Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

How can you start with true agnosticism, when you assume that everything is natural?
This doesn't make any sense. What do you mean? An agnostic only believes what there is evidence to believe. There is evidence that everything is natural so an agnostic would believe that. There is no evidence of the supernatural so the agnostic wouldn't believe that.

I'm not sure why that would be difficult to understand?
 
Last edited:
Where the hell is "Outside Of Time"? Time is a measurement of duration, not a physical place-if your god exists at 10:00am, and she/he/it still exists at 10:25am, we can safely say your god existed for those 25 minutes at least. It makes as much sense as saying "Outside Of Weight" or "Outside Of Height"-that is, none at all.
 
Last edited:
The answer to the first question is deduction.

However, the premises fail to lead to a conclusion when the subject of the conclusion has no meaning.

One can dress it up using logical sounding descriptions, but it is simply theatrics. That may have a certain efficacy on some percentage of the population, but here it has little chance of succeeding.

You might try a short cut and admit that we are discussing a set of beliefs rather than a process of logical argumentation.
 
Where the hell is "Outside Of Time"? Time is a measurement of duration, not a physical place-if your god exists at 10:00am, and she/he/it still exists at 10:25am, we can safely say your god existed for those 25 minutes at least. It makes as much sense as saying "Outside Of Weight" or "Outside Of Height"-that is, none at all.
I listened to an interview with Brian Green and he dealt with this. Unfortunately nonintuitive concepts like space-time, time dilation, multi-dimension and special relativity, etc., give pseudo-intellectuals ammunition to make up anything that they like to justify their beliefs. There is no theoretical basis for it though. It's just poorly hobled together fantasy.
 
Before I answer this, we need to first realize fully 100% that the definition
for find only naturalistic explanations for origins is the product of circular
reasoning.


As soon as we can first expose this circular assumption in science, then
we can proceed without philosophical bias to look at the evidence.

~Michael

Naturalistic explanations are products of circular reasoning? Are you going to make an attempt to establish this claim?
 
Naturalistic explanations are products of circular reasoning? Are you going to make an attempt to establish this claim?
I can guess at a possible response. If we don't accept first principles then we can get into an Infinite regress. It's an abuse of skepticism. The axiom that there are only natural explanations can be argued to beg the question. One would first need to establish that everything can only be explaind with natural explanations. However, that everything is natural is an empirical claim that to date has not been falsified. We work from that first premise because it is the only one that is consistent with all of the models that we have for the known universe. It is upon the basis of this first principle that we discovered the structure of the Atom, DNA, carbon molecules, travelled to the moon, measured the speed of light, created the internal combustion engine, the computer, developed modern medicine, etc., etc..
 
I wasn't quoting it as a proof argument. I was just noting the irony. Or perhaps I just wanted someone to actually look up a bible verse once in
awhile. The bible isn't just a book, it is a collection of different manuscripts
written by different prophets and apostles in different centuries.

You have assumed we have not and do not.

Some of us were hard-core fundies most of our lives. I happen to have read the entire bible, cover to cover, several times, over the course of my life. As my cogntion improved and was refined, I realized I was reading...well, a bunch of made-up, tribalistic, fairy-tale crap.

My reference to the Romans verse was not for a circular assumption. It was
only noting the irony.

Until that god is proven, there is no irony.



So, are you responding to Yrreg's OP at all, or just hijacking another thread you didn't start? It will be interesting to see the two of you converse.
 
This is about "you" vs. "you" and whether you have discovered objective
truth.
The only things that even come close to "objective truth" status are things that are true by definition in whatever logical or mathematical framework you happen to be working in at the time. When dealing with the shared experience we call reality, there is only how accurate your observations are and how elegant and predictive your models that explain those observations are.

You think this is about mere "debate" instead of discovering "facts???"
On the R&P section of the JREF forums? Yes. That is kinda the point.

But if there is truly an objective determining Creator. If there is truly an Infinite God Who will impose eternal logical consequences on each one of you for all of eternity, "what will it profit to win a debate and
actually lose your eternal soul?" How will this be "me" vs "you" on the day of your death, the day when "death" is your final reality and the present fantasy we "all" live under and experience to different degrees is finished???

Oh, lookee, an instance of Pascal's Wager. Which god was inflicting the punishment, how do you know that god even exists, and why is it deserving of worship if it is the sort of psychopath that will mete out endless torment over finite infractions?

I ask a starting question of "how do you know?" to clearly expose the fact that you don't know about the supernatural and if you deny the supernatural then it is philosophically a logical fallacy at its premise.
Oh, look, a philosophical premise is sneaking up behind Breckmin, and it has big, pointy teeth! That bite on the arse is going to hurt.

Methodological naturalism is one of the most powerful philosophical stances out there. You may know it by its common name of the scientific (or Baconian) method. It has been responsible for the stupendous progress Western civilization has made over the last 3 - 4 hundred years. It does not deal in supernatural anything by definition.

Your argument fails.

This isn't about debate, this is about truth before the Creator. I do not care who wins a debate here. I lose every debate where no one's life is changed.
This board is not exactly fertile ground for witnessing, you know.
 
Last edited:
I lose every debate where no one's
life is changed.

You're steadily losing this one, for sure. I already did all the god-crap for over 30 years. I was able to put it away quite easily, after 3 decades of slavish devotion to it.

It is not true that there is nothing out there that could change my mind. But you are coming nowhere close to it, only rehashing the same old arguments and fallacies I've already examined carefully and rejected.

Some of this "factual" stuff you keep talking about might help, could you but come up with an objective fact I could verify on my own without your input.

I'll just wait for it, shall I? Breathing normally.
 
You have assumed we have not and do not.

Some of us were hard-core fundies most of our lives. I happen to have read the entire bible, cover to cover, several times, over the course of my life. As my cogntion improved and was refined, I realized I was reading...well, a bunch of made-up, tribalistic, fairy-tale crap.
One of the things that people like Breckmin should realise as soon as possible is that the biggest reason for Christians turning into atheists and agnostics is because they started really reading the bible and figured out how enormously incoherent it is about so many things. Like for example that it has two creation stories that contradict each other.

And even people like me, who've been atheistic all my life, have certainly read my share of the bible, which helped me realise it was a rather big bunch of complete nonsense about a trigger-happy, sadistic, and all-round cruel deity who, should it exist in the first place (which it almost certainly doesn't) isn't worthy of licking my boots, far less being worshipped by me.
 
Please explain what you mean by the word "natural" in natural selection.

How do you gauge what is natural? What is "natural" specifically?

~Michael
Dear Michael.
your original question was for a definition of "natural" in natural selection ( see above)
The answer is that it is a term used in the field of evolutionary biology.It distinguishes it from Artificial selection. Generally speaking there is-
"Artificial selection" This is the process that humans use to change organisms to their own benefit/aesthetic liking, etc. Wheat for food, dogs for shows, etc. Pick the traits that you want and breed from the animal/plant that will give you a high chance of inheritance. Repeat.

"Natural selection" This is an algorithmic process that occurs within a local environment.
Beneficial mutation, higher breeding rate, inherited trait, etc.

Intelligent manipulation in the first. None needed in the second.

I may be wrong but I hope this helps anyway. There is a thread somewhere, specificaly to answer questions regarding Natural selection.
 
Last edited:
whether we assume a supernatural or not, we have no reason to assume that you could know something about it that we or scientists could not know.

By what magical means would you gain this knowledge? How would you prove that your knowledge was more legitimately obtained than Tom Cruise's wisdom in regards to Scientology or Hindu teachings on reincarnation? Joe Smith is said to have gotten magical insight from gold plates. What makes you a better source than him?

Observation. You. You. You. Your whole post assumes this is about
me personally or Tom Cruise personally or Joseph Smith personally rather
than about basic deduction from the starting point of agnosticism.

~Michael

I hold no brief at all for Articulett, but you have not answered the question she asked, and it's a good one.

You have (once again) sidestepped, this time with the disingenuous protest, "Hey, it's not about you and me."

If you prefer, change the universal "we" and "you" to the impersonal pronoun "one:"

Whether [one] assumes a supernatural or not, [one] has no reason to assume that [one] could know something about it that [others] or scientists could not know.

By what magical means would [one] gain this knowledge? How would [one] prove that [one's] knowledge was more legitimately obtained than Tom Cruise's wisdom in regards to Scientology or Hindu teachings on reincarnation? Joe Smith is said to have gotten magical insight from gold plates. What makes [another] a better source than him?

Several of your posts seem to indicate that you are a believer in standard Christianity, complete with redemption and damnation. It's fair to ask why that belief is any more likely to be valid and true than other beliefs.

With regard to Tom Cruise, Joseph Smith and Hindus, are you hauling out that old chestnut, "They are mistaken in the details of their beliefs but they have an inkling of the truth"?

Once again, if you would state clearly what your thesis is and your reasons for advancing it, then discussion could proceed more easily.

But that would mean you have to pin yourself down to a simple declarative statement, wouldn't it?
 
I can guess at a possible response. If we don't accept first principles then we can get into an Infinite regress. It's an abuse of skepticism. The axiom that there are only natural explanations can be argued to beg the question. One would first need to establish that everything can only be explaind with natural explanations. However, that everything is natural is an empirical claim that to date has not been falsified. We work from that first premise because it is the only one that is consistent with all of the models that we have for the known universe. It is upon the basis of this first principle that we discovered the structure of the Atom, DNA, carbon molecules, travelled to the moon, measured the speed of light, created the internal combustion engine, the computer, developed modern medicine, etc., etc..

Then infinite regress is virtually the perfect tool to employ if one does not have empirical evidence. Now I can see why Breckmin related Romans 1:20 to this.
This route of argument is disingenuous and it appears Yrreg does it as well.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, Slingblade. That's what I thought. And thanks to Elizabeth for parsing. I got confused with all the "you you yous".

(I'm sure there's a clever rhyme in there somewhere... confuse... yous...woos...)
 
Thanks, Slingblade. That's what I thought. And thanks to Elizabeth for parsing. I got confused with all the "you you yous".

(I'm sure there's a clever rhyme in there somewhere... confuse... yous...woos...)

It's that thing they do...could even be a song title.:p
 
There's a type of person who wants to make the argument, but not be responsible for supporting it.

I may not be putting that exactly right, so I hope my meaning is at least somewhat clear.

It usually takes a particular and familiar form.



Opening Poster:
Ok, Here is my argument!
1) Premise
2) Premise
3) Conclusion.

Whadda ya think about that?


Response:
Your argument fails for the following reasons...

OP:
MY argument!? MY argument!? How did this get to be about ME all of a sudden!?


I'm sure it's recognizable in that form, at least. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom