning male circumcision is not a reasonable thing to ban.


Orly?
 
It's not a logical fallacy at all. It is a valid rebuttal of the reason you offered for continuing a particular cultural or religious practice: we've done it for a long time.

Ok, but it is a logical fallacy. Slavery absolutely does not equate to a circumcision. :boggled:

Really? If this is the level of argument on this forum, perhaps this was a huge mistake for me to have signed up on these forums. "Critical thinking," indeed! :rolleyes:
 
Which sources are you going to cite for this? And does said source say those "deaths of some babies" results specifically from the surgery itself, or could it have been from some other cause?

Babies being driven in cars are killed in car accidents at a far greater rate than babies being circumcised. Do we ban parents from hauling babies around in cars? Do we ban parents from taking their kids out on strollers? Surely, there are some babies that get hit by a car, or something falls on them from out of the sky. And at far greater rates as well.

See? I can play the slippery slope game as well.

You can play all sorts of games. No I cannot cite sources. Can't be bothered with someone who cannot understand such basic things. Even people getting a tooth filled sometimes die. It's a fact.
Your second paragraph reeks of desperation. Surely you can see the difference between subjecting a child to an unecessary medical procedure and normal everyday activities where we do what we can to reduce risk. And we do ban parents from failing to restrain their children in cars.
 
Ok, but it is a logical fallacy. Slavery absolutely does not equate to a circumcision. :boggled:

Really? If this is the level of argument on this forum, perhaps this was a huge mistake for me to have signed up on these forums. "Critical thinking," indeed! :rolleyes:

Perhaps.

:)
 
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=how+many+babies+die+due+to+circumcision+every+year+in+the+USA?

http://www.circumstitions.com/death.html

"Abstract: Baby boys can and do succumb as a result of having their foreskin removed. Circumcision-related mortality rates are not known with certainty; this study estimates the scale of this problem. This study finds that approximately 117 neonatal circumcision-related deaths (9.01/100,000) occur annually in the United States, about 1.3% of male neonatal deaths from all causes."

Perhaps you should be spending your time campaigning for a more useful cause first. Banning mothers from smoking, before you go on a crusade to wipe out the separation clause from the Constitution.

http://www.aolhealth.com/2010/06/08...-smoking-still-major-cause-of-newborn-deaths/

The researchers found that prenatal smoking caused about 5-8 percent of premature births and about 13-19 percent of the low-birth weight cases. If the mother had avoided smoking during pregnancy, it could have prevented 5-7 percent of preterm-related infant deaths and 23-34 percent of infant deaths caused by sudden infant death syndrome, according to the study.
 
if that was the case, and no comparison is intended, then why not instead liken it to cooking pumpkin pie on Thanksgiving, or eating a goose for Christmas?

...why not compare it to painting Easter eggs......or dressing up on Halloween?

;)

.....clearly, slavery is brought up in order to liken circumcision of 8-day olds to something totally cruel and barbaric.

Cooking pumpkin pie because you like pumpkin pie is a good reason to cook it. Cooking pumpkin pie, even if you don't like it, because it has always been done, is not a good reason.
The same with easter eggs or any other tradition you care to name, including cutting bits off babies and keeping slaves.
 
.
Vaginal circumcision (clitorodectomy) is common in Islam, and older cultures, frequently seen in African societies.


No, it's not common in Islam. It's rooted in certain tribal cultures which are islamicized today. And male circumcision is, as others have already remarked, not common in christianity, contrary to what Nihilianth claims. It's common in US american christianity.
 
This is a beautiful example of missing the point by a country mile.
The comparison was not with those examples, but with the reason for continuing their practice.

This is a slippery slope of the grossest kind. Just because Z was around for most of human history, therefore A should be banned.

You're right. I missed your point by a country mile. But then again, apples don't taste like oranges to me. Maybe to some people they do.....
 
Ok, but it is a logical fallacy. Slavery absolutely does not equate to a circumcision. :boggled:

Really? If this is the level of argument on this forum, perhaps this was a huge mistake for me to have signed up on these forums. "Critical thinking," indeed! :rolleyes:

It is not a logical fallacy. Slavery was not compared to circumcision. Would it help your understanding if I shouted? SLAVERY WAS NOT COMPARED TO CIRCUMCISION.
I find it hard to believe that you really cannot grasp the point.
Anyone else feel free to jump in here...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom