Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

No. The only question now is: Why should we appease/worship it?
Yeah... maybe... but such a question involves at least one supplementary question:
'Has anyone heard of anyone that might have an even remotely plausible reason to suggest why we should appease/worship it?'​
 
Yeah... maybe... but such a question involves at least one supplementary question:
'Has anyone heard of anyone that might have an even remotely plausible reason to suggest why we should appease/worship it?'
​
We'll, we could construct a building. Put in pretty windows with inlaid glass images. Add a pulpit and pews for worship and provide collection boxes for apeasement. The money should be left in the collection box overnight so god can take out what he needs. Whatever is left in the morning can be used to cover expenses. Like trips to spas, nice cars, a private jet, prostitutes, cocaine.... I'm sorry, I digress.
 
I'm just saying you're going to get a difference of opinion if you ask a cat and a mouse about the morality of rodenticide, so how much moreso when the difference in kind is even further than a virus to a man?

I agree you'll get a difference of opinion there. Unfortunately, we can't (in this analogy) ask the cat. All we have is some of the mice telling the other mice that they're being killed and eaten for their own good.

If we can't ever hope to understand why God is doing something, why assume it's going to be in any way beneficial to us, rather than just to Him?
 
I pretty well suspected you'd be one of the few. :)
What an arrogant assumption to make, especially in the light of you not even responding to joobs' post. Just because f.ex. I haven't told you specifically how I came to my morals - a mixture of what joobs and Slingblade have mentioned, and also reading up on f.ex. Dawkins' "Nice Guys Finish first" hypothesis, doesn't mean I haven't thought about my morals in what can be called a skeptical manner.

I expected better from you than that sort of sassy and condencending comment, Pisci.
 
Show us how.
Well, to be fair to Radrook for a brief moment, if the brain is capable of error and delusion, it ought to work both ways. Even if you have no reason to believe there's a god to misinterpret, if there were, one could. Of course, saying that is basically saying "brains is brains:" not very helpful, but we mustn't set our standards too high here.
 
Yreg, since you have not abandoned this thread( a point in your favor) could you please answer just one question from another thread?

Could you give us an example of a being that you believe is fictional that you are mad at?
 
What an arrogant assumption to make, especially in the light of you not even responding to joobs' post.
I didn't think it wanted responding to. If he's thought about it critically, great for him. And arrogance? just because I have an impression based on what people post?

Just because f.ex. I haven't told you specifically how I came to my morals - a mixture of what joobs and Slingblade have mentioned, and also reading up on f.ex. Dawkins' "Nice Guys Finish first" hypothesis, doesn't mean I haven't thought about my morals in what can be called a skeptical manner.
And I didn't specifically say you hadn't either.

I expected better from you than that sort of sassy and condencending comment, Pisci.
I certainly didn't indend it that way. I've spoken to Sling many times, I've been made aware of some of thing things she's gone through, and have gone through some small measure of similar experiences myself. She's suffered, more and deeper than many of us here, and in my experience such suffering lends an insight into such matters that less seasoned or tested individuals can easily comprehend. Maybe this sounds "arrogant", but the best and dearest lessons in ethics and morality don't come from books.

Far from "sassy and condescending", my comment was meant as acknowledgment of such and admiration of her.
 
The brain can also interpret no God where there is.

Show us how.

Well, to be fair to Radrook for a brief moment, if the brain is capable of error and delusion, it ought to work both ways...

I'd like to think theses discussions aren't about being "fair to" any individual; rather they're concerned with evaluating the merits of various thoughts and opinions regarding relevant aspects of R&P topics

The idea that the "brain can also interpret no God where there is" is no more relevant than the notion that 'the brain can interpret no flying pink unicorns where there is'
 
Last edited:
Yes... unless your god has detectable properties that distinguish it from an IPU, then it's just absurd to say that someone can have a "blind spot" against detecting such a thing.
 
I'd like to think theses discussions aren't about being "fair to" any individual; rather they're concerned with evaluating the merits of various thoughts and opinions regarding relevant aspects of R&P topics

The idea that the "brain can also interpret no God where there is" is no more relevant than the notion that 'the brain can interpret no flying pink unicorns where there is'
I was in the process of writing a longish response to this to defend my position but somewhere along the way it disintegrated. I do think that in some basic, theoretical sense, Radrook is right, and the irrelevance of direct spiritual experience or the illusion of it could be seen to cut both ways, but when I try to imagine an atheistic parallel, it falls apart. I have never heard an atheist claim direct spiritual experience of no-god. It's an oxymoron. I was planning on scolding Slingblade for a peevish response, but I'm now inclined to suggest to Radrook that his post, while it might have some syntactical symmetry, has little bearing on anything.
 
...I'm now inclined to suggest to Radrook that his post, while it might have some syntactical symmetry, has little bearing on anything.
Agreed.

Rad said:
The brain can also interpret no God where there is.

"The brain can also interpret no God where there is." = The brain can also interpret no ^X* where there is. = incomplete sentence

Tossing in undefined terms renders the sentence broken and meaningless.
 
Last edited:
"The brain can also interpret no God where there is." = The brain can also interpret no ^X* where there is. = incomplete sentence

Tossing in undefined terms renders the sentence broken and meaningless.
I'm not having any trouble understanding it. Human brains are subject to both false positive errors and false negative errors.

False negatives are more likely to be evolutionarily disastrous though. If I see a shadow and believe it's a predator, I don't lose anything except a little energy running away from a shadow. If I see a predator and believe it's a shadow, I quite possibly become lunch.

Hence, the propensity towards false positive errors (which includes pareidolia, by the way) would be, if anything, evolutionarily advantageous, while propensity towards false negative errors would eventually result in the extinction of my species.
 
Last edited:
It's not just undefined (or vaguely and multiply defined),-- it applies to entities that have no discernable characteristics--that is, they are all identical to invisible pink unicorns or mythological beings. It applies to all woo your mind can generate and the infinity of woo you've never thought of yet.

It might sound like a touche' type argument for god... but only so far as you realize it applies equally well to Thetans, ESP, and magic.
 
Yes, we evolved to detect agency and meaning that isn't necessarily there, because that is a better survival strategy than missing agency and meaning that IS there.

There are rational reasons for human irrationality.

Forum member, Zytheran, gave an excellent talk on this subject to Las Vegas Atheists after TAM last year.
 
I was planning on scolding Slingblade

Slingblade greatly appreciates correction. :D

Slingblade is 50, and does not appreciate being scolded. :mad:


for a peevish response


Not at all.

If the brain can interpret there is no god, where a god actually is, I want to know how it does that.

Because there must be something there to interpret, you see?

I also want to know what studies Rad is citing as evidence for this claim.
 
Far from "sassy and condescending", my comment was meant as acknowledgment of such and admiration of her.

And you aknowledged her by putting her as "one of the few", and it's very difficult for me to ascertain any other meaning in that comment, than that you're arrogantly dismissing "the most" of the atheists as -not- having thought about their morality. Way to aknowledge one person, by putting others down in the same comment. :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom