Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Maybe because the right topic or the right questions haven't yet come up for us to express that skepticism...OR...we have, but it hasn't been read that way in the context in which it was seen.

I express my skepticism about the "moral code" every time I have to explain that mine now comes solely from my empathy for others, my sense of self, and the way these things interact on a daily and circumstantial basis. I don't just blindly accept that certain things are wrong, or are always wrong.

I pretty well suspected you'd be one of the few. :)
 
So I think we could define yrreg's God as:

An entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth
and everything.​

But what does defining God as "independent of man's mind" add? How could an entity dependent on man's mind be the creator of heaven and earth and everything? If God is dependent on man's mind, then man must exist in order for God to exist, which would mean that such a God couldn't be the creator of everything -- assuming that "man" is part of "everything".

So, that leaves us with:

Creator of heaven and earth
and everything.​

Which is a bit redundant, since surely "heaven and earth" are part of everything.

So, I would say that yrreg's definition is equivalent to: "The creator of everything".



Although I said earlier I would accept yrreg's definition (quintessential concept) of God for sake of this discussion, not much discussion has actually taken place.

I do have a few problems with it though. First, I don't think existence is an attribute that can be included within the definition of something you are trying to prove exists. Second, I am aware of what the Earth is and I understand the concept of everything (all that is) but what is this Heaven thing he's talking about?

So, agreeing with skoob, I think the definition should be shortened to:


God: That which caused, directly or indirectly, all that is.​


The only question now is: How should we appease/worship it?
 
That's overlooking the possibility that killing people, while not "good" for the people killed, may be "good" for other people or things, or good for god. It also assumes that death is somehow "not good".
Meh~ Aside from the "but", which I concede draws a distinction and perhaps an implication, I make no assumptions

Seriously, with all of us being skeptical of god and religion, how is it so few of us seem to be even the slightest bit skeptical of the basic moral code that was indoctrinated into us at the same time?
I remain skeptical of evrything. You can find me discussing and debating just about every point and I've changed my mind on many things since I've come here including the rights of gays and lesbians to marry (I'm for it). I could be more skeptical but it's not fair at all to say I'm not even the slightest bit skeptical.
 
So good is whatever God does?
I think that's how some theists would view it, and how they manage to reconcile the brutality, terror, incest, murder and genocide of the Old Testament with their notions of Christian morality. It's different when God tells you to do it. I find that comforting, don't you? :eek:
 
...

So, agreeing with skoob, I think the definition should be shortened to:


God: That which caused, directly or indirectly, all that is.​


The only question now is: How should we appease/worship it?
I imagine that if there is a god that meets that definition, that god would be most appeased and complimented if we were to do our best to understand the universe he made, and use it wisely. Any god worth his salt would have far better things to do than to worry about whether or not we're saying our hosannas often enough.
 
I imagine that if there is a god that meets that definition, that god would be most appeased and complimented if we were to do our best to understand the universe he made, and use it wisely. Any god worth his salt would have far better things to do than to worry about whether or not we're saying our hosannas often enough.
Or who we sleep with.
 
I remain skeptical of evrything. You can find me discussing and debating just about every point and I've changed my mind on many things since I've come here including the rights of gays and lesbians to marry (I'm for it). I could be more skeptical but it's not fair at all to say I'm not even the slightest bit skeptical.

I meant the basic stuff- the the Thou Shalt Not stuff- lying, stealing, killing.
 
Name the organs of experience you employ to prove your things. [ Take 2 ]

Title of post: Name the organs of experience you employ to prove your things.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Originally Posted by Hokulele

joobz, Foster Zygote, RandFan, six7s, and Mr. Hokulele.


What organs of 'empiricalization' or experience have you availed yourself to come to the proof that these items stated by you above exist independently of your mind?



Please, Hokulele, at the risk of being warned again by moderators here on not directing my words at posters instead of their arguments, I must remind you that you are one poster who have nothing to contribute of usefulness to readers except to act naive.




To readers of this thread: atheism is not about such things as fossils and Big Bang, but about people whose brain and consciousness and organs of experience and reason and intelligence are not constructively and productively employed by themselves to discover positive things in the universe of existence, but to invent negative pseudo-concepts and play naive to eschew the concept and the existence of God as the:

Existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth
and everything.​





Yrreg


When you guys are through with playing naive, remember to pm me to inform me that you have discovered the organs of experience by which you experience the 'empiricalization' or experience you have availed yourselves of, to come to the proof that those items stated by you above exist independently of your mind.


For that purpose please try to think about empirical evidence and come up with a verbal account of empirical evidence in not more than twenty words.


What I notice in you guys is that you swallow a lot of verbal stuffs but cannot digest them but much assimilate them into your brain, conscious experience, reason and intelligence.



I will not visit again this thread until after 24 hours from now, to wit: it is now 010709 Wednesday 0743hrs -- local time, just to find out one thing: if you have located your organs of experience whereby you experience the 'empiricalization' or experience you have availed yourselves of, to come to the proof that those items stated by you above exist independently of your mind.





Yrreg
 
We answered you several pages ago, Yrreg. The ears, eyes, nose, tongue, and skin are the organs of experience. The brain is the organ of processing information. Now that I've re-answered your question, you don't have to go away for 24 hours.
 
When you guys are through with playing naive, remember to pm me to inform me that you have discovered the organs of experience by which you experience the 'empiricalization' or experience you have availed yourselves of, to come to the proof that those items stated by you above exist independently of your mind.
Translation: "When you guys are ready to start pretending that I'm making sense, please let me know."
I will not visit again this thread until after 24 hours from now, to wit: it is now 010709 Wednesday 0743hrs -- local time, just to find out one thing: if you have located your organs of experience whereby you experience the 'empiricalization' or experience you have availed yourselves of, to come to the proof that those items stated by you above exist independently of your mind.

"You have 24 hours to comply."

In 24 hours, we will not have PMed you to claim that you've said anything worth discussing. In 24 years, we will still not pretend that you are making sense. Unless you actually start making a lucid argument.
 
For that purpose please try to think about empirical evidence and come up with a verbal account of empirical evidence in not more than twenty words.

(emphasis added)

Yeah, because you're a big believer in brevity.
 
When you guys are through with playing naive, remember to pm me to inform me that you have discovered the organs of experience by which you experience the 'empiricalization' or experience you have availed yourselves of, to come to the proof that those items stated by you above exist independently of your mind.
I'm not playing naive. You've not as yet offered any coherent argument in support of your belief. And I'm not real clear as to your belief. Now it looks like you are making an argument from idealism. Is that correct?
 
How could we expect to understand God, if it did exist?

Why should morality come into it at all?
We expect an existing God to be moral; it isn't.
This should not be cause in itself of rejecting the concept, or existence, of God.

reality should be enough to go on, as per deciding god/no-god.
It is what it is. relatively unexplored.
 
My five are:
1.) Groucho
2.) Harpo
3.) Chico
4.) Zeppo
5.) Gummo

Prove it! Oh, yeah, you HEAR about Gummo, but has anyone ever actually seen him? Even a picture?

I'd love to be on a game show someday. I have too much trivia in my head not to put it to some financial use. I do pretty good at trivial pursuit and other such games.

Don't you live in SoCal? Get yourself over to Sony Studios and audition for "Jeopardy" or "Wheel of Fortune."

Or if you don't live there, both shows take their contestant searches on the road periodically. That's how I got on "Jeopardy."

Please, Hokulele, at the risk of being warned again by moderators here on not directing my words at posters instead of their arguments, I must remind you that you are one poster who have nothing to contribute of usefulness to readers except to act naive.

Hokulele said:
I will let the readers be the judge of that. Your opinion hasn't proved too reliable.

Damn! I'm jealous. I thought I had done a pretty good job of contributing nothing of usefulness.
 
Prove it! Oh, yeah, you HEAR about Gummo, but has anyone ever actually seen him? Even a picture?
According to teh interwebs, it would seem so

However, there seems to be a complete absence of even anecdotal reports of anyone ever seeing Gummo and yrreg in the same room at the same time...

:jaw-dropp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom