Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

There's that phrase again, "empirical evidence."

I'll clarify my point here because you seem to have misunderstood what was asked.
No one naturally concludes or decides there is a God before they actually are told/read to/taught about God. Only after this fact does the questioning really begin. A great many believe it by just plain faith, while there are others who believe by "experiences."

What empirical evidence caused you to believe there was existence of a God?


Since you use that phrase, suppose you bring up at least five things proven on empirical evidence to exist independently of your brain, consciousness, reason and intelligence.

Then on your examples, I will also look for empirical evidence to prove God's existence, or show you that on the basis of your empirical evidence you have not really proven the things you present as established on empirical evidence.




Yrreg
 
--snip==

The answer is independent of your individual existence and if I can't find
it some place else, I might ask later. I expect you to someday change your position anyway.

~Michael
Rand already did that once: Mormon to atheist. What makes you think he'll change that profoundly again.

Something you've offered us here? :confused:
 
Rand already did that once: Mormon to atheist. What makes you think he'll change that profoundly again.

Something you've offered us here? :confused:


To be completely fair, and please note, I don't pretend to predict the future, but anything can change at any time in the future. I have known relatives to have a stroke, and it really did change their personality completely. As we age, things do change, including strong opinions. Who knows how I will feel about certain basic philosophical concepts when I am in my eighties?

Although I do agree completely, if RandFan does ever change profoundly, it will not be due to the efforts of those such as Breckmin. :cool:
 
My positions on God are already stated in the following posts:


Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things.

Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things. [ Take 2 ]

Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things. [ Take 3 ]


Briefly:

1. My concept of God is the following:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth,
and everything.​

2. My empirical evidence of God are the communication satellites and the moon and man's brain, experience, consciousness, reason and intelligence.​


Please concentrate on the thoughts in those two positions.

If you have already concentrated on those two positions, please just choose one particular point and shorten your text to the utmost brevity your focus of objection, and I will respond to you.


Please abstain from irrelevant words.




Yrreg
Irrelevant words bolded, pertinent instruction in red.

You really need to learn what "empirical" means.

You might be able to experience God. You cannot experience his definition.

Whether or not you experience God, and whether or not you experience communication satellites, and whether or not the connection you infer is correct, reasonable, or true, the connection you infer is not itself empirical.
 
I've reported this to forum management but I've not gotten a response. I'm sorry about that I don't know why it is happening.
He might have been hitting the edit button rather than the quote button, and not realizing it.

DR
 
Can god tell a lie so convincingly that even he believes it?
Sure, merely by telling the truth.

(Six, your question is of course nonsensical, if we are discussing the conventional 3 O, as belief is an unnecessary step, or function, for a 3 O God and Creator that seems to be the topic here. Then again, it's an yrreg thread, so I'm not sure.)
 
Last edited:
My empirical evidence of God are the communication satellites and the moon and man's brain, experience, consciousness, reason and intelligence.

None of which show any indication that there is any god, deity, or supernatural being in existence in this universe.

Please come up with some actual evidence before spamming this forum with repeats of your previous posts.
 
Before anything else, concentrate on the concept of God from theists like myself, thus described already several times here:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth,
and everything.



Please abstain from all indications of nitpicking while the thrust of our discussions should be on the biggest pictures of things, not for example on the anthropomorphic detail used by simple men to verbalize in human language his thoughts on God in a concrete human way.


I find this kind of an attitude from atheists here bemusedly annoying but indicative of the kind of heart and mind of atheists here.

Atheism is not about molecules and atoms but about humans, so it is impossible to discuss atheism without bringing in their kinds and manners of speech, thought, and exchange of ideas.


If you are not aware why people in the US hold atheists in their midst to be the most distrusted of minority, my impression is precisely because they cannot deal with them in a way that is constructive, and they believe that on this kind of a posture from atheists, atheists are tergiversating.




Yrreg

Seriously Yrreg, when are you going to present empirical evidence to establish the existence of a supernatural entity?
Simply using differences of seen and unseen objects is no basis for "hey, think in terms of the big picture" because you have nothing established here except for your concept of an existent entity.
 
Another example of irrelevancy to the biggest pictures of this thread, viz., repeated flights to language barriers.
Bollocks

You evidently started this thread on the false assumption that you had/have the prerequisite skills to communicate

The OP
Just in case there are atheists here who are non-tergiversative on the one hand, and sincere and interested on the other to engage with me on exchange of ideas in regard to the existence of God or non-existence of God, let us first work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God.

<snip/>
Yrreg

It is abundantly clear that you are unable to communicate; insofar as you are demonstrably incapable of conveying any meaningful ideas

In 'communication', responsibility for comprehension rests with the sender - not the recipient

Furthermore, your posts demonstrate a complete lack of willingness to consider the opinions of those you invited to contribute; as this is the hallmark of a troll it is supremely hypocritical on your part to suggest that anyone (other than you) should enlist the aid of someone "more conversant with English" for 'enlightenment'

On my part I have already resolved to not react to people whose heart and mind are not into genuine constructive exchange of ideas, but into tergiversations, thinking that they are so smart for continually playing the naive.
Hah!

You are incapable of "genuine constructive exchange of ideas" - simply because you haven't got any to exchange

You can wank on and on as often as you like, but nothing will disguise the simple fact that you are a troll with the integrity of a dog on a croquet lawn
 
Last edited:
Foster, as an aside to this discussion, you could search the forum for the following terms over the past year.

sky daddy
bearded sky daddy

I think you'll find evidence of both. (terms)

DR

I've often seen the image used in a derogatory manner, but I still haven't met anyone who really rejected the Abrahamic god because they took it literally. Breckmin was claiming that atheists reject God because they think he is literally defined as a big old man with a long white beard in the sky.



By the way, love the new avatar.
 
Can god tell a lie so convincingly that even he believes it?
Sure, merely by telling the truth.

(Six, your question is of course nonsensical,
Indeed :)

When in Rome...

if we are discussing the conventional 3 O, as belief is an unnecessary step, or function, for a 3 O God and Creator that seems to be the topic here. Then again, it's an yrreg thread, so I'm not sure.)
Is anyone sure of anything in a 'yrreg thread'?

I assume '3 O' is the three omni-wotsits
 
Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander.

I think I have figured out yrregs basic proof of god.

"I think, therefore god is"


And the atheist answers "Chaos exists, therefore I am chaotic."


By the way do you atheists really insist chaos is the whole of the universe of existence whatever at all times and in all places?


Read this post from someone I know who looks back at me when I look onto the mirror.

It is my impression that for atheists everything came about from chaos by way of chance.

That includes man the conscious intelligent life form that manifests free choice.

Why then are we still around if everything came from chaos by way of chance?

Let's put it this way:

You are inside a safe bunker, but outside everything is chaos, and if you step outside you will certainly perish because the situation is all chaos.

Why will you instantly perish outside in the chaos? because chaos is not a safe environment for any living entity.

Yes, it was only by chance that you survive if you should step outside, but do you know that immediately when you should be congratulating yourself for the rare chance of surviving in the chaos, please keep in mind if you are still around that chaos is still prevailing, and right away in the next split second you will be destroyed and vaporized into gaseous fumes.

But in reality you are not inside a safe bunker; besides if you were, since everything is chaos even your bunker will be demolished without you even noticing your sudden death when your bunker got pulverized by the chaos which your bunker cannot withstand at all.

So, you should not be around if chaos and chance is the environment surrounding your existence and life.

But you are in fact still around and writing in this forum.

Wherefore the conclusion is obvious there is order and system and intention from some agent enabling you to have begun existing and live and continue to survive to this very split second as you read this post.

http://forums.about.com/n/pfx/forum.aspx?tsn=10&nav=messages&webtag=ab-altreligion&tid=3153

http://forums.about.com/n/pfx/forum.aspx?msg=3153.6&nav=messages&webtag=ab-altreligion



I am now reading about the chaos of atheists and the chaos theory of mathematicians, they are not absolutely not the same chaos; because chaos theory is not about atheists' chaos, not in the least.




Yrreg
 
And the atheist answers "Chaos exists, therefore I am chaotic."

By the way do you atheists really insist chaos is the whole of the universe of existence whatever at all times and in all places?

No, we don't.

Why do you think we worship chaos? Or have you redefined "chaos" to mean the lack of God?
 
Read this post from someone I know who looks back at me when I look onto the mirror.
Why then are we still around if everything came from chaos by way of chance?
Huh?

Why shouldn't we be around?

And why should an atheist know the answer to your inane question?

Let's put it this way:

You are inside a safe bunker, but outside everything is chaos, and if you step outside you will certainly perish because the situation is all chaos.
That you imply that chaos equates to peril suggests you have no foxtrotting idea about either
 
Should have made up your own self-help do it yourself monotheism.

You have assumed we have not and do not.

Some of us were hard-core fundies most of our lives. I happen to have read the entire bible, cover to cover, several times, over the course of my life. As my cogntion improved and was refined, I realized I was reading...well, a bunch of made-up, tribalistic, fairy-tale crap.



Until that god is proven, there is no irony.



So, are you responding to Yrreg's OP at all, or just hijacking another thread you didn't start? It will be interesting to see the two of you converse.



Corruptio optimi pessima.​


It is typical of shallow minds to switch from one extreme to the opposite extreme.


Another apothegm of the ancients for you to ruminate on in your brain, consciousness, reason and intelligence.


Ne quid nimis.​




Happy and fruitful thinking!





Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom