Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Very good, now just state what you know to be empirical evidence...

We answered you several pages ago, Yrreg. The ears, eyes, nose, tongue, and skin are the organs of experience. The brain is the organ of processing information. Now that I've re-answered your question, you don't have to go away for 24 hours.



Very good.


Now, Dave, just give me in not more than twenty words what you understand by empirical evidence, to convey to readers here that you do know what is empirical evidence, which you people keep harping on, for the ascertainment of the existence of things independent of man's mind.

When you have come up with that account in not more than twenty words of your own composition, what is empirical evidence, then I will engage you on what you are proving or not proving at all, the existence from empirical evidence of the things brought up by Hokulele to be existing independently of man's mind.

Why in your own words and in not more than twenty words?

Because if you can't give an account of what is empirical evidence in your own words and in not more than twenty words, then I will hold you to be not really knowledgeable about what is empirical evidence.




Readers of this thread: see message #890, above, for your orientation.




Yrreg
 
Anything I can engage with my senses, and examine using my cognition, experience, and reason.
 
Any measurable quality which allows me to distinguish what is real from a delusion or illusion.
 
Empirical evidence is evidence from observations, either natural or experimental. 10 words.
 
Very good.


Now, Dave, just give me in not more than twenty words what you understand by empirical evidence, to convey to readers here that you do know what is empirical evidence, which you people keep harping on, for the ascertainment of the existence of things independent of man's mind.

When you have come up with that account in not more than twenty words of your own composition, what is empirical evidence, then I will engage you on what you are proving or not proving at all, the existence from empirical evidence of the things brought up by Hokulele to be existing independently of man's mind.

Why in your own words and in not more than twenty words?

Because if you can't give an account of what is empirical evidence in your own words and in not more than twenty words, then I will hold you to be not really knowledgeable about what is empirical evidence.




Readers of this thread: see message #890, above, for your orientation.




Yrreg

You used 167 words. In future, limit your messages to 20 words or less. When you use more than 20 words, you demonstrate that you are spouting drivel.
 
And you aknowledged her by putting her as "one of the few", and it's very difficult for me to ascertain any other meaning in that comment, than that you're arrogantly dismissing "the most" of the atheists as -not- having thought about their morality. Way to aknowledge one person, by putting others down in the same comment. :rolleyes:

Way to go looking for offense where none was intended. ;)
 
Way to go looking for offense where none was intended. ;)
In truth, I did take a bit of an offense to it as well. But I also know from your posts that you tend to not be mean or arrogant, and simply blew it off.
 
Anything I can engage with my senses, and examine using my cognition, experience, and reason.
15 words.

Any measurable quality which allows me to distinguish what is real from a delusion or illusion.
16 words.

Empirical evidence is evidence from observations, either natural or experimental.
10 words.

yrreg, your request has been met. Take your pick. I sincerly tried to come up with a better response but I honestly could not.

Please note that posters here are trying to accomodate you even though you are rather abrasive and patronizing.
 
I enjoy the part where Gerry limits us to just a few words, but doesn't limit himself at all.

I know where a little tin god is, if anyone's interested.
 
I'm not having any trouble understanding it.
I was specifically referring to the three letter grouping of words that has no meaning. Take out the word "God" and then read the sentence.

"The brain can also interpret no ___ where there is"

The meaning (or rather the lack of) remains the same.



Human brains are subject to both false positive errors and false negative errors.

False negatives are more likely to be evolutionarily disastrous though. If I see a shadow and believe it's a predator, I don't lose anything except a little energy running away from a shadow. If I see a predator and believe it's a shadow, I quite possibly become lunch.

Hence, the propensity towards false positive errors (which includes pareidolia, by the way) would be, if anything, evolutionarily advantageous, while propensity towards false negative errors would eventually result in the extinction of my species.
I might reduce that to..."if there is a trait that increases genetic fitness of the group (including specific compartmentalized irrationality) it could be favored by the natural selection process."
 
I enjoy the part where Gerry limits us to just a few words, but doesn't limit himself at all.

I know where a little tin god is, if anyone's interested.

(At first I thought you said "tin of god"... and I wondered if god was a "spotted dick" :p )
 
Emprical evidence:

information gained by observation which aides in determining the truth of a claim.
 
(At first I thought you said "tin of god"... and I wondered if god was a "spotted dick" :p )
I've been assured that size doesn't matter and I'm tempted to believe that is true (confirmation bias) but is spotted dick prefferable to dick that isn't spotted? I thought you and slingblade might know about these things.
 
Paging Godless Dave, please produce your account of empirical evidence.

Yesterday [ January 8, Thursday ], 05:35 PM #922



Title of post #922: Very good, now just state what you know to be empirical evidence...


http://www.randi.org/forumlive/showpost.php?p=4330574&postcount=922

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Posted by godless dave
We answered you several pages ago, Yrreg. The ears, eyes, nose, tongue, and skin are the organs of experience. The brain is the organ of processing information. Now that I've re-answered your question, you don't have to go away for 24 hours.

​


Very good.


Now, Dave, just give me in not more than twenty words what you understand by empirical evidence, to convey to readers here that you do know what is empirical evidence, which you people keep harping on, for the ascertainment of the existence of things independent of man's mind.

When you have come up with that account in not more than twenty words of your own composition, what is empirical evidence, then I will engage you on what you are proving or not proving at all, the existence from empirical evidence of the things brought up by Hokulele to be existing independently of man's mind.

Why in your own words and in not more than twenty words?

Because if you can't give an account of what is empirical evidence in your own words and in not more than twenty words, then I will hold you to be not really knowledgeable about what is empirical evidence.




Readers of this thread: see message #890, above, for your orientation.




Yrreg


It is now in my place 0516hrs of Friday, January 9, 2009.


I am still waiting for Dave to write his account of what is empirical evidence in not more than twenty words.


I will visit this thread again after twenty-four hours, to see whether Dave has produced his account of what is empirical evidence in not more than twenty words, to show to readers that he is really knowledgeable or not knowledgeable about what is empirical evidence.


Remember readers here, atheists are the people who are always harping on empirical evidence.


And I have always the impression that atheists are tergiversators.

So, Godless Dave, show me that you are not a tergiversator, produce your account of what is empirical evidence in not more than twenty words.





Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom