Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

What organs of 'empiricalization' or experience have you availed yourself to come to the proof that these items stated by you above exist independently of your mind?


I can ask them "Are you real?" and they will respond. I can ask for further proof, and they will provide it. I can ask others if they have identical experiences of the existence of those 5 things I have listed, and they will agree.

Please, Hokulele, at the risk of being warned again by moderators here on not directing my words at posters instead of their arguments, I must remind you that you are one poster who have nothing to contribute of usefulness to readers except to act naive.


I will let the readers be the judge of that. Your opinion hasn't proved too reliable.

To readers of this thread: atheism is not about such things as fossils and Big Bang, but about people whose brain and consciousness and organs of experience and reason and intelligence are not constructively and productively employed by themselves to discover positive things in the universe of existence, but to invent negative pseudo-concepts and play naive to eschew the concept and the existence of God as the:
Existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth
and everything.​

​
See what I mean?
 
Hmmmm... interesting. What is the benifit of not playing arrogant and naive? Or have we not gotten that far yet? Thanks for the help though.
Opps:o

In my rewording of his argument, I meant to replace naive with arrogant.

I'll leave it stand as is for honesty sake.
 
Opps:o

In my rewording of his argument, I meant to replace naive with arrogant.

I'll leave it stand as is for honesty sake.
:) Thanks for the correction.

Believers are often oblivious to the consequences of the belief. Yrreg seems to think that providing this definition of god is somehow sufficient but it raises so many questions.

Existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth and everything.

Assuming the "evidence" proves what he claims, does the entity care about it's creation and does it involve itself with the affairs of humans? Is there any reason for us to care whether or not there is a creator? Why should we assume it is independent of the human mind? Though I'm atheist I like the idea, as a supposition, that we are all simply part of god's mind ala Scott Adams book God's Debris.

Yrreg has at best given us a largely useless definition and disconnected premises that don't formulate any argument. It would be generous to state that the argument is disjointed. Though to be fair I don't think he ever claimed that he was making an argument only providing evidence.

So, after pages of this I'm at a complete loss and I find myself longing for the ramblings of lifegazer.
 
yrreg said:
Existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth
and everything.​
I know that this is against the "rules", but it has to be said: That's a lousy definition.

What does stating that God must be existent add to the definition? Let's say we define X as something which has a set of properties y and X' as something which exists and has the properties in y. If we find something that has all the properties in y, then we have found an X, so Xs exist. But since it exists, it is also an X'. If we can't find any Xs, we won't find any X's either, so there's really no point in the definition X'.

So I think we could define yrreg's God as:

An entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth
and everything.​

But what does defining God as "independent of man's mind" add? How could an entity dependent on man's mind be the creator of heaven and earth and everything? If God is dependent on man's mind, then man must exist in order for God to exist, which would mean that such a God couldn't be the creator of everything -- assuming that "man" is part of "everything".

So, that leaves us with:

Creator of heaven and earth
and everything.​

Which is a bit redundant, since surely "heaven and earth" are part of everything.

So, I would say that yrreg's definition is equivalent to: "The creator of everything".

Or, could anyone give an example of a hypothetical god which would satisfy yrreg's definition, but not mine, or vise versa? yrreg?
 
And to extend skoob's argument, since yrreg has already accepted that men create comunications satellites, it is clear that God didn't create everything. So we are now left with: "The creator of stuff that wasn't created by man. Or birds. Or ants. Or beavers. Or cucumber vines. Or jellyfish."
 
Ok Skoob, Hokulele, good job.

God, it makes stuff. Sounds like GE's pitch, "brings good things to live". But then god makes parisites and viruses which kill people so that's got to be included in the "stuff" and that brings good things, like people, to death.
 
skoob, I think that is what yrreg was struggling to come up with but it didn't have enough words. I've come up with another one:

god is aether

That should satisfy the critics who say, "Tell me what god is, not what he does."
 
Is God allowed to be the creation, without being the creator? I would define the creation as 'what is'. Once I stumble into the zone of defining the creator, I think I've gone into theism. It feels hopeless to me to define the creator as independent of the creation.
If there is one, how could my my small part of it ever hope to describe the whole?

Theism seems hopelessly bound to anthropomorphizing. I recoil at the concept of a god that is bound up with man to the exclusion of the rest. Too arrogant.

Funny how this thread goes on and on.
If I was an attention whore, I'd surely post something controversial, with an unyielding attitude.

(I am, btw, but can't think of the proper subject)
 
So, I would say that yrreg's definition is equivalent to: "The creator of everything".

Which is nearly identical to the definition of god given in the first line of the Nicene CreedWP:
I believe in one God, the Father Almighty, the maker of heaven and earth, of things visible and invisible.
 
Ok Skoob, Hokulele, good job.

God, it makes stuff. Sounds like GE's pitch, "brings good things to live". But then god makes parisites and viruses which kill people so that's got to be included in the "stuff" and that brings good things, like people, to death.

That's overlooking the possibility that killing people, while not "good" for the people killed, may be "good" for other people or things, or good for god. It also assumes that death is somehow "not good".

Seriously, with all of us being skeptical of god and religion, how is it so few of us seem to be even the slightest bit skeptical of the basic moral code that was indoctrinated into us at the same time?
 
That's overlooking the possibility that killing people, while not "good" for the people killed, may be "good" for other people or things, or good for god. It also assumes that death is somehow "not good".

Seriously, with all of us being skeptical of god and religion, how is it so few of us seem to be even the slightest bit skeptical of the basic moral code that was indoctrinated into us at the same time?
1.) I want to live. Whether this desire is a preprogrammed genetic trait or an actual choice doesn't matter. We have no evidence for death being anything other than not being and I still want to be. I love my be.

2.) If I can justify the killing of another as "good", then someone else can make that same equal justification to kill me. I would like to continue Be-ing in a society that I need not spend time worrying if someone else has justified to kill me.


I have critically assessed my moral code and find it acceptable.
 
That's overlooking the possibility that killing people, while not "good" for the people killed, may be "good" for other people or things, or good for god. It also assumes that death is somehow "not good".

Seriously, with all of us being skeptical of god and religion, how is it so few of us seem to be even the slightest bit skeptical of the basic moral code that was indoctrinated into us at the same time?

I suppose you could argue that children dying in pain as they are consumed internally by God-given parasites may indeed be "good" for God. I confess that my own moral code is not sufficiently malleable to see a deity that would cause such a situation as anything other than malign.
 
Addressing Vic Vega: If you prefer you can go straight to the text of my present message at the end of these three reproduced posts.

I am glad that you can accept a concept without believing in it, because otherwise it is impossible for two people to exchange ideas constructively and productively on any topic that has been discussed by mankind since the dawn of human conscious reason and intelligence.

That is why I don't read people here who keep insisting that they cannot consider at least consider my concept of God as:

An existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


I am working on questions which people like you can answer with Yes or No, assuming that they have a conscious brain and working reason and intelligence.


Right away can you answer this question with an Yes or No?


Communication satellites are produced by manufacturers. Yes No.​





Yrreg


OK. I'll play.


"An existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything."

I can accept this definition as reasonable for the sake of this discussion.



"Communication satellites are produced by manufacturers."

Of course. They don't spontaneously build themselves.


What's next?
 
That's overlooking the possibility that killing people, while not "good" for the people killed, may be "good" for other people or things, or good for god. It also assumes that death is somehow "not good".

Seriously, with all of us being skeptical of god and religion, how is it so few of us seem to be even the slightest bit skeptical of the basic moral code that was indoctrinated into us at the same time?

Maybe because the right topic or the right questions haven't yet come up for us to express that skepticism...OR...we have, but it hasn't been read that way in the context in which it was seen.

I express my skepticism about the "moral code" every time I have to explain that mine now comes solely from my empathy for others, my sense of self, and the way these things interact on a daily and circumstantial basis. I don't just blindly accept that certain things are wrong, or are always wrong. And I do know that some things I think are wrong could be the right thing to do, given the circumstances.

"God says this is wrong, so it's wrong," is the expression of a complete absence of critical thought. It's lazy. It's easy and convenient. It displaces responsibility and accountability. And it allows abuse of power. If a god exists, it has to be smarter than that, or else it's no better than any given human being. And that's not a god, whatever else it may be.

I expressed it to my kids while I was still (but just barely) a theist, when I said "an act is not wrong because it is 'a sin.' An act is wrong because it harms you or others." I was trying to explain to them that I could easily call almost any act a sin, and convince them it was wrong to do it, but that by doing so, there wasn't a lot of thinking going on. I did expressly tell them "Saying it's a sin doesn't say anything; it's an empty phrase waiting for you to fill it with meaning."

My moral code has changed somewhat since I admitted I don't believe in gods or magic anymore, but it honestly hasn't changed all that much. I did some things as a theist and Christian that under my former code were wrong, but I did them secretly, because I didn't really believe they were in fact wrong at all. I did feel guilty, but it was for my dishonesty, more than for the actual thing I was doing. The only thing that really changed is that I started doing those things openly and without guilt.


...well, at least one thing isn't done exactly openly...but with an absence of guilt, yes. :o
 
I suppose you could argue that children dying in pain as they are consumed internally by God-given parasites may indeed be "good" for God. I confess that my own moral code is not sufficiently malleable to see a deity that would cause such a situation as anything other than malign.

Of course not- you're not a god.
 
So good is whatever God does?

I'm just saying you're going to get a difference of opinion if you ask a cat and a mouse about the morality of rodenticide, so how much moreso when the difference in kind is even further than a virus to a man?

It frankly bothers me when skeptics and fellow atheists start making arguments based on the premise that men and gods are equivilent beings, because every conclusion that's arrived at is going to be flawed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom