Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Let me repeat my post:
How can you make this "assumption."

We know that the universe exists, but on what basis can we
claim that it is it's own cause?

How do you know that the universe was not "caused" by something
other than itself?

~Michael
Why should I assume Anything else?
there must be a first cause.
There is no proof of anything beyond this universe.
So to make the universe the first cause is simply a matter of simplifaction.


You've asked me how do I know that there isn't a process that keeps the natural environment functioning. (this is a paraphrase).

The short answer is, I do not know. The fact is that noone can know. There has been no evidence for it and therefore it is simply a question for the imagination.
 
Must I conclude that you will not answer the question, because instead of
answering something that is directly related (natural, unnatural, supernatural)
to knowing an existence you appeal to imaginary concepts which do not
define what is natural???

I did provide an answer. You simply did not understand it. You are the one appealing to imaginary concepts that do not define nature.
 
I did provide an answer. You simply did not understand it. You are the one appealing to imaginary concepts that do not define nature.
I can't help but think that breckmin's vision of the universe resembles the maps of the middle ages, except instead of labeling the uncharted edges with "there be dragons" it says "there be god".
 
But if there is truly an objective determining Creator. If there is truly an Infinite God Who will impose eternal logical consequences on each one of you for all of eternity, "what will it profit to win a debate and actually lose your eternal soul?" How will this be "me" vs "you" on the day of your death, the day when "death" is your final reality and the present fantasy we "all" live under and experience to different degrees is finished???


This is a form of Pascals Wager (believe in god because it is the best option).
It doesn't work.
If you want to know why people on this board are laughing at it, consider the following:
You should become a Scientologist, because if you don't, you will never be rid of the Thetans that are stuck to you, and will never acheive your full potential as a human..​
Does that argument inspire you to join Scientology?
Of course not.
Because you don't believe in Thetans. So you're being threatened with a consequence you have no belief in.

Telling atheists that we are gambling with our eternal soul is the same thing. You may believe in the soul, but we don't. A Scientologist may believe in Thetans, but you don't. It's the same thing, and that is why it fails.

I do hope you can understand the point I'm making here.



I ask a starting question of "how do you know?" to clearly expose the fact that you don't know about the supernatural and if you deny the supernatural then it is philosophically a logical fallacy at its premise.


So the default position is belief?

That is nonsense.

You are correct in that we don't know about the supernatural. However, we are quite able to dismiss it because it has not been proven. Your premise is that I should believe every supernatural claim because I can't know it doesn't exist.

If you truly believe that belief should be the default position, it follows logically that you believe in fairies, UFOs, homoeopathy, invisible pink unicorns, several thousand gods and goddesses, indigo children, energy vortexes, etc.

After all, "if you deny the supernatural then it is philosophically a logical fallacy at its premise."



Can anyone sum up what he's said so far...


He is saying that the default state for a claim about the supernatural is belief. Anything else is a logical fallacy.
 
Originally Posted by Breckmin
Must I conclude that you will not answer the question, because instead of
answering something that is directly related (natural, unnatural, supernatural)
to knowing an existence you appeal to imaginary concepts which do not
define what is natural???


I did provide an answer. You simply did not understand it. You are the one appealing to imaginary concepts that do not define nature.


Indeed FZ. Have you noticed that a certain contingent of the membership aren't aware of the irony they provide?


I'll give 'em a 7.5 (not bad)
 

Attachments

  • irony.gif
    irony.gif
    4.4 KB · Views: 127
How do you know that the universe was not "caused" by something
other than itself?

He doesn't. But as a scientist he will not use his ignorance as an excuse to insert into the unknown the properties that he wishes the universe to possess. Your argument seems to boil down to a simple god-of-the-gaps position. "We don't know what, if anything, lies beyond our ability to observe. Therefor I am going to make assertions about what lies beyond our ability to observe."
 
Breckmin, the heart of your position seems to rest with the claim that there are structures in organic chemistry that are too complex to have evolved from simpler structures by known natural processes. I have asked you to name any one such structure. Joobz has asked you a specific question regarding polypeptide production. A response to either of these questions would be a good place for you to begin laying out your case.
 
But if there is truly an objective determining creator. If there is truly an Infinite God Who will impose eternal logical consequences on each one of you for all of eternity, "what will it profit to win a debate and actually lose your eternal soul?" How will this be "me" vs "you" on
the day of your death, the day when "death" is your final reality and the present fantasy we "all" live under and experience to different degrees is finished???


But what if there "is truly an Infinite God Who will impose eternal logical consequences" upon you, and it doesn't happen to be the one that you have chosen to worship? Remember Exodus 34:14, for example - these guys tend to get kind of pissed off about that sort of thing.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg hasn't posted here lately, I suppose he has no empirical evidence of the supernatural either.
 
Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things. [ Take 4 ]

My positions on God are already stated in the following posts:


Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things.

Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things. [ Take 2 ]

Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things. [ Take 3 ]


Briefly:

1. My concept of God is the following:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth,
and everything.​

2. My empirical evidence of God are the communication satellites and the moon and man's brain, experience, consciousness, reason and intelligence.​


Please concentrate on the thoughts in those two positions.

If you have already concentrated on those two positions, please just choose one particular point and shorten your text to the utmost brevity your focus of objection, and I will respond to you.


Please abstain from irrelevant words.




Yrreg
 
1. My concept of God is the following:
​
An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth,
and everything.
​
2. My empirical evidence of God are the communication satellites and the moon and man's brain, experience, consciousness, reason and intelligence.
​
I don't understand why communication satellites, the moon, the human brain, experience, consciousness, reason and intelligence are empirical evidence of god?
 
1. My concept of God is the following:
An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth,
and everything.​

​
You have not presented any evidence for the existence of such an entity. Indeed, the concept requires that your God create himself, a logical impossibility.

2. My empirical evidence of God are the communication satellites and the moon and man's brain, experience, consciousness, reason and intelligence.
Your "empirical evidence" does not provide any real evidence for your God. A Raeliean might look at the exact same evidence and claim it is "empirical evidence" for the existence of wise extraterrestrials who planted and cultivated us here. In fact, both of those conclusions do not follow from the evidence at all, but are based on a fundamental presupposition that we could not arise without something guiding us. This presupposition is based on humans' particular self-infatuation with their own intelligence, believing that intelligence is necessary for the universe to operate. That presupposition, though widely held, has no basis in evidence. Just the opposite.
 
Please concentrate on the biggest picture of things.

Posted by Breckmin
God is a "He" in the scriptures because He is revealed in the masculine, but this gender is not established by sex, but rather by standard.​


Why?



Before anything else, concentrate on the concept of God from theists like myself, thus described already several times here:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth,
and everything.



Please abstain from all indications of nitpicking while the thrust of our discussions should be on the biggest pictures of things, not for example on the anthropomorphic detail used by simple men to verbalize in human language his thoughts on God in a concrete human way.


I find this kind of an attitude from atheists here bemusedly annoying but indicative of the kind of heart and mind of atheists here.

Atheism is not about molecules and atoms but about humans, so it is impossible to discuss atheism without bringing in their kinds and manners of speech, thought, and exchange of ideas.


If you are not aware why people in the US hold atheists in their midst to be the most distrusted of minority, my impression is precisely because they cannot deal with them in a way that is constructive, and they believe that on this kind of a posture from atheists, atheists are tergiversating.




Yrreg
 
Again, please concentrate on the biggest pictures of things.

Posted by Breckmin
Masculine spirituality and the reasons for it, and the assumptions that are actually "built" to get there are evasive to first assumptions.​

English, please.



Another example of irrelevancy to the biggest pictures of this thread, viz., repeated flights to language barriers.


Please ask people who are really more conversant with English to enlighten you, everytime you come to some text which you claim to be incapable of grasping.


On my part I have already resolved to not react to people whose heart and mind are not into genuine constructive exchange of ideas, but into tergiversations, thinking that they are so smart for continually playing the naive.




Yrreg
 
Another example of irrelevancy to the biggest pictures of this thread, viz., repeated flights to language barriers.
Actually, Hokulele's point was that Breckmin's explanation was devoid of information. It was an honest response.

FYI, Why do you not critize Breckmin for defining specifics of god?
He was the one to claim that god has a gender. Is this acceptable? What if someone were to claim that god is female? Would you also find this acceptable?
 
Which videos are those?

By the way, I'm an atheist and I didn't make any such videos either. The image of a bearded old man is familiar to our culture, but I have yet to meet an atheist who disbelieves in any god because he or she thinks it to literally be a big bearded man in the sky. By implying that atheists often do just this you were yourself committing a strawman fallacy.
Foster, as an aside to this discussion, you could search the forum for the following terms over the past year.

sky daddy
bearded sky daddy

I think you'll find evidence of both. (terms)

DR
 
Another example of irrelevancy to the biggest pictures of this thread, viz., repeated flights to language barriers.


You were the one asking for simplification, and now you are criticizing me for requiring the same?

How hypocritical.

Please ask people who are really more conversant with English to enlighten you, everytime you come to some text which you claim to be incapable of grasping.


OK, please explain to me the point Breckmin was trying to make with the bit that I questioned. Thank you in advance for your effort.


On my part I have already resolved to not react to people whose heart and mind are not into genuine constructive exchange of ideas, but into tergiversations, thinking that they are so smart for continually playing the naive.


So I can now add mind-reading to the list of your talents?

Hmmm...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom