Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Can man's brain experience God as defined by yours truly in the following words?

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

In my own case, I see for example the moon, and I know what is an artificial satellite made by man, from that point as by a flash of light my brain or I experience the human certitude of a shall we or may I say a fragment of God's existence.

Brains can imagine such a god, despite its non-existence, just as brains can imagine unicorns, despite their non-existence.



Your last sentence is completely garbled. Can you rewrite it?
 
No imagination needed. Just honesty and humility

Brains can imagine such a god, despite its non-existence, just as brains can imagine unicorns, despite their non-existence.

Argumentum ad absurdum. You can not use imaginary finite constructions
that based on your uniform and repeated experience you know don't exist
and apply them as tantamount to Infinite Personal Existence which would
explain the origin of the universe and its complexity. IOW, unicorns, invisible
dragons in your garage, flying spaghetti monsters, and teapots in outer
space are clearly not responsible for the programming of biological code
and Information in RNA/DNA nor are they responsible for the complexity
of the nano factory we observe in the living cell.

Clearly, the human brain and its biological complexity should have taught
you alone that its engineering requires an intelligent source.

No imagination needed.

Just honesty.

That starts with 'humility.'

Question everything. It just might lead you in the right direction..

~Michael
 
There is something unavoidably strange about the very existence of the the universe; something that science needn't concern itself with. Why was there a big bang, or whatever, that led me to typing these words?

It strikes me as incredibly unlikely that there is something...instead of nothing.
It doesn't seem necessary, some how, that we exist. It could have easily been a 'no-show', and followed all the laws of physics; not that anyone would know.

Some atheists are capable of having a sense of reverence for this cosmic weirdness.
It isn't significantly different than believing in god.
It is god, if you like.

And it doesn't imply any irrational behaviour.
The god that atheists don't believe in is not god.

god is the reality that atheists do believe in...except, that word (god) is all tainted.
So thinking atheists believe in god, if god is allowed to be the whole thing.

In a way, atheists are more religious than theists...because they reject cheesy versions of the underlying awesome weirdness of existance. They refuse to sell god short; buying into some limiting religious view. They remain passionately honest, and can't be seduced by nonsense.
 
Yrreg,

Can it be that after all the threads you've started and countless posts, it comes down to you claiming that *feelings* you have in your brain are in fact you sensing the existence of God. Is that it? My sense organs tell me no such thing.
 
Argumentum ad absurdum. You can not use imaginary finite constructions
that based on your uniform and repeated experience you know don't exist
and apply them as tantamount to Infinite Personal Existence which would
explain the origin of the universe and its complexity

You can't use it either. That particular fallacy works both ways. A thing is not false just because it can't be proven true, but a thing is not true just because it can't be proven false.

I can't prove god or disprove it. I can have an opinion. It is my firm opinion no gods exist, and no gods have ever existed.

You can't prove god or disprove it. However, you have every right to your opinion that god exists. I simply don't agree with you, and I have my arguments and reasons why.

I reserve the right to change my mind, when and if I ever see any compelling evidence. I doubt seriously I ever shall.

Question everything. It just might lead you in the right direction.

I did, I do, and it has, thanks.


Still finding it ironic that you dish out that advice like a robot, yet haven't yet taken it yourself.
 
They don't even have God there to make the miracle happen..

In a way, atheists are more religious than theists...

It certainly takes more "faith" to believe in the miracle of abiogenesis
and not even have God there to perform the miracle which defies all logic...

Perhaps it has something to do with a circular assumption in their definition
for science?

Question everything. There may be a day when my posts bring you peace
rather than unrest...

~Michael
 
It certainly takes more "faith" to believe in the miracle of abiogenesis
and not even have God there to perform the miracle which defies all logic...

Perhaps it has something to do with a circular assumption in their definition
for science?

Question everything. There may be a day when my posts bring you peace
rather than unrest...

~Michael
You argue that life, and intelligence just coming into being without guidance is illogical.

So what created God?
 
Let the record show, it was admitted to be a fallacy

You can't use it either. That particular fallacy works both ways.

So you first admit that he used a fallacy. O.k., let the record show that
slingblade has agreed that unicorns, and other imaginary constructs are
indeed a fallacy to bring up...

A thing is not false just because it can't be proven true, but a thing is not true just because it can't be proven false.

No one made this claim for theism. That is what you and Sagan and Dawkins
and every atheist misses. We are bringing EVIDENCE!!!! The proof of supreme intelligence is in our uniform and repeated experience that Information of arranged complexity always comes from an INTELLIGENT
SOURCE!! If you disagree, then by all means "falsify it." I fully claim
that the law of information is falsifiable and always have. If you can
produce information by random process or observe replication form at
random under natural conditions, then by all means falsify the law of
biogenesis. You can ignore PROOF by claiming "you don't know."

It is my firm opinion no gods exist, and no gods have ever existed.
As I demonstrated in another thread which you did not respond to the
specific point, btw, strong atheism is a logical fallacy because of personal
lack of knowledge about the universe. This is why technical atheism and
agnosticism is clearly the starting point.

You can't prove god or disprove it.

Proof requires honesty. Why don't we start with the first two pieces of
"information" and "complexity" that have been entered in as evidence...

It is true, receipt of proof is a state of mind.

I reserve the right to change my mind, when and if I ever see any compelling evidence.

That is indeed a better place to start than those who deny and ignore
evidence and remain stubborn in their own tracks.

~Michael
 
It certainly takes more "faith" to believe in the miracle of abiogenesis
and not even have God there to perform the miracle which defies all logic...

Both are equally incredible. I knew someone long ago who honestly thought maggots just...spontaneously emerged from garbage. I'd rather been hoping for a brain cell or three to spontaneously emerge in his skull, but I can see we were both quite, quite wrong.

Perhaps it has something to do with a circular assumption in their definition
for science?

So....to whom are you speaking? Anyone in particular, or are you just making a gross, unfounded assumption based on your own biases and misinformation?

Question everything. There may be a day when my posts bring you peace
rather than unrest...

"Hu-mi-li-ty...or isn't it fashionable in France this year?"
 
For Breckmin:

http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2008/12/idiotic_gitt_aig_and_bad_infor.php
http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2008/12/fitness_landscapes_evolution_a.php
http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2008/11/evolution_produces_better_ante.php
http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2006/08/qa_what_is_information.php
http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2006/06/an_introduction_to_information.php

Pay special attention to the last post,a quote:

"o - what happens if I take a string in very non-compressed format (like, say, an uncompressed digitized voice) and send it over a noisy phone line? Am I gaining information, or losing information?

The answer is: gaining information. Introducing randomness into the string is adding information.

"AAAABBBB" contains less information than "AAAABxBB".

The way this is used to refute bozos who claim things like "You can't create information" should be obvious."
 
I have an observation.

You argue that life, and intelligence just coming into being without guidance is illogical.

So what created God?

I have an observation here. You are countering with the question of "where
did God come from?" as though this is somehow how a valid reason from which
to deny scientific EVIDENCE.

You can not come to scientific observation with such bias, either against
the Christian God, or questioning where any God would have come from.

That is a separate question. Clearly the evidence that arranged information
and a nano factory of a living cell are a separate question from "where did
the Engineer come from?

This is why we go round and round. It is actually a diversion away from
information and observations about the living cell.

To answer the question "So what created God?" First, this is a pseudo
question because it is a question with a false assumption. The false
assumption is that somehow God was created.

God is not a result. He is not just information. He is not just a living
cell. The problem with atheists is they do not understand this for some
reason. They do not differentiate between "result of creation" and the
Fundamental Reality which is the "cause of everything that was specifically
created." God by very definition is the uncaused cause of the universe.

If God were have to come from "somewhere," then whereever He came
from, THAT would be God. How can you create a Personal Existence that
is Infinite beyond the dimensions of time and space?? Why in the name
of all that is reasonable would be suppose creation for God's Infinite existence?
~Michael
 
Can man's brain experience God as defined by yours truly in the following words?

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


No. Even if your definition of God is true, man's brain was not present when the universe was created, so it can't have experienced the creation of the universe.
 
So you first admit that he used a fallacy. O.k., let the record show that slingblade has agreed that unicorns, and other imaginary constructs are indeed a fallacy to bring up...
Reread what she said.

No one made this claim for theism. That is what you and Sagan and Dawkins and every atheist misses. We are bringing EVIDENCE!!!! The proof of supreme intelligence is in our uniform and repeated experience that information of arranged complexity always comes from an INTELLIGENT SOURCE!! If you disagree, then by all means "falsify it." I fully claim that the law of information is falsifiable and always have. If you can produce information by random process or observe replication form at random under natural conditions, then by all means falsify the law of biogenesis. You can ignore PROOF by claiming "you don't know."
No, you aren't bringing up evidence. You are using yet another logical fallacy. You state that arranged complexity always comes from an intelligent source, but this isn't the case. It's true that every building and piece of man-made engineering on Earth was designed by a Human, but that's circular logic. Of course it's true, "every man-made thing is man made" is a tautology. However, termites build structure that are larger in proportion to them than any Human structure is in proportion to a Human. Do you suggest that termites are intelligent?

Looking further out than just our Earth, there are many examples of Grand Design spiral galaxies, which are highly ordered, complex structures. Are they designed by an intelligence? You could say, of course they are, God made them, but that's another logical fallacy. It only works if you assume a priori that God exists. If you don't assume that then you can see that a Grand Design spiral can be created by gravity and conservation of angular momentum, with no requirement for an intelligent designer. "Fine," you might say, "but God created the laws of the Universe". Only you yet again commit the fallacy of a priori" assumption that God exists. The laws of the Universe were created in the Big Bang, which could have come about by a quantum fluctuation, a naturalistic explanation, again with no requirement for an intelligent source.

As I demonstrated in another thread which you did not respond to the specific point, btw, strong atheism is a logical fallacy because of personal
lack of knowledge about the universe. This is why technical atheism and
agnosticism is clearly the starting point.
I agree, but to leap from that to theism via your argument is not warranted, since your argument is fallacious.

Proof requires honesty. Why don't we start with the first two pieces of "information" and "complexity" that have been entered in as evidence...
No, proof requires evidence, of which none has so far been forthcoming.

It is true, receipt of proof is a state of mind.
No, acceptance of proof is a state of mind.

That is indeed a better place to start than those who deny and ignore
evidence and remain stubborn in their own tracks.
What evidence? Show me some, and I'll consider it.
 
<<"AAAABBBB" contains less information than "AAAABxBB".>>

What you do not understand is that neither one of these little snips contains
any useful information. Feel free to post any assertions from those links
and I will provide the rebuttal. They are all easily shown to be either incongruous
or strawmen. You are missing the point about falsifiability and useful
information. So are they.

<<The way this is used to refute bozos who claim things like "You can't create information" should be obvious.">>
Either you don't understand the complexity and arrangement of nucleotides and
exactly the degree of information you are dealing with, or you are just using
induction to claim small amounts of order equal being able to form millions of
simultanious complexity. Just like the snowflake to somehow induce to apply
to entropy. This is far from a realistic model or mechanism.
Plus "bozos" is nothing more than name calling...

A lazy mind trying to express itself perhaps? Or just ad hominem (drawing attention
to the asserter rather than the data and conclusions)
~Michael
 
Still ignoring alleged evidence. Fascinating. Perhaps that is all you can do.

No, you aren't bringing up evidence.

Fascinating. I point to two scientific observations as alleged evidence
and you claim they are non existent.

No wonder you do the exact same thing with the Creator.


You state that arranged complexity always comes from an intelligent source,

Actually I said "The proof of supreme intelligence is in our uniform and repeated experience that information of arranged complexity always comes from an INTELLIGENT SOURCE!!"

This is clearly "useful" information which is translated, transcribed, recognized,
and understood to perform a particular function, etc. "Junk DNA" is evasive
to information that IS useful (therefore Junk DNA is a red herring).

However, termites build structure that are larger in proportion to them than any Human structure is in proportion to a Human. Do you suggest that termites are intelligent?

Do they recognize the structure that they built? Or do they believe that
it formed by random chance...

Question everything. It just might lead you away from random confusion.
~Michael
 
So you first admit that he used a fallacy. O.k., let the record show that
slingblade has agreed that unicorns, and other imaginary constructs are
indeed a fallacy to bring up...

You did not comprehend what you read. I said neither of us can use Argumentum ad Absurdum, because it's a fallacy that works both ways.

No one is claiming our imaginary constructs are anything but imaginary. You claim yours is factual.

You have no more facts for your imaginary construct than there are facts for unicorns, orbiting teapots, and invisible dragons. You know what? I can't prove unicorns, orbiting teapots and invisible dragons either do or don't exist. But I don't believe they do. I will reserve my right to change my mind if and when evidence to the contrary arises.

That's the point of using them in the argument. Let me show you:

Do you think unicorns--the actual hybrid of a horse, lion, and goat--exist or ever have existed? Do you think those three animals could, in some combination, cross-breed and produce unicorns? A pure white beast with a horse's head, a goat's hooves, a lion's tail, and a single spiraling horn in its forehead; bearing healing powers, the ability to purify water with its horn, and a deep, irresistible attraction to virgins--that unicorn.

If I were to say unicorns are a factual entity, what would you reply?

If I were to say it is a proven fact that unicorns do not exist, what would you reply?

No one made this claim for theism. That is what you and Sagan and Dawkins
and every atheist misses. We are bringing EVIDENCE!!!! The proof of supreme intelligence is in our uniform and repeated experience

Anecdotal evidence is not evidence. So far, I have seen none.

that Information of arranged complexity always comes from an INTELLIGENT
SOURCE!! If you disagree, then by all means "falsify it."


http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/9452500/page/2/
[...] the concept of specified complexity can also be tested.

"If Dembski were right, then a new gene with new information conferring a brand new function on an organism could never come into existence without a designer because a new function requires complex specified information," Miller said.

In 1975, Japanese scientists reported the discovery of bacteria that could break down nylon, the material used to make pantyhose and parachutes. Bacteria are known to ingest all sorts of things, everything from crude oil to sulfur, so the discovery of one that could eat nylon would not have been very remarkable if not for one small detail: nylon is synthetic; it didn't exist anywhere in nature until 1935, when it was invented by an organic chemist at the chemical company Dupont.

The discovery of nylon-eating bacteria poses a problem for ID proponents. Where did the CSI for nylonase—the actual protein that the bacteria use to break down the nylon—come from?

There are three possibilities:

The nylonase gene was present in the bacterial genome all along.
The CSI for nylonase was inserted into the bacteria by a Supreme Being.
The ability to digest nylon arose spontaneously as a result of mutation. Because it allowed the bacteria to take advantage of a new resource, the ability stuck and was eventually passed on to future generations.
Apart from simply being the most reasonable explanation, there are two other reasons that most scientists prefer the last option, which is an example of Darwinian natural selection.

First, hauling around a nylonase gene before the invention of nylon is at best useless to the bacteria; at worst, it could be harmful or lethal. Secondly, the nylonase enzyme is less efficient than the precursor protein it's believed to have developed from. Thus, if nylonase really was designed by a Supreme Being, it wasn't done very intelligently.

You're welcome.


I fully claim
that the law of information is falsifiable and always have. If you can
produce information by random process or observe replication form at
random under natural conditions, then by all means falsify the law of
biogenesis. You can ignore PROOF by claiming "you don't know."

Falsify God.

As I demonstrated in another thread which you did not respond to the
specific point, btw,

The thread was derailing. If it gets split off, we'll see.

strong atheism is a logical fallacy because of personal
lack of knowledge about the universe. This is why technical atheism and
agnosticism is clearly the starting point.

Theism is a fallacy for the same lack.
Atheism is the default position, however; I agree.



Proof requires honesty. Why don't we start with the first two pieces of
"information" and "complexity" that have been entered in as evidence...

It is true, receipt of proof is a state of mind.



That is indeed a better place to start than those who deny and ignore
evidence and remain stubborn in their own tracks.

~Michael

And you aren't a bit stubborn, we can clearly see that.

I know what proof will satisfy me. If your god exists, he supposedly knows it too. And he knows where I am.
 
Last edited:
The proof of supreme intelligence is in our uniform and repeated experience that Information of arranged complexity always comes from an INTELLIGENT
SOURCE!!

I don't understand this. If the claim is that the world and everything in it is "information of arranged complexity" (a curious phrase in itself) then my experience is that it it hardly ever comes from an intelligent source. I see a lot of things around me and I see no "intelligent source" at all: many more such things than the other kind. That seems to me to be self evident. Does an an amoeba come from an intelligent source? From what I heard it comes from another amoeba: it is a funny definition of intelligence if it includes amoeba: though if you wish to hijack the ordinary use of the word I cannot stop you, of course.

It is true that mankind can make some things. And that man is arguably intelligent. But that is a vanishingly small part of all that is: it does not seem to me to be humble to assume that the particular talents that mankind has are necessary to the existence of the universe: just the opposite.

TH White pointed out long ago that we value intelligence because that happens to be the tool we have which allows us to survive: we imagine it is important for that reason. And for a human being it is important: for an earthworm or a grass, not so much. To assert that the universe reflects the central important of intelligence over, say, claws, is just arrogant, or so it seems to me. A lot more things get by because of claws than because of brains: and although at present brains seem to be the best tool, that has not always been so and may not be so in the future.

ETA: Wollery made many of the same points, and made them better, while I was writing this. :)

If you disagree, then by all means "falsify it." I fully claim
that the law of information is falsifiable and always have. If you can
produce information by random process or observe replication form at
random under natural conditions, then by all means falsify the law of
biogenesis. You can ignore PROOF by claiming "you don't know."

The world itself falsifies it.

There seem to be two possibilities here: If man can, at least in theory, learn to make a universe by using intelligence, then on this conception we are gods. Do you find that a satisfactory conclusion? It is not fanciful, because there is a strand in human thinking which takes that very seriously and which opposes certain kinds of enquiry for that reason: but if all that is has an intelligent source, and if the universe is lawful, then that is where we might end up.

On the other hand, if man cannot learn to make a universe, even in theory, then intelligence has nothing to do with it and therefore intelligent design does not help us to explain the existence of what is, in any way.

For myself I do not care. I am not going to play quarky's "more spiritual than thou" game, because his proposition seems to me to be an abuse of language: god is not "allowed to be the whole thing": that is not what the word means.

I am not going to positively assert that there is a god or no god: this is not knowable and it is not important either. It would matter if god was as described by various religions: that is, if it existed and it cared whether we acknowledged it or not: there is no evidence that it cares at all and so I can ignore it as it ignores us. And absolutely nothing changes whichever route I take.

I am an atheist simply because that is what I do in all sorts of areas of my life: I take the evidence I have and I come to a conclusion. That conclusion changes if the relevant facts change. So far they have not.
 
Last edited:
So you quote something Bill Dembski claimed about specified complexity and then
show how Ken Miller provided rebuttal and claim this met my criteria?

I'm not saying Ken Miller's point is a valid one, but where did "I" specify Dembski's
specified complexity?

Hint: There is at least a fourth possibility to Ken Miller's assertion on the nylonase gene.

~Michael
 
We don't have to "believe in abiogenesis" or anything else to reject your magical story or anyone else's. Just as rational humans could say that mental illness or aberrations were not demon or spirit possessions even without knowledge of epilepsy, schizophrenia, autism or other neurological disorders.

We don't have to know what the flying creature is to reject the idea that it's aliens or a chupacabra or a wormhole bigfoot. The same goes for your invisible friend. We don't have to know what you believe or why to presume that consciousness cannot exist outside a body-- and even if it could-- we have no reason to think that ANY human could distinguish it from a delusion. We have tons of evidence that humans are really easy to fool in this area once they've been indoctrinated or come to believe a particular story. No evidence that any of it is based on anything real at all.
 
Last edited:
I am not reading the messages here of a good number of posters, because they are in my observation engaged in non-thinking ways of writing, and giving a black eye to atheists.


A pity.
You are missing out on some very good questions by employing this arbitrary selection bias.



Just the same if anyone says that the brain of man is not an organ of man whereby man undergoes experiences, enabling man to come to the human certitude of the existence of things outside man's mind...

Just give me the link in this thread.


I can't understand what you are trying to say with this section.
Doesn't matter, I suppose. Neuroscience is not my field. There are probably people on this board better versed in the relevant areas of study who could give you a more meaningful answer than I can.



Can man's brain experience God as defined by yours truly in the following words?

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


I'm going to address this "definition" again, from a slightly different tack.
I'm going to try to define a god that would be a fit for the above statement.
But I'm going to try to keep it as grounded in reality as I can.
We'll see what we come up with.

"God is an existent entity":
Let me propose that a god could exist (take note here that this does not mean I believe the following god exists, merely that I let this stand as a hypothetical for the purposes of this discussion). This god does not necessarily exist, but there will be nothing in the definition I come up with would prevent it from being possible. It is, however, a physical entity.
A unicorn, for example, is possible. An animal that shares ancestry with horses and zebras, and somewhere along the line grew a horn like a rhino of a narwhal (which actually has a tusk, but the effect is similar). It doesn't have any special powers. There is absolutely no (none, zilch, nada, zip) evidence of the unicorn existing on Earth, apart from some old fables. But physically speaking, a creature like this could exist. There are no contradictions inherent in such a creature.​

"independent of man's mind":
Very well, let us assume this entity is not a function of our minds or a byproduct of antiquated evolutionary heritage. That is, god is not some left-over bit of brain wiring from early ancestors, run amok with new stimulus. It is separate from humans.​

"creator of heaven and earth and everything.":
May I assume that this god is the creator of everything except itself? I'm going to. Let us assume that god is timeless. Note the word I used: "timeless". Not eternal. Not infinite. It would not do to have a god who has existed for eternity. What did god do? Sit around doing nothing for an infinite amount of time before deciding to create the universe? Too problematic. I use timeless. That is, god exists independently of time. Thus, the concept of time had no meaning prior to that point, rendering the "what did god do before?" question null and void. At least, in my opinion. Additionally, for something to be created it must have a cause. A timeless god has no cause, because such a thing is time-dependent. Instead, time is now a by-product of what god brought into being. This is a slight deviation from what you said. You stated "creator", but, for this definition to work, such a term is meaningless. I have already explained why. Hence, I phrased my statement as "brought into being". This might of might not avoid the problem. It depends who you talk to. It also avoids the problem of making the god immortal.
Next, I will postulate that this god is extremely powerful. Supremely powerful. But again, I choose my words carefully. I did not say "all-powerful". All-powerful creates contradictions. Supremely powerful only makes for difficult questions.
Further, I will put forward that this god is not all-knowing. Knowing everything means knowing every decision you will ever make, in detail. This would render the god as little more than a computer, running a program. Unable to change its own mind. A pathetic god, that, even for all its power. HOwever, in order to design a universe from the basic physical laws up, it would have to be unimaginably intelligent. Not omniscient, just hugely smart.
​


So what we have then is a physical entity existing independent of time. This entity is very powerful, but not omnipotent. It is very intelligent, but not omniscient.

This is a god concept for which I can see no immediate problems. Perhaps other can. And hopefully they would be willing to suggest improvements to the definition to fix any shortcomings.

The thing here is that such an entity could conceivably exist.

It is not, to my knowledge, self-contradictory (although someone may point out a contradiction I didn't catch) unlike many of the classic conceptions of the Christian god.
side note: I'm what you would call and "agnostic atheist". I don't think it's possible to know if a god exists, however, there is no evidence for it. But a lack of evidence is no reason to believe something. Russel's teapot, which I know you've mentioned in one of your frequent rants about "non-thinking", is physically possible. There is certainly nothing preventing a teapot from being in orbit about the sun somewhere between Earth and Mars. However, just because it is possible does not mean we accept the notion. If someone shows me a picture of a teapot orbiting the sun that has not been doctored, I will immediately accept the evidence. But I don't assume it's true just because it can't be disproven. Nor do you I suspect, which is the point people are trying to bring up with that analogy. However, as much as I am an agnostic atheist, I am willing to say categorically that a god "does not exist" if the definition for that god is self-contradictory. A square circle, for example, does not exist. I don't need to prove it's non-existence. The concept is a contradiction in terms, much like the "omnis" are often self or mutually contradictory.​

Thus, we have a definition, in the true sense of the word.

So tell me, yrreg: is the definition in bold above suitable to you? If so, I shall move on to a discussion of how to test for it.



In my own case, I see for example the moon, and I know what is an artificial satellite made by man, from that point as by a flash of light my brain or I experience the human certitude of a shall we or may I say a fragment of God's existence.



Yrreg


What?
This is a very confusing sentence.

I think you are talking about the ability to tell the difference between a natural object (the moon) and an artificial one (International Space Station, for example).

But I don't know for sure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom