Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

please just choose one particular point and shorten your text to the utmost brevity your focus of objection, and I will respond to you.


Please abstain from irrelevant words.




Yrreg


Yrreg, I am going to ask you to do something similar. Part of the problem here is that you are not prepared to lay out an argument and people are second guessing because of that. That is not fair on you and not fair on us. So, without copy/pasting previous posts, can you please now elaborate at least one of your points so that we can see what you actually mean:

Let us take what seems to be an important issue for you: you have said that for you the moon and communication satellites are in some way relevant to the question of the existence of god. It may be that you have been convinced by this yourself and that you have lived with it so long that you believe the point is self evident: but it isn't.

We have the moon: we have communication satellites. They are both in orbit around the earth. The satellites are man made. Now what is there in those facts which says anything about the existence or non existence of god? People have guessed how you think they are relevant, but I want you to tell us in plain language and in sufficient detail that I (or at least someone) can follow your thought process. Please include sufficient detail to make all the steps plain to the meanest intelligence: strip it to the essentials if you wish, or even elaborate a bit if that is pleasing to you. But ensure that your account is full enough that it illustrates your argument in full

Thanks
 
I have brought forth the communication satellites, the moon, man's brain, consciousness, reason and intelligence as empirical evidence to prove God's existence.


You have not established that these prove God's existence.
 
Donner, Donder = Thunder. To go with Blitzen, lightning.

(used to be Blixem, but was changed to rhyme with Vixen.)

Thanks! I always learn something new on JREF.

(I have been on game shows, and I have won money on them... so one never knows when trivia will pay off. You didn't come by this information through divine knowledge did you?)
 
:dl:
Suddenly, this thread is entertaining! Czar, I didn't know there was a Gummo Marx.

Articulett, you are blinding Me with science. :D
 
Last edited:
<snipped the Non-Briefly part>

Briefly:

1. My concept of God is the following:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth,
and everything.​

2. My empirical evidence of God are the communication satellites and the moon and man's brain, experience, consciousness, reason and intelligence.​


Please concentrate on the thoughts in those two positions.

If you have already concentrated on those two positions, please just choose one particular point and shorten your text to the utmost brevity your focus of objection, and I will respond to you.


Please abstain from irrelevant words.




Yrreg

Aha! I see where you've made your mistake now.

These are all evidence of The Flying Spaghetti Monster, not your god! Duh! You should listen to the preaching of apostle Mario Batali.

GOTCHA!
 
Indeed :)

When in Rome...

Is anyone sure of anything in a 'yrreg thread'?

I assume '3 O' is the three omni-wotsits
Yessir, that 3 O was a quick shorthand for the old Omni, Omni, Omni deal not standardized, and was not a reference to the multi thing she thanked me -- sorry, must not kiss and tell.

As to is anyone sure of anything in a 'yrreg thread' question, I'll baldly steal an idea from somewhere else:

yrreg threads are where reason goes do die.

DR
 
1. I've often seen the image used in a derogatory manner, but I still haven't met anyone who really rejected the Abrahamic god because they took it literally. Breckmin was claiming that atheists reject God because they think he is literally defined as a big old man with a long white beard in the sky.

2. By the way, love the new avatar.
1. Got it.
2. Orphia Nay and Paulhoff made it for me for Christmas. Their brilliance caused a disturbance on the force, like a million souls golf clapping. :D (or was that just me?)
India Sierra India Hotel Alpha Foxtrot Charlie
I thought this through, and had a lovely phonetic alphabetical laugh when I got it. :D
That you imply that chaos equates to peril suggests you have no foxtrotting idea about either
He's more about control, but he isn't Smart. ;)
It is typical of shallow minds to switch from one extreme to the opposite extreme.

Yrreg
Thank you for that irony.
Have you brought forth five things you have proven to exist from empirical evidence?
joobz, Foster Zygote, RandFan, six7s, and Mr. Hokulele.
I, on the other hand, do not exist, but am rather an empirical permutation of the Dark Side of the Farce. What hath Lucas wrought? :jaw-dropp
It was silly the first time and it doesn't get any better with repetition.
Is there a way to add that as a tag to each yrreg thread?
I can't help but think that we are being given the Chubaca defense form of apologetics.
Chewbacca apologetics mostly sound like loud yawps and groans, wth a few bellows thrown in. Now the Emperor form of apologetics might fit but it isn't this:
"Wookies on endor?
That does not make sense.
If that does not make sense, you must admit that God exists...
"
Ewoks made less sense.

As the Emperor said shortly before he exploded

The Ewoks are revolting.

Id was an understandable sentiment.
 
Last edited:
Right, I'm just dying to know what communications satellites and the moon have to do with proving the existence of God. I have little hope of a coherent explanation from Gerry, but does anyone else have the faintest notion what he's on about?
 
The website is very slow for me lately, so i had to skip ahead here.

If i was a floundering atheist, wanting to adopt yrreg's philosophy, how would I go about it?
Are there some basic tennants?
Or is it a sudden realization?

So far, I can't figure out which color Kool-aid to drink, so to speak.
 
I think Yrreg is going for something like 'we made artificial satellites, so natural satellites must be made by someone, too. Therefore, God.'

A thought on design. The watchmaker argument postulates a watch in a natural setting, like a beach. We see it and naturally conclude that it was designed and made for a purpose by a conscious being. Therefore, we are supposed to conclude that natural things are designed and made for a purpose by a conscious being. Natural things like the grains of sand on the beach. But the characteristics that lead us to conclude that the watch was designed and made by a conscious being are exactly the qualities that distinguish it from natural objects like grains of sand and rocks and moons. So the argument is essentially that the obvious artificiality of the watch (or other crafted or manufactured object) is evidence that natural objects-things that are not obviously artificial-are, in fact, artificial, that is, artifacts made by a conscious being. I think it doesn't follow.
 
Rand already did that once: Mormon to atheist. What makes you think he'll change that profoundly again.

Something you've offered us here? :confused:

To be completely fair, and please note, I don't pretend to predict the future, but anything can change at any time in the future. I have known relatives to have a stroke, and it really did change their personality completely. As we age, things do change, including strong opinions. Who knows how I will feel about certain basic philosophical concepts when I am in my eighties?

Although I do agree completely, if RandFan does ever change profoundly, it will not be due to the efforts of those such as Breckmin. :cool:
:)

It's easy. Show me the evidence. Houkulele is right, anything is possible. But I came to atheism kicking and screaming. It's not what I wanted. It's not what I chose. It was quite simply the result of a commitment to the truth. It was a journery that spanned years and it took the Monty Hall problem to get me to fully accept that my intuitions were quite falible which is why I now rely on empirical evidence for situations like whether or not I should talk to an invisible man in the sky. My intuition still works for stuff like when my wife asks me if the pants she is wearing makes her butt look fat.

Not the yrreg kind of empirical evidence though. Which is rather bizarre.
 
Last edited:
yrreg, I tried, I really did. What I'd like now is a lovely bunch of coconuts.
 
Were you not told about the guiltless masturbation?
Sorry, I don't believe in Christ but he's with me always nonetheless. It might be guiltless but it's rather awkward. 20 years of indoctrination will do that to ya. I kinda wish I were gay or Christ was a well endowed blonde.
 
God doesn't exist.

End of thread.
But according to your avatar, you are the Fiend God.

If god does not exist, then you are the fiend of nothing, making you nothing. ouch. I got poopy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom