Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?


Yes, but which of those deities don't you believe in? Please provide a list.

Incidentally... there is a rather obscure book that I think might help here. Comes in two volumes.... Yrreg has it on his bookshelf.... Full of examples of informal demonstrations of divine manifestations. I realize that the Bible doesn't contain much in the way of double blinded, statistically significant trials or anything, but wouldn't the kind of proofs offered to hoards of people in the Bible go a long way to changing attitudes here? I mean, if a burning bush started talking to me, and I could find any hidden speakers, I'd open my mind a little wider.

A less facetious answer would be, say, if studies of prayer produced and replicated results that couldn't be put down to chance or poor experimental design.

Your turn Yrreg, do you have any thoughts on an experiment?
 
Anyway, let me throw a spanner into the gears here. Yrreg, how would you approach this series of questions if you were dealing with an agnostic, rather than an atheist, point of view? By definition, an agnostic does not have a pure concept of God, since he or she is in doubt as to the true nature, or existence, of said God.


Actually, I suspect that that would be pretty much the position of most, if not all, of the "atheists" on this forum*. Certainly, as far as I'm concerned my non-belief in gods is provisional; provide good evidence for the existence or former existence of any god or gods, whether it be Allah, Odin, the FSM or the Great Green Arkleseizure, and I'll be forced to concede that that particular deity most likely exists (or has done in the past). On the other hand, given the amount of time for which people have been trying to come up with proofs of the existence of various gods (in my particular culture generally the Christian one) I think it is unlikely that any such evidence will be forthcoming. But basically non-belief is nothing more than the default position in the face of a lack of evidence.

The "Strong Atheist", who believes that there is no God, is really just a strawman put up by theist propagandists who wish to portray atheism as a system of belief, or by theists who are simply unable to understand the "atheist" position. Yrreg is defining "atheists", not as "people who don't believe in gods", but as "people who deny the existence of God"; hence his demands for a definition of the particular God that they deny (and his parallel insistence on his own definition of "God" as the one to be used). He refuses to accept that atheists simply don't believe in any gods.

*Perhaps we should have some sort of poll on this?
 
Last edited:
Yrreg: I have probably accused you of lying at some point, because I do believe that you have misrepresented the statements of those who are responding to your posts. If you don't like it, too bad. You get what you give. And you know as well as anyone that posts cannot be edited beyond a certain age.

If you're so sensitive that you can't respond to people who have insulted you after you have dealt out page after page of relentless insults, then you should go somewhere else to whine.

I have, however tried, over and over again, to engage in serious, civil discussion of the question that you began this thread with, and the question that arose out of it, which is how one might define God, and whether such a God and such a definition can be empirically proven. You still have not addressed this question in a serious way.

I will try once more.

1. You have come up with a working definition of God as an entity that exists outside of ourselves, and which created (if I might paraphrase, but I think you'll agree to the wording) everything of any sort that exists, except for himself. This is a useful working definition, and can be discussed whether or not such a God exists, and even whether or not such a God can exist.

2. The first question that arises is: could such a God, if he existed, be proven empirically to exist? I do not think such a God exists, but for the purposes of the discussion, will stipulate that if such a God did exist, it would be possible for its existence to be seen, heard, or felt empirically, by senses now acknowledged to exist, senses imagined to exist, or through religious experience not dependent on the physical senses. Again, for the purposes of this discussion it need not actually be so, but let us imagine that it is.

3: The second question that arises, however, is this: given the proven existence of that deity, could the qualities provided in the definition above be empirically proven? To that I say NO!

Let us step for a moment into a stipulated world, in which we acknowledge that there is indeed a God. That God is the very one described so eloquently in scripture, and the description is accurate. The God who walked the garden, bargained with Abraham, warned Noah, and spoke to Job out of the Whirlwind. That one. Let's assume for the moment that he's real, and all he's claimed to be. Nonetheless, it is absolutely, positively, practically and theoretically impossible to know, empirically, that that God created the universe. The only way we would ever know that is from inference, faith, or reliance on direct authority.

Moses could not look at the face of God, and neither can we.
 
Dear Yrreg,

Since your belief in God is so strong, what convinces you that God exists?
 
Last edited:
Ah, this is so exciting! It looks like yrreg is going for the Solipsism Detour combined with the Perfect Solution fallacy. I predict something like this:

"You can't know for certain that the rock you see, touch, and smell really exists. Therefore sense data and objective evidence is useless. Therefore empirical testing is impossible. Therefore God exists. Praise Jesus, and stop doing those naughty things with your private parts!"
Sure you can. Crack open your head and rub the rock against your brain. Observe the results. That is, if you still can in the midst of all your sensory functions going haywire. :D
 
Are you forgetting the most important organ of man for experiencing, the brain?

If you are brain-damaged what is the use of having eyes?




Yrreg
 
Are you forgetting the most important organ of man for experiencing, the brain?

If you are brain-damaged what is the use of having eyes?




Yrreg

I think you owe people who actually do have brain damage an apology.
 
Sensory organs experience. The brain interprets.



Brain-damaged how?

Yes, our most famous brain damage cases involve people who's eyes work fine. And even when visions is altered by brain damage, what is perceived tells us much about how the brain doesn't just see it interprets. I loved reading Oliver Sack's account of the artist who became totally colorblind--that is, he could only see the world in black in white or the women who saw things in "freeze frame" fashion.

Of course optical illusions are the simplest example of showing how our brain doesn't just "see"--it interprets. And it gets things wrong. Memory is similar.
 
I am waiting for Phase Inverter to talk for himself.
Yrre

No need to wait. Did you not see post 266? It was just before your post 267. What about Phase Inverter's post 278?

He's talking for himself but you don't seem to be listening.
 
Last edited:
Brain damage is a sad thing. It can leave a person unable to comprehend things people are trying to explain to them, riddled with emotional problems, and even cause them to spell things backwards.
 
So it is not off topic for an atheist to inform the readers here what is his concept of God he is denying.
I am an atheist. I deny that "God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything." Is that what you were looking for, yrreg?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom