Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

This isn't about debate, this is about truth before the Creator. I do
not care who wins a debate here. I lose every debate where no one's
life is changed.

~Michael
1. This is about debate, because I don't remember signing up for "The Breckmin Lecture".
2. You obviously care.
3. Debates are about putting forward the better argument, not changing lives.

Speaking of which(and getting back on topic), what is the best empirical evidence you've got for your particular version of God?
 
I ask a starting question of "how do you know?" to clearly expose the
fact that you don't know about the supernatural and if you deny the
supernatural then it is philosophically a logical fallacy at its premise.

This isn't about debate, this is about truth before the Creator. I do
not care who wins a debate here. I lose every debate where no one's
life is changed.

~Michael

What is the empirical evidence used by you to establish the existence of the supernatural?
 
Uggh.... It's Yrreg II with a dash of KK and Maatorc... wake me if this Breckmin dude ever makes a point.
 
When I read woo talk I always think if they are repeating the indoctrination techniques used on them. When Breckmin, speaks he thinks he's making valid claims... he doesn't know that he sounds as wacky as Tom Cruise speaking on Scientology. I wonder if we are hearing him recreate the manipulative language that was used to make him believe in whatever it is he feels so humble (ha!) about "believing in".

I love the wry warning about "what if he's right"...

I think that if we had eternal souls and that some undetectable being or force was de how these eternal souls would "feel" for eternity.... Breckmin is not the first choice I'd go to for further information. I mean if I was silly enough to be bullied into Pascal's wager, I think I'd resort to a more coherent, less arrogant, belief system... Buddhism maybe--especially since it's so anathema to yrreg.

But as it is, until one can demonstrate that consciousness outside of a brain is more likely than sound inside a vacuum, I'll presume that what one "believes" on the subject has little to do with reality.
 
The logical fallacy of starting with circular reasoning before you conclude anything

If we do not know about the supernatural (or even its existence) why do you think you do?
What is the logical fallacy?

The answer to the first question is deduction. The answer to the second
question is "the logical fallacy is in "assuming" there the is NO supernatural.

You MUST start from not knowing whether or not science is the study of
processes which are strictly naturalistic. If you start with concluding that
every process is natural, then your conclusion is equal to your assumption.

First you have to justify how you know that "natural" exists apart from
supernatural. You have to first justify what "natural" is, and how you
know it is indeed natural and not the process of random interaction.

IN FACT, how do you know any process is truly random? IOW, how do
you know these random processes which appear random to a finite observer
are not infinitely determined by a Creator (assuming the possibility of a
Creator). How do you know there even is such a thing as "random," IF
there is an Infinite Creator Who is omniscient Who knows every role of
the dice or every mutation or electron orbital, how do you even know
that there IS a process that is truly random?

I am not saying the inverse. I am not saying that random does not
exist.

I am just asking a few questions first before I start to build an argument.

~Michael
 
Still talking about a person who posts rather than the subject of posts

When Breckmin, speaks ....he doesn't know ..... he sounds as wacky as Tom Cruise .....to make him believe in whatever it is he feels so humble (ha!) ........
Breckmin is not the first choice ....
.

Breckmin...this and Breckmin that...

How does this change deductions made based on scientific observation
without assumptions???

~Michael
 
God was not a finite being that He should have had to "wait."
I'm really sorry you spent so much time on that. It wasn't warranted. You are not making any headway. I'm sorry if you can't understand the problem inherent with your thesis. Declaring god outside of time doesn't solve any problems. It's like saying it's magic. It's not an explanation.

First, you can't logically say "god always existed" but there is no time. Also, no one said he had to wait. I asked how he knew when to start time? The point was that there was a point when there wasn't time and then a point when there was. "When" wasn't really the important part of that.

Declaring that god is infinite (not finite) doesn't solve any of the problems. It's not a magical statement that resolves the contradictions.

Move on.
 
Last edited:
whether we assume a supernatural or not, we have no reason to assume that you could know something about it that we or scientists could not know.

By what magical means would you gain this knowledge? How would you prove that your knowledge was more legitimately obtained than Tom Cruise's wisdom in regards to Scientology or Hindu teachings on reincarnation? Joe Smith is said to have gotten magical insight from gold plates. What makes you a better source than him?
 
I would love to answer this question, but first we need to remove the bias of circula

What is the empirical evidence used by you to establish the existence of the supernatural?

Before I answer this, we need to first realize fully 100% that the definition
for find only naturalistic explanations for origins is the product of circular
reasoning.

As soon as we can first expose this circular assumption in science, then
we can proceed without philosophical bias to look at the evidence.

~Michael
 
Breckmin...this and Breckmin that...

How does this change deductions made based on scientific observation
without assumptions???

~Michael

If you want me to answer your 3 question marked sentence, you'll have to get a smart person to translate it into "non-woo". I have no idea what you are asking here.

I'm trying to find out why you think we should respect your claims of "divine knowledge" more than all such other claims that are inflicted upon us here daily. It's a skeptics forum, remember?
 
Observation.

whether we assume a supernatural or not, we have no reason to assume that you could know something about it that we or scientists could not know.

By what magical means would you gain this knowledge? How would you prove that your knowledge was more legitimately obtained than Tom Cruise's wisdom in regards to Scientology or Hindu teachings on reincarnation? Joe Smith is said to have gotten magical insight from gold plates. What makes you a better source than him?

Observation. You. You. You. Your whole post assumes this is about
me personally or Tom Cruise personally or Joseph Smith personally rather
than about basic deduction from the starting point of agnosticism.

~Michael
 
Before I answer this, we need to first realize fully 100% that the definition
for find only naturalistic explanations for origins is the product of circular
reasoning.

As soon as we can first expose this circular assumption in science, then
we can proceed without philosophical bias to look at the evidence.

~Michael

What circular assumption? Science addresses things which are amenable to its methods. It makes no assertions about things which lie outside that. What are you talking about?
 
Is Breckman making sense to anyone?

Is he making more sense than yrreg?

Is anyone following?

Can anyone sum up what he's said so far...
 
I am just asking a few questions first before I start to build an argument.
Forget your questions for a minute or three and acknowledge that you have (conveniently?) overlooked many, many questions that have been posed in a calm, clear, concise and polite manner

Please observe netiquette

Failure to do so will support the notion that you are nothing more than a troll
 
Let's ask the question. Is everything natural or is everything supernatural?
Let me make this as simple as possible. Call it what ever you like. Let's start by pointing out that what we are talking about is "everything" that we can quantify. It might be natural it might be supernatural. I only know that whatever it is it isn't the other.

If "everything" is A then A isn't ~A

So let's skip the semantic games. You pick the label because I don't care. If you choose natural to label everything we can quantify and you are discussing a god that is outside of time and space then the god you are talking about is supernatural.

If everything we can quantify is physical then god would be metaphysical.

Ok?
 
It's late and I have to get up for church tomorrow but I would like to leave tonight
with this parting thought.

How can you start with true agnosticism, when you assume that everything is natural?

~Michael
 
Observation. You. You. You. Your whole post assumes this is about
me personally or Tom Cruise personally or Joseph Smith personally rather
than about basic deduction from the starting point of agnosticism.

~Michael

Thanks for sharing.

I was wondering if this post has any coherent meaning to anyone other than Michael Breckmin. Am I missing some communication here? I understand that he doesn't like being compared to Tom Cruise or Joseph Smith... but is this his excuse for not being able to say why I (we?) should take him more seriously than we'd take them?

And what's with the "yous" and "agnosticism"? Can someone parse?
 
Before I answer this, we need to first realize fully 100% that the definition
for find only naturalistic explanations for origins is the product of circular
reasoning.
This collection of words does not make sense in English

I sincerely wonder if your collected thoughts make sense in any language
 
It's late and I have to get up for church tomorrow but I would like to leave tonight
with this parting thought.

How can you start with true agnosticism, when you assume that everything is natural?

~Michael

We don't assume it: we just don't assume we or anyone else has the means of knowing anything about the supernatural until or unless someone demonstrates that it can exist.

Jeez.

How hard is it to understand that?

You're the one assuming that it does exist and then using it to explain the god you've been indoctrinated to believe in.
 
You may as well be saying "magic is real and I know which kind".

Great. Which woo doesn't. If only all the woos would get on the same page regarding all the supernatural claims.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom